Towards the Agile Supply Chain Prof.Dr. Remko I. van Hoek Cranfield School of Management, UK Corporate Executive Board, Washington DC.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Strategic Decisions (Part II)
Advertisements

Chapter 3 Network Planning.
Bringing the Voice of the Consumer Into Your Supply Chain Jake Barr Director, Consumer Driven Supply Network Global Mfg, Planning & Logistics The Procter.
Dr. A. K. Dey1 Inventory Management, Supply Contracts and Risk Pooling Dr. A. K. Dey.
1 Information Technology & Information Sharing in Supply Chains Zhi-Long Chen Michael O. Ball Robert H. Smith School of Business University of Maryland.
1 Session 22 Planning and Scheduling JIT Operations Session 22 Planning and Scheduling JIT Operations John Striebich Copeland Corporation.
LOG 408: Global Logistics Management
Supply Chain Management Managing the between all of the parties directly and indirectly involved in the procurement of a product or raw material.
Supply Chain Management
Distribution Strategies
© 2005 Wiley1 Chapter 4 – Supply Chain Management Operations Management by R. Dan Reid & Nada R. Sanders 2 nd Edition © Wiley 2005 PowerPoint Presentation.
Module: Supply Chain Management Operations Management as a Competitive Weapon.
Supply Chain Management
McGraw-Hill/Irwin ©2008 The McGraw-Hill Companies, All Rights Reserved CHAPTER 8 SUPPLY CHAIN MANAGEMENT.
Supply Chain Enablers Organizational Infrastructure
Section 4 part 2.  The Magnitude  In 1998, American companies spent $898 billion in supply chain related activities (or 10.6% of Gross Domestic Product)
Reasons for Inventory To create a buffer against uncertainties in supply & demand To take advantage of lower purchasing and transportation cost associated.
Functional Versus Innovative Products
Supply Chain Management
Agile or lean? High “Lean” works best in high volume, low
Consumer Sales at Retailer Consumer demand Retailer's Orders to Wholesaler.
Chapter 2 Supply Chain Strategy. Objectives After reading the chapter and reviewing the materials presented the students will be able to: Explain how.
Supply Chain Management Common Learning Block I Copyright © 2015 McGraw-Hill Education. All rights reserved. No reproduction or distribution without the.
9. Coordinated Product and SC Design Case: HP Desk-jet Printer Supply Chain (Read pages ) HP-founded in 1939 Electronic test and measurement equipment.
Chapter 7 The agile supply chain
ICS321 – Management Information Systems Dr. Ken Cosh.
ISQA 407 Introduction to Global Supply & Logistics Management Winter 2012 Portland State University.
Global supply chain problem. Different Cases (CASE-1) In March 2000, a serious fire at the plant destroyed critical production equipment. Within three.
Delivering Change in the Digital Economy: The Value of Supply Chain Collaboration in SA FMCG CGCSA Summit - September 2015 Paul Dickson.
Inventory/Purchasing Questions
Slides 6 Distribution Strategies
Supply Chain Agility in the Volatile World 12 th June 2014 CII Conference of Next Generation Supply Chain.
Global Supply Chain Management and Uncertainty Sources: Dornier et al., GOL, 1998 Flaherty, GOM, 1996.
8-1 McGraw-Hill/Irwin Operations Strategy Copyright © 2008 The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved. Coordinating the Supply Chain Chapter 8.
Supply Chain Performance COSC 643 Sungchul Hong. Competitive and Supply Chain Strategies A company’s competitive strategy defines the set of customer.
INVENTORY MANAGEMENT IN A SUPPLY CHAIN
Inventory Management and Risk Pooling (1)
Team Development Slide 1 © The Delos Partnership 2005 Supplier Relationship Management Module 4 – Project Team Development Vision & Strategy Supplier Interfaces.
MANGT 660 (A): Supply Chain Planning and Control Chapter 12 Manufacturing Focused Supply Chain Integration (1/2)
1 Facility and Supply Chain Strategy in a Global Environment Donald B. Rosenfield Leaders for Manufacturing Program LGO and SDM Alumni Web-cast 4/27/01.
Presented by Shaibal Roy 12 th June SUPPLY CHAIN CHALLENGES OF TODAY.
PUSH, PULL AND PUSH-PULL SYSTEMS, BULLWHIP EFFECT AND 3PL
Copyright ©2013 Pearson Education, Inc. publishing as Prentice Hall.1-1 Course Code MGT 561 Supply Chain Management Book: Supply Chain Management Strategy,
SUPPLY CHAIN MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS Part I. 7-2 LEARNING OUTCOMES 1.List and describe the components of a typical supply chain 2.Define the relationship between.
Introduction to Supply Chain Management Designing & Managing the Supply Chain Chapter 1 Byung-Hyun Ha
Intelligent Supply Chain Management Strategic Supply Chain Management
© 2003 McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc., McGraw-Hill/Irwin INTEGRATING SUPPLY CHAIN AND LOGISTICS MANAGEMENT 16 C HAPTER.
Main Function of SCM (Part I)
Syn Lean and Agile 1 © The Delos Partnership 2005 Lean and Agile Applying the ideas to the Demand side.
Famosa S.A. Full Speed Supply Chain Jorge León Bello__Master GEPS.
1 © 2006 The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc., All Rights Reserved Chapter 10 Supply-Chain Strategy.
INTRODUCTION TO SUPPLY CHAIN MANAGEMENT. What is a Supply Chain? A supply chain consists of the flow of products and services from: Raw materials manufacturers.
Chapter 2 Supply Chain Performance: Achieving Strategic Fit and Scope
BIA 674 supply chain analytics Lecture 2b
Agile or lean? “Lean” works best in high volume, low
Business, Operations and Supply Chain Strategy (BOSCS)
Homework 1 - ZARA.
Distribution Strategies
Online Retailing The consumer is not primarily price-driven when shopping on the Internet but instead considers brand name, trust, reliability, delivery.
Chapter 3 Supply Chain Drivers and Obstacles
Chapter 7 The agile supply chain
Chapter 3 Supply Chain Drivers and Obstacles
Challenges in Managing Supply Chains
UNIT –V SUPPLY CHAIN MANAGEMENT
Chapter 2 Supply Chain Performance: Achieving Strategic Fit and Scope
Chapter 3 Supply Chain Drivers and Obstacles
Chapter 9 Achieving Operational Excellence and Customer Intimacy: Enterprise Applications.
19th September 2004 Dusit Dubai SCLG - Dubai
Chapter 3 Supply Chain Drivers and Obstacles
Chapter 2 Supply Chain Performance: Achieving Strategic Fit and Scope
Presentation transcript:

Towards the Agile Supply Chain Prof.Dr. Remko I. van Hoek Cranfield School of Management, UK Corporate Executive Board, Washington DC

The Agile Supply Chain = 3W  P 1. What is it? 2. Who needs it? 3. Where do you stand? 4. Practices and their achievement. Sources: Cranfield study agility in the supply chain among 264 companies and Cranfield study on postponement among 293 companies

What has happened to your forecast? What about zero inventory policies and JIT? What about global sourcing and supplier relations? 911 Alarm call for traditional supply chains

Slowdown or breakdown? Inventory write off’s, Supplier discounts, Chips industry: capacity building in peak period and price cutting in the valley, Capacity squeeze or supply chain reconfiguration needed?

Some answers that have not worked sofar >Information integration as an answer to bullwhip effects >Supplier partnerships in the light of inventory reductions >Supply chain integration by all major players? >End-customer driven?

With changing supply chain requirements….

…and changing management priorities

the Agile Supply Chain is commonly targeted “From supply chains of one to supply chain for one” Gaining competitive edge in volatile markets through rapid responsive in and rapid reconfigurability of the supply chain

Example: Smart Car l Customer specified car (on the web or using a product configurator in the dealership) l Ordered straight into the factory where l Suppliers are co-located l Making modules to order l Based upon shared order information and co-design l Assembling the car in 4.5 hours and l Delivering to the customer in 2/3 weeks

Example: Nike l From 60% delivery accuracy l With a 6 months lead time for l Products with a 45 day lifecycle l To a diversified distribution capability with >direct delivery of large volumes, >central replenishments of smaller orders, >establishment of satellites and >information integration all around.

The Agile Supply Chain, What is it? IBM Compaq Toshiba N Parts Modules Manufacturing Distribution B Horizontal supply web based structuresA Vertical company based chains Source: Based on Fine, 1998 From single company to multicompany entry, From physical to physical and information flow, From focal company to consumer centric, From rigid integration to dynamic and temporal integration

The Agile Supply Chain, What is it? Primary design principle: Processes Functional/ Geographical/ Product departments Make and sell Sense and respond Agile supply chain What we do today Control based on networking Vertical command and control CustomizationLow High Service window LongShort

Contrasting archetypes “What we do now” “What could/should we be doing” Cost driven Customer driven Manufacturing Service efficient effective Full pallets, No fixed sizes; full container “Batches of one” loads, large batches Push/manufacturing Pull/customer in out Select from what is Meet demand instantaneously/ available or wait within customer time window (ever decreasing) Strategy Organization Logistics Ops. Service

Which requires a lot…..

