Indonesia Update: Illegality, tracking, enforcement and corruption by TELAPAK representative of Indonesian Civil Society.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

Tackling Illegal Logging and Associated Trade Lessons Learned for REDD Design and Implementation Indonesia Case Study May 28, 2009 AFP Dialogue.

Advertisements

Third GOPAC Conference Dr. Muhyieddeen Touq Kuwait November 2008.

Philippines Development Forum Rule of Law Working Group.

Towards a Unified Methodology for Measuring Corruption Global Forum V on Fighting Corruption and Safeguarding Integrity 2 – 5 April 2007 Johannesburg,

EU strategy for supporting FLEG regional declarations Mathieu Bousquet European Commission, DEVCO F3.

Trade & environment Case study: International Timber trade Trade & environment Case study: International Timber trade.

Law Enforcement and Compliance: Illegal logging Aniko M. Nemeth, REC April 2009.

Evaluation of Current Situation of Anti-Corruption in Thailand

Logging in the Brazilian Amazon and Enforcement of Forest Laws Brenda Brito Assistant Researcher and Vice-Executive Director of Imazon

The Civil Society-Independent Forest Monitors An independent forest monitoring team made up of four members of the NGO Coalition of Liberia. Focus on.

Cambodian HE Vision 2030 By Mak Ngoy From Policies to Practices: “Efforts to Excel Cambodia and to Successfully Engage in ASEAN Community through Education”

6 August 2015 Rule of law: implementing a comprehensive and integrated approach in prevention and fight against corruption in the Danube region,

A Structured Approach for Measuring Progress towards the ENA FLEG Ministerial Declaration July 09, 2014, Tbilisi, Georgia (Joanne Gaskell, Vladislava Nemova,

Montenegro Anti-corruption Conference, 19/10/2005 Anti-corruption Measures and Policies: European Integration, its Standards, and Regional Co-operation.

Commission for the Prevention of Corruption Republic of Slovenia INTEGRITY I ACCOUNTABILITY I RULE OF LAW.

Prepared By Mas Achmad Santosa Indonesian Center for Environmental Law.

Indonesia: Transparency in the Forestry sector Fred Stolle World Resources Institute Forest Team.

Update on FLEGT VPA processes internationally Presentation by Jannik Vaa, EU Delegation, Accra June 7th, 2011 West Africa Forest Governance Forum.

Successful strategies for supporting regional FLEG declarations Regional Conference on ”Update on the 2005 Saint Petersburg Ministerial Declaration” Tbilisi,

Module 3 Why measure corruption? Assessment anxiety? vast diversity of approaches that serve different purposes UNCAC reporting mechanism asks countries.

Improve Forest Law Enforcement and Governance in the Mekong Region World Bank-FLEG – Todd Sigaty ASEAN ASOF 2009.

1 Preparing VPA in Indonesia through multi-stakeholders process Presented to Illegal Logging Update and Stakeholder Consultation Chatham House, London.

© OECD A joint initiative of the OECD and the European Union, principally financed by the EU. TRANSPARENCY OF THE PUBLIC INSTITUTIONS Josip Kregar Conference.

AN OVERVIEW OF WWF GFTN ACTIVITIES TO IMPROVE FOREST MANAGEMENT IN GHANA BY: ABRAHAM BAFFOE FOREST OFFICER WWF-WARPO.

1 EUROPEAN COMMISSION CHATHAM HOUSE EU FLEGT Initiative: Analysis of national legislation of relevance to excluding illegal timber from EU markets – Italy.

By Charles K. Miller VPA Support Unit Mamba Point, Monrovia, Liberia West Africa Forest Governance Forum Held at: Grand Royal Hotel Monrovia, Liberia A.

A REPORT ON GOVERNMENT IMPLEMENTATION OF THE 1999 SUMMIT RESOLUTIONS : 26 TH MARCH 2003 A review and revision of legislation COMBATING CORRUPTION A review.

Laws Related to GHG Mitigation Efforts: Indonesian Experience Dr. Laode Syarif Dr. Andri G. Wibisana 2008 AECEN Forum -- Bali, Indonesia November 26, 2008.

National Policy and Legal Frameworks to Curb Illegal Wildlife Trade Jorge Eduardo Rios Coordinator, UNODC Anti-Wildlife and Forest Crime Programme ADB.

License to operate = License to finance illegal operations? An overview of policy options to regulate financial institutions servicing deforestation.

MOSCOW, NOVEMBER 12 – 14, THE RESEARCH 1.Respondents 8 respondents from SAI Indonesia : auditor, investigator, R &D 2.Time 3 weeks (Sept to Oct.

Ratification of the United Nations Convention against Corruption in Lithuania A Review of the Compliance of the Lithuanian Legal and Institutional Framework.

1. EU-FLEGT In 1998, after international meeting of G8, EU adopted the action plan to address the problem of illegal logging and related trade. In 2003,

FLEGT and REDD+ reflections from VPA negotiations 4 October 2011 Julia Falconer, European Commission, DEVCO C2.

Why do corruption risks need to be addressed now? What are corruption risks in REDD+? What are risk mitigation actions? What are the tools? Who can prevent.

Transparency and Anti- Corruption in Bulgaria Mr. Stefan Sofianski, Mayor of Sofia, Former Prime-Minister of Bulgaria Presentation at MADAGASCAR GOVERNMENT.

WRI’s Forest Landscapes Initiative Overview September 2008 WRI’s Forest Landscapes Initiative Overview September 2008.

Records and Accountability Presentation made by Sahr J. Kpundeh World Bank Institute.

Stopping Illegal Logging With A Financial Approach Indonesian Working Group on Forest Finance Chatam House, March 2006.

Duncan Brack Brussels, 27 April Support to timber-producing countries 2. Trade in timber 3. Public procurement 4. Private sector initiatives.

Introduction The Liberia chainsaw and timber dealers union is Liberian founded and driven institution with intent to improve forest governance sustainable.

INDONESIA-EU VOLUNTARY PARTNERSHIP AGREEMENT Indonesia Civil Society Experience Mardi Minangsari/TELAPAK.

Ministry of the Interior of the Republic of Latvia STATE POLICE of LATVIA CENTRAL CRIMINAL POLICE DEPARTMENT Economic Crime Enforcement Department.

Mobilizing Anti-Money Laundering regimes to Combat Wildlife Crime Marilyne Pereira Goncalves, World Bank.

Poverty and VPAs Mary Hobley and Marlene Buchy 25 th April FLEGT week.

Current stattus of laws in Indonesia Chatam House, March 2006.

THINKING beyond the canopy "Follow the money" Anna C. Sinaga, Sofi Mardiah Wollongong, February 23, 2010 An integrated law enforcement approach to combat.

Human Trafficking in Bosnia and Herzegovina SAMIR RIZVO State Coordinator for Combating Trafficking in Human Beings and Illegal Migration.

Joanita Rwebangira University of Kwazulu-Natal Human Trafficking- A Contemporary African Perspective.

EU Delegation to Moldova Moldova closer to the European Union Support to civil society © EU delegation to Moldova.

FOLLOWING THE PROCEEDS OF ENVIRONMENTAL CRIME: FISH, FORESTS AND FILTHY LUCRES University of Wollongong February 2010 Arif Havas Oegroseno Director-General.

M O N T E N E G R O Negotiating Team for the Accession of Montenegro to the European Union Working Group for Chapter 27 – Environment Bilateral screening:

Local Governance Anti-Corruption & REDD in Latin America and the Caribbean.

Delegation of the European Commission to Turkey Delegation of the European Commission to Turkey Brussels, 4 May 2009 EU Action for Human Rights in a Candidate.

1 New EU legislation to prevent trading in illegal timber on the EU market SARAWAK INDUSTRY UPDATE Kuching, 20 July 2009 Vincent van den Berk European.

Forest Law Enforcement and Governance in Central Asia Kassel Project financed by the European Union The objective: Promotion of legal and sustainable.

Kingdom of Cambodia 1 Anti-Corruption Mechanism In Cambodia Presenter: Mr. Try Sothearith Dean of Business Faculty of Business and Economics, Western University,

M O N T E N E G R O Negotiating Team for the Accession of Montenegro to the European Union Working Group for Chapter 27 – Environment and climate change.

FOREST GOVERANCE AND FLEGT MASTERCLASS

Name: Faten Al-Mohsin ID: Major: Finance

GFIS – Indonesian Current Condition

Procurement Law in Indonesia Legal Context

Criminal Justice and the Law

A dry look at a very interesting part of government.

Ministry of Environment and Forestry of Indonesia

Partners: EUI, Hertie, SAR, Basel Institute, and BCE

Policy Recommendations for Negotiations with US

Criminal Justice and the Law

A good practice of harmonisation between reforms: public internal control and anti-corruption Edit Németh, Head of CHU Ministry of Finance.

Phanindra Gautam September, 2017

Presentation transcript:

Indonesia Update: Illegality, tracking, enforcement and corruption by TELAPAK representative of Indonesian Civil Society

Overview Iniative to combat forest crime in Indonesia is not simple as being imagined. The mastermind behind the illegal operation are still untouchable, and only the field operator jailed. ICS  monitor the forestry crime by using the comprehensive approach, including anti corruption and anti money laundry act.

Enforcement in Indonesia Policy: Forestry Act Number 41/1999. Actions for Combating Illegal Logging Act. President Instruction Number 4/2005 on Combating Illegal Logging. Anti Money Laundering Act Number 25/2003. Anti Corruption Act Number 19/2001. Review Government Law Number 34/2002 on Forest Management and Administration.

…..continued Action: Enforcement Operation. Anti Money Laundring.

Result There are a lot of government institutions who involve in the area for tackling the forest crime issues yet success story still limited. The moral commitment of law enforcer in order to deal with the problems is low where in lot of cases corrupt officials were highly suspiciosed involved in the crime. There are lack of understanding on the relevant laws, including the Anti Money Laundry Act and Anti Corruption Act. These are lots of cases resulted the released of the offender or low verdict in the courts and that almost all of the masterminds behind the illegal operation are untouchable. There are cases where civil society which include the local communities that actively monitored the forest crime were experienced violance actions from the timber mafia and corrupt officials.

ICS Position GoI: to implement comprehensive strategy to curb the forest crime through reviewing the relevant regulations and reforming the governance. also effectively use the regulations of Anti Money Laundry Act and Anti Corruption Act to get hold the master mind behind the illegal operation. to accelerate the process of setting up the witness protection act in order to give the assurance for ICS and local communities to monitor the forest crime activities

…. Continued EU and GoI: to put the Anti Money Laundry approach in VPA negotiation with the result to implement the prevention effort to avoid the corruption financial issues.