Public Health, Alcohol Regulation and the Three-Tier Distribution System James F. Mosher, JD Alcohol Policy Consultations Addictions organizers conference.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

Advocating in the Public Health Interest Dr Evelyn Gillan Chief Executive Alcohol Focus Scotland.

Advertisements

Effects of Alcohol Marketing during European Football Championship 2008 By Avalon de Bruijn STAP: Dutch Knowledge Institute for Alcohol Policy.

ALCOHOL POLICY – CAN WE LEARN FROM HISTORY? NDSAG Annual Conference 2013 Dr James Nicholls – Research Manager, Alcohol Research UK.

Understanding the Regulatory System for Alcohol Beverages: Three Tier & Tied House Evil Responsible Retailing Forum Las Vegas, March 11, 2004 Mitchell.

Pamela S. Erickson, President/CEO, Public Action Management and Former Director of Oregon Liquor Control Commission The Important Role of Tied House Laws.

Legal possibilities of a European wide ban on alcohol advertising.

Pamela S. Erickson President/CEO Public Action Management Alcohol Law Symposium, September 12, 2011 Chicago, Illinois

 * Costco-sponsored ballot measure privatizes Washington state liquor stores and deregulates wine.  * Privatization is an issue in most “control” states.

Public health and licensing workshop Outlet density and cumulative impact Dr James Nicholls Alcohol Research UK.

3 Prevention Updates SAPT+ Committee California Behavioral Health Directors Association March 26, 2015.

July 2011 Legal Issues Affecting the BC Wine Industry BC Wine Grape Council Conference, Penticton, BC Mark Hicken, Vintage Law Group.

Australian Health Insurance Association “ The ACCC View of Key Competition Issues Impacting on Private Health” Presented By John Martin Commissioner Australian.

Privatizing Idaho’s Liquor Stores: What’s the Harm? Ted R Miller, PhD PIRE or NO CONFLICTS OF INTEREST Funding:

Pamela S. Erickson, President Public Action Management, PLC Why can’t we sell alcohol like tires and mayonnaise?

The Marketing Environment. The External Environment Demographics Social Change Social Change Economic Conditions Economic Conditions Political & Legal.

Restricting Access to Alcohol. Background  Injuries  Liver diseases  Cancers  Heart diseases  Premature deaths  Poverty  Family and partner violence.

Making alcohol everybody’s business Rosanna O’Connor, Public Health England.

Policy Options to Restrict Tobacco Marketing in Stores Ellen Feighery RN MS Public Health Institute Oakland, CA.

1 Understanding Alcohol Regulation in the United States James F. Mosher, J.D. President, Alcohol Policy Consultations Senior Policy Advisor, The CDM Group,

Supply Side policies AS Economics.

Big Alcohol’s Attempt to Dismantle Regulation State by State A Marin Institute Report Control State Politics September 2010.

Campaign for MUP in Scotland Dr Evelyn Gillan Chief Executive Alcohol Focus Scotland.

Tim Stockwell Director, Centre for Addictions Research of BC ( ) Professor, Department of Psychology University of Victoria, BC,

The Marketing Environment 3 Principles of Marketing.

Alcohol Density & Community Safety March 3, 2015 Presentation Agenda CPP/CURB Background Overview of the Local Problem Alcohol Density-why it’s a problem.

MKTG 442 FOOD MARKETING REGULATIONS Lars Perner, Instructor 1 FOOD MARKETING REGULATIONS  Types of regulations –Economic –Food safety –Consumer protection.

Restricting Access to Alcohol. Background  Injuries  Liver cirrhosis  Cancers  Cardiovascular diseases  Premature deaths  Poverty  Family and partner.

Alcohol Control Advocacy in the Public Health Interest Dr Evelyn Gillan Chief Executive Alcohol Focus Scotland.

Alcoholic Energy Drinks and Youth Alcohol Problems: An Overview James F. Mosher, JD Alcohol Policy Consultations October 12, 2010 Presentation at the California.

ACE alcohol culture exchange Alcohol policy in context.

1 1 Regional Conference on Alcohol Control, August 2006, Bangkok, Thailand ALCOHOL CONSUMPTION CONTROL – POLICY OPTIONS FOR THE SOUTH-EAST ASIA REGION.

Gerald A. Dinallo, Jr. Senior Managing Director NABCA 16 th Annual Symposium on Alcohol Beverage Law & Regulation “Who’s Tied to the House?” March 9 –

TransAtlantic Dialogue on Underage Drinking Royal College of Surgeons London, England June 28, 2011 “Global Trade Issues Related to Addressing Underage.

Revision of Elasticity Promotion Promotion is divided in two categories 1. Above the line advertising 2. Below the line advertising.

Alcohol beverage regulation - Emerging trends Some lessons from public health science Peter Anderson, MD, MPH, PhD 12 March 2008.

Safe, Sensible, Social. Significantly reducing alcohol harm: An argument for minimum pricing in Blackpool Stephen Morton Alcohol Harm Reduction Policy.

Sacramento ~ June 5, Why Tackle The Retail Environment?  Tobacco Industry’s Main Point of Entry  Historical Experience and Success  National.

What are coalitions? A coalition is a formal arrangement for cooperation and collaboration between groups or sectors of the community, in which each group.

© 2011 John Wiley and Sons, Inc. All Rights Reserved Selection and Procurement for the Hospitality Industry Purchasing ANDREW HALE FEINSTEIN AND JOHN M.

Banning Forms of Alcohol Advertising. Background  Injuries  Liver cirrhosis  Cancers  Cardiovascular diseases  Premature deaths  Poverty  Family.

Business and Society POST, LAWRENCE, WEBER Antitrust, Mergers, and Global Competition Chapter 9.

Minimum Pricing in Scotland Dr Evelyn Gillan, Chief Executive Alcohol Focus Scotland AFS is Scotland’s national alcohol charity working to reduce the harm.

Trends in alcohol marketing New products Digital marketing Alcohol as a health food Stakeholder marketing.

The Four Ps of Marketing Product Any goods, services, or ideas that we wish to sell. Goods, Services, or Ideas Defining Target.

1 Role of Government SECTION 1: Growth of Government SECTION 2: Economic Goals SECTION 3: Government and the Public CHAPTER 12.

Conduct in the Industry Evidence. Conduct Pricing Advertising Research & Development Coordination vs. Rivalry.

~What factors influence the growth of government? ~Why have government expenditures increased over time?

Alabama Alcohol Beverage Study Commission January 12, 2016.

When it comes to alcohol, how to make healthier choices easier choices Peter Anderson Armagh 26 January 2012.

Warm UP 1.Explain Recession and Depression. 2.What caused the Great Depression.

Entrepreneurship CHAPTER 11 SECTION 1.  To stay in business, you must make a profit.  Costs and expenses can be fixed or variable: 1.Fixed costs – do.

Sofia, 3 June 2011 Illicit tobacco: tax policies and the risks of organised crime.

Substances – Science – Politics Addictions: Regulating Risk Gert-Jan Meerkerk PhD, IVO Addiction Research Institute Rotterdam SciCom, Brussels, Tuesday.

MeTA Phase I: Where are we? MeTA18/06/ MeTA2 The MeTA Phase I Proposal Purpose To pilot a new multi-stakeholder approach towards increasing transparency.

Addressing the Federal Legalization of Cannabis Briefing to Standing Committee on Priorities and Planning June 7, 2017.

Regulation of alcohol marketing in Finland

Addressing the Federal Legalization of Cannabis Briefing to Standing Committee on Priorities and Planning June 7, 2017.

III About market structures

Cannabis conversations brought to you by

The effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of alcohol control policies PHE Evidence Review 31st January 2017.

Government and Business

إدارة التسويق.

Acquire knowledge of the impact of government on business activities to make informed economic decisions 5.04.

Campaign for MUP in Scotland

Pricing You don’t sell through price. You sell the price.

Role of the state.

Federal Research Institute for Health Organization and Informatics of Ministry of Health of the Russian Federation Policy and substance use among adolescents.

2. SUPPLY, DEMAND AND PRICE

Place - Channels of Distribution/ International Marketing

Economic and Fiscal Considerations of Legalized Cannabis

Presentation transcript:

Public Health, Alcohol Regulation and the Three-Tier Distribution System James F. Mosher, JD Alcohol Policy Consultations Addictions organizers conference call, March 19, 2013, General Board of Church and Society, United Methodist Church

Producer The Alcohol Distribution Three-Tier System Wholesaler Retailer Consumers Tied House Laws Direct Shipment Laws

Public Health Goals of the Three-Tier System Deter undue producer influence on retailers  Sales and advertising practices Reduce competition; maintain an orderly market  Restrict quantity discounting  Maintain minimum prices Protect small retailers Deter sales to minors

Wholesaler Tier  Under attack by big-box retailers and producers  In “control” states, operated by the state (either directly or through contract)  Highly profitable  Until recently, private wholesalers have been strong opponents of public health initiatives

Fundamental Question Is alcohol an ordinary commodity subject to the same market pressures and rules as other consumer products? Federal Trade Commission, alcohol producers, big box retailers: YES! Public health and wholesalers: NO!

Regulatory Measures At Risk (through court and legislation action) Measures directly related to the three tier system:  Restrictions on direct shipments  Quantity discounts; minimum pricing  Restrictions on producer/wholesaler promotions for retailers  Push to privatize state retail and wholesale operations  Protection of wholesaler tier

Regulatory Measures At Risk (through court and legislation action) Measures indirectly related to the three-tier system  Restrictions on alcohol advertising/marketing  Restrictions on days and hours of sale  Restrictions on type, number, and location of retail outlets  Other restrictions on alcohol availability and marketing

What the Science Tells Us Increased alcohol prices/taxes Decreased alcohol consumption Decreased public health/safety problems Source: CDC Community Guide 2010

What the Science Tells Us: Alcohol Availability Increased alcohol availability Increased alcohol consumption Increased public health/safety problems Source: Babor et al. 2010

What the Science Tells Us: Youth Exposure to Alcohol Marketing Increased youth exposure Increased intention to drink Earlier initiation/increase in drinking Source: Anderson, et al. 2009; Babor et al. 2010

Great Britain A case study in the risks of treating alcohol as an ordinary commodity The Guardian Headline:  Hospital admissions due to drinking double in 10 years  Doctors' leaders call for stricter controls over the sale of alcohol, including minimum pricing