Current Western Canada Beef Value Chain Approach Rancher / Cow Calf Annual Slaughter requirements 3.8 million fats; 700,000 cows 5,000 greater than 100.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
EMIG Electricity Market Investment Group Presentation to the Ontario Energy Board February 17, 2004.
Advertisements

Merchanting and other trade- related services SNA Chapter 14 (external transactions)
ECONOMICS.
Farmland Values and Leasing Key Questions Chapter 20 §What determines the value of farmland? §What are the advantages and disadvantages of owning vs. leasing?
The Strategy of International Business
Specialty Agriculture in Virginia A Growth Opportunity Charles R. Green, Virginia Department of Agriculture & Consumer Service.
Introduction to Derivatives and Risk Management Corporate Finance Dr. A. DeMaskey.
Virtual Prairie Feeders Kurtis Sanguin Cory Holeha Brad Dempsey.
Pricing Strategy Considerations for a New Business A Macro Overview of Setting & Influencing Prices Class 26 Marketing Pricing Strategies Tuesday November.
Beef Contracting: Why Are We Moving That Way, and How Far Will We Go Vern Pierce, Ph.D.
Free Trade? Despite policy reforms enacted as a result of the Uruguay Round Agreement on Agriculture, global dairy markets remain among the most protected.
International Finance Chapters 12, 13, and 14 Foreign Exchange Exposure.
Chapter 4 Marketing.
Competing in Commodity Product Markets AG BM 460.
Unit 6: Business, Factors, & Economies Chapters 18, 19, & 26.
WestCan Hormone-Free Beef Exports By: Tanner Bradley Justin Dereniwski Keith Thoner Mark Riou.
Chapter 5 the free enterprise system Section 5.1
The future of Australia’s cattle industry: grass or grain? Address to ABARE Outlook Conference March 2006 Peter Barnard General Man ager Economic, Planning.
Economics of Risk Management in Agriculture Bruce A. Babcock Center for Agricultural and Rural Development Iowa State University, USA.
Current Situation “If you owe the bank $1,00 dollars, that’s your problem. If you owe the bank $1 million that’s the banks problem”
Chapter 2: Types of Businesses Forms of Business Ownership
Econ 337, Spring 2014 ECON 337: Agricultural Marketing Chad Hart Associate Professor Lee Schulz Assistant Professor
Investment Basics Clench Fraud Trust Investment Workshop October 24, 2011 Jeff Frketich, CFA.
Animal ID: Opportunities for Value-Added Marketing and Production Efficiencies Prepared by: Kynda R. Curtis Assistant Professor and State Specialist Department.
Exploring the Beef Industry
The International Financial System
Product/Service Name: Team Leader: Faculty / Research Alliance: Mobile Tel:
Chapter 13 Financial Derivatives. Copyright © 2002 Pearson Education Canada Inc Spot, Forward, and Futures Contracts A spot contract is an agreement.
Chris Zemlak Heather Sherstobitoff Heather Sherstobitoff Jason Kuchinka Jason Kuchinka Kimberly Russell Kimberly Russell Jennalee Ecklund.
Collaborative Business for Local Sustainable Meats Part 2 Slav Heller St. Paul, AB November 2012.
Exchange Market as a Part of International Financial Markets, Participants and Functions of Exchange Market Matúš Czakó Ján Lajda.
Ch. 22 International Business Finance  2002, Prentice Hall, Inc.
IGCSE®/O Level Economics
Competency 51: Analyze Evolving Economic Systems Competency 52: Describe Impact of Global Marketing on Business in America.
Estimation of the value of unquoted shares of enterprises in the public sector OECD Working Party on Financial Statistics 2008 Paris Paper prepared by.
Consumer Demand Drives Beef Industry Ted C. Schroeder Professor of Agricultural Economics Kansas State University National Beef Industry Development.
Entrepreneurship & Small Business Management 10/2/
Duane Horvey Curtis Ridgway Eldon Forrest Karrie Buxton.
EU-funded Project “Implementation of Ukraine’s Commitments under WTO and ENP Frameworks in the Rural Sector (Sector-Wide Approach)” Improving Animal Slaughter.
‘Impacts of Country of Origin Labeling on North American Beef Trade’ Prepared for the Organized Symposium: ