Environmental Flows Bruce A. Moulton Chief Engineer’s Office Texas Commission on Environmental Quality.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
PINE HOLLOW WATERSHED ENHANCEMENT PROJECT Sherman County Soil & Water Conservation District.
Advertisements

Implementation and Monitoring Implementing the Building Blocks recommendations into prescribed hydrographs (Engineering) Implementing the Building Blocks.
Presentation Texas Water: What You Should Know November 6, 2010.
Flood the Sugar Cane Farms Now to Save the Estuaries: Is This Feasible ? Water Resources Advisory Commission January 5, 2006 Meeting.
Eduardo Garaña , P.E. Director-Water Department October 15, 2003
US Army Corps of Engineers BUILDING STRONG ® Mid-West Electric Consumers Association September 16, 2014 Corps of Engineers US Army Missouri River Mainstem.
South Llano River: One of 2011’sTop Ten National Fish Habitat Action Plan named SLR as “water to watch” WHY?? –Conserve freshwater, estuarine, and marine.
Approaches to Establish Minimum Flows to Bays and Estuaries Paul Montagna Marine Science Institute University of Texas at Austin Port Aransas, Texas.
California Recycled Water Plan California Recycled Water Plan A comprehensive approach to California’s long-term water supply By Gregory B. Ryan and Meagan.
Comprehensive Everglades Restoration Plan Picayune Strand Restoration Project Janet Starnes, Principal Project Manager Office of Everglades Policy and.
Northeast Corridor Greenway Acquisition – Mitigation Feasibility Study Results City Council Workshop June 24, 2014.
Klamath Watershed in Perspective A Review of Historical Hydrology of Major Features of the Klamath River Watershed and Evaluation of Hardy Iron Gate Flow.
Yellowstone River Compact Commission Technical Committee Discussions Sheridan County Courthouse Sheridan, WY April 24, 2007 Bighorn Reservoir operations.
Drought and the Central Valley Project August 2014.
Colorado River Overview February Colorado River Overview Hydrology and Current Drought Management Objectives Law of the River Collaborative Efforts.
CRFS Technical Committee Spring Meeting LC Operations Update March 26, 2015.
CRFS Technical Committee Fall Meeting LC Operations Update November 20, 2014.
Texas Clean Rivers Program Nueces River Authority Texas Commission on Environmental Quality Citizens.
Environmental Flows Under Texas Senate Bill 3: Did We Leave Enough Water for the Fishes? Kirk Winemiller, Dept. of Wildlife and Fisheries Sciences, Texas.
Lake Superior Binational Program and Lakewide Management Plan Lynelle Hanson Lake Superior Binational Forum Meeting Ashland, Wisconsin March 23, 2012.
Cost Allocation Studies for the MP Region Bureau of Reclamation April 29, 2008 Central Valley Project Cost Allocation Study Update Public Meeting #2: October.
Columbia River Water Management Program (CRWMP) Review of Year One Upper Crab Creek Planning Unit Meeting April 17, 2007.
1. Natural Resources Conservation Service Strategic Plan Strategic Plan
TCEQ – Environmental Flows and Water Rights Permitting Bruce Moulton Policy & Regulations Texas Commission on Environmental Quality.
FERC Relicensing of the Toledo Bend Project – Hydroelectric Power Generation Drought Hydroelectric vs. Water Supply Sabine River Authority Issues.
WATER AVAILABILITY MODELING for the SULPHUR RIVER BASIN Texas Natural Resource Conservation Commission Austin, Texas Consultant: R. J. Brandes Company.
Jack W. Tatum Sabine River Authority of Texas Chair – Sabine and Neches Rivers and Sabine Lake Bay Basin and Bay Expert Science Team.
Texas Bay and Estuary Study Program Cindy Loeffler Flows for the Future October 31, 2005.
US Army Corps of Engineers BUILDING STRONG ® 2012 Alabama Water Resources Conference Orange Beach, Alabama September 6, 2012 Beneficial Use Opportunities.
IMPROVING MILLERTON LAKE FLOOD CONTROL OPERATIONS TO INCREASE WATER SUPPLY Mr. Antonio M. Buelna, P.E. Mr. Douglas DeFlitch Ms. Katie Lee October 29, 2009.
An Interregional Water Solution with Conjunctive Use of Groundwater Haskell L. Simon President, Coastal Plains Groundwater Conservation District Vice President,
Managing Western Water as Climate Changes Denver, CO February 20-21, 2008.
Dominguez-Escalante National Conservation Area Dominguez Canyon Wilderness Resource Management Plan Scoping Meetings August 30 and 31, 2010.
Ecological Characteristics of Region K. Region K.
2011 Upper Basin Stakeholder Forum Nueces River Authority Feb 16, 2011 – Uvalde Feb 23, 2011 – Corpus Christi.
Solano Habitat Conservation Plan 580,000 Acres 36 Covered Species; 4 Natural Communities 17,500 acres of Urban Development; 1,280 acres of other New Facilities.
Wetland Wetland San Francisco Bay & Delta San Francisco Bay & Delta Wetland Wetland Steven Ortiz Per.1.
Channel Rehabilitation Projects TAMWG - June ‘04 Trinity River at Hocker Flat 1/16/2003.
Evaporation in Texas CE 394K.2 Spring Evaporation In Texas  Evaporation is an important component of the hydrological cycle.  Globally volumes.
Lee County Water Resource Initiative: Community Sustainability Committee June 16, 2010 Kurt Harclerode Operations Manager Lee County Natural Resources.
1 December 19, 2007 North-of-the-Delta Offstream Storage Project Overview State of California Department of Water Resources U.S. Department of the Interior.
Status update presentation #1 for the Cayucos Sustainable Water Project Status update presentation #1 for the Cayucos Sustainable Water Project November.
Upper San Joaquin River Basin Storage Investigation ACWA Regions 9 and 10 Carlsbad Water Summit U.S. Department of the Interior Bureau of Reclamation State.
Department of Port Control Center for Regional Economic Initiatives February Doan Brook Stream Restoration Project Center for Regional Economic.
1 Atchafalaya River and Bayous Chene, Boeuf, and Black, Louisiana Dredged Material Management Plan (DMMP) Kick off Meeting April 13, 2005 Project Manager.
1 September 13, 2007 North-of-the-Delta Offstream Storage ACWA Regions 9 and 10 Carlsbad Water Summit North-of-the-Delta Offstream Storage ACWA Regions.
NOAA’s National Marine Fisheries Service Biological Opinion for Water Supply, Flood Control Operations & Channel Maintenance by the Army Corps, SCWA, and.
California Water Plan Update Advisory Committee Meeting January 20, 2005.
HAMPTON ROADS REGIONAL WATER RESOURCES MANAGEMENT PROGRAM Presentation John M. Carlock, AICP Deputy Executive Director, Physical Planning Hampton Roads.
Susan Sylvester Department Director Operations Control Department Mechanics of the Primary Water Management System.
San Gabriel Valley From Stormwater to Supply
Chapter 21 Water Supply, Use and Management. Groundwater and Streams Groundwater –Water found below the Earth’s surface, within the zone of saturation,
Water Reservation for Caloosahatchee Estuary April 16, 2010 Caloosahatchee Estuary Reservation Team Everglades Restoration and Capital Projects Office.
Do not reproduce any photos that are in this presentation.
CRFS Technical Committee Fall Meeting LC Operations Update December 8, 2015.
DELAWARE NATIONAL ESTUARINE RESEARCH RESERVE Promoting stewardship of the nation’s coastal areas through science and education …
Reclamation and Hoover Dam It’s All About The Water.
Beth Kacvinsky - Lead Project Manager Office of Everglades Policy and Coordination March 1, 2016 IRL-S / C-44 Overview.
Strategies for Colorado River Water Management Jaci Gould Deputy Regional Director Lower Colorado Region.
CRFS Technical Meeting LC Operations Update November 14, 2012.
CRFS Technical Meeting LC Operations Update March 27, 2014.
Environmental watering – How is it the same or different from floods? Denis Flett Chairperson, Victorian Environmental Water Holder Friday 14 November.
Savannah River Projects
Texas Hydrological Conditions An Overview
Drought on the Colorado River System: Impacts and Response
Environmental Flow Protection in TCEQ Permitting
Water Quality and Environmental Flows
Albeni Falls Dam Operations
Drought in Upper Colorado Basin
State Agency Perspective of Estuary Program Subcommittees
Presentation transcript:

