Strategic Partnership in Crisis Dexter Whitfield Centre for Public Services May 2005.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
CASE STUDY – SUFFOLK HIGHWAYS PARTNERSHIP HEADLINE CWC assessed the potential for the implementation of Open Book Cost Management and Target Costing into.
Advertisements

A Health and Wellbeing Board for Leicestershire Cheryl Davenport Programme Director.
Options appraisal, the business case & procurement
Value for Money – new requirements and challenges
Pursuing Effective Governance in Canada’s National Sport Community June 2011.
Northern Refugee Centre Regional Event SHARED SERVICES AMONG RCO’s.
1 A risk-based approach to auditing procurement in English councils Mark Wardman Senior Manager Audit Commission 19 May 2014.
Health and social care integration - update Accounts CommissionMarch 2014.
Waveney District Council Councillor C Law Deputy Leader & Portfolio Holder for Customer Access.
Auditing, Assurance and Governance in Local Government
Niki Clemo Service Director – Children’s Social Care Cambridgeshire 14 December 2011.
Buying Better Outcomes Workshop 4 Equalities and Contract Management If you do not take it seriously, why should the supplier?
8 - 1 ©2006 Prentice Hall Business Publishing, Auditing 11/e, Arens/Beasley/Elder Audit Planning and Analytical Procedures Chapter 8.
Governing Board for the Inkomati CMA Inaugural Meeting Planning 22 nd September 2005.
Children’s Social Care Workload Management System (WMS) A Two-fold approach DSLT 16 th November 2010 Updated with new SWRB standards.
Water Framework Directive Stakeholder Forum 30 June
BS1033 Local Government – Continuity and Change 5. Modernising Local Government – Best Value.
Regulation and Competition in Professional Services: Accounting services.
Auditing II Unit 1 : Audit Procedures Unit 2: Audit of Limited Companies Unit 3: Audit of Government Companies.
Legal & Administrative Oversight of NGOs Establishing and Monitoring Performance Standards.
Smart Service Delivery in Challenging Times Shared services – what does it mean for you? Alan Higgins Chair, CIEH Council Director, Environmental Health.
UNIVERSITY ACCOUNTABILITY An Ontario and New Zealand Perspective.
Strategic Service Partnerships and UNISON Strategy Colin Meech National Officer.
Army Directorate of Public Works Support Contractor of the Year Carlos Garcia Owner/CEO KIRA Maximizing Return on Investment in Business Development.
Good Governance Diagnostic Vale of Glamorgan Council Initial key messages Louise Fleet, Emma Giles and Simon Jones GL4865 July 2009.
Waste Strategy Project Waste Management Strategy Implementation Governance Arrangements – Joint Working Agreement / Project Management John Whiddon: Project.
Attracting appropriate user funding in the context of declining public funding.
Working in partnership with Crescent Purchasing Consortium Buying Temporary & Teaching Staff 5 th May 2010.
Supporting tools in an IT Project & Portfolio Management environment Ann Van Belle -
1 1 BRANCH: CORPORATE AFFAIRS 1. CORPORATE MANAGEMENT SERVICES To provide financial and strategic support services that enhance service delivery by the.
Cost Reduction: With or Without Headcount Reduction
©2012 Prentice Hall Business Publishing, Auditing 14/e, Arens/Elder/Beasley Audit Planning and Analytical Procedures Chapter 8.
©2010 Prentice Hall Business Publishing, Auditing 13/e, Arens/Elder/Beasley Audit Planning and Analytical Procedures Chapter 8.
Chapter 8 Audit Planning 1.
Audit Advisory Committee Public health transition update 22 January 2013.
©2008 Prentice Hall Business Publishing, Auditing 12/e, Arens/Beasley/Elder Audit Planning and Analytical Procedures Chapter 8.
INTERNAL AUDIT AND INVESTIGATION SERVICES PRESENTATION TO THE PORTFOLIO COMMITTEE ON THE UNIT’S ACTIVITIES FOR THE YEAR ENDING 31 MARCH 2006 Z MXUNYELWA,
Age & Disabilities Odyssey Conference Tuesday, June 21, 2011.
Joint Reviews of Local Authority Social Services JOINT REVIEW OF SALFORD COUNCIL 17 th June 2003.
Tenant Scrutiny in Croydon Marilyn Smithies & Michael Hewlett, Tenant Scrutiny Steering Group Chris Stock, Head of Performance, Croydon Council.
Torrington, Hall & Taylor, Human Resource Management 6e, © Pearson Education Limited 2005 Slide 21.1 Views on Trade Union Recognition The proportion of.
A wide range of clients Housing associations 3 rd sector bodies Private companies supplying services to the public sector Colleges and government bodies.
EU Code of Practice Peer Review 2006 – 8 :A Peer’s Perspective Frank Nolan Office for National Statistics UK.
IRSPM 2014 Intersections: Governance, Democracy, Accountability D1 Special Interest Group Accounting and Accountability A strategic state firework fallen.
Nottingham Trent University Alternative Futures Conference 2014 The OECD concept of the ‘Strategic State’ and its application to 3 inter-related areas.
Presentation to the Portfolio Committee for Public Works 14 August 2002.
Leading Nottingham Programme update to ACOS 7 September 2010 Angela Probert Director of HR and Organisational Transformation Contributions from Lisa Sharples.
Scottish Local Authority Chief Internal Auditors Group Conference - June 2013.
Moving Towards Better Housing- Scrutiny Commission on the Future of Council Housing Amanda Skelton Executive Director, Neighbourhood Services 4 March 2003.
REVIEW OF EARLY YEARS, CHILDREN’S CENTRES AND FAMILY SUPPORT PROPOSALS FOR CHANGE.
By the public sector, for the public sector About LGSS  LGSS established in October 2010 as a joint shared services partnership between Cambridgeshire.
Torbay Council Partnerships Review August PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP Date Page 2 Torbay Council Partnerships Background The Audit Commission defines.
RESOURCES AND CORPORATE DEVELOPMENT SCRUTINY COMMITTEE Tuesday 17 th June 2003 RESOURCES DIRECTORATE Julie Alderson Executive Director Resources.
Effective Board Governance & role of the Audit Committee Presentation by Cluster Audit Committee – July / August 2012.
1 Balanced Scorecard Philosophy, Basics, Fundamentals, and Functions.
Use of Resources Lifting the burden CAA experience at Barrow in Furness Borough Council Mick McKinnell, ICT & Customer Services Manager.
Copyright © 2014 Pearson Education, Inc. Publishing as Prentice Hall. Chapter
North Somerset Partnership Priorities & Opportunities 2 December 2015.
©2005 Prentice Hall Business Publishing, Auditing and Assurance Services 10/e, Arens/Elder/Beasley Audit Planning and Analytical Procedures Chapter.
NHS Milton Keynes CCG Constitution This document is not a legal document and is not to be used as a replacement for the full version of the NHS Milton.
Audit Committee 1 June 2005 Overview of the Audit Function in the Council and Role of Audit Committee.
©2010 Prentice Hall Business Publishing, Auditing 13/e, Arens/Elder/Beasley Audit Planning and Analytical Procedures Chapter 8.
4/29/2018 NDA STRATEGIC PLAN AND ANNUAL PERFORMANCE PLAN PRESENTATION TO THE PORTFOLIO COMMITTEE ON SOCIAL DEVELOPMENT 3 MAY 2017 MRS THAMO MZOBE CHIEF.
Successful Integration is a result of good governance – getting the wiring right Integrated care as an aspiration is simple, and simplest if one begins.
Christian Carter Performance For University of Bristol
Audit Planning and Analytical Procedures
The partnership principle in the implementation of the CSF funds ___ Elements for a European Code of Conduct.
GPW ANNUAL PERFORMANCE PLAN 2018/19
Equality and Diversity Council
MARIAM SOCK – THE GAMBIA
Presentation transcript:

Strategic Partnership in Crisis Dexter Whitfield Centre for Public Services May 2005

Methodology Analysis of information on the SSP held by the Bedfordshire County Council UNISON branch. Analysis of Audit Commission Best Value and Comprehensive Performance Assessment (CPA) and OFSTED Local Education Authority (LEA) inspections. A search of Bedfordshire County Council’s web site for reports and minutes of the Council, the Executive, Strategic Partnership Management Board, Scrutiny etc. Semi-structured interviews with a cross section of staff and trade union representatives. A review of reports and technical notes published by the Office of the Deputy Prime Minister’s (ODPM) Strategic Partnering Taskforce. Bedfordshire-relevant material from research reports and surveys on SSPs by the Centre for Public Services.

