AAN –Toronto, April 11, 2010 Development of a harmonized protocol for hippocampal tracing An EADC-ADNI joint effort INTRODUCTION.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Agenda: - Certification Platform: performance for training - I round - II round -Feedback from naives - Beta testers proposals - Congress presentations.
Advertisements

Agenda: - Update master tracers - Update validation vs pathology - Hippocampal 3D Object for AR Visualization - Papers - Next congress presentations &
National Alliance for Medical Image Computing Diffusion Weighted MRI.
Development of a harmonized protocol for hippocampal tracing An EADC-ADNI joint effort 4 th Meeting, Paris, July 20, 2011 Principal Investigators: Giovanni.
Agenda: - Validation vs Pathology - Congress presentations & Meetings - Paper publication VI PMT meeting – Feb 1, 2011.
Answers to previous TC issues: - Demographic features of the selected subjects (age, sex, disease, ApoE) - Check for SIEMENS-Allegra scans at 3T for the.
Development of a harmonized protocol for hippocampal tracing An EADC-ADNI joint effort 3 rd Meeting, Honolulu, April 13, 2011 Principal Investigators:
Agenda: - Update on master tracers’ segmentation check - Update validation vs pathology - PMT application submission of “Study on the validation of VSRAD”
The BRAINs Orientation
Agenda: - New benchmark ICC and Dice’s - Training set for Naïve - Beta testers proposals - Congress presentations XII PMT meeting – September 26, 2012.
Agenda: - Axes check - Validation vs Pathology - Paper Publications - Congress presentations & Meetings VII PMT meeting – Feb 29, 2012.
Agenda: - Validation Harmonized Protocol: update - Validation vs pathology - Hippocampal Label Expansion project: update - News - Congress presentations.
Integrated Studies Applied Neuroscience Seminar Evan Fletcher, Mario Ortega Dr. Charles DeCarli, IDeA Lab Director.
Agenda: - Certification Platform: Training - I round - Beta testers proposals - Congress presentations - Paper “check for axes” XIII PMT meeting – October.
PVEOut project, EU IBB, 2004 Cortical GABA-A CBZR and rCBF in Alzheimer`s disease: SPET studies with Partial Volume Effect Correction Mario Quarantelli.
Disclosures/Conflicts Consulting: GE Healthcare Bayer Abbott Elan/Janssen Synarc Genentech Merck.
Alzheimer’s Disease Neuroimaging Initiative STEERING COMMITTEE April
Diffusion Tractography of the Fornix in Male Schizophrenic Patients Background: White matter fiber tracts, especially those interconnecting the frontal.
Newly Described Anatomic Signs Reliably Define Temporal Lobe Anatomy in Multiple Planes on MRI Vance T. Lehman, MD Kirk M. Welker, MD David F. Black, MD.
Brain Changes in 676 ADNI subjects: Summary of 10 Studies using Tensor Based Morphometry & Automated Hippocampal Maps Paul Thompson and the UCLA ADNI.
Development of a harmonized protocol for hippocampal tracing An EADC-ADNI joint effort 1 th Project Management Team Meeting August 31, 2011.
IST8A Fall 2008 Introduction to the Brain. Outline of Topics 1.Imaging: postmortem and MRI 2.Brain Macro anatomy – lobes, tissues, cortex, hippocampus,
Mapping the correlations between CSF Abeta and tau and hippocampal atrophy in 282 ADNI subjects Liana G. Apostolova, Amity E. Green, Kristy S. Hwang, Jonathan.
A New Method for Mapping the Linkage between Abnormal Gray Matter Loss and the Clinical and Cognitive Deficits in Childhood-Onset Schizophrenia 1 Christine.
Susceptibility Induced Loss of Signal: Comparing PET and fMRI on a Semantic Task Devlin et al. (in press)
Quantitative analysis of radiologic images: Image segmentation and registration, statistical atlases Christos Davatzikos, Ph.D. Professor of Radiology.
Agenda: - Axes check - Validation vs Pathology - Publication Policy - Paper Publications - Congress presentations & Meetings VIII PMT meeting – Mar 21,
