Science, Technology and Innovation (STI) Indicators Training Workshop (Cairo; September 28-30, 2009) National Council for Scientific Research (CNRS), Lebanon Ms. Rabab Majzoub & Ms. Rula Atweh Central Administration for Statistics (CAS), Lebanon Dr. Alissar Nasser & Dr. Ziad Abdallah

The National Council for Scientific Research CNRS The CNRS is an autonomous public institution created in 1962 under the direct authority of the Prime Minister. The CNRS is in charge of elaborating the national science and technology policy in Lebanon. The Government asks for its expertise in all subjects pertaining to science and technology. There are four specialized centers in the CNRS that carry out researches and programs having a socio- economic impact on the development of the country.

OVERVIEW Board of Administration: where decision making authority of the CNRS is vested. General Secretariat: prepares and implements annual programmes submitted to and approved by the board of administration. The office of the Secretary General operates though five major divisions and its research centers: 1.National Center for Geophysics 2.National Center for Marine Sciences 3.National Center for Remote Sensing 4.Lebanese Atomic Energy Comission – CLEA Centers Programmes 1.Grant Research Programme (GRP) 2.Associate Research Units (ARU) 3.Scholarships 4.Publications 5.Science, Technology and Innovation Policy (STIP) 6.LORDI

GRP CNRS Accepted Projects by Discipline

1.Guiding National Science policy and Public Research 2.Conducting and Granting Research Projects 3.Allocating External and Internal Scholarship Programs 4.Establishing Science, Technology and Innovation Policy 5.Establishing National, Regional, and International Bilateral Cooperation Programs 6.Issuing Scientific Publications 7.Conduct specialized research through its centers (4) CNRS General Mandate

CNRS policy to sustain Science Technology and Innovation (STI) Meant to formulate a comprehensive plan to involve Science, Technology and Innovation Policy (STIP) in the National Socio-Economic Development through: Setting the Objectives: Concepts Adopted in STIP implementation Meeting the Challenges and Needs of the Lebanese Market Initiating the Plan Implementing, Monitoring and Evaluation

In preparing the STIP, these scientists and experts undertook elaborate Strength, Weakness, Opportunity and Threats Analysis (SWOT) of most relevant societal needs, to formulate priority scientific research programmes that were incorporated in the STIP plan of actions. The Plan is an outcome of a joint effort of some 30 Lebanese professional scientists and international experts - who worked together for three years in three task forces, namely Basic Sciences, Industry and Engineering, Environment and Agriculture, and Health and Medical Sciences

Recommendation of the STIP: Establishing the core of the Lebanese STI Observatory Two pieces of analysis are needed:  An analysis of research activities and research outputs in Lebanon in the last 5 years  Identify what human resources and infrastructure facilities exist in Lebanon A Project Document has been developed by the CNRS, through an ESCWA technical assistance with International Experts. Lebanese Observatory for Research, Development and Innovation: LORDI

Main Challenge Private Institutions Public Institutions CNRS Reliable Statistics and Indicators

Objective: To set-up the LORDI to be in charge of producing reliable statistics on resources (inputs) and production (outputs) in science and technology; maintaining an inventory of the main R&D resources and skills in both the academic and business sectors; and conducting analysis of the R&D system in Lebanon as requested by concerned institutions.

Outcomes: The national S&T potential of Lebanon assessed and the ability to meet the challenges of the socio-economic development determined Government ability to monitor and evaluate the implementation of its science and technology policy through enhanced R&D input and output indicators Statistical base for an R&D strategy for Lebanese Institutions and businesses Outputs: List of Indicators (inputs and outputs) developed and validated Database of scientific indicators and measurement developed and functioning The skills of core personnel enhanced in data collection and analysis Website, periodic reports and relevant analytical studies published and disseminated

