What you learn from experience relates to the quality of your thinking Jenny Moon, Centre for Excellence in Media Practice, Bournemouth University, UK.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Peer Mentoring Works : In the students own words…
Advertisements

Learning from work experience: helping young people identify and articulate learning outcomes Faith Muir and Trisha Fettes Centre for Education and Industry.
Critical and Analytical Thinking Transition Programme
By Anthony Campanaro & Dennis Hernandez
Strengthening the Problem-Solving Abilities of Our Students Emma Carberry, School of Mathematics and Statistics.
Reflective learning Tutors’ Conference 17/05/12.
COGNTION & LEARNING: STAGES OF INTELLECTUAL DEVELOPMENT Jennifer Lange.
The role of Reflective Practice in CPD.
Mentoring Awareness Workshop
Evaluating Thinking Through Intellectual Standards
LISTENING. COMMUNICATION requires talking and LISTENING.
WRITING CRITIQUE GROUP GUIDELINES Writing responses to your group members’ work and receiving responses from others is the most important step in revising.
Breakfast PL April, Teacher read-alouds are planned oral readings of a range of texts. They are a vital part of daily literacy instruction in all.
Definitions – John Dewey
Case study Developing students as critical consumers of business information A reflective practice framework.
SUNITA RAI PRINCIPAL KV AJNI
Types of Essays... and why we write them.. Why do we write essays? Hint: The answer is NOT ‘because sir/miss told me to’
Developing Business Practice – 302LON Preparing for a Successful Work Experience Unit: 9 Knowledgecast: 2.
Reflective practice Session 4 – Working together.
School of Education Faculty of Education, Social Sciences & Law Teacher Cognition & Second Language Grammar Teaching Dr Simon Borg.
How the Social Studies Interns are Viewed by their Mentors Going Public Presentation Mike Broda, Mark Helmsing, Chris Kaiser, and Claire Yates.
Questioning techniques The nature and range of teacher questioning can also help to develop thinking skills and understanding. Open and closed questions……
SAT Prep: Improving Paragraphs AVID III Spring 2012.
Mixed-level English classrooms What my paper is about: Basically my paper is about confirming with my research that the use of technology in the classroom.
Why Did You Leave Your Last Job? Why do they ask? to understand your motives and gain insight as how you handle your work relationships to ensure you’re.
Thinking Actively in a Social Context T A S C.
Term 2 – Contemporary Relationships with Outdoor Environments.
Progressing Thinking: New Perspectives on Teaching Philosophy Emma Williams Philosopher in Residence Rugby School
What factors enhance student teacher understanding of tacit knowledge when working with experienced teachers? Nicola Warren-Lee Background – Ed D research.
Bringing it Back to School An Exercise in -Community Involvement -Group Work -Environmental Responsibility -Independent Learning.
Gateway Engineering Education Coalition Cognitive Development A Look at How Students Think.
Cognitive Development, College Students, & Information Literacy Meghan Sitar Instruction and Outreach Librarian University of Texas Libraries
A workshop on Reflective Learning Jenny Moon, Bournemouth University UK and Independent Consultant
The Reflective Practitioner
Developing Assertiveness. What is this session about? Define passive, aggressive, & assertive behaviors Assertiveness – important life skill Handling.
Jim Fay and David Funk – Tracy and Gyseka
TABLE OF CONTENTS  PAGE TITLE PAGE  PAGE SKILLS  PAGE APTITUDES  PAGE VALUES 
Dr. Pat Cartney  To talk about a pedagogic research project I am currently undertaking  To say what I am doing & why  To outline my research.
Critical Thinking and Reflective Learning - one afternoon’s worth! Jenny Moon, Bournemouth University Centre for Excellence in Media Practice, UK / Independent.
Communication skills Test. You can judge your communication skills by answering strongly agree, agree, neutral, disagree or strongly disagree.
EXPECTATIONS OF POSTGRADUATE STUDY: Study Skills Reflective practice and learning through reflection.
Students seizing responsibility: A revolution of collegiality Amie Speirs, Zoe Welsh, Julia Jung and Jenny Scoles Introduction: In our project Students.
Philosophy 1050: Introduction to Philosophy Week 3: Personal Identity II.
Long and Short Term Goals To develop a responsible and positive attitude we chose Respect for Self, Others and Learning for the long term goal. Our students.
Critical Thinking An education’s central mission.
Review In the past three months we have discussed Hitlamdut, Behira Points and Anavah. I asked that you try to practice these by yourselves, discuss it.
Dealing with Problems in Daily Life – Unit 337
Reflective Thinking. Reflective thinking Critical thinking and reflective thinking are often used synonymously. However, where critical thinking is used.
CC1H01N1 – Study Skills for Computing/Multimedia Week 2 – Lecture – Reflective Writing.
Reflective Practice. Aims & Outcomes Clarify what is meant by reflection Identify & discuss strategies & techniques of reflective.
How to structure good history writing Always put an introduction which explains what you are going to talk about. Always put a conclusion which summarises.
Epistemology (How do you know something?)  How do you know your science textbook is true?  How about your history textbook?  How about what your parents.
Self Management Project MGT 494 Lecture-7 1. Recap Teaching versus Learning The Learning Process – Auditory – Visual – Kinesthetic Self-Assessments 2.
Meeting the Grading Criteria Evaluation asks the question 'Is this the best way of doing it?'
Critical Thinking  A key academic skill  Required for successful study.
Chapter 8: Constructing Understanding of Change Intervention Mushrooms 1.
A Critical Postmodern Approach to Education 1. Constructed by: Brady Gallego Master’s Candidate California State University, San Bernardino 2.
Developing and Assessing Students’ Complex Reasoning Abilities Applications of the Reflective Judgment Model 2008 International Assessment & Retention.
Verbal listening: Listening.
Marcia Baxter Magolda Learners’ Narratives: Real-life Stories about Constructivist- Developmental Pedagogy Improving Student Learning.
What is “Employability” and how do I develop it?
Title of notes: Text Annotation page 7 right side (RS)
Coaching in Practice.
How did we come to know … Different sources of knowledge: Experience
Critical and Analytic Reading and Writing
Reflective Practice.
A workshop on Reflective Learning
Teamwork.
Reflective Writing.
AICE General Paper What IS this class?.
Presentation transcript:

What you learn from experience relates to the quality of your thinking Jenny Moon, Centre for Excellence in Media Practice, Bournemouth University, UK

Summary The meaning of ‘experiential’ learning How it might relate to other learning Epistemological development A practical exercise on epistemological development How epistemological development relates to experiential learning Some practical implications

The meaning of ‘experiential learning’

At the Centre: She might have: observed events been involved in the practical activities and learnt practical skills. or been allowed to be more independent - making decisions etc.

So what she might learn from the situation depends on: her actions, activities and opportunities the attention she gives to those actions etc the manner in which she approaches and processes the experiences and on how she exploits those opportunities to learn more.

To generalise, what we learn from experience depends on: the opportunities for learning that are inherent in a situation; the quality of attention that we give to those opportunities the manner by which we approach and process the experiences. how we can further exploit opportunities.

I focus on: the manner by which we approach and process the experiences. how we can further exploit opportunities.

Different terms for epistemological development: development of epistemological beliefs development of the understanding of the nature of knowledge and I will tend to talk of the sophistication of the quality of thinking

Epistemological development affects: the manner in which learners function intellectually their capacity for critical thinking, their ability to understand the nature of knowledge their ability to manage situations of uncertainty their understanding of the nature of scientific endeavour and their idea of theory and its relationship to evidence

I mention the work of: Perry – 1970 Belenky, Clinchy, Goldberger and Tarule (1984) King and Kitchener (1994) Baxter Magolda (1992) and Lucas (2009)

Baxter Magolda’s stages Absolute knowing Transitional knowing Independent knowing Contextual knowing

Charlie Learning in my sociology classes seems hard now. I am used to having clear handouts but this teacher says that we have to learn to think for ourselves and will not give us handouts. It seems to be a complicated way of learning – but then I have come to see the value in having to think a bit.

Elke I like having to work in groups in psychology. It is amazing that we have all developed such different perspectives since we have come back from placement. We are much better at listening to each other. I know that I am all the time trying to understand how each of us justifies our views, and listening to others helps me to put together my own thoughts.

Michael I was asked to critically analyse some theories about delinquency last semester. I wasn’t sure exactly what was meant by that. I thought it was probably about discussing theory and arguing my case for the one I thought to be right.

Samuel In our tutorial, it came out that there are differences of opinion among experts about how much different mammals ‘plan’ their actions. I suppose it is just that people have not done the research yet. There does not seem much point in disagreeing about it when the work has not yet been done.

Janine I have been a bit confused by the way that the two lecturers I have had in this subject have dealt with the battle of Samargo. They seem to have different attitudes to it. One said that it came about because of political reasons and the other said that it resulted from an uprising of the poor. I don’t know how to handle these different attitudes but maybe I have to learn to deal with them. It makes thing so uncertain.

Darren When I was reading this chapter, I was thinking ‘how does this fit’ and ‘ why does the author seem so sure about this?’ and I was relating it all to my views and I think my views might have changed now. I will have another look at it and decide where I stand.

Emma I am not sure why we have such a long reading list for this subject. I mean why does someone not just write a textbook on the subject and then we could learn what we need from the textbook. Lectures sometimes confuse me, the way they wander around the subject.

Dale It is good in seminars now. I see that my mates sometimes have all made different sense of the lectures on education. It’s not that one of us is right and the rest are not right – but that we have to get good at justifying the way we see it.

Experiential learning and epistemological development

A crucial piece of research by Baxter Magolda….. How do students shift from independent knowing to contextual knowing?

through postgraduate study through in good internship experiences or professional situations where they are required to make independent judgements in situations of ill- structured knowledge

That suggests that a good placement is one in which there are opportunities for making independent judgements: learners have a good degree of autonomy. They to deal with ill- structured knowledge

Three further crucial qualities of a situation of good experiential learning are that: There is learning from the representation of learning – learning from doing The student is required to reflect on her learning

However: Learners do also seem to be able to learn from observation (mirror neurones) And I also think they need to see examples of good and poor practice…

To summarise, the following will tend to feature in better experiential learning situations – there is: emphasis on autonomy and independent judgement opportunity to deal with ill-structured knowledge learning from the representation of learning which may be actively doing something and /or learning from reflection learners need examples of good and poor practice

Resources to download…