Participatory Budgeting – Southampton’s experience ‘Your Health, Your Community, Your Vote’ 28 th June 2008.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Participatory Budgeting and Health - pilot in Thornhill, Southampton
Advertisements

Resident Engagement – feedback from first stage and strategic level proposals 2 nd stage consultation events March 2012.
Evaluating the online questionnaire
Avril Imison LaMPS conference Southampton 5 July 2013.
Local Education and Training Boards Adam C Wardle Managing Director, Yorkshire and the Humber Local Education and Training Board.
Hampshire Children’s Services Personalisation and Personal Budgets Pilot A Parent and Carer Guide.
Life Coaching Frances Donohoe MAC Member Association For Coaching 19/06/2013.
Dynamite In Control of My Future. A chance to learn first No commitment to ‘taking control’ at the end of the project A real chance to think about how.
Sustaining your wellbeing strategy by engaging your staff 26 th March 2014.
Improving Youth Engagement in Your Organisation How to turn Youth Engagement into opportunities for young people…
Big Lottery Fund What REALLY does make a good application and why funding applications fail Sarah Carroll Funding Officer (Local) 15 May 2014.
Carlisle. Getting Started Children’s Centre Staff identified potential volunteers Coffee mornings held to plan the project Applied to Daycare Trust for.
Stuart Hollis Social value and wider impact in community learning Ian Yarroll.
Personalisation, Direct Payments so what is the difference? Offering more choice and control for families or a way of saving money?
The future of the NHS in North Central London Islington Voluntary Sector Health Network 18 January 2011 Jacqueline Firth Engagement Manager, NHS Islington.
Moving to a Unified Grants Process and a Single Monitoring Framework Jim Gray Acting Head of Community Planning, Corporate Services Dept, Glasgow City.
Workshop B: Maximising the use of PMF reviews within NDCs Case study: NottinghamNDC National data – local knowledge NDC National Evaluation.
Yorkshire and Humber Personal Budget Event Elaine Baulcombe (Service Manager - SEND) & Andrew Mahoney (Lead for SEND and Personalisation Children's Transformation)
Introduction to School Council: a guide for prospective members.
Welcome to the Healthy Working Lives Conference. Improving Healthier Choices Andrew Steenson, Belfast Strategic Partnership Claire McLernon, Sustrans.
Aiming High Short Breaks Parents Event Becky Powell Aiming High Project Manager 11 th June 2009.
What is the Big Society ? Katherine Runswick-Cole Jodie Bradley
Education and Employment June 2010 ”We Can Work it Out”
SEN and Disability Green Paper Pathfinders March 2012 Update.
11 An Orientation Session for Individuals with Developmental Disabilities and Families What to Expect during Your ReBAR Assessment Interview.
A summary of feedback from service users and carers: Adult Social Care – what does good look like?
Future of the Partnership Board. The Board asked for a working group to look at the future of the Board People were worried about – Too many meetings.
The Future of Adult Social Care John Crook March 2011.
Strategic Commissioning
TRANSFORMING CARE and the PROGRAMME OF ACTION since WINTERBOURNE VIEW What we are doing in Liverpool.
Tuesday 10 June 2014 Liz Blyth, Director of Culture and Neighbourhood Services LEICESTER CITY COUNCIL DEVELOPING MY POLITICAL AWARENESS: A PERSONAL REFLECTION.
Your Choice Your Voice Your opportunity to influence decisions and actions concerning issues and services in your area Have Your Say Event Tuesday 2 nd.
The Reading Agency. Young people’s research Links between reading for pleasure and literacy 1 in 4 struggling with mental health Disproportionally high.
Feedback from the National Forum 7 th & 8 th September 2011.
Your Ambulance Service Foundation Trust Consultation.
The serious benefits of fun Manchester Art Gallery Dec 3 rd, 2013.
Neighbourhood Agreements Neighbourhood Agreements, Community Activists and the Big Society?
What to Expect During Your Support Needs Interview Orientation Session for Individuals with Disabilities and Families.
NHS Next Stage Review Helen Griffiths Principia Support and Implementation Manager Wednesday 21 st.
22 nd April 2015 Heather Ford and Fiona MacKenzie Integration Change Managers Strengthening the Links Staff Engagement -The Fife Story.
Societies Assembly Please Sign in at the Desk to receive your voting card Wednesday 3 rd June.
Davy Jones Consultancy Participatory Budgeting in Brighton Davy Jones East Sussex PB event in Lewes 14 May 2012.
Innovation grant guidance. When should this model be used? This funding should be used when we wish to pilot a new project or test a new method of delivery.
1 Self-directed Support – Older People’s Service Providers EVOC thinkSpace 20 June 2014.
Building Better Neighbourhoods Cllr Alice Smyth Lead Member Brian Wroe Asst Director Community Services Tony Walsh Neighbourhood Manager EVERY ONE CAN!
Alain Thomas Overview workshop Background to the Principles Definitions The National Principles for Public Engagement What.
Children’s Champion Report to Children’s Services Scrutiny Committee Children's Champion in Salford, all activities relate to Article 12 of the UNCRC;
Flu Service in Berkshire Carol Trower Chief Executive Officer Berkshire LPC Berkshire LPC - Improving the Health of the County through Pharmacy.
L E A R N I N G SEND Pathfinder Report to Children’s Trust July Jane Marriott, Psychology and Inclusion Service Manager and Pathfinder Lead Medway.
Insert organisational logo here on master slide What is PPI? (Public & Patient Involvement) Name Title Organisation Name.
Charnwood Together AGM 1 4th September 2015 Chris Traill Strategic Director Neighbourhoods & Community Wellbeing.
Courtesy Reminders: During the webinar, you may select *7 on your phone to speak, and use *6 to mute. Please refrain from placing the phone on HOLD during.
NHS Reform Update October Context Health Reform Agenda Significant pace of change Clear focus on supporting the Transition Process At the same time.
Tackle problems identified by local communities – bottom up problem solving approach Natural links with other DMG projects i.e. Joint assets, high need.
Kickoffs 101. Kickoffs 101: SFSP Marketing and Outreach Strategies.
Brockley Assembly Thursday 27 January 2011 Spending the Mayor’s Fund 2010/11 and 2011/12.
Community Health Champions in Sheffield – the story so far! Real change can only come from the local community itself by harnessing the energy, skills.
REVIEW OF EARLY YEARS, CHILDREN’S CENTRES AND FAMILY SUPPORT PROPOSALS FOR CHANGE.
Area and Neighbourhood Working Cllr Joanne Bell. What do we mean by Area and Neighbourhood Working? Decision making arrangements, management of services,
Parent & Maternal Provide & Secure Commission & Provide Listen & Deliver EMPOWER & CO- PRODUCE.
This version is brought to you by. What’s happening? We all want Greater Manchester to be a better place to live with healthier, wealthier and happier.
1 Briefing for Schools and Education Department Lisa Bibby Director Schools and Education 16/ 19 November 2012.
North Aldershot Citizen Engagement Process Presentation to Burlington Development and Infrastructure Committee – June 17, 2013 By Eagle Heights Technical.
NHS Listens: Feedback Summary. NHS Listens: The Event Held on Wednesday 12 June 2013 Held at Clarendon Suites Part of the BSC Engagement Journey Over.
Citywide Connect: locality events Presentation to the Partnership Board 14 th April 2015.
Youth project pilot report
and people with Learning Disabilities
Presentation by Siobhan O’Kane River Clyde Homes
Emotional Health and Wellbeing through Physical Activity
Presentation transcript:

Participatory Budgeting – Southampton’s experience ‘Your Health, Your Community, Your Vote’ 28 th June 2008

The context Southampton’s New Deal for Communities programme £48.7m to spend over 10 years Led by a partnership board Delivered according to themes

Thornhill Community Health Group funding Joint initiative with Southampton City PCT to build a new health clinic in Thornhill

NDC return on funding for health clinic - £100,000 a year for 10 years Overseen by Thornhill Community Health Group – PCT, Southampton City Council, Thornhill Plus You, residents

Participatory budgeting - timescales December 2006 – idea first discussed in Thornhill February 2007 – agreement from Community Health Group to develop PB June 2007 – PB planning day with representative from the PB Unit

January 2008 – Agreement from Southampton City Council and Southampton City PCT to go ahead March 2008 – Southampton named as one of 10 pilots June 28 th, 2008 – ‘Your Health, Your Community, Your Vote’ event

Stakeholders SCC and local PCT, Thornhill Plus You, residents Staff time, resources for the event, approval for spending money this way Some suspicion at first Public involvement agenda used as leverage Named by Hazel Blears – no going back!

Objectives for the pilot Empower local groups to bid for money for and manage health related projects Increase resident participation in decision making which should be both engaging and enjoyable Establish processes and accountability lines that are clear, concise and productive

Develop effective support and project planning mechanisms (e.g. monitoring, establishment of criteria and use of qualitative feedback from residents) Test new ways of involving communities in managing resources and transferring this knowledge to other neighbourhoods

The process Applications invited for projects bidding from £1,000-£10,000, which have health objectives 22 applications received, totalling £134, Applications subject to a brief appraisal

The event 18 presentations, 3 minutes long Projects on the day totalled £93,559 Transport and childcare provided Lunch and entertainment Prize draw linked to evaluation forms 60 residents attended Local dignitaries – Councillors, local Sergeant, John Denham MP Media coverage

ProjectTotal ScoreFunding £ Crafty Crafters218 2,000 Anti-bullying Programme206 5,000 Our Lives, our health, improving our life chances197 5,853 Summer Fun!196 1,423 Looking out for me186 3,600 Water Walkers179 1,345 Health Kicks176 5,000 Street Sport176 8,650 Eyes on Thornhill173 8,000 The Star Project171 9,764 Teen Pregnancy Show169 3,825 Sun Safety168 1,000 Sprint Start Healthy Kids Programme166 7,580 Healthier Options166 1,000 REACH Thornhill165 7,550 EMPOWERing You!139 9,409 Community Building Family Links135 9,500 Keep Fit today!134 3,060

Resources £10,000 provided to fund the event Task group set up to oversee organisation of the day Appraisal team Support for applicants Approximately 500 hours involved

Evaluation – residents responses ‘I think it was good for the Thornhill community. I wish I had it when I was young, I have lived here for 44 years.’ ‘well done, do it again’ ‘ I think it’s important for the general public to have a say in these projects’ ‘Big thanks for making my vote count’

Resident’s responses… ‘We need more of this type of event’ ‘It was good to see the faces behind the projects’ ‘A good day for everyone who attended’ ‘More events like this please!’ ‘Why has it taken us so long to hit on this way of doing things??!! Well done – a great success!!’

Applicants responses ‘It was a privilege to participate. We got to speak to real people. Now we know the community are keen on the idea, it has given us confidence.’ Action for Blind People ‘A very fair approach that fits into the NHS vision of people having a say. It was fair and transparent.’ Sun Safety

‘Not a fair way to allocate funding. Process is open to abuse, especially if large amounts of funding are at stake.’ Unsuccessful project ‘Really good fun, would definitely do it again. It was nerve-wracking but a very friendly atmosphere.’ Water Walkers ‘It was a remarkable experience, I enjoyed the challenge. I can’t express how impressed I was, this is the first time I’ve seen a community participation project that was successful.’ YMCA

My evaluation of the day People are generally suspicious of this approach Good organisation is crucial to the success of the day Don’t forget about having fun! Don’t get too bogged down with issues around representation – what is the alternative? Transparency of the process