Production of S&T indicators in Lebanon Macro scale (country) for regional or international comparisons Micro scale (by institution, discipline, or sectoral) Input Indicators (Frascati)  The expenditure of R & D which must be consolidated by origin of financing (public-private, national, international), by sector (academic, private public, companies), and by fields/disciplines;  Personnel of R & D (by sector and by fields/disciplines); Output Indicators (Bibliometrics)  Scientific production (by institutions and discipline)  Visibility of the scientific production (index of impact)  Technological production: national and international patents Other indicators (Innovation Surveys)  Indicators of economic impact of R&D: creation of companies, modernization, transfers of research, financing by private sector. Innovation Indicators (OsloManual)  Cooperation indicators: national, regional and international co-operation, through co-publications and co-financing)

Management Plan: A Project Team will be set up and entrusted with the overall supervision and implementation of the project. Staffing / Unit of Management of the LORDI:  The Director (Named by the Board of Directors of the CNRS for a period of Two Years – renewable)  Administrator  1 or 2 persons in Charge of Mission (with expertise in one of the following: evaluation of public policy, economy of innovation, statistician / indicator specialist  Data Processing Specialist (responsible for the development and maintenance of the database, and statistical analysis)  Others (ex. a creation of a network of university professors working under the Director)

Stakeholders Identified: (Steering Committee)  CNRS Representatives (Secretary General, Administration and others)  Representatives of principal ministries and authorities concerned in R&D (Ministry of Education and Higher Education, Ministry of Industry, Ministry of Economy and Trade, Central Statistical Administration, Ministry of Public Health, Ministry of Environment, etc...)  Representative of principal academic institutions, public and private (ex. Lebanese University, American University of Beirut, Université Saint Joseph, Lebanese Agricultural Research Institute, Industrial Research Institute, Lebanese American University, Beirut Arab University, Balamand University, University Saint Esprit de Kaslik and others)  Representatives from the industrial sector (Association of Lebanese Industrialists, Order of Engineers)

The role of the LORDI will be at several levels: Up streaming the collection of data Direct responsibility for the collection of certain data (for example concerning the industries); Development and maintenance of the data bases on a national scale; Assembly of the data and development of the indicators. (The role/function of the LORDI will need to be further defined and elaborated as part of the next steps)

Parallel initiatives: ESTIME: Evaluation of Science and Technological Capabilities in Mediterranean Countries MIRA: Mediterranean Innovation and Research Coordination Action

Mandate of the central Administration of Statistics- Lebanon To assume itself or in cooperation with the involved administrations to set forth all statistics related to the economical and social life of the country. To unify the data bases related to institutions or individuals used in the administrations to extract the statistical data from it, and to supervise technically the statistics that the administrations lay down and to centralize and coordinate it. To set up the internal economical accountings (the national accounts), the balance of payments, and the other annual statement regarding the economical and social activities of the country. To carry out the statistics, investigations, and studies requested by the Council of Development and Reconstruction, and the other economical studies requested by the other administrations. To carry out mandatory statistical surveying, should be considered as mandatory any statistical survey carried out by the central administrations of statistics directly, or through another institution, and published in the official journal. Analysis and publication of the statistics that are laid down. To contribute, with the Civil Service Council, to the preparation and training of the employees working with statistical units related to the administrations.

Role of CAS in STI projects There is real need to improve service statistics on STIs in order to expand the coverage and improve reliability. CAS helps in the development of indicators to benchmark innovation performance. It is essential to involve CAS in the analysis and conceptual phases of STI projects.

R& D Registered companies in Lebanon

Thank You Rabab Majzoub, Grant Research Programme / ARU & Rula Atweh, Coordinator - MIRA Project National Council for Scientific Research, CNRS P.O.Box , Ryad El Solh Beirut, Lebanon Tel: (Ext. 312) Fax: s: Dr. Alissar Nasser, Analyst Dr. Ziad Abdallah, Statistician Central Administration of Statistics Army Street, Kantari Finance and Commerce Building, 5 th Floor Beirut, Lebanon s: