Comments to “Do entry Regulations deter Entrepreneurship and Job Creation?: Evidence from Recent Reforms in Portugal” Carmen Pagés March 2011.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Schumpeterian Restructuring by P. Francois and H. Lloyd-Ellis Discussion.
Advertisements

Do Entry Regulations Deter Entrepreneurship and Job Creation? Evidence from Recent Reforms in Portugal Lee Branstetter, Francisco Lima, Lowell J. Taylor.
SMALL BUSINESS UPDATE Matthew James Thursday, 19 th May 2005.
Chapter 1 Understanding Entrepreneurship. Copyright © Houghton Mifflin Company. All rights reserved.1 | 2 Tonight Administration, Comments and Questions.
The Effects of Taxes on Entrepreneurial Activity A Presentation to the President’s Advisory Panel on Federal Tax Reform Donald Bruce March 8, 2005.
1 Microsimulation of Businesses in ILUMASS Part 2: Firmography Rolf Moeckel and Michael Wegener Workshop of the Land Use Transportation Modelling Group.
BUSINESS AND FINANCIAL LITERACY FOR YOUNG ENTREPRENEURS: EVIDENCE FROM BOSNIA-HERZEGOVINA Miriam Bruhn and Bilal Zia (World Bank, DECFP)
SMEs’ Finance and Participation in Global Markets Koji ITO Centre for Entrepreneurship, SMEs and Local Development (CFE) Organisation for Economic.
Effective Learning Service
2008 Impacts of Michigan’s Small Business and Technology Development Centers May 7, 2009.
Herbert Mapfaira Department of Mechanical Engineering Gosekwang Setibi
FRANCISCO VELOSO 1 PEDRO CONCEIÇÃO 2 1 Faculdade de Ciências Económicas e Empresariais Universidade Católica Portuguesa 2 Center for Innovation, Technology.
The Impact of Business Environment Reforms on New Firm Registrations By Leora Klapper and Inessa Love Discussant Comments Mary Hallward-Driemeier March.
Rural Non-Farm Enterprises Operate Mainly in Survival Mode Paula Nagler and Wim Naudé Annual Bank Conference on Africa, Paris, 23 June 2014 AGRICULTURE.
NADEZHDA GOREYKO SVETLANA AVDASHEVA
H OW D O S TART -U P F IRMS F INANCE T HEIR A SSETS : E VIDENCE F ROM THE K AUFFMAN F IRM S URVEYS Rebel A. Cole DePaul University Tatyana Sokolyk Brock.
OHS Risk Management - Overview Risk management is a system that allows workplaces to identify OHS issues and to methodically control them by the best means.
Bureau of Labor Statistics Timely Statistics on SMEs and Entrepreneurs in the U.S. Labor Market James R. Spletzer U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics October.
Work Allocation Forms: Substitution between Full-time, Part-time and Contracted Labour in the Creative Industries Ralitza Dobreva and Gregory John Lee.
Alcohol Availability & Alcohol Consumption: New Evidence from Sunday Sales Restrictions Kitt Carpenter (UC Irvine) & Daniel Eisenberg (University of Michigan)
Start-up Grant – A Key to Entrepreneurship Tallinn, EST Pekka Stenholm, University of Turku, Turku School of Economics, TSE Entre.
Centre for Market and Public Organisation Understanding the effect of public policy on fertility Mike Brewer (Institute for Fiscal Studies) Anita Ratcliffe.
Do entrepreneurs really learn? Evidence from Bank data Julian Frankish, Barclays Richard Roberts, Barclays David J Storey, Warwick Business School.
Anna Lovász Institute of Economics Hungarian Academy of Sciences June 30, 2011.
1 Alternative Measures of Business Entry and Exit By Ron Jarmin, Javier Miranda, and Kristin Sandusky September 16, 2003.
T HE G ALLUP O RGANIZATION Eric Thompson University of Nebraska-Lincoln Entrepreneurship in Nebraska: Economic Indicators.
Study on social policy effects resulting from the scope of application of the European framework agreement on the prevention of health risks in the hairdressing.
Welcome to Econ 325 Economics of Gender Week 10 Beginning April 2.
The route out of the routine: mobility and the changing structure of occupations Craig Holmes and Ken Mayhew International Labour Process.
1 Workplace job satisfaction: a multilevel analysis WERS 2004 Users Group Meeting, NIESR March 16, 2007.
Expert Group on Business Registers 12 th Session – Paris, September 2011 Linking business registers across statistical domains: An application to.
Business R&D Intensity in Canada and the United States: Does Firm Size Matter? Presentation to: The 2008 World Congress on National Accounts and Economic.
Lecture 1: Trade and Labour H. Vandenbussche. Research questions Link between imports from low-wage countries and firm-level employment growth? Link between.
Export Spillovers from FDI: Evidence from Polish firm-level data Andrzej Cieślik (University of Warsaw) Jan Hagemejer (National Bank of Poland)
Adapted from Peng, Growing and Internationalizing the Entrepreneurial Firm Dr. Ellen A. Drost.
Where does employment growth come from? Dr Luke Hendrickson Innovation Research Analytical Services Branch Economic and Analytical Services Division 15.
MONITORING of Administrative Barriers to Small Business Development in Russia Conducted by CEFIR in collaboration with the World Bank and financial support.
Competitiveness and Growth in LAC: The Chilean Case Competitiveness and Growth in LAC: The Chilean Case Comments to: Juan Blyde, IDB.
Who is an Entrepreneur. Entrepreneur – – Generally, small business.
“Firm Dynamics and Job Creation in Turkey" I.Atiyas, O.Bakis and Y.K.Orhan II. Girişim İstatistikleri Analizi Çalıştayı 27 Mart 2015.
Why are so many firms sub-optimal? Primary aim: An empirical foundation of evolutionary processes.
A PROJECT REPORT On Total Quality Management in Manufacturing Organization In partial fulfillment o f the requirement for the award of the degree IN [
LAUNCHING NEW ventures – AN ENTREPRENEURIAL APPROACH, 7e
Are Male Entrepreneurs more Productive than Female Entrepreneurs? Evidence from Transition Economies Shwetlena Sabarwal PREM-Gender Katherine Terrell PREM-Gender.
FOREIGN DIRECT INVESTMENT AND PRODUCTIVITY SPILLOVERS: Firm Level Evidence from Chilean industrial sector. Leopoldo LabordaDaniel Sotelsek University of.
Module 4A-Industry Analysis Virtual Business. What is Industry Analysis? Industry analysis is a market strategy tool used by businesses to determine if.
EXCHANGE RATE PASS-THROUGH INTO IMPORT PRICES Paper by: José Manuel Campa Linda S. Goldberg Presentation by:Fanta Nicolas Mohylová Aneta Polena Michal.
THE EFFECTS OF FIRMS’ ENTRY CARLOS CARREIRA AND PAULINO TEIXEIRA FACULTY OF ECONOMICS AND GEMF, UNIVERSITY OF COIMBRA Does Schumpeterian Creative Destruction.
R ETURN TO COMMUTING IN S WEDEN Sergii Troshchenkov PhD student L.A.S.E.R.
Human resources Human resources in Croatian manufacturing: situation, changes, and effects.
PRELIMINARY-PLEASE DO NOT QUOTE Trends & Determinants of Self- insuring Health Benefits Philip F. Cooper Kosali I. Simon.
Warwick Business School. Key learning objectives  Have an understanding of the role played by new businesses in economic growth  Consider the contribution.
Exam Preparation Session for International Entrepreneurship Research & Practice (IERP) Exam Day, Place & Time - June 9, Monday - Room & Time ??? 2 Tasks:
Import competition and company training: evidence from the U.S. microdata on individuals Hao-Chung Li Department of Economics, University of Southern California.
Juan (Francisco) Carluccio Banque de France
Labor Markets and Unemployment Rates: — A Cross Country Analysis
Discussion of “The Role of Hard and Soft Information in Peer-to-Peer Lending” by Ester Faia and Monica Paiella Balgobin Y., Telecom ParisTech 10th Financial.
Gender wage inequalities in Serbia
Trade Unions in the UK Labour Market
October 18, 2005 Ron Jarmin, Shawn Klimek, and Javier Miranda
Entry and Regulation – Evidence from Health Care Professions
#. shop now P1080P · /' '
Evidence from Chinese firm level data Ingrid Nielsen, Russell Smyth
Review of Trends & Performance
What drives merger waves? Jarrad Harford 汇报人 孙毅.
Political uncertainty and cash holdings: Evidence from China
Research Paper Overview.
Case Study Water Bills Kevin Andrews Defra
Absolute survival probability (per cent who have not quit successfully) of reported quit attempts of longer than 1 year during the first 18 months of observation.
Agenda No.10.2 Updated Extra-EU methodology Manual
Presentation transcript:

Comments to “Do entry Regulations deter Entrepreneurship and Job Creation?: Evidence from Recent Reforms in Portugal” Carmen Pagés March 2011

What does the paper do? Evaluates experience of deregulation in Portugal using a D-D methodology. It uses the fact that the program starts at different times in different municipalities. It compares firm entry, employment in newly created firms and survival of new firms in ´treated´vs ´untreated´ municipalities. It also assesses the characteristics of firms and their entrepreneurs for firms created after deregulation.

What do they find? The introduction of one stop shops is associated with 17% increase in firm entry and a 22% increase in employment in new firms. The increase comes from firms of 2 and 3-5 employees. No change for firms >5. Firms which started after program had lower survival rates (4 pp. less) Increase in entry of female, older, and less educated entrepreneurs.

Are the results convincing? D-D methodology used already in similar papers: Bruhn 2008; Kaplan et al, forthcoming. It does not specify # of “controls”. How many counties without change? It uses two types of specifications: – Z cmy = 1 from opening month afterwards, o otherwise. – Full set of dummies: Z lc =1, l=-10….,0,1,…10, for example Z -1c =1 in the month prior to the opening of one stop shop

Does is start before?

Are the results convincing? Could run with a trend, to assess impact of other factors that lead towards higher firm entry in this period. What happens when period FE are introduced? Probability of being an entrepreneur less than LPM bad approximation in the extremes. Coud use a triple D-D-D model using as controls the industries in table A.1 (excluded).

Could also examine: Were these workers/firms already active but unregistered/informal? – More likely given the types of firms that registered – Were the entrepreneurs employees before? What happened to overall employment? – Did employment in continuing establishments decline as a consequence of increased competition? Are the results big/small? – How much does imply in terms of % of total employment/economic activity?

In conclusion A very nice paper with a very nice dataset… – Want to know more!

THANKS!