Earth’s Initial Condition Dave Stevenson Caltech CIDER, KITP, July 18.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Differentiation of the Earth Differentiation is the process by which random chunks of primordial matter were transformed into a body whose interior is.
Advertisements

Proto-Planetary Disk and Planetary Formation
Water in the Atmosphere
Interior structure, origin and evolution of the Moon Key Features of the Moon: pages
The nebular hypothesis
Plate tectonics is the surface expression of mantle convection
ROCK NOTES I. What is a rock? Rock - two or more minerals (found in the earth’s crust) bound together in a solid form.
The Layers of Earth Lexile 850L
Chapter 17 Earth’s interior. Earth’s interior structure Earth is composed of three shells; –Crust –Mantle –Core.
Structure of the Earth.
The Layers of the Earth!. Earth Layers The Earth is divided into 4 main layers.  Inner Core  Outer Core  Mantle  Crust.
Impact plumes: Implications for Tharsis C.C. Reese & V.S. Solomatov Dept. of Earth & Planetary Sciences Washington University in St. Louis Saint Louis,
Europa Scenarios: Physical Models Ice-cracks on surface consistent with either “warm-ice” or water beneath the surface Near infrared mapping consistent.
Core-Mantle Boundary Physical Processes Dave Stevenson, Caltech CIDER Workshop, KITP, July 27, 2004.
The Universe. The Milky Way Galaxy, one of billions of other galaxies in the universe, contains about 400 billion stars and countless other objects. Why.
Accretion and Differentiation of Earth Dave Stevenson Caltech Neutrino Sciences 2007 Deep Ocean Anti- Neutrino Observatory Workshop Honolulu, Hawaii March.
GEOMAGNETISM: a dynamo at the centre of the Earth Lecture 1 How the dynamo is powered Lecture 2 How the dynamo works Lecture 3 Interpreting the observations.
Ge/Ay133 When and how did the cores of terrestrial planets form?
When and how did the cores of terrestrial planets form?
Introduction to Deep Time Physics Perspective Dave Stevenson Caltech CIDER, July 2012.
FREE CONVECTION Nazaruddin Sinaga Laboratorium Efisiensi dan Konservasi Energi Jurusan Teknik Mesin Universitas Diponegoro.
ICES OF THE SATURN SYSTEM ICES OF THE SATURN SYSTEM V.A. Dorofeeva Vernadsky Institute of Geochemistry and Analytical Chemistry RAS, Russia.
Terrestrial Atmospheres Solar System Astronomy Chapter 8.
Structure of the Earth. Gravity reshapes the proto-Earth into a sphere. The interior of the Earth separates into a core and mantle. Forming the planets.
I NTERACTIONS BETWEEN MANTLE CONVECTION AND DENSE MATERIAL ACCUMULATION ON THE CORE - MANTLE BOUNDARIES IN LARGE TERRESTRIAL PLANETS Agnieszka Płonka Leszek.
Slide 1 Observations/Inferences: Rocky inner, icy outer solar system Asteroid differentiation temperatures heliocentrically distributed Gross zonal structure.
Chapter 5: Igneous rocks
Lecture 35. Habitable Zones. reading: Chapters 9, 10.
Chapter 8: Terrestrial interiors. Interiors How might we learn about the interior structure of the Earth, or other planets?  What observations can you.
Composition of the Earth. The Size of the Earth The Earth is almost spherical with a radius of nearly km. Variations in the value of acceleration.
Thermal evolution of an early magma ocean in interaction with the atmosphere T. Lebrun 1, H. Massol 1, E. Chassefière 1, A. Davaille 2, E. Marcq 3, P.
STRUCTURE OF THE EARTH. Differentiation of Earth Earth is divided into layers based on density and composition Solid Layers – Core (iron-nickel) – Mantle.
Earthquakes and the Interior  Earthquakes are definitely a geologic hazard for people living in earthquake regions, but the seismic waves generated by.
Geodynamics VI Core Dynamics and the Magnetic Field Bruce Buffett, UC Berkeley.
E. M. Parmentier Department of Geological Sciences Brown University in collaboration with: Linda Elkins-Tanton; Paul Hess; Yan Liang Early planetary differentiation.
Formation of the Universe and Earth’s Interior 1.
Solid Earth System. The Earth is like an onion, it is made up of many layers. Although we have not been to the center of the Earth, Earthquakes, and volcanoes.
Earth’s Composition Standard S6E5
The Layers of the Earth!. Earth Layers The Earth is divided into 4 main layers.  Inner Core  Outer Core  Mantle  Crust.
1 Marginal Thermobaric Stability in the Weddell Sea Miles McPhee McPhee Research Company.
Inside the Earth Planet Earth All objects on or near Earth are pulled toward Earth’s center by gravity. Earth formed as gravity pulled small particles.
The Structure of the Earth Internal Structure and Heat.
Earth’s Internal Structure
Magma Oceans in the Inner Solar System Linda T. Elkins-Tanton.
An Overview The Earth is made of 5 main internal layers and one external layer (the atmosphere). This diagram shows the locations and approximate thicknesses.
Convection Current in the Mantle SAYRO PAW. The Four Layers of Earth Inner Core Outer Core Mantle Crust The inner core is the hottest layer in the Earth.
Processes in Protoplanetary Disks Phil Armitage Colorado.
Section ‘3’. 14 billion years ago, the Big Bang—an incomprehensibly large explosion that sent all matter of the universe flying outward at incredible.
Slide 1 The Earth is differentiated How and When did this occur? Two Sets of Constraints: Physical Mechanisms and Chemical Signatures.
Habitability: Making a habitable planet 26 January 2016.
Earth Systems 6.E.2.1 Earth’s layers.
Layers of the Earth The Layers of the Earth are the Inner Core, Outer Core, Mantle and Crust.
Earth’s Layers. The Layers: Lower mantle Transition region.
Origin of the F-layer by “snowfall” in the core. Outer Core Inner Core F-layer PREM AK135 PREM2.
I.Layers of the Earth II.Plate Tectonics III.Continental Drift.
MAP TAP The Layers of the Earth 1 The Layers of Earth.
EARTH’S INTERNAL STRUCTURE And processes. What Was Early Earth Like?  Describe what Earth was like right as the Solar System was forming?  Why did earth.
Accretion and Differentiation of Earth
The Layers of the Earth!.
Structure of the Earth.
When and how did the cores of terrestrial planets form?
The Sun.
Compositional Balancing Before Moon Formation
Structure of the Earth.
Origin of the terrestrial planet‘s water, crust and atmosphere
Stochastic Late Accretion on the Earth, Moon and Mars
Earth’s Composition Standard S6E5
Part 1: Earth’s Dynamic Interior
Crust mantle Outer core Inner core.
Presentation transcript:

Earth’s Initial Condition Dave Stevenson Caltech CIDER, KITP, July 18

Estimating Processes Timescales, Energies, Mixing, Unmixing, Equilibration Why is Earth (probably ) completely molten after a giant impact? – But this does not imply good mixing – Problems with impact simulations Why can impacts inject volatiles? (Net gain) Why might imperfect equilibration occur in core addition events arising from giant impacts? – Siderophiles in the core & Hf/W chronology Do magma oceans lead to a differentiated state? – Is a basal magma ocean likely? – Timescales Why might mixing be easier in solids than in liquids!? – Preservation of a basal layer in a giant impact Why are some things so poorly understood? – Looking to the future

Moon-forming Giant Impact (Ongoing work with Miki Nakajima)

Entropy Distribution in Disk & Planet Initial entropy

Entropy distribution in Post-Giant Impact Mantle Initial entropy

Why is Earth (probably ) completely molten after a giant impact? The pre-impact state is surely near the solidus. – This is crucial to the argument… initially cold material will not all melt – Near solidus pre-impact state expected because of enormous heat input from previous impacts; not enough time for that energy to escape Giant impact calculations indicate an entropy increase in the deep mantle ~2 x entropy of fusion (ΔS fusion ~ 500J/kg.K) A small amount may escape melting at mantle base but this will be enveloped in hotter material (like putting an ice cube in coffee and stirring)

Entropy distribution in Post-Giant Impact Mantle Initial entropy Entropy increasing with radius is stably stratified! According to SPH, the particles are not well mixed (deep mantle largely undisturbed).

Stable Density profile but unstable velocity (differential rotation) profile? (Ri~0.3?, Ri<1/4 needed for overturn) (b)(a)

Need to improve thermodynamics “Something is rotten in the state of Denmark“ (actually,everywhere)

Why can impacts inject volatiles? (Net gain) During an impact, a transient cavity forms and the interface between projectile and target develops rapid shear (Kelvin-Helmholtz) instabilities). Turbulence ensues down to the Kolmogorov inner scale length (typically mm) Diffusion (e.g. water into molten silicates) can proceed a mm in the timescale of the strong shear flow (tens of seconds to minutes)- big impacts are better than small; may fail below tens of km. Comets on the moon?

Core Formation with Giant Impacts Diffusion time ~R 2 /D ~hours for R~ few cm; transport time is ~ (few years) /R 1/2 (R in cm) provided Re>10 3. For large R, get disequilibrium Blobs “fission” when they fall their own diameter so only the largest blobs are expected to make it without fragmenting all the way to droplets. Droplet size determined by surface tension. Molten mantle Core Unequilibrated blob

Turbulent mixing of fluids Rayleigh-Taylor Instability Kelvin-Helmholtz Instability dense light dense light dense Dalziel et al. J. Fluid Mech Smyth et al. J. Phys Ocean Turner J. Fluid. Mech 1986 See also Dahl & Stevenson, 2010, EPSL

Why might imperfect equilibration occur in core addition events arising from giant impacts? Iron from the core of the projectile may be distributed heterogeneously onto Earth- some parts of the mantle may not “see” this iron and therefore some of the Hf-derived 182 W has no opportunity to go into the core The SPH does not resolve break-up of the iron but some of it may be in large enough blobs to ”crash” through the molten mantle in a few hours (almost free fall time) Can it break up into small enough droplets to equilibrate?

Popular Cartoons of Core Formation Stevenson, 1989 Wood et al, 2006

Giant ImpactsSmall Impactors Thermal effectResets the magma ocean to great depth & pressure Helps maintain magma ocean to ~ transition zone EquilibrationPoor for the Fe core of the projectile Good for all components T, P for any equilibrationExtends up to core-mantle boundary P and very high T (plausibly 6000K) Modest T (2500K) and P(maybe 30GPa) Implications for Hf/WCould mislead chronology (but some disequilibrium is OK) Can give good guide to chronology Implications for siderophiles Not known since we don’t know the partition coefficients at extreme T and P Can be estimated; some evidence for agreement with observation

Three Kinds of Magma Oceans Naked – Earliest stage of lunar magma ocean? Veiled (or Blanketed) – Silicate vapor, water, CO 2, H 2 … – Earth (throughout much of accretion) Capped – Stable or Unstable (foundering) crust – Late stage lunar magma ocean – Io? (Khurana et al, 2010) – Conceptually, Europa’s ocean and Earth’s outer core are magma oceans – Earth in transition zone or above CMB

What Regime (for Earth)? Giant impact will melt the entire mantle, allow efficient core formation, but also cool fast, perhaps “healing”. (Could even have a water ocean quickly in few million years!) Large (~ km scale) impactors create transient magma oceans, or add to existing magma ocean. Background quasi-continuous flux of small bodies can sustain an “equilibrium” shallow (few to 500 km thick) magma ocean indefinitely, provided the flux exceeds a critical value (of order 1M Earth /100Myr; but set by opacity of overlying atmosphere). A partially molten state could persist for a long time…potentially up to present

Characteristic Timescales If magma ocean depth d and temperature T radiates at T e then time to cool to 0.9T (with no freezing) is 0.1ρC p Td/σT e 4 ~ (300yr)(T/2000K) (d/1000km)(1000/T e ) 4 But capped magma oceans can cool on very long (thermal diffusion) timescale (Stefan problem): 3 million yr. (d cap /10km) 2 Capping can also arise from the lower slope of the solidus in the transition zone, so cooling of a mid-mantle magma ocean can take hundreds of millions of years. Foundering crust models can have T e ~few hundred K so cooling times are intermediate but can be short (e.g., ten or hundred thousand yr).

Differentiation in the Mantle? CORE Dense suspension, vigorously convecting. May be well mixed Solomatov & Stevenson(1993) Much higher viscosity, melt percolative regime. Melt/solid differentiation? High density material may accumulate at the base. May be relevant to 142 Nd

Elkins- Tanton,2008

Coltice et al,2011

Two Ways to have a very long-lived magma ocean Flotation Crust – Lunar case – Borg et al(2011) may be explained this way. Cross-over of adiabat & solidus/liquid isentrope Melting curve SOLIDMAGMA OCEAN

Do magma oceans lead to a differentiated state? Not in a vigorous early stage, despite crystallization (assuming it starts out homogeneous) Yes, when you enter the percolative regime (crystal fraction exceeds 20 or 30%) But if this evolves to an unstable state then large scale Rayleigh –Taylor can remix We lack sufficient information to be sure this remixing happens

Why might mixing be easier in solids than in liquids!? solid liquid ρ-Δρ ρ In a solid, the density changes due to temperature anomalies are significant & viscous stresses can be large In a liquid, the density changes due to temperature anomalies are tiny & viscous stresses very small… can get double diffusive convection

Why are some things so poorly understood? Material properties – Especially at extreme conditions Inability of numerical codes to handle multiple scales (impact events, emulsification, very high Reynolds number) – Divide & conquer Possible futility in attempting to reconstruct the particular (non-unique?) way in which our solar system reached its observed state

“Doubt may be uncomfortable but certainty is absurd” -Voltaire