 In the objective approach the focus is on measuring ‘hard’ facts, such as income in dollars or living accommodation in square metres.  The subjective.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
MICS4 Survey Design Workshop Multiple Indicator Cluster Surveys Survey Design Workshop Questionnaires For Individual Women and Men: Life Satisfaction.
Advertisements

The Marginal Utility of Income Richard Layard* Guy Mayraz* Steve Nickell** * CEP, London School of Economics ** Nuffield College, Oxford.
Employment quality in the OECD Better Life Initiative Anne Saint-Martin Meeting of the Group of Experts on Measuring Quality of Employment September.
Cross Sectional Designs
Donald Lien September 12,  What is this?  Where does it come from?  Why do we care?  Is it here to stay?
Wellbeing Watch: a monitor of health, wealth and happiness in the Hunter Shanthi Ramanathan.
John W. R. Phillips National Institute on Aging 16 th Annual Meeting of the Retirement Research Consortium August 7-8, 2014 Comments do not necessarily.
Seven possibly controversial but hopefully useful rules Paul De Boeck K.U.Leuven.
Understanding children’s well-being: A national survey of young people’s well-being 27 January 2010.
Quality of Life in Ireland Presentation by Clive Brownlee, Diageo Ireland & Gerard O’Neill, Amárach Consulting 11 th March 2003.
Stéfan Lollivier, Insee 27/06/2012 Improvements in the measurement of quality of life and well-being in France Measuring Well-Being and Fostering the Progress.
MSS 905 Methods of Missiological Research
What Is Perception, and Why Is It Important?
MEASURING A NATIONS INCOME.  Microeconomics  Microeconomics is the study of how individual households and firms make decisions and how they interact.
Conceptions of Poverty Comparing classifications of people Mariano Rojas FLACSO-México & UPAEP New Directions in Welfare Economics, Paris July 6-8, 2011.
ORGANIZATIONAL BEHAVIOR
1 WELL-BEING AND ADJUSTMENT OF SPONSORED AGING IMMIGRANTS Shireen Surood, PhD Supervisor, Research & Evaluation Information & Evaluation Services Addiction.
Health related quality of life and satisfaction with life in Croatia Gorka Vuletic, BPsychol, PhD Andrija Stampar School of Public Health Medical Faculty,
Discovering and Describing Relationships
Dr. Mario MazzocchiResearch Methods & Data Analysis1 Correlation and regression analysis Week 8 Research Methods & Data Analysis.
Chapter 5.
Economic Development & Classification Systems
By Sanjay Kumar, Ph.D National Programme Officer (M&E), UNFPA – India
Stéfan Lollivier 20/02/2014 Satisfaction and quality of life SILC longitudinal training.
UK POVERTY GCSE ECONOMICS: UNIT 12 Measurement of standards of living.
Econ 231: Natural Resources and Environmental Economics SCHOOL OF APPLIED ECONOMICS.
The new HBS Chisinau, 26 October Outline 1.How the HBS changed 2.Assessment of data quality 3.Data comparability 4.Conclusions.
National Outcomes and Casemix Collection Training Workshop
Unit 3: Macroeconomics By Ms. Lane. Doctors of Macroeconomics For this unit, you will be a doctor. Your patient is the economy of the country. Label the.
1 Assessments of the Environment in the European Quality of Life Perception Surveys Klaus Trutzel German KOSIS Association Urban Audit c/o Bureau for Statistics.
Valuing Health Effects of Air Pollution in DevelopingCountries: The Case of Taiwan* JOURNAL OF ENVIRONMENTAL ECONOMICS AND MANAGEMENT 34, 107 ]
Student Engagement Survey Results and Analysis June 2011.
September In Chapter 14: 14.1 Data 14.2 Scatterplots 14.3 Correlation 14.4 Regression.
Origins of Attraction MATTHEW CORRINET. Biological: Fischer et al. (2003)  “... used an fMRI... to investigate blood flow in the brains of 20 men and.
Heart health Regular physical activity can lower your blood pressure and cholesterol levels and can reduce the risk of illnesses such as Type II diabetes.