…of things not yet achieved 0505 Market responsiveness Process integration Network integration Virtual integration

Who needs it? Contingency based practical approach to agility; Pareto Distribution

Segmenting production Base Surge Time DemandDemand CacItyusageCacItyusage Level production For surge For base

Segmenting the plant network Variety Speed Innovation plant, projects Mass production Centralized distribution Modular consortium Direct distribution Quick response from inventory

Demand characteristics Supply characteristics Long lead-time Short lead-time Predictable Unpredictable markets JIT Plan and execute Lean React and execute Agile Hedge and deploy Hold inventory

Levels of postponement and customization

Market sensitivity ProcessNetworkintegration/ innovativenesscooperation Virtual integration Goal Supply chain capa- bilities The Agile Supply Chain, Where do you stand? EG E does not stand for everything, From key dimensions to key practice….

The Agile Supply Chain, Practices Preliminary level; adjust existing organization Advanced level; integrate and reconfigure flow of goods Far reaching level; involve knowledge and information Variance Time Volumes

The Agile Supply Chain, Key Practices Variance Seasonality swapping Prosuming Reversed life cycling

Time Demand variance A) Two season pattern B) Two season after swapping Time Variance 1 Move peak to before peak low 2 Peak decreases 3 Safety net created 4 Repeat The Agile Supply Chain, Key Practices

Phases of lifecycle Need for agile entrepeneurship Need for standardization

The Agile Supply Chain, Key Practices Time Rapid Upstream Information replenishment speed dissemination

The Agile Supply Chain, Key Practices Volumes Flexibility Supply network Information content

 The Agile Supply Chain,  A)Multiplant tiering Volume Variety Plant A Plant B Examples: >National Bicycle >Concorde Lighting

 The Agile Supply Chain,  B)Design for supply chain (E=MC 2 ) Beyond design for logistics (packaging etc.) and product modularity towards: Modular process, Service content, Multimedia support Example: Smart

 The Agile Supply Chain,  C)Segmented distribution at Nike LeanAgile A B & C Segment Direct distribution from factory to customer warehouse Indirect distribution through central warehouse with combined shipments, small sized, frequent and with customized timetable

 The Agile Supply Chain,  D)Information as source of knowledge and supply chain learning, anticipating “surprising” consumers

So are we for real? l Postponement applications internal only? l Marginal side-lines (15-25% of volume) or a key feature of volume? l Customization or just adding SKU’s? l The only thing we know about forecasts is that they are wrong? l 10 forecasts for one market (by function, business unit and player)? l Sales and competitive gaming? l Deterministic planning systems? Market responsiveness

l 60% of TPL contracts are discontinued < 3 years l Nike has 10 LPL’s in Europe? l Zero inventory is a waste of time l Do we use open books or dual books? l Target costing or cost squeezing? Example: A car manufacturer established supplier partnerships (co-location, JIT, on sequence delivery within 1.5 hours after ordering of specific parts) but did not provide suppliers with mid-long term forecasts and +3 year contracts. As a result suppliers did not invest and hired a TPL warehouse where they stored enormous amounts of parts to deliver to order. Network integration?

Process integration? l Are S&OP tables just great lunch opportunities? l Is there just no synergy opportunity between the 83 supply chains within our organization? l Do we now call logistics supply chain? l Do we still draw supply chains as linear sequences of (internal) functions (the Porter curse) Example: In car manufacturing, assembly processes have been lowered to about 9 hours thanks to leaning, time compression and FMS. After fast cycle assembly however, the typical car is stored in the factory lot, a DC or at the dealership for several months.

Virtual integration? Focal player Integration scores in information space: Nike: 178 Internal legacy systems Demand filters upstream; no signal 2 tiers up Sales gaming and data aggregation

Virtual integration, really virtual? l ERP systems are typically applied within organizations only and l Several organizations have multiple ERP’s l Dual systems in the supply chain with manual interfaces? l Do you get charged for POS data too? l Does every player has to have his own exchange? l And participate in several exchanges to spread risks? Example: When a lead supplier asked a manufacturer about demand filters and poor visibility of demand the manufacturer responded: “Don’t look at us, we don’t know either.”

Implications: A wake up call l The economic slowdown was a painful awakening for the proclaimed leaders l Information availability is not the answer l All strings are off: forget about what you grew up with (EOQ, Batching, Volume Discounting, EOScale) l Don’t stretch existing systems for customization, it will lead to large scale customer dissatisfaction and unprofitability l BE READY TO DESTROY AND REBUILD BEFORE SOMEBODY ELSE WILL DESTROY YOU