Environmental Flows Bruce A. Moulton Chief Engineer’s Office Texas Commission on Environmental Quality

Texas Estuaries: Case Study Named for river sources, not bays. 7 along 370 linear miles of coast. About 1 million acres in total.

Nueces Watershed History La Fruta Dam (old Lake Corpus Christi) –Built in 1935; storage capacity of ~55,000 acre-ft Wesley Seale Dam (Lake Corpus Christi) –Built in 1958; storage capacity of ~300,000 acre-ft (257,260) Choke Canyon Dam –Built in 1982; storage capacity of ~700,000 acre-ft (695,271)

Background Choke Canyon Water Right Permit issued: October 12, 1976 “Following completion and filling of Choke Canyon Dam and reservoir, scheduled releases shall be made from the reservoir system at Lake Corpus Christi Dam together with return flows to the estuaries for the proper ecological environment and health of related living resources therein.

Background (cont.) Water provided to the estuaries from the reservoir system under this paragraph shall be released in such quantities and in accordance with such operational procedures as may be ordered by the Commission. Permittees shall provide not less than 151,000 acre-feet of water per annum for the estuaries by a combination of releases and spills from the reservoir system at the Lake Corpus Christi Dam and return flows to Nueces and Corpus Christi Bays and other receiving estuaries.”

Nueces River Frio River Atascosa River Wesley Seale Dam Choke Canyon Dam Nueces Delta Nueces River Watershed

Nueces Delta and Estuary

Extreme Annual Variability

Effects on Estuary Inflow Average annual freshwater inflow into the Nueces Estuary has declined over the period of record. La FrutaLCCCC-LCC

Flooding Frequency (Average number of flood events per year)

Management History Physical construction of Choke Canyon reservoir completed (1982). Coalition About Restoration of Estuaries letter to TNRCC in 1989 questioning compliance with permit conditions TAC established and the first Commission Order issued requiring reservoir releases.

1992– Interim Agreed Order Implemented the Interim Reservoir System Operational Plan for freshwater inflows. Called for the Creation of an Estuarine Advisory Council (Nueces Estuary Advisory Council) Established to: “…consider such additional information and related issues and to formulate recommendations for the Commission’s review and action…”

NEAC Goals Preserve the ecological environment and health of related natural resources in the Nueces River Basin and Nueces Estuary Maintain and preserve (protect) a supply of water to meet the demands of identified beneficial uses in the Nueces River Basin and Corpus Christi area.

NEAC Goals (cont.) Minimize the release of stored waters consistent with the preservation of a healthy Nueces River Basin and Nueces Estuarine system. Protect the economic interests of all citizens that are dependent upon the Choke Canyon/Lake Corpus Christi reservoir system and the Nueces Estuary.

1995-Final Agreed Order KEY change from 1992 Order included a switch to the “Pass-Thru” approach (rather than releases from storage) and implementation of drought-contingency measures Continued the NEAC…to monitor implementation of the Order and to prepare recommendations, as needed, relating to any future changes to the Order

Current NEAC Membership TCEQ CBBEP CC Area Econ. Dev. Corp. GLO Port of CC City of CC Coastal Cons. Assoc. Nueces River Auth. UTMSI San Patricio MWD TWDB TAMU—CC City of Three Rivers S. TX Water Auth. Sierra Club

NEAC Membership (cont.) TPWD City of Mathis Coastal Bend Bays Foundation Private Citizens Save Lake Corpus Christi

Matters to be considered: The effectiveness of the inflow requirements contained in the Agreed Order on Nueces Estuary and any recommended changes; The effect of the releases from the Reservoir System upon the aquatic and wildlife habitat and other beneficial and recreational uses of Choke Canyon Reservoir and Lake Corpus Christi;

