Public-Private Partnerships in the Global Perspective: Outstanding Methods, Constraints and Challenges A Comparative Study of Partnerships between Public.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

Capacity-building for Public-Private Partnerships Ljiljana Stancic Secretary, Team of Specialists on Public-Private Partnerships United Nations Economic.

Advertisements

Electric Vehicles Industrial Cluster - NPO IKEM Corp. (Business entity of EVIC) Changing the Government Agenda of EU's poorest countries using the power.

Tax Increment Financing Town Center Project Midwest City, OK.

WASHINGTON JOBS INVESTMENT COALITION SUPPORTING TAX INCREMENT FINANCING AUTHORITY December, 2010.

PPP’s IN NIGERIA: Prospects in the Water Sector

Fostering the Adoption and Adaptation of Innovative Solutions for Water Challenges 5 th Delft Symposium on Water Sector Capacity Development 31 May 2013.

P3s: Public-Private Partnerships Jessica Yates Snell & Wilmer, L.L.P. May 8, Commuting Solutions.

Wheeling Stamping Building and Stone Center Wheeling, WV Regional Economic Development Partnership PO Box 1029 Wheeling, WV /

Dr. Ewa Ruminska-Zimny Director, Gender and Economy Programme, UNECE “The Challenges of Engendering Economics – Way towards Social Justice and Equal Opportunities”

WHO GOVERNS? The Dilemmas of Urban Government (Lessons from the U.S.A.) PROF. RICHARD WALKER DEPARTMENT OF GEOGRAPHY GLOBAL METROPOLITAN STUDIES UNIVERSITY.

Next Street Financial LLC © Copyright 2009 – CONFIDENTIAL 1 October 22, 2009 Open Classroom Policy Series: The 21 st Century City.

Francesca Romanin Jacur Milan University

Tools for Redevelopment Courtney Knight Managing Director, Redevelopment Revitalizing Atlanta 1.

Delaware Community Investment Fund Committee of 100 Economic Roundtable June 26, 2015.

Slide 1 Sudan Private Sector Forum A Forum to support Sudanese Public – Private Sector Dialogue Prepared by Amin Sid Ahmed- World Bank, PSD Advisor Presented.

Tax Increment Financing TIF: A method for funding public investments in an area slated for redevelopment by capturing for a time all or a portion of the.

Overview Summary from Africa and ASEAN assistance Dr. Peter Pembleton, UNIDO.

Public-Private Partnerships: State of Practice and Research Needs The 14 th Annual Public Private Partnership Conference World Bank, Washington, DC September.

Diversification and Incentives Framework Paul Siegel Rural Economist, Consultant World Bank Prepared for IDB/WB/USAID Central America Coffee Crisis Workshop.

WHAT THE HAPPENED TO ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT IN CALIFORNIA!? Steve Andrews Senior Policy Advisor Mayor’s Office of Economic Development City of Los.

23/08/20151 European Investment Bank EUROPEAN INVESTMENT BANK Urban Development Projects 29 th May 2009 Barbara Lemke Urban Planner Projects Directorate.

BUILDING SUSTAINABILITY: PARTNERSHIPS AND FINANCE by S. Adrian Ross Senior Programme Officer PEMSEA.

Learning the local business Workshop I. Good governance – role of local governments in LED and their efficiency 23 March, 2011, Gödöllő Gábor Péteri

Financial instruments for social economy workshop.

ETF Conference, Building & Financing European Transport Infrastructure, Brussels, 23rd Oct Building & Financing European Transport Infrastructures.

Finding balance in financial uncertainty Speakers Mark Ruff, Senior Financial Advisor, Ehlers Rick Collins, Vice President of Development, Ryan Companies.

City of Asheville ECONOMIC & COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT INITIATIVE

Iraq Finance 2012 Public Private Partnerships Abraham Akkawi September 18, 2012.

Investment Policies in Russia: The Northern Dimension by Rainer Geiger Deputy Director, OECD Financial and Enterprise Affairs The Northern Dimension Forum.

Tax Increment Financing and New Markets Tax Credit Incentives for Real Estate Development Materials Prepared for Discussion Courtney D. Pogue, CCIM, CEcD,

3TB Project Review Tax Increment Financing (“TIF”) Overview January 25, 2013.

THE MINISTRY FOR ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT OF THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION The SME Support Measures in Russia.

Building Blocks for a Successful Public- Private Partnerships Presented by Igor Abramov Counsel & Co-chair, Eurasia and Russia Practice Group, Heenan Blaikie.

1 The World Bank Sandro Zanus-Michiei St. Petersburg – March 2003 The role of Development Agencies in promoting and fostering SMEs.

An Assessment of Business Owners in the 87 th & Cottage Grove TIF Business District Chicago, Illinois A Comprehensive Report In partnership with 87 th.

Working with the private sector – experience from Russia Business Focal Points Workshop Bratislava, 25 October 2004 United Nations Development Programme.

Solving Challenges Others Cannot Using Public Private Partnerships Parkland Blue Ribbon Panel Christopher D. Lloyd October 22, 2007.

Astana Economic Forum PPPs In the United States and Their Lessons for Central Asia Astana, Kazakhstan 1-2 July 2010 Arthur L. Smith

Town Of Hamilton Home Rule Petition Hamilton Development Corporation.

Russia and its neighbours Territory – 16,9 mln. km 2 Population - 147,5 mln. people.

Page1 Decentralization of Functions International Conference on Governance and Accountability in Social Sector Decentralization Dana Weist

Investment in Water Infrastructure California Water Association.

Session 3: Planning and organizing PPPs 1. Planning and organizing 2. Defining Objectives 3. Defining Parameters (scope) 4. Collecting information PPPUE/Capacity.

From Russia with Love – PPP in St Petersburg Case Study: PPP in Transport Nadzemny Express (NADEX) LRT Russian Federation – St Petersburg Vickram Cuttaree,

Kiichiro Fukasaku Development Centre

Public–Private Partnerships in Health Carmen Carpio Senior Operations Officer

July 2010 The Copenhagen Agreement and Finance Issues- What are the Implications for Business? The Private Sector’s Role in Climate Change.

Project NSTL Kara Clay Joshua Rucker. Purpose To revitalize North Saint Louis City and bring prosperity O Jobs O Sustainability O Long lasting Business.

Alexandra B. McGoldrick Director, Central Grants Office City of Bridgeport Bill Finch Mayor.

Report of the 2nd ad hoc Committee on the TB epidemic Jaap F. Broekmans STOP TB Partner’s Forum NEW DELHI June 2004.

How Port Authorities can be used for Economic Development MEDFA ANNUAL CONFERENCE October 8, 2015 Thomas J. Winston Vice President, Administration & Chief.

CAI-Asia is building an air quality management community in Asia Investment Implications of the Action Plan Sustainable Urban.

Public-private partnership (PPP)  describes a government service or private business venture which is funded and operated through a partnership of government.

Interaction Private Sector Working Group Discussion with USAID Global Partnerships January 30, 2014.

Created by Way Development Ventures as a public service The following presentation provides background information to assist voters in gaining an understanding.

Albina Nikkonen Russian Private Equity and Venture Capital market review 2006 Russian Private Equity and Venture Capital Association.

Russia Netherlands Economic Forum 18 November 2007.

UN-OHRLLS Improving transit cooperation, trade and trade facilitation for the benefit of the LLDCs: Current Status and Policy implications - Global Report.

UN Capital Development Fund What, Why and How? PERFORMANCE BASED CLIMATE RESILIENCE GRANTS October 2013.

Architecture 2000 Inc. HOK Canada, City of Moncton Conference Meeting Centre Feasibility Study.

1 CASE STUDY ON DEUTSCHE BANK MARKET RISK MANAGEMENT SUBMITTED BY SNEHA B. SHAH SUBMITTED TO MS. MUDRA MISTRY 1.

Strategy of economic and social development of St. Petersburg until 2030 Committee for Economic Policy and Strategic Planning of St. Petersburg

Mortgage Finance Opportunities and Challenges By Taimur Afzal, Chairman ASSOCIATION OF MORTGAGE BANKERS (AMB) March 25th

#gamainst What is Georgia Main Street? Presented by: Billy Peppers Director, Office of Downtown Development Department of Community Affairs.

Dr. Ewa Ruminska-Zimny Director, Gender and Economy Programme, UNECE “Property Rights – A Condition of Women’s Success in Business” Warsaw, 14 March 2008.

Finding the Revenue Stream to Make P3s Work

Finance Advisory Committee – October 17, 2017

Developing a financially resilient public-private partnership framework Proposal and Analysis of Crowdfunding in Public-Private Partnership Projects.

The Role of Private Sector in Capital Budgeting

Presentation transcript:

Public-Private Partnerships in the Global Perspective: Outstanding Methods, Constraints and Challenges A Comparative Study of Partnerships between Public and Private Sectors in the United States (Kansas City, Missouri) and Russia (St. Petersburg) By Alexey Dorofeev United Nations University Office at the UN, New York The Hauptman School for Public Affairs, Park University

Summary Outstanding administrative methods utilized by Capital Improvements Management Office (CIMO) in Kansas City and the Government of St. Petersburg Administrative Constraints Implications to Public Administrators

Why Kansas City and St. Petersburg? Kansas City Urban Redevelopment Project = one of the most innovative PPP projects in the United States Infrastructure Projects in St. Petersburg = enormous scale of projects and direct financial support from the state

Kansas City, Missouri Urban Redevelopment Project $ 850 mln Power & Light District Partnership of Capital Improvements Management Office (CIMO) and the Cordish Company (major U.S. real estate developer) Management Team was comprised of employees from MWH Americas (a comprehensive management consulting firm), Burn & Engineering (architecture and construction consulting solutions firm) and City employees

Kansas City, Missouri Urban Redevelopment Project (Results) Revitalized Downtown Kansas City A broader array of services provided by the private sector A stronger sense of a community

St. Petersburg, Russia Infrastructure Development Projects Orlovski Tunnel The Western Speed Diameter (WSD) Nadzemni Express Pulkovo Airport Approx. $ 1 Billion Each

Outstanding Methods Kansas City, Missouri, U.S. Central Administrative Role of the Capital Improvements Management Office (CIMO) Tax Increment Financing (TIF) St. Petersburg, Russia Direct Allocation of Funds from the Investment Fund of the Russian Federation (IFRF) Innovative Legislation Political Support from the Central Government The World Bank Group

Constraints and Challenges Kansas City, Missouri, U.S. Fiscal Administration of TIF Significant risks related to future revenue forecasts and project’s over cost St. Petersburg, Russia Weakness of the legal framework High risks associated with reliance on state funding Lack of public officials’ expertise with managing PPP projects Cost assessment risks

Lessons Learned Kansas City, Missouri, U.S. An accurate estimate of project’s costs is important. Tax burden should be fairly distributed among citizens. St. Petersburg, Russia A stronger legal framework is needed. More substantial support from the state is key to successful implementation of the projects.

Recommendations Each PPP project is unique and requires an individual approach. A special centralized public entity, akin to CIMO in Kansas City, is a great way run and oversee the projects. Tax subsidies are an effective tool to attract private businesses to participate. In developing countries, such organizations as the World Bank Group or the United Nations Development Programme should be utilized as a great source of advice and expertise.

Questions?

Thank you.