AAN –Toronto, April 11, 2010 Development of a harmonized protocol for hippocampal tracing An EADC-ADNI joint effort INTRODUCTION.
Imaging Anatomy of the CNS
MRI as a Potential Surrogate Marker in the ADCS MCI Trial
Wei Chen CCNI Journal Club Alzheimer’s disease (AD): imaging & cognition imaging & cognition.
Jalal Jalal Shokouhi – MD
AAN –Toronto, April 11, 2010 Development of a harmonized protocol for hippocampal tracing An EADC-ADNI joint effort METHODS.
Maquire, Gadian, Johnsrude, Good,Ashburner, Frackowiak & Frith Navigation-Related Structural Changes in the Hippocampi of taxi-drivers Zachary Saadon Brian.
conflicts of interest to report.
References [1] Coupé et al., An optimized blockwise nonlocal means denoising filter for 3-D magnetic resonance images. IEEE TMI, 27(4):425–441, 2008.
ANTERIOR CINGULATE The Anterior Cingulate Cortex (ACC) resembles a collar around the Corpus Collosum. The ACC is an area of profound biological importance.
2 Limbic System Limbic lobe Hippocampal formatiom Hipocampus.
White Matter Structural Integrity in Healthy Aging Adults and Patients With Alzheimer Disease: A Magnetic Resonance Imaging Study Bartzokis, et al. UCLA.
Development of the hippocampal region demonstrated by fetal MRI D. Bajic, N. Canto Moreira, J. Wikström, R. Raininko.
Apolipoprotein E and Gray Matter Loss in Mild Cognitive Impairment and Alzheimer’s Disease Spampinato MV, Goldsberry G, Mintzer J, Rumboldt Z Medical University.
National Alliance for Medical Image Computing Volumetric Studies.
Hippocampal Contouring: A Contouring Atlas for RTOG 0933
Maguire Physiological Psychology The Core Studies.
Advanced brain imaging and neurodegenerative disorders. Dott.ssa Ingrid Inches.
MRI IMAGING OF THE LUMBAR SPINE USING A LOW-FIELD DEDICATED TILTING SCANNER: COMPUTED ASSISTED MORPHOMETRIC EVALUATION OF POSITIONAL CHANGES (1) Institute.
CASES SERIES BRAIN FDG PET SCAN IN DEMENTIA PATIENTS
Baseline and longitudinal patterns of brain atrophy in MCI patients, and their use in prediction of Short- term conversion to AD: Results from ADNI Xuejiao.
Introduction  Recent neuroimaging studies of memory retrieval have reported the activation of a medial and left – lateralised memory network that includes.
Imaging in Medial Temporal Epilepsy
Date of download: 7/8/2016 Copyright © ASME. All rights reserved. From: Voxelized Model of Brain Infusion That Accounts for Small Feature Fissures: Comparison.
DECIDE: "Scientific and Clinical Perspectives“: Claudio Babiloni (UNIFG) and Giovanni Frisoni (IRCCS Brescia)
Hippocampal Contouring: A Contouring Atlas for RTOG 0933
Hippocampal Contouring: A Contouring Atlas for RTOG 0933
Imaging Anatomy of the CNS
MORPHOMETRIC brain volume measurements in medical cadaveric scans WITH DEMENTIA and metabolic syndrome Natasa Dragicevic* MD PhD, Joe Grajo*
FIGURE 1. Homonymous hemianopsia after LITT for TLE
BRIEF INTRO TO CORTICAL NEUROANATOMY
- Volumetric MRI Analysis of The Prefrontal Cortex in Patients With
Date of download: 10/24/2017 Copyright © ASME. All rights reserved.
Volume 21, Issue 4, Pages xv-xxiii (December 1998)
Magnetic Resonance Imaging Clinics
Detecting Gray Matter Maturation via Tensor-based Surface Morphometry
Michael Ewers, Reisa A. Sperling, William E. Klunk, Michael W
Cerebral Cortex.
Four-point subjective rating scale of the perihippocampal fissures (PHF).A and B, Axial and coronal view of same case. Four-point subjective rating scale.
César F. Lima, Saloni Krishnan, Sophie K. Scott 
Z-score brain surface map represents the result of group comparison between 2 healthy subjects groups such as control group (CG) and data base group (DBG).
Clusters of reduced grey matter concentration in the medial temporal region in patients with Alzheimer’s disease (n = 9) relative to healthy controls (n.
Case 2. Case 2. A, Coronal unenhanced T1-weighted image through the base of the skull. The left pterygopalatine fossa appears infiltrated by soft tissue.
Presentation transcript:

AAN –Toronto, April 11, 2010 Development of a harmonized protocol for hippocampal tracing An EADC-ADNI joint effort INTRODUCTION

Structure: MR hippo volumetry Biochemistry: CSF tau/Abeta Function: FDG PET Amyloid deposits: PET BACKGROUND Hippocampal volume as a diagnostic marker Dubois, Feldman et al., Lancet Neurol 2007

Geuze et al., Mol Psychiatry 2005;10: Ref.Med border Lat border Inf border Norm. hippo vol (cm 3 ) LeftRight Watson et al. Mesial edge of temporal lobe Temp horn of lat ventr Incl subicular complex & uncal cleft w/ border separating subicular complex from parahippo gyrus Zipursky et al. Regional outline at choroidal fissure Not mentioned The interface of hippocampal tissue and parahippocampal gyrus white matter BACKGROUND The effect of segmentation protocols on hippocampal volume

BACKGROUND Hippocampal volume as an outcome measure in trials of disease modifiers DrugStudyEffectSegment. methodRef TramiprosateAlphase 68% (100 mg) 120% (150 mg) Not mentionedGauthier et al., JNHA 2009 AtorvastatinADCLT “CHV* mm³ -134±174 vs - 583±354 p>.05” Manual protocol Insausti et al., 1998 AJNR; Machulda et al., 2001, Neuroimage Sparks et.a,l CCJM,2008 LEADe “significant at p<.05” MIDAS (semiautomated) Jones et al., Alz&Dem 2008 Feldman et al., Neurology 2010 AN1792 “CHV* % 3.78±2.63 vs 2.86±3.19 p = 0.124” Manual protocol Watson et al., 1992, Neurology Fox N et al., Neurology, 2005 Xaliproden Sanofi- Aventis Trials “significant atrophy” §Not mentionedFrom Vellas B et al. (Review), Lancet Neurol.,2008 Donepezil “CHV* % -6.14±3.49vs ±2.28 p= 0.07” ε4 carriers only Manual protocol Jack et al., 1989;Radiology Jack et al., 2004; Neurology Jack CR et al., Neurobiol. Aging, 2008 * CHV= Change in hippocampal volume; § referenced link not working

BACKGROUND Hippocampal volume (manual segmentation) as gold standard for automated segmentation algorithms Morey et al., NeuroImage 2009

To Harmonize Available Protocols for Manual Hippocampal Segmentation To Test the Validity of the Harmonized Protocol AIMS

F Barkhof/P ScheltensAmsterdam B Dubois/S LehericiParis N FoxLondon GB Frisoni Brescia H Hampel/J PantelFrankfurt A SimmonsLondon H SoininenKuopio S TeipelRostock LO WahlundStockholm THE WORKGROUP EADC

CR Jack Jr Rochester, MN G Barzokis UCLA, CA D Bennet Chicago, IL J Csernansky NorthW U, WA C DeCarli UC Davis, CA M De Leon New York, NY J Kaye Portland, OR R Killiany Boston USM, MA PM Thompson LoNI, UCLA, CA M Weiner/S Mueller UCSF/VAMC THE WORKGROUP ADNI

THE WORKGROUP other relevant hippo experts R CamicioliUniv Alberta, Canada J O’BrienNewCastle, UK J PruessnerMcGill, QC, Canada

EADC-ADNI P.I.s B VellasToulouse, France B WinbladStockholm, Sweden M WeinerUCSF, US Population-based studies M Breteler/ T Den HeijerRotterdam Scan Study P Sachdev/ JJ Maller PATH through life L LaunerNIA Bethesda W JagustBerkeley THE WORKGROUP Advisory Boards

Statistical Board S DuchesneLaval Univ, Canada L CollinsMNI, McGill, Montreal P PasqualettiAFaR, Rome Clinical Advisor PJ VisserMaastricht, The Netherlands Dissemination/Education G WaldemarCopenhagen, Denmark THE WORKGROUP Boards

Marina Boccardi psychologist, PhD Rossana Ganzola psychologist Enrica Cavedopsychologist Michela Pievanimathematician Anna Carolimathematician Alberto Redolfibioinformaticist THE WORKGROUP Personnel in Brescia

AAN –Toronto, April 11, 2010 Development of a harmonized protocol for hippocampal tracing An EADC-ADNI joint effort METHODS

Operationalization of protocols’ differences and extraction of tracing units Quantification of tracing units’ features Harmonized protocol METHODS

Selection criteria i)Being based on 3D T1 MRI with field strength greater than 1 Tesla ii)Providing explicit description of landmarks for tracing of hippocampal borders iii)Being validated on AD/MCI samples, or being widely adopted in the literature about AD. OPERATIONALIZATION Selection of segmentation protocols

Plane of tracing: AC-PC line; Normalization to the Talairach space Tracing start from the tail of hippocampus to the hippocampal head In the following slices, you can find the hippocampal tracing on consecutive coronal slices (1.5T) of the control subject and AD patient according to Pruessner's criteria OPERATIONALIZATION Protocols’ features extraction

Tracings carried out on a control and an AD subject from the ADNI dataset Tracings sent to the Authors for correction or approval OPERATIONALIZATION Prototypical tracings

CTRL Most posterior slice : slice where an ovoid mass of gray matter (1) started to appear inferomedially of the atrium of lateral ventricle (2) Sagittal view 2= Atrium of lateral ventricle 4= Parahippocampal gyrus 5= Gyrus dentatus 6= Cornu Ammonis 7= Gyrus fasciolaris 8= Gyrus of Andreas-Retzius 9= Isthmus The fornix can be excluded by a horizontal line (in fuchsia) from the superior border of the quadrigeminal cistern (3) to the lateral ventricle (2). Part of gyrus fasciolaris (7) and of Andreas-Retzius gyrus (8) can be excluded by a vertical line (in red) from the medial end of the lateral ventricle (2) down to the parahippocampal gyrus (4).

AD Most posterior slice : slice where an ovoid mass of gray matter (1) started to appear inferomedially of the atrium of lateral ventricle (2) 2= Atrium of lateral ventricle 4= Parahippocampal gyrus 5= Gyrus dentatus 6= Cornu Ammonis 7= Gyrus fasciolaris 8= Gyrus of Andreas Retzius 9= Isthmus Sagittal view In AD subjects the cerebral structures are atrophic, lateral ventricle (2) and ambient cistern (3) result enlarged. Therefore, the lines used to exclude the gyrus fasciolaris, the Andreas- Retzius gyrus and the fornix do not intersect the hippocampal tail. That being so, is there another way to exclude the gyrus fasciolaris, the Andreas-Retzius gyrus and the fornix in these subjects?

For each protocol: features extraction, tracing and author’s certification AD CTRL X 10 OPERATIONALIZATION Authors’ check

OPERATIONALIZATION Extraction of similarities and differences Harmonized language Reduction of redundancy Tracing units and subunits

OPERATIONALIZATION Extraction of similarities and differences

Plane of tracing Axis of hippocampus [B,C,J,L,S] AC-PC line [H,K,M,Pa,Pr] Most posterior slice Where inferior and superior colliculi are jointly visualized [B] Where crus of fornix is visible in full profile [C,K,L] Where the crura of the fornices are seen in full profile on both sides [J,S] Where gray matter is visible inferomedially to the trigone of the lateral ventricle [H,M,Pa,Pr] Superior border Lower border of alveus/fimbria [B,H,K,Pa,S] Upper border of alveus/fimbria [C,J,L,M,Pr] Horizontal line from the superior border of the quadrigeminal cistern to the lateral ventricle (tail) [Pr] Separation subiculum/enthorinal cortex vertical line from the CA to the WM of the parahippocampal gyrus [C] 45° line connecting the most inferior part of the subiculum medially to the cistern (head and body) [Pr] Oblique line with same inclination of parahippocampal WM, connecting the inferior part of the subiculum to the quadrigeminal cistern [K,L,M ¥ ] Orizontal line from the highest medial point of the parahippocampal WM to the cistern [B,H,J ¥ ] Line outlining the contour of white matter of parahippocampal gyrus [Pa,S]

Operationalization of protocols’ differences Quantification of tracing units’ features Harmonized protocol METHODS

Contribution to hippo volume in control and AD Effect on re-test variability Contribution to differences between AD and controls QUANTIFICATION OF TRACING UNITS’ FEATURES

Operationalization of protocols’ differences Quantification of tracing units’ features Harmonized protocol METHODS

Participants to a Delphi panel based on: expertise in hippocampal anatomy manual tracing scientific production Assisted decisions based on: Low variability, highly informative....included in harmonized protocol High variability, little informative....excluded from harmonized prot HARMONIZED PROTOCOL

Validation with neuropathological data Comparison with currently used protocols Public tracings and probability maps Standard environment for tracing, learning, and certification HARMONIZED PROTOCOL Validation & implementation

AAN –Toronto, April 11, 2010 Development of a harmonized protocol for hippocampal tracing An EADC-ADNI joint effort EARLY RESULTS

Protocols’ features extraction & differences operationalization Modeling & computations of the operationalized differences Discussion EARLY RESULTS

B Bartzokis G, et al. Psychiatry Res 1998;82:11-24 C Convit A, et al. Neurobiol Aging 1997;18:131-8 HHaller JW, et al. Radiology 1997;202: JJack CR Jr. Epilepsia 1994;35 - Suppl 6:S21-9 KKilliany RJ, et al. Arch Neurol 1993;50: LLehéricy S, et al. Am J Neuroradiol 1994;15: MMalykhin NV, et al. Psychiatry Res 2007;155: PaPantel J, et al. Hippocampus 2000;10:752-8 PrPruessner JC, et al. Cereb Cortex 2000;10: SSoininen HS, et al. Neurology 1994;44: PROTOCOLS’ FEATURES EXTRACTION

PROTOCOLS’ FEATURES EXTRACTION

Harmonized language Reduction of redundancy Tracing units and subunits

Plane of tracing Axis of hippocampus [B,C,J,L,S] AC-PC line [H,K,M,Pa,Pr] Most posterior slice Where inferior and superior colliculi are jointly visualized [B] Where crus of fornix is visible in full profile [C,K,L] Where the crura of the fornices are seen in full profile on both sides [J,S] Where gray matter is visible inferomedially to the trigone of the lateral ventricle [H,M,Pa,Pr] Superior border Lower border of alveus/fimbria [B,H,K,Pa,S] Upper border of alveus/fimbria [C,J,L,M,Pr] Horizontal line from the superior border of the quadrigeminal cistern to the lateral ventricle (tail) [Pr] Separation subiculum/enthorinal cortex vertical line from the CA to the WM of the parahippocampal gyrus [C] 45° line connecting the most inferior part of the subiculum medially to the cistern (head and body) [Pr] Oblique line with same inclination of parahippocampal WM, connecting the inferior part of the subiculum to the quadrigeminal cistern [K,L,M ¥ ] Orizontal line from the highest medial point of the parahippocampal WM to the cistern [B,H,J ¥ ] Line outlining the contour of white matter of parahippocamp al gyrus [Pa,S]

No longer an issue thanks to software for 3D navigation PROTOCOLS’ FEATURES EXTRACTION Most anterior slice

H. Haller-Csernansky et al 1997 K. Killiany et al 1993 M. Malykhin et al 2007 Pa. Pantel et al 2000 Pr. Pruessner et al 2000 B. Bartzokis et al 1998 C. Convit et al 1997 J. Jack 1994 L. Lehéricy et al 1994 S. Soininen H et al 1994 Axis of hippocampusAC-PC PROTOCOLS’ FEATURES EXTRACTION Plane of tracing

PROTOCOLS’ FEATURES EXTRACTION Most posterior slice

A. Level where the inferior (1) and superior (2) colliculi are jointly visualized [B] B. Slice where the crus of fornix is visible in full profile (3) [C, K, L] C. Slice where the crura of fornices on both sides are seen in full profile (4, 5) [J, S] D. Slice where an ovoid mass of gray matter (6) appears inferomedially to the trigone of the lateral ventricle (posterior to anterior) [H, M, Pa, Pr]

Yellow = Alveus PROTOCOLS’ FEATURES EXTRACTION Alveus

Yellow = Fimbria PROTOCOLS’ FEATURES EXTRACTION Fimbria

PROTOCOLS’ FEATURES EXTRACTION Upper border

PROTOCOLS’ FEATURES EXTRACTION Medial border Vertical line [C] 45° line [Pr] Line with same inclination WM [K, L, M] Horizontal line [B, H, J] Morphological details [Pa, S]

EARLY RESULTS Protocols’ features extraction & differences operationalization Modeling & computations of the operationalized differences Discussion

Plane of tracing Axis of hippocampus [B,C,J,L,S] AC-PC line [H,K,M,Pa,Pr] Most posterior slice Where inferior and superior colliculi are jointly visualized [B] Where crus of fornix is visible in full profile [C,K,L] Where the crura of the fornices are seen in full profile on both sides [J,S] Where gray matter is visible inferomedially to the trigone of the lateral ventricle [H,M,Pa,Pr] Superior border Lower border of alveus/fimbria [B,H,K,Pa,S] Upper border of alveus/fimbria [C,J,L,M,Pr] Separation subiculum/enthorinal cortex vertical line from the CA to the WM of the parahippocampal gyrus [C] 45° line connecting the most inferior part of the subiculum medially to the cistern (head and body) [Pr] Oblique line with same inclination of parahippocampal WM, connecting the inferior part of the subiculum to the quadrigeminal cistern [K,L,M ¥ ] Orizontal line from the highest medial point of the parahippocampal WM to the cistern [B,H,J ¥ ] Line outlining the contour of white matter of parahippocampal gyrus [Pa,S] MODELING & COMPUTATIONS

Modeling by Simon Duchesne and Nicolas Robitaille Université Laval and Centre de Recherche Université Laval – Robert Giffard Quebec City, Canada

MODELING & COMPUTATIONS

J Pr M PaH BCK L S MODELING & COMPUTATIONS

DISCUSSION Features operationalization: 4 tracing units, and subunits Preliminary info on contribution of units to total hippo volume 3D models may help Delphi panel for developing harmonized protocol Available: draft paper, and online material

April 14: Poster 24 PO3: Ageing and dementia imaging - other

Lilly International Wyeth International ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS