GALAXIES IN DIFFERENT ENVIRONMENTS: VOIDS TO CLUSTERS:  Simulations will require to model full physics:  Cooling, heating, star formation feedbacks…

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Astronomical Solutions to Galactic Dark Matter Will Sutherland Institute of Astronomy, Cambridge.
Advertisements

arvard.edu/phot o/2007/m51/. Confronting Stellar Feedback Simulations with Observations of Hot Gas in Elliptical Galaxies Q. Daniel Wang,
18 July Monte Carlo Markov Chain Parameter Estimation in Semi-Analytic Models Bruno Henriques Peter Thomas Sussex Survey Science Centre.
Effects of galaxy formation on dark matter haloes Susana Pedrosa Patricia Tissera, Cecilia Scannapieco Chile 2010.
Lecture 21 updates. Hubble’s STIS Spectrograph Please include this image at the start of the images of STIS.
Formation of Globular Clusters in  CDM Cosmology Oleg Gnedin (University of Michigan)
Andrey Kravtsov Kavli Institute for Cosmological Physics (KICP) The University of Chicago Simulating galaxy formation at high redshifts.
Forming Early-type galaxies in  CDM simulations Peter Johansson University Observatory Munich Santa Cruz Galaxy Workshop 2010 Santa Cruz, August 17 th,
How Do Galaxies Get Their Gas? astro-ph/ Dušan Kereš University of Massachusetts Collaborators: Neal Katz, Umass David Weinberg, Ohio-State Romeel.
Clusters & Super Clusters Large Scale Structure Chapter 22.
Entropy in the ICM Institute for Computational Cosmology University of Durham Michael Balogh.
G. Murante – INAF OATo P. Monaco – Univ. Ts M. Calabrese – SISSA Ts G. De Lucia - INAF OATs S. Borgani – Univ. Ts K. Dolag – Obs..Munchen Heidelberg, May.
The 6 th KIAS Workshop on Cosmology & Structure Formation Nov. 4, 2014 Effects of hot halo gas during distant galaxy-galaxy encounters Jeong-Sun Hwang.
Numerical issues in SPH simulations of disk galaxy formation Tobias Kaufmann, Lucio Mayer, Ben Moore, Joachim Stadel University of Zürich Institute for.
The two phases of massive galaxy formation Thorsten Naab MPA, Garching UCSC, August, 2010.
Theoretical work on Cosmology and Structure Formation Massimo Ricotti.
Early Evolution of Massive Galaxies Romeel Davé Kristian Finlator Ben D. Oppenheimer University of Arizona.
How Galaxies Assemble Romeel Davé, Univ. of Arizona With: Dušan Kereš & Neal Katz (U.Mass), and David Weinberg (Ohio State)
Simon Portegies Zwart (Univ. Amsterdam with 2 GRAPE-6 boards)
Gustavo Yepes Universidad Autónoma de Madrid KNAW International Colloquium on COSMIC VOIDS Amsterdam 2006.
X-Ray Group Scaling Relations: Insights for Galaxy Formation Romeel Davé (Arizona) Neal Katz (UMass) David Weinberg (Ohio State) (work in progress)
Are Galactic Winds Shaping the Properties of Dwarf Galaxies? Konstantinos Tassis The University of Chicago Andrey Kravtsov University of Chicago Nick GnedinFermilab,
Cosmological N-body simulations of structure formation Jürg Diemand, Ben Moore and Joachim Stadel, University of Zurich.
Dark Matter and Galaxy Formation (Section 3: Galaxy Data vs. Simulations) Joel R. Primack 2009, eprint arXiv: Presented by: Michael Solway.
Krakow 2010 Galactic magnetic fields: MRI or SN-driven dynamo? Detlef Elstner Oliver Gressel Natali Dziourkevich Alfio Bonanno Günther Rüdiger.
Cosmological MHD Hui Li Collaborators: S. Li, M. Nakamura, S. Diehl, B. Oshea, P. Kronberg, S. Colgate (LANL) H. Xu, M. Norman (UCSD), R. Cen (Princeton)
PRESIDENCY UNIVERSITY
Missing baryons and missing metals in galaxies: clues from the Milky Way Smita Mathur The Ohio State University With Anjali Gupta, Yair Krongold, Fabrizio.
THE STRUCTURE OF COLD DARK MATTER HALOS J. Navarro, C. Frenk, S. White 2097 citations to NFW paper to date.
Estimate* the Total Mechanical Feedback Energy in Massive Clusters Bill Mathews & Fulai Guo University of California, Santa Cruz *~ ±15-20% version 2.
MODELING INTRACLUSTER MEDIUM AND DARK MATTER IN GALAXY CLUSTERS Elena Rasia Dipartimento di Astronomia Università di Padova Padova, April 9th, 2002.
Cosmological formation of elliptical galaxies * Thorsten Naab & Jeremiah P. Ostriker (Munich, Princeton) T.Naab (USM), P. Johannson (USM), J.P. Ostriker.
Galaxies…. + On the largest scales… they trace the cosmic structure as the “living fossils” of the earliest density fluctuations of the universe They are.
Galaxy Characteristics Surface Brightness Alternative to Luminosity I(R) = Flux/area = erg/s/cm 2 /arcsec 2 I(0) – center flux I(R) = at radius R Define.
Effects of baryons on the structure of massive galaxies and clusters Oleg Gnedin University of Michigan Collisionless N-body simulations predict a nearly.
Superbubble Driven Outflows in Cosmological Galaxy Evolution Ben Keller (McMaster University) James Wadsley, Hugh Couchman CASCA 2015 Paper: astro-ph:
, Tuorla Observatory 1 Galaxy groups in ΛCDM simulations and SDSS DR5 P. Nurmi, P. Heinämäki, S. Niemi, J. Holopainen Tuorla Observatory E. Saar,
The Main Mode of Galaxy/Star Formation? Avishai Dekel, HU Jerusalem Leiden, September 2008 HU Flow Team Birnboim, Freundlich, Goerdt, Neistein, Zinger.
The Warm-hot Gaseous Halo of the Milky Way Smita Mathur The Ohio State University With Anjali Gupta, Yair Krongold, Fabrizio Nicastro, M. Galeazzi.
Dwarf LSB galaxies in the Virgo cluster Jonathan Davies.
Large-scale structure at high z: the SHADES survey Eelco van Kampen, University of Edinburgh with Jim Dunlop, John Peacock, Will Percival, Chris Rimes,
Sean Passmoor Supervised by Dr C. Cress Simulating the Radio Sky.
Stellar Feedback Effects on Galaxy Formation Filippo Sigward Università di Firenze Dipartimento di Astronomia e Scienza dello Spazio Japan – Italy Joint.
The coordinated growth of stars, haloes and large-scale structure since z=1 Michael Balogh Department of Physics and Astronomy University of Waterloo.
Lecture 29: From Smooth to Lumpy Astronomy 1143 – Spring 2014.
Large-scale Structure Simulations A.E. Evrard, R Stanek, B Nord (Michigan) E. Gaztanaga, P Fosalba, M. Manera (Barcelona) A. Kravtsov (Chicago) P.M Ricker.
Simulations by Ben Moore (Univ. of Zurich)
 Density and temperature conspire to have higher ionization species peak at higher radii (below); this qualitative behavior is seen for all feedback models.
Feedback Observations and Simulations of Elliptical Galaxies –Daniel Wang, Shikui Tang, Yu Lu, Houjun Mo (UMASS) –Mordecai Mac-Low (AMNH) –Ryan Joung (Princeton)
1 Carlo Nipoti Dipartimento di Astronomia Università di Bologna Thermal evaporation, AGN feedback and quenched star formation in massive galaxies Chandra.
Energy Balance in Clusters of Galaxies Patrick M. Motl & Jack O. Burns Center for Astrophysics and Space Astronomy University of Colorado at Boulder X-ray.
How do Galaxies Get Their Gas? Dušan Kereš Institute for Theory and Computation - Harvard-Smithsonian CFA Collaborators: Neal Katz, David Weinberg, Romeel.
1 Suparna Roychowdhury Groups of galaxies in nearby universe, Santiago, Chile, december, 2005 Astronomy Group, Raman Research Institute Bangalore,
The influence of baryons on the matter distribution and shape of dark matter halos Weipeng Lin , Yipeng Jing ( Shanghai Astronomical Observatory , CAS.
What determines the gas content of galaxies?. Galaxy formation - a reminder of the puzzle The fraction of baryons that are “cold” (stars+cold gas) is.
The Inter-Galactic Populations and Unbound Dark Matter Ing-Guey Jiang and Yu-Ting Wu National Tsing-Hua University Taiwan.
Lyman Alpha Spheres from the First Stars observed in 21 cm Xuelei Chen (Beijing) Jordi Miralda Escudé (IEEC, Barcelona).
SPH Simulations of the Galaxy Evolution NAKASATO, Naohito University of Tokyo.
OWLS: OverWhelmingly Large Simulations The formation of galaxies and the evolution of the intergalactic medium.
The High Redshift Universe Next Door
The Formation and Evolution of Galaxies Michael Balogh University of Waterloo.
KASI Galaxy Evolution Journal Club A Massive Protocluster of Galaxies at a Redshift of z ~ P. L. Capak et al. 2011, Nature, in press (arXive: )
Interpreting the relationship between galaxy luminosity, color, and environment. Andreas Berlind (NYU, CCPP) SPH predictions: Michael Blanton (NYU) David.
Preventing Star and Galaxy Formation Michael Balogh Department of Physics and Astronomy University of Waterloo.
The Physics of Galaxy Formation. Daniel Ceverino (NMSU/Hebrew U.) Anatoly Klypin, Chris Churchill, Glenn Kacprzak (NMSU) Socorro, 2008.
Arman Khalatyan AIP 2006 GROUP meeting at AIP. Outline What is AGN? –Scales The model –Multiphase ISM in SPH SFR –BH model Self regulated accretion ?!
The formation of ultra-compact dwarf galaxies and nucleated dwarf galaxies Collaborators: Ben Moore, Stelios Kazantzidis, Tobias Kaufmann, Andrea V. Macciò.
The formation and dynamical state of the brightest cluster galaxies
Core of Coma Cluster (optical)
Brightest ~500,000 Galaxies in the Northern Hemisphere (1977; RA & DEC only) 2-D “lacework” pattern.
Presentation transcript:

GALAXIES IN DIFFERENT ENVIRONMENTS: VOIDS TO CLUSTERS:  Simulations will require to model full physics:  Cooling, heating, star formation feedbacks…  Large dynamical range: resolving galaxies in different density environments.  Important problems to address:  Excess of small scale structure in CDM models: making small halos invisible?.  Hubble sequence (formation of disks)  Interactions galaxy -ICM

GALAXIES IN VOIDS M. Hoeft, G. Yepes, S. Gottlober and V. Springel astro-ph /

Void dwarf dark halos. Gottlöber et al 03 Void dwarf galax

Halo Mass function in Voids

The missing dwarf galaxy problem in VOIDS ● No galaxies brighter than M b =-15 found. ● What happens with baryons of small halos in voids? – Are they visible but faint?. Magnitude, colors. (Red Dwarfs) – Are they just baryonless dark halos? ● What are the physical mechanism – Gas evaporation by UV photoionization – Supernova feedback (e.g Dekel & Silk) ● What is the typical halo mass for this to happen?

VOIDS FROM A 80/h Mpc Box effective particle in void region M gas = M gas = 5.5  10 6 M  M dark = M dark = 3.4  10 7 M  Smoothing= kpc Smoothing= kpc 10/h Mpc Simulations done with GADGET2 Primordial Cooling Photoionization Multiphase medium Star formation FeedbackThermal Kinetic (Winds)

effective particles RUN with –M gas = 1.5  10 6 M  –M dark = 8.2  10 6 M  Spatial smoothing= 0.5 kpc Different feedback params. Same void was resimulated with full resolution –M gas  2  10 5 M  –M dark  10 6 M  –Spatial smoothing= 0.5 kpc (ULTRA)HIGH-RESOLUTION SIMULATIONS OF A VOID IN THE 50/h Mpc Box 10/h Mpc

The missing dwarf galaxy problem in VOIDS ● No galaxies brighter than M b =-15 found. ● What happens with baryons of small halos in voids? – Are they visible but faint?. Magnitude, colors. (Red Dwarfs) – Are they just baryonless dark halos? ● What are the physical mechanism – Gas evaporation by UV photoionization – Supernova feedback (e.g Dekel & Silk) ● What is the typical halo mass for this to happen?

Baryon fraction Halos below few times 10 9 M sun are baryon-poor Characteristic mass scale depends on redshift Baryon fract

Characteristic mass Characteristic mass M c baryon-rich baryon-poor M c rises significantly with z Halo may start baryon-rich and become later baryon-poor Char mass

T entry Density temperature phase space Cold mode of galactic gas accretion: gas creeps along the equilibrium line between heating and cooling (Keres et al. 04) Rho T

Max gas temperature Relate radius to mass Prediction for M c Measurement M c Condition for suppression How to suppress gas condensation? How to

Entry temperature versus characteristic mass General scaling: factor 1.3 High redshift: empty halos has to develop T entry

Mass accretion history Mass accr hist

Baryon poor small halos MAH, several total massbaryonic (condensed) mass

Age of stars In small halos stars can only be formed at high redshift Age

Thermal feedback Strong wind model z=0 Luminosity function

Color evolution z=0 z=1

SOME CLUES ABOUT DWARF GALAXIES IN VOIDS Halos below M lim ~ 7x10 9 M  (v c ~ 27 km/s) are photo- evaporated and have almost no baryon content, either cold gas or stars. This mass scale decreases with redshift. Very small dependence of UV flux. UV-heating not able to suppress small galaxies: Problem for semianalitical models to explain substructure in the Local Group. Thermal feedback does not play a significant role in keeping gas out of halos. Kinetic feedback (winds) can be very efficient in inhibitting star-formation: Z agreement, redder colors,

WORK IN PROGRESS...

DWARF GALAXIES IN GROUPS:

Group five

Baryonfraction again

Metallicity enrichment: Remove baryons by feedback? Dekel+Woo Feedback

GALAXIES IN CLUSTERS Entropy generation from galactic feedback. Scaling relations and non-adiabatic physics. Understanding Intracluster light. Effect of central Cd-galaxy on ICM radial profiles. Cold fronts and cold flows. How many galaxies survive in the cluster environment? Very demanding simulations: E.g. Cluster 6 simulated with 4.5 million particles within 3 virial radius took more than 680,000 timesteps to finished.

STAR FORMATION IN CLUSTERS  Photonisation  Cooling  Multiphase medium  Metallicity  Wind model  Springel & Herquist 2003  Obtain observational properties of dark halos from stars using BC2003 SSP models  Study

 CDM CLUSTER SIMULATIONS   m =0.3;   =0.7, h=0.7;  8 =0.9 ● 80/h Mpc box size. (Initial P(k) for ) ● Resample to particles. ● Identify clusters for resimulation GADGET (2-5 kpc)

Z=1;  =3 A=1 z=0

LARGE-SCALE SPH SIMULATIONS   m =0.3;   =0.7, h=0.7;  8 =0.9,  b =0.045  500/h Mpc box size. (Initial P(k) for )  Runs with up to particles.  # Halos=4x10 5 (M>10 12 M  )  M dark = 7x10 10 M   Identify clusters for resimulation with  Mass of clusters  M cluster  2.5  M   Same resolution than previous simulations 500 h -1 Mpc

Z=1;  =3 A=1 z=0

Lx-Tx T x 1.9. M vir > M  < M vir < x10 13 < M vir < Clusters at 500 Mpc/h

Lx-Tx. M vir > M  < M vir < x10 13 < M vir < T x 1.9 Observations Clusters at 500 Mpc/h

Lx-Tx. M vir > M  < M vir < x10 13 < M vir < T x 1.9 Observations Clusters at 500 Mpc/h Resimulated clusters at 80 Mpc/h

X-ray Temperature Function

LARGE-SCALE SPH SIMULATIONS  The MareNostrum Universe Simulation:  500/h Mpc box size. (Initial P(k) for )  2x particles.  # Halos=10 6 (M>10 12 M  )  M dark = M   Resolution 15 kpc. 500 h -1 Mpc