Ethnographic “Truth” “The writing and reading of ethnography are overdetermined by forces ultimately beyond the control of either an author or an interpretive.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Renaissance.
Advertisements

Revisiting The Crisis of Representation. Decolonizing Participant Observation. Conference: (Be-)Deutungsansprüche in qualitativer Forschung Positionen,
Popular Culture & Visual Rhetoric. What is pop culture? Popular - Everyday things Whats hot ? Fashion Technology Music Food Lifestyles Sports Places.
WHAT IS ANTHROPOLOGY? The term originates from two words in Greek:
A post-modern ethnography is a cooperatively evolved text consisting of fragments of discourse intended to evoke in the minds of both reader and writer.
CMNS801 Presentation Postmodern ethnography (The postmodern turn in anthropology) Ayaka Yoshimizu October 21, 2008.
New Historicism Exploring the value of history in literature A sociological and anthropological approach to criticism.
English 472 A Review. Overview  Histories  Theories  Questions and Quandaries.
Chapter 5 Print Language, Literate Culture
The Rainforest Katie Farlow, Whitney McManus, Rita Hill, Quiana Allen & Lauren McCarthy.
Sex and the Anthropologist Sexuality in the field was treated as a joke, brushed aside with funny anecdotes about how to avoid “romantic encounters” or.
The crucial poetic problem for a discursive ethnography becomes how to achieve by written means what speech creates, and to do it without simply imitating.
VES 186c. Film & Photography, Image & Narration Professor David Rodowick Office hours: Monday and Wednesday 3-4 pm, or by appointment. M-06 Sever Hall.
Ways of Knowing Ethnographies have always been written in the context of historical changes: the formation of state systems and the evolution of a world.
Cultural Appropriation: The Politics, and Ethics of Ethnographic Inquiry In Canada, in the 1990's, Aboriginal writers are a growing and vibrant population.
Politics of Ethnography: Translated Woman Part Two What is particularly important in the discussion that hovers around the self-consciously experimental.
Ways of Knowing Ethnographies have always been written in the context of historical changes: the formation of state systems and the evolution of a world.
Postmodernism. According to Sarup, poststructuralists like Foucault, Derrida, and Lyotard are postmodernists There are similarities between poststructuralist.
VISUAL CULTURE.
The Politics of Ethnography: Translated Woman In this book I attempted something that was taboo for anthropology. I not only presented Esperanza’s life.
Rhetoric and the Reader
Ethics and Methods in Cultural Anthropology
Chapter 15 Ethnographic Designs
Copyright © 2011 Pearson Education, Inc. All rights reserved. Chapter 3 History of Anthropological Theory.
POST- MODERNISM P OST - MODERNISM P OST - MODERNISM POST-MODERNISM.
Modernism --the breaking away from established rules, traditions, and conventions; fresh ways of looking at a human’s position and function in the universe.
Disciplines of the Humanities Arts Disciplines Visual art- drawing, painting, printmaking, sculpture, photography Performing art- music, theatre, dance,
Film Theory What Films Do.
Interpretation of Culture By Clifford Geertz. Taking Culture Seriously ICTs, Cultures and Development Chris Westrup et al.
What is Rhetoric? Danna Prather. Well…it depends  Different people are going to give you different definitions for rhetoric. According to Aristotle rhetoric.
Ethnography 1 CRESWELL QUALITATIVE INQUIRY 2E. The purpose of ethnography is to describe and interpret the shared and learned patterns of values, behaviors,
Larry D. Yore Distinguished Professor Emeritus University of Victoria August 6, 2015.
B 203: Qualitative Research Techniques Interpretivism Symbolic Interaction Hermeneutics.
Literary Movements Literature in the context of historically developing perceptions of the world.
Theme of Propaganda Throughout history, art has been used as propaganda to shape public opinion. Propaganda takes many forms, such as architecture, paintings,
Visual ethnography “Truth” Is socially constructed and experientially subjective: Ethnography re-explore important stories,statements, and topics, varying.
LITERARY THEORY 101.
Geovanny J. Berríos. New Criticism  Is a type of formalist current of literary theory that dominated Anglo- American literary criticism in the middle.
From ‘Othering’ to Incorporation: the dilemmas of crossing informal and formal learning boundaries Julian Sefton-Green
Academic Vocab: Part 1.
New Historicism. one of the more recent criticisms One tenet is referentiality: Literature refers to—and is referred to by— things outside itself.
Modernism and Postmodernism
What is Postmodernism?. A POSTMODERN JOKE What do you get when you cross a Deconstructionist with a Mafioso? An offer you can’t understand.
Ways of Studying Religion. The Academic Study of Religion - Assumptions - One religion is neither better nor worse than another religion; they are simply.
Unit 1 Art Reading. Pre-reading- a short history of Western painting  Do you ever visit art galleries?  What are the names of some famous Western or.
Post-Colonialism From political to cultural independence.
How To Analyze a Reading Presented By: Dr. Akassi Content From The Norton’s Field Guide To Writing.
New Historicism Exploring the value of history in literature
What is Anthropology? Anthropology. What do you think of when you think of Canada??? What is Culture?
Critical Approaches to Literature. Critical Approaches -used to analyze, question, interpret, synthesize and evaluate literary works, with a specific.
Common Core State Standards in English/Language Arts What science teachers need to know.
Critical Discourse Analysis
Mr. Bishop Mission Viejo High School. CLOVERLEAF MAP, 1581.
Representations could be: Linguistic Figurative Theoretical.
Literary Critical Theories: Ways of Analyzing Text (overview) Mr. Watson, AP Lit & Comp.
LITERATURE TERMS Fiction Unit. Characterization  The use of literary techniques to create a character. Writers use three major techniques to create characters:
Post Modernism 1939-present. Post Modernism When did it begin: Early post-modernism started before the onset of the second world war. However, some critics.
Do Now Pick up a vocabulary sheet and review the documentary vocabulary words.
Postmodern ethnography (The postmodern turn in anthropology) Ayaka Yoshimizu.
Lecture 1/Term 3: Postmodernity/Postmodernism Dr Claudia Stein.
Critical Lenses and Literary/Film Interpretation.
Modernism and James Joyce Baldo Sara V A A.S
from Magic, through marvellous, to magical
Ambiguities & epistemology (ways to know and produce knowledge): documentary as organized ethnographic texts SM6324 Dr. Linda C.H. LAI.
More information than you ever thought you wanted to know!
NEW HISTORICISM/ CULTURAL STUDIES
English Courses in Grades 11 &12
NEW HISTORICISM/ CULTURAL STUDIES
Literary Criticism the art or practice of judging and commenting on the qualities and character of literary works.
Passage Types Question Types
Presentation transcript:

