Assertion The variety embraced by prevailing positivist paradigms of learning is insufficient to match the variety of the situations to which they are.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Development Economics was Bright and Optimistic – Reflections on Early Years of the Discipline.
Advertisements

SOCIAL WORK PRACTICE WITH DIVERSE GROUPS.
Ideal-types of Health Promotion Evaluation Practice Louise Potvin, PhD Université de Montréal III Saminario Brasileiro de Efetivivade da Promoçao da Saude.
Embracing Present Challenges Nancy J. Ramsay February 10, 2012.
Creative Holism: A critical systems approach to complex problem situations 49 th Annual Meeting of the ISSS, Cancun, Mexico.
RECONSIDERING THE BICYCLE: An Anthropological Perspective on a New (Old) Thing CHAPTER FIVE: On the Need for the Bicycle © Routledge 2013.
Higher Education as Intellectual and Moral Development for Responsible Considered Change.
WHAT IN THE WORLD IS ETHICS? N. Yasemin YALIM, MD. PhD Professor of Bioethics Ankara University School of Medicine.
 Topics due today.  Thought papers and discussion grades  Method and proposal sign ups  Job talks coming up.
Systems Thinking Prof Roger Maull Innovation and Service Research University of Exeter
The Varieties of Action Research Action and Case Research in Management and Organizational Contexts.
Making Social Science Matter A dialogue on science... Is there a ”natural science logic” and a ”social science logic”?
Scientific realism. Varieties of (the problem of) realism Ontological: is there a mind-independent world? Epistemological: can we know something about.
Is there added value in using different paradigms in real estate research? Norbert Bol, 17/6/2011.
THEORY OF KNOWLEDGE and SCHOOL ECONOMICS AND BUSINESS Whose Perspectives? and other Problems of Knowledge.
13.1 Revision IMS Information Systems Development Practices.
Politics of Sustainable Development 1. Introduction.
ISYS 3015 Research Methods ISYS3015 Analytical Methods for Information systems professionals Week 2 Lecture 1: The Research Process.
12.1 Frameworks for comparing ISD methodologies IMS Information Systems Development Practices.
Centre for Development Innovation Intro to MSP Jim Woodhill, Centre for Development Innovation.
© 2005 Prentice-Hall 10-1 Leadership and Creating Trust Chapter 10 Essentials of Organizational Behavior, 8/e Stephen P. Robbins.
1 Action and Case Research in Management and Organizational Contexts.
Transformative Paradigm EDLP 711
A RHETORICAL PERSPECTIVE ON TECHNOLOGY Defining Technology and Technology Transfer Competing Theories of Technology Rhetorical Theory of Technology My.
Culture, Worldview and Transformative Philosophy of Mathematics Teacher Education in Nepal: A Cultural-Philosophical Inquiry Bal Chandra Luitel.
Qualitative vs Quantitative Research By Adelaide Collins Maori Development Research Centre.
The Journey of Scholarship Connecting Teaching & Student Scholarship By Considering Indigenous Research Methodologies Based on the work of Shawn Wilson,
Philosophical Roots of Education
Qualitative Research Methods Deborah Landry, PhD.
Chapter 3 Paradigms and Communication Theory. Paradigms and Communication Theory Paradigm Shift (see discussion of Kuhn, Ch. 2) Paradigm: Metatheory:
Dimensions of Human Behavior: Person and Environment
Chapter 3 Paradigms and Communication Theory
The Critical Skills Classroom (c) Antioch University New England, 2009 Erin M. Hunter River Valley Technical Center Peter R. Eppig Antioch University New.
Roger Packham.  Aim is to help Victorian State government participants to improve the complex situations confronting them in their everyday work  Science.
Copyright © 2006 Elsevier, Inc. All rights reserved Chapter 21 Cultural and Spiritual Awareness.
Conducting a Systemic Conversation:. Discourse for ‘Public’ Judgment in the Risk Society of a Mixed-up World Richard Bawden Michigan State University.
Through Experiential Education. Experiential Education Experiential Education means: Activities that challenge your thoughts and opinions of a given group,
Research paradigms and perspectives EDL 714 Fall 2010.
PHILOSOPHY OF SCIENCE WEEK 4 HOLISTIC SYNTHESIS part one.
INF Lecture 27th of December 2005 Introduction to Qualitative Research Methods.
2009 Orientation group session “The critical choices in research process” Paula Kyrö For Group number 5 compulsory to other PhD course participants elective.
What is Philosophy? Ronald F. White, Ph.D. Professor of Philosophy.
The Sciences Natural and Human (Social) Sciences as Areas of Knowledge
IB ARTS La Paz Community School. IB learner profile Inquirers: They develop their natural curiosity. They acquire the skills necessary to conduct inquiry.
Development of Research Methodologies in Various Disciplines By Dr Ranu Varshney & Mrs. Nisha Chaturbedi.
WELCOME TO THE WORLD OF PSYCHOLOGY THE ART & SCIENCE OF STUDYING THE HUMAN PERSON IN RELATION TO SELF, OTHERS & WORLD.
Decision Making Good decision making is an essential skill for personal & career success, and effective leadership.
Howard Gardner “In the 21 st century, the most valued mind will be the synthesizing mind: the mind that can survey a wide range of sources, decide what.
Topic Thirteen: Indigenous knowledge in Research and Extension.
Our school library and the AASL Standards A Presentation for _____.
Johan Mouton © February Comparing science and ordinary knowledge Ordinary KnowledgeScientific Knowledge Personal authorityCollective, accumulated.
Orlikowski & Baroudini: Studying Information Technology in Orgaizations: Research Approaches and Assumptions Presentation for INF9200 by Lasse Berntzen.
Session 1 Beliefs about Research and Evaluation Introduction to Research and Evaluation in Education.
WELCOME TO THE WORLD OF PSYCHOLOGY THE ART & SCIENCE OF STUDYING THE HUMAN PERSON.
Transformative Mixed Methods in Evaluation Donna M. Mertens Gallaudet University Katrina L. Bledsoe Walter R. McDonald & Associates, Inc. AEA/CDC 2010.
Contradiction & the Carnival: A study of McGregor’s Theory X and Theory Y framework applied to communication within a carnival setting By: Ashley Johnston.
Core Communication Questions. What is communication?
AN INTERPRETIVE ARGUMENT FOR MULTIPLE METHODS
The research philosophy
Relational Developmental Systems: An Introduction
INTRODUCTION TO ORGANIZATIONAL BEHAVIOR
The Nature and Scope of Organizational Behavior
Experimentalism (Pragmatism – Instrumentalism)
WEEK 8 HOLISTIC SYNTHESIS
NJCU College of Education
STEPS IN THE RESEARCH PROCESS and FOCUS ON MAJOR PARADIGMS IN RESEARCH
The research philosophy
My Attitudes What I Show!.
INVITATION TO PHILOSOPHY
The Journey of Scholarship
Presentation transcript:

Assertion The variety embraced by prevailing positivist paradigms of learning is insufficient to match the variety of the situations to which they are applied.

Complexity = High Variety

natural social political economic cultural technological technological inter-personal

natural social economic cultural political inter-personal

Economic viability Practical achievability Technical possibility Social desirability Political plausibility Prevailing paradigms essentially privilege objective dimensions of:

Technical possibility Economic viability Practical achievability Social desirability Political plausibility Aesthetic acceptability Ethical defensibility Cultural feasibility Spiritual compatibility Ecological responsibility and Systemic paradigms embrace contextual dimensions of:

“Paradigms are….entire constellations of beliefs, values, techniques and so on, shared by a given community” Thomas Kuhn

Paradigms can be characterised by: beliefs about the nature of nature ontologiesbeliefs about the nature of nature ontologies beliefs about the nature of knowing epistemologiesbeliefs about the nature of knowing epistemologies beliefs about the nature of human nature axiologiesbeliefs about the nature of human nature axiologies beliefs about the nature of human inquiry methodologiesbeliefs about the nature of human inquiry methodologies

Finding out Taking action Experiential Learning

Finding out Taking action Thinking Sensing Designing Acting

Being Told Telling it Back Propositional Learning

Showing it Back Being Shown Practical learning

Finding out Taking action

Theory Practice Praxis Praxis

weltanschauung

Praxis Praxis Phronesis Theory Practice Propositional Practical learning learning learning Experiential Experiential learning to KNOW systems theory to DO systems practice to BE systemic Experiential/Inspirational learning to MAKE systemic judgements

HOLISM HOLISM REDUCTIONISM CONTEXTUALISMOBJECTIVISM

H E H E E T

HOLISM HOLISM REDUCTIONISM OBJECTIVISM ACTUALISED MAXIMUM MAXIMUM OPTIMALINCLUSIVE CONTEXTUALISM WELL-BEINGPERFORMANCE SELF SELF YIELD YIELD

Inspirational Learning Finding out Taking action

Finding out Taking action Accepting Applying Focussing Disengaging

inspirational inquiry experiential inquiry inspirational inquiry experiential inquiry

emotions dispositions Critical researching/learning system