The partnership Between Bedfordshire County Council and HBS Business Services Group Ltd (Terra Firma - equity investment group). £267m 12-year contract starting June Local authority services - information technology, financial services, human resources, school support services, communications, management of outsourced contracts. HBS has similar contracts in Lincolnshire, Middlesbrough, Milton Keynes and Bath.

HBS company performance Financial indicators03/200103/200203/200303/2004 Turnover (£m) Profit/Loss before tax (£m) Profit margin (%) Return on Capital Employed (%) Gearing (%) Liquidity Ratio Number of employees1,7742,9932,7952,887

The promises A Regional Business Centre in Bedford to win additional work and create new jobs. A 45 seat Customer Contact Centre for all services. Investment of £7.8m in new IT, including integrated resource management system, SAP. £6.9m investment to improve accommodation. High quality and competitive support services to schools. A review of training facilities and a National Centre for Excellence in Education. Improved services to achieve upper quartile Best Value performance. An annual reduction in service costs of 2% (about £900,000).

Impact on Services Service delivery problems Performance down in the 4 Best Value Corporate health indicators. No evidence of Regional Business Centre or new jobs. Quality of school support services in decline. National centre of Excellence in Education constantly delayed. Council incurred considerable additional costs and unclear whether original savings target met. Only part of £7m investment in County Hall spent. “The strategic partnership is not delivering improvement in services” - District Auditor, January HBS achievements Customer Contact Centre and SAP implemented

Performance

Performance comparison

Additional evidence “The strategic partnership is not delivering improvement in services” Annual Audit and Inspection Letter, District Audit, January Failure to publish Council 2003/04 Accounts on time partly blamed on arrangements with HBS. “The Council has not yet been able to gain capacity from its strategic partnership” Comprehensive Performance Assessment, 2004, Audit Commission.

Impact on Jobs 550 jobs transferred to HBS in June HBS employed new staff on different terms and conditions- sometimes big wage differentials. Two-tier workforce and Best Value Code of Practice on Workforce Matters does not apply because contract started before March HBS refuses to sign local or national recognition agreement with UNISON and other unions. HBS poor record in communicating with staff. Some services now being transferred back to the council from HBS.

Strategic Lessons Sharpen critique of partnerships - they are essentially large contracts but with a contractor in a powerful position inside the local authority. Get the message across to Elected Members and the trade union membership about the limitations of partnerships. Demand that the Scrutiny Committee(s) fully monitors and assesses the implementation process and all aspects of the partnership. Ensure that Strategic Partnerships and PPPs are democratically accountable and transparent.

Alternative to Partnership Original UNISON position: –Council should acquire hardware, software and expertise/training as and when required on ‘best in class’ basis. –A phased qualitative implementation of ICT involving staff and user organisations. –Staff remain council employees. Advantages - builds council capacity, minimises risk and reliance on one contractor, better employment conditions, greater staff involvement, phased process learning lessons as it progresses.

Recommendations The partnership contract with HBS should be terminated. Council should adopt an incremental approach to ICT based on testing and using best-in-class suppliers. In the interim period HBS should :1. negotiate a recognition agreement locally/nationally with UNISON. 2. eliminate the two- tier workforce with HBS agreeing to voluntarily abide by Code of Practice on Workforce Matters. 3. agree to full participation and consultation with staff, UNISON and other trade unions. Comprehensive evaluation of contract - evidence from elected members, staff, trade unions, schools and user organisations. Improve the governance and transparency of the partnership. Public debate about the need, role, cost and plans for a National Centre for Educational Excellence. UNISON and other trade unions should be fully involved in the service review process.