Ethnographic “Truth” “The writing and reading of ethnography are overdetermined by forces ultimately beyond the control of either an author or an interpretive community. These contingencies--of language, rhetoric, power, and history--must now be openly confronted in the process of writing” (Clifford 1986: 25).

Realist Ethnographies (conventions) Experiential authority-- Ethnographic form-- One point of view--, Interpretive omnipotence--

Experiential Authority absence of author, academic credentials, audience expectations

Particular style (Ethnographic form) arrangements of presentation, editing process “Early in the morning each village almost literally explodes. Asak and odok come down and the village reveals itself for what it is, a conglomeration of individuals of all ages, each going his own way in search of food and water, like a plague of locusts spreading over the land” (Turnbull, The Mountain People, 1971).

Third convention: Absence of native point of view Monovocality Closely edited quotations Verbatim transcriptions

Interpretive Omnipotence final word, link to a theoretical approach

Interpretive Anthropology Science and Literature start to coexist Changing of mentality Redressing of ethnocentric past

Writing … not only as a method influenced by politics, intentionality, positionality,

No longer a marginal, or occulted, dimension, writing has emerged as central to what anthropologist do both in the field and thereafter. The fact that it has not until recently been portrayed or seriously discussed reflects the persistence of an ideology claiming transparency of representation and immediacy of experience (Clifford, 1986: 2).

It draws attention two aspects of anthropology to the historical predicaments of ethnography--tied to a Western mentality the fact that ethnography is interpretation, invention and not an unbiased, totally objective representation of a culture--literary processes affects: 1. cultural phenomena 2. audience

Literary Process metaphor, figuration, narrative style

Literary processes metaphor, figuration, narrative style

Ethnographic writing (art) is characterized in at least six ways contextually rhetorically institutionally generically politically historically

Classicism: artistic and academic movement characterized by the admiration and imitation of Greek and Roman literature.

Modernism: an artistic (and sometimes an academic) movement that represents a wide range of experimental and avant-garde trends in the literature. Example: “Each in His Own Way” Pirandello 1930’s

MODERNISM VERSUS POSTMODERNISM

J.F Lyotard “The Postmodern Condition” (1977) Attacked the totalizing notion in modernism Representing wholeness, truth ness “Writing Culture” Clifford and Marcus (1986) “Anthropology as a Cultural Critique” Marcus and Fisher (1986). Stephen Tyler “Post-modern Ethnography: From Document of the Occult to Occult Document (1986)

Stephen Tyler Evocation rather than representation The split between orality and literacy One perspective (literacy) Versus polyvocal present of multi realities (orality). Object (anthropologist) with subject (the Other)

Timothy Mitchell “Orientalism and the Visionary Order”1989 The vision of the Other “The visual Western episteme,”

THE WEST THE REST The observerThe other CultureNature HistoryStories ORDER SAVAGE Noble Barbarian Wise Evil State: JUSTICE UTOPIA Paradisiac Communist Innocent Illusory Thought: REASON HereElsewhere