Matters (cont.) The development and implementation of a short and long-term regional water management plan for the Coastal Bend area; The salinity level to be applied for relief measures contained in the Agreed Order;

Matters (cont.) The feasibility of discharge at locations where the increased biological productivity justifies an inflow credit computed by multiplying the amount of discharge by a number greater than one; and Any other matters pertinent to the conditions contained in the Agreed Order

Agreed Order The City of Corpus Christi, as Operator of the Reservoir System, shall provide not less than 151, 000 acft of water per annum for the estuaries >70% storage capacity—138,000 acft target >40% but less than 70%--97,000 acft target >30% but less than 40%-- 1,200 acft target* <30%-- Total suspension of Pass-thrus* * Implementation of Lawn Watering Restrictions

Target f.w. Inflow Regime (acft) for the Nueces Estuary MONTH >70%>40-<70%>30-<40% <30% January 2,500 1,200 0 February 2,500 1,200 0 March 3,500 1,200 0 April 3,500 1,200 0 May 25,500 23, June 25,500 23,000 1,200 0 July 6,500 4,500 1,200 0 August 6,500 5,000 1,200 0 September 28,500 11,500 1,200 0 October 20,000 9,000 1,200 0 November 9,000 4,000 1,200 0 December 4,500 1,200 0 TOTAL 138,000 97,000 14,400 0

Public Reaction

Rincon Bayou Demonstration Project Restoring Freshwater to the upper Nueces Estuary U.S. Bureau of Reclamation

Rincon Bayou Demonstration Project To increase the opportunity for freshwater flow events into upper Nueces Delta via Rincon Bayou Restore estuarine conditions, increase productivity

Rincon Overflow Channel Nueces Overflow Channel

Project Features Nueces Overflow Channel –40-ft wide, 900-ft long –Increase the opportunity for freshwater flow events into the upper delta.

Project Features Rincon Overflow Channel –100-ft wide, 2000-ft long –Distributes freshwater within the upper delta.

Hydrography Increased freshwater/ decreased average salinity value from over 50 ppt to about 25 ppt. Restored duration and timing, but not volume.

Vegetation Communities Decreased soil salinity stimulated annual seed reproduction. Increases in vegetation percent cover and decreases in bare area after freshwater flow events.

Benthic Communities An inverse relationship was observed between salinity and –The number of individual benthic animals, and –The number of species of benthic animals. The function of the delta as nursery habitat was improved.

Conclusions - Ecology The “reverse estuary” condition largely corrected. A significant degree of estuarine function was restored to the delta. River Delta BayGulf Partially Restored Salinity Gradient

Flooding Frequency (Average number of flood events per year) nWith overflow channel

Synthesis of Results ATTRIBUTEBEFORE the Demonstration AFTER the Demonstration GeomorphologyDead-endFlow-through with free exchange Salinity gradientHigher in the upper delta than in the bay Lower in the upper delta than in the bay Nutrient cyclingRecycled nitrogenNew and recycled nitrogen Primary productionLow in marshHigher in marsh Secondary productionConstrained by dry conditions Increased by flow events Habitat utilizationConstrained by dry conditions Increased during spring and fall

Research indicated the Nueces Delta would benefit more if releases trigger “pulsed” flow events into the upper delta, especially during the spring and fall. Potential water resource development tool if water released has greater environmental value. Integration with Release Schedule

A Permanent Diversion Project Filled in Fall Rebuilt by City of Corpus Christi Fall 2001 for rule changes. Conservation groups trying to buy land. New monitoring program. Ecological credits?

Management History – Cont order amended to increase firm yield by 3,000 ac-ft/y and change drought plan in exchange for diversion of river water to delta (Rincon Bayou) for environmental purposes. Levels automatically trigger drought plan and relief from releases. Less water, but more environmental benefit. Public still not happy.

“Adaptive Management” The Nueces Delta is an ideal place to determine how to most effectively balance human need for freshwater resources with environmental needs.