Categories of Mental Disorders 1 Child and youth mental health problems can be classified into two broad categories: 1Internalizing problems  withdrawal.
Measuring Well-being: What Role for Social Indicators? Dr. Jongwook Won Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs.
Dikla Segel, Peter Bamberger. Introduction Later life depression and depressive symptoms are prevalent and of major concern for health systems. It causes.
Teens lesson one making decisions presentation slides 04/09.
Making Financial Decisions
What is mental health?. “Mental Health refers to a broad array of activities directly or indirectly related to the mental well-being component included.
Review of the previous lecture Oligopolists maximize their total profits by forming a cartel and acting like a monopolist. If oligopolists make decisions.
Psychodiagnostics An overview.
Attraction Communication/ consolidation Buildup Ending Deterioration and decline Relationship continues Triggering factors: Proximity, Similarity, Erotic.
Andrew Gibson, Kieran Francis, Harriet Brown, Emily Williams, Claire Massett and Felicity Lindsay.
© 2007 Thomson South-Western Measuring a Nation’s Income Microeconomics is the study of how individual households and firms make decisions and how they.
Measuring a Nation’s Income Week-1 Pengantar Ekonomi 21.
Subjective well-being Ype H. Poortinga Tilburg University, Netherlands & University of Leuven, Belgium.
1.What is GDP? 2.What does GDP measure? 3.Which is more useful when comparing a nation’s income from one year to the next, nominal or real GDP? 4.Why should.
State University – Higher School of Economics Alexander Tatarko A Study of Perceived Social Capital in a Multicultural Society: the Case of Russia (Moscow,
Introduction Introduction Alcohol Abuse Characteristics Results and Conclusions Results and Conclusions Analyses comparing primary substance of abuse indicated.
1 Gross Domestic Product ©2006 South-Western College Publishing.
Economics: Class 9 9/23/2014. GDP vs. National Welfare  GDP should not be confused with national well-being, although it is closes related  Limitations.
OECD Guidelines on Measuring Subjective Well-being
Data Weighting Issues Adult Equivalent Scales, Stratified Sampling and general Population Weighting Issues.
Personal Control over Development: Effects on the Perception and Emotional Evaluation of Personal Development in Adulthood.
Chapter 7 Measuring of data Reliability of measuring instruments The reliability* of instrument is the consistency with which it measures the target attribute.
IGCSE ECONOMICS Section C 1/9/14. OUTPUT  The output of an economy is also known as National income. This measures the total value of goods and services.
WHAT’S IN GDP? ) How Can We Measure Economic Growth?  Gross Domestic Product (GDP) – dollar value of all goods and services produced in the country.
What is development? How can we measure development?
Econ 215: Economy of Ghana National Income Accounting Lecture 2.
Measuring Well-being October 2011 OSI Education Programme workshop Charles Seaford Head of the Centre for Well-being, new economics foundation.
DEVELOPMENT. DEFINITION Development is a process that leads to changes in the natural and human environments.
The transition to motherhood Peter Hoffenaar Faculty of Social and Behavioural Sciences University of Amsterdam Assessing women’s subjective well-being.
Thinking about Well-being: nef’s dynamic model October 2011 OSI Education Programme workshop Charles Seaford Head of the Centre for Well-being, nef.
4 GDP & National income accounting
Cross Sectional Designs
Expert Group on Quality of Life Indicators
Main recommendations and Impact on Social Statistics
Model and Hypothesis Table Explanation of Variables
Presentation transcript:

 In the objective approach the focus is on measuring ‘hard’ facts, such as income in dollars or living accommodation in square metres.  The subjective approach, in contrast, considers ‘soft’ matters, such as satisfaction with income and perceived adequacy of dwellings.

 1- SUBSTANCE There is a difference in the substance of the matter measured. Objective indicators are concerned with things that exist independent of subjective awareness. For instance: someone can be ill in an objective sense, because a tumour is spreading in the body, without that person knowing.

2- ASSESSMENT  Objective measurement is based on explicit criteria and performed by external observers. Illness can be measured objectively by the determining presence of antigens in the blood (Given these operational definitions, any impartial observer will come to the same conclusion).  Subjective measurement involves self-reports based on implicit criteria. When we say we feel sick, we mostly cannot explain in much detail why we feel so and someone else, with the same symptoms, may be less apt to define himself as unwell.

Objective–subjective difference: basic configurations actual ‘wealth’ of a person when measured by her bank account. Measuring wealth using self-perceived wealthiness measuring happiness by relating it to the use of anti-depressants measuring happiness using self-report

Type 1 Illness revealed by symptoms such as weight loss or biochemical tests; Type 2 Illness diagnosed by a doctor on the basis of a patient’s complaints; Type 3 Perception of being ill by one-self (possibly without feeling sick); Type 4 Being and feeling ill as apparent in sickness behaviours such as absenteeism and visiting the doctor; Type 5 Being and feeling ill measured by a health questionnaire that involves both perceptions of functional health and health complaints; Type 6 Being and feeling ill as reported directly by a person; Type 7 Feeling ill as apparent by consumption of relief drugs, such as painkillers or tranquilizers; Type 8 Feeling ill measured using a sickness complaint inventory; Type 9 Feeling ill measured using a response to a single question on how fit or sick one feels.

 Alternative way of measuring society’s wellbeing, based on time use and affective (emotional) experience National Time Accounting (NTA).  National Time Accounting is a set of methods for measuring, categorizing, comparing, and analyzing the way people spend their time, across countries, over historical time, or between groups of people within a country at a given time.

 Perhaps related to the outpouring of research into subjective well- being, policymakers and statistical agencies around the world have shown increased interest in measuring subjective well- being as part of their national statistics.  National Time Accounting provides a method for tracking time allocation and assessing whether people are experiencing their daily lives in more or less enjoyable ways.

 Most past efforts to evaluate time use rely on researchers’ external judgments regarding which activities constitute enjoyable leisure and which constitute arduous work and home production.  NTA relies on individuals’ own evaluations of their emotional experiences during their arious uses of time.

 Widely used measures from the National Income Accounts (NIA), such as gross domestic product (GDP) per capita and consumption per capita, only represent a component of total welfare.  Well- being depends on more than economic output and material consumption.  In addition, aspects of life that contribute to economic output may detract from well- being. For example, an increase in pollution could be associated with decreased welfare but increased production and national income.

 Thus, the circle representing NIA partly falls outside the box representing total welfare.  National Time Accounting partly overlaps with NIA, but also reflects other features of well- being that are not captured by NIA. For example, time spent socializing with friends is not measured in national income but is important for well- being.

 A society’s well- being or “true welfare” is represented by the rectangle.

 The scale of measurement is unclear.  Different people are likely to interpret the same scale differently.

 The U- index measures the proportion of time an individual spends in an unpleasant state.  The U- index is an ordinal measure at the level of feelings.  The first step in computing the U- index is to determine whether an episode is unpleasant or pleasant. There are many possible ways to classify an episode as unpleasant or pleasant.

 The data collected with Experience Sampling Methods (ESM) or the Day Reconstruction Method (DRM) include descriptions of an individual’s emotional state during each episode in terms of intensity ratings on several dimensions of feelings, some of which are positive (e.g., “Happy,” “Enjoy myself,” “Friendly”) and some of which are negative (e.g., “Depressed,” “Angry,” “Frustrated”).

 First, classify an episode as unpleasant if the most intense feeling reported for that episode is a negative one—that is, if the maximum rating on any of the negative affect dimensions is strictly greater than the maximum of rating of the positive affect dimensions (this definition relies purely on an ordinal ranking of the feelings)

 The group U- index can be interpreted as the average proportion of time that members of the group spend in an unpleasant state.

 Most people would prefer to be married to a partner who is happy and satisfi ed rather than depressed and dissatisfi ed. Consistent with this preference, several longitudinal studies show that people who report in sample surveys that they are happy.

 The Experience Sampling Method (ESM) and Ecological Momentary Assessment (EMA) were developed to collect information on people’s reported feelings in real time in natural settings during selected moments of the day

 Emphasize that subjective- well being is multidimensional.  At the individual level within a country, the demographic correlates of experi- enced well- being and life (or happiness) satisfaction mostly have the same sign.  Life satisfaction and the U- index, however, yield a different ranking of France and the United States, most likely because of cultural differences in reporting that lead the French to appear less satisfied.

 Differences in subjective well- being between age groups can be attributed to a component due to differences in time allocation and a component due to differences in feelings for a given set of activities. This analysis revealed that differences in time use account for a majority of the difference in experienced well- being between younger and older individuals.

 NTA is a descriptive, not prescriptive, technique. The method of NTA does not lead to immediate policy recommendations. For example, the fact that spending time socializing may be more enjoyable than working for pay for the average person does not necessarily lead to the recommendation that people should socialize more and work less.