IREG Forum University Rankings, Warsaw 16 -17 May 2013 Positional impact of reputation in global university rankings Philippe Vidal and Ghislaine Filliatreau.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

EuroPa - Establishment of an European Network of Excellence Müller, M.(1), Neumann, H.(2), Jungraithmeier, T., Almann, F. J., Wagner, M., Smith, S. (1)

Advertisements

Current initiatives in rankings: how do you see them from the perspective of your agency? Tia Loukkola 28 September 2009.

What is the capital of the UK? London What is the capital of France? Paris.

Państwa w Europie Countries in Europe There are 47 countries althogether Karolina Klasa.

The baby-boomer generation and family support - a European perspective Jim OGG, Young Foundation, London and Caisse Nationale d’Assurance Vieillesse, Paris.

The Comparison of European Countries on the Base Human Development Index Zlata Sojková, Zlata Kropková Slovak University of Agriculture, Nitra, Slovak.

Lisbon, July 13th, 2005 Global Entrepreneurship Monitor Portugal 2004.

What does it take to make online deliberation happen? -A comparative analysis of 28 online discussion forums Martin Karlsson PhD Student in.

Hanns-D. Jacobsen – - Cold War: CoCom COCOM The „Coordinating Committee on Multilateral Export Controls“ Prof. Dr. Hanns-D.

ACCENT/GLOREAM 2006, October, Paris Photo-oxidants formation and transport over Europe during the heat wave period in July 2006 Joanna Struzewska.

Aid Effectiveness in Africa African Union Commission Department of Economic Affairs November 24, 2011 By Lulit Bereda.

Statistical Information and some methodological considerations.

Macroeconomic Measurement: Environmental and Social Dimensions

Edouard Mathieu Head of the Benchmarking Center Invest in France Agency * ARWU: Academic Ranking of World Universities 2005 A few remarks on ARWU*

Table 12.1: Ranking of countries by happiness, World Values Survey Sample The Economics of Immigration, by Bansak, Simpson & Zavodny ©2015 Country Average.

When was the European Union formed? About fifty years ago in Where was the European Union? Belgium, France, Germany, Italy, Luxembourg, and The.

Students’ understanding of decimal numbers – a longitudinal study of learning Kaye Stacey University of Melbourne Australia.

Porto, October 18th, 2005 Global Entrepreneurship Monitor Portugal 2004.

De Nederlandsche Bank Eurosysteem RETAIL PAYMENTS – costs and revenues Carlo Winder Conference Financial Sector of Macedonia on Payments and Securities.

MEDIA Salles is an initiative of the MEDIA Programme of the European Union with the support of the Italian Government

Global Science Forum OECD Global Science Forum Study on Declining interest in science studies Preliminary Report on the Quantitative Analysis Prof. Jean-Jacques.

Change and Globalisation: is HRM converging?

Innovation for Growth – i4g Universities are portfolios of (largely heterogeneous) disciplines. Further problems in university rankings Warsaw, 16 May.

Ipsos Survey A study of the Business Section of the Your Europe Portal. 1.

Research Data Centre network for transnational access - four years of experiences by seven European RDCs Karen Dennison (UK Data Archive) and David Schiller.

Impact of civic & cultural education on social cohesion Bryony Hoskins, LLAKES, Institute of Education, University of London.

Countries of Europe France Spain Italy Germany Which country is this?

European County Research Project. Task Your job is to research a country from Europe. Your job is to research a country from Europe. You will be exploring.

Europe Map By: Ms. Kelly. Can you name this country? 1 France.

Comparative Policy Evaluation: Constructing Indices Alison Smith Social Policy University of Edinburgh.

WHAT’S THE ECONOMY FOR, ANYWAY? Part 3 of 3. Life Expectancy at Birth (2004) Rank 1Spain (80.3)9Netherlands (78.6) 2Sweden (80.2)10Finland (78.5) 3Italy.

1 МOSCOW 2009 MODERN UNIVERSITY FOR THE HUMANITIES MODERN UNIVERSITY FOR THE HUMANITIES Higher education in the world countries: Higher education in the.

The strength of the EU economy on global scale The EU is the world´s largest economy - 20 % of world GDP World´s largest trading block Between.

ASTRONET Coordinating Strategic Planning for European Astronomy T HE N ETWORKING.

1 Impact of methodological choices on road safety ranking SAMO conference: 20/06/07 Elke Hermans: Transportation.

Political Map of Europe Western European Countries.

© World Energy Council 2014 Energy Security in Focus: from Local to Global The Baltic States as the testing ground for more balanced energy policy Einari.

Oversampling the capital cities in the EU SAfety SUrvey (EU-SASU) Task Force on Victimization Eurostat, February 2010 Guillaume Osier Service Central.

Carbon Pricing Forum November 2, 2015 Berkeley CA Peter Barnes.

COUNTRIES WHERE ARE YOU FROM?.

Labor Force... Economics 102, Winter 2009B, E, F: Smitka.

European Survey FENCA Number of respondents Austria 0 Belgium 0 Czech Republic 4 France 11 Germany 103 Greece 0 Italy 30 Netherlands 0 Norway.

Northern Europe Label the following countries on the next page, using the color each countries is labeled in, then add capitals to each country using a.

1 Consumer Preference & Packaging in Europe © InSites Consulting Europeans vote for glass Recommendation of glass (results per country) Q : Would you recommend.

The Changing Face of the International System. In the next 9 slides you will be looking at maps of the international system from 1772 to the year 2000.

1© GfK 2016 | Concerns about safety and security Concerns about safety and security Global GfK survey July 2016.

Project number: FR01-KA REALISE Realising the potential of the international mobility of staff in higher education.

International marketing and core debate: adaptation versus homogenization Elena Horská.

Do secular people have Protestant values?

Countries and Capitals of Western Europe

Philippe Vidal and Ghislaine Filliatreau

Can you identify the following physical features of Europe

The Most Visited Countries

Bric's Countries in the Webometrics Ranking of World Universities

Selection of cities Anastasios Maroudas Eurogramme

Regions of Europe By: D. Price.

الجودة في التدريس الجامعي ضمن أعمال ملتقى التطوير والجودة الأول

4.8% 6.9 MILLION OLIVE OIL Evolution 2016 versus 2015 PRICE INCREASE

EU: First- & Second-Generation Immigrants

Today is a special day ... It is the 10 year anniversary of ...

Do Now for Monday, October 10

London Water Directors Meeting

Cost Effectiveness Analysis Questionnaire Results

Quiz on Physical Features of Europe

Map Quiz March 1.

One of these things is not like the other!

By Prof. Danuta Hübner Brussels, 30 May 2007

GNP and per capita GNP Top of the world!?.

2006 Rank Adjusted for Purchasing Power

Presentation transcript:

IREG Forum University Rankings, Warsaw May 2013 Positional impact of reputation in global university rankings Philippe Vidal and Ghislaine Filliatreau Observatoire des Sciences et Techniques, Paris

IREG Forum University Rankings, Warsaw May 2013 Reputation is an idle and most false imposition, oft got without merit, and lost without deserving Shakespeare, Othello, II, 3

IREG Forum University Rankings, Warsaw May 2013 In Global university rankings and their impact. Report II, EUA Report on rankings Superficial descriptions of methodology and poor indicators …. Use of poor indicators also persists. In spite of widespread criticisms, reliance on reputation is becoming more and more widespread…..

IREG Forum University Rankings, Warsaw May 2013 Rankings graphical comparison as an approach for deconvoluting ranking patterns Reputation surveys: ARWU: 0%, THE: 34.5%, QS: 40% Webometrics taken as a proxy for reputation Facts vs reputation

IREG Forum University Rankings, Warsaw May 2013 Methodology 1 Ternary diagrams

IREG Forum University Rankings, Warsaw May 2013 Methodology 2 Ranking A vs Ranking B

IREG Forum University Rankings, Warsaw May 2013 Methodology 3 Absolute and relative differences Diagrams (ARWU-Y) vs ARWU and (ARWU-Y)/ARWU vs ARWU

IREG Forum University Rankings, Warsaw May 2013 Methodology 4 Diagram ARWU/X vs ARWU

IREG Forum University Rankings, Warsaw May 2013 Methodology 5 Rankings reproducibilities - years selected: average deviations to the average from one year to next: ARWU: 2-3 % THE: % QS: 6-7 % Webometrics: %

IREG Forum University Rankings, Warsaw May 2013 Methodology 6 Filtering rules 90 % of the universities (259) selected 62 % ranked in 4 rankings 6 % in 3 rankings 22 % in 2 rankings First 250 ARWU ranks: 131 universities

IREG Forum University Rankings, Warsaw May 2013 Targets United States United Kingdom Northern Europe (Germany, Scandinavia, Netherlands) Southern Europe (France, Spain, Portugal, Italy)

IREG Forum University Rankings, Warsaw May 2013 Results 1 Ternary diagrams

IREG Forum University Rankings, Warsaw May 2013 Results 2 Ternary diagrams left: ARWU 1->500, right:1->250

IREG Forum University Rankings, Warsaw May 2013 Results 3 ARWU vs THE 1

IREG Forum University Rankings, Warsaw May 2013 Results 4 ARWU vs THE 2

IREG Forum University Rankings, Warsaw May 2013 Results 5 ARWU vs QS 1

IREG Forum University Rankings, Warsaw May 2013 Results 6 ARWU vs QS 2

IREG Forum University Rankings, Warsaw May 2013 Results 7 ARWU vs Webometrics 1

IREG Forum University Rankings, Warsaw May 2013 Results 8 ARWU vs Webometrics 2

IREG Forum University Rankings, Warsaw May 2013 Results 9 US: Relative differences ordinate scale: 1 = 100%

IREG Forum University Rankings, Warsaw May 2013 Results 10 Europe: Relative differences THE-QS: Continental Europe Webometrics=whole Europe ordinate scale: 1 = 100%

IREG Forum University Rankings, Warsaw May 2013 Summary Underestimatation of universities best ranked for research Overestimation of universities less well ranked for research Clear for THE and QS, even clearer for Webometrics And for the best research universities: US: underestimation THE/QS, overestimation Webometrics UK: overestimation THE/QS, underestimation Webometrics N + S Europe: underestimation THE/QS/Webometrics

IREG Forum University Rankings, Warsaw May 2013 Conclusions Reputation concept still on its infancy Necessity to do research on the concept as well as its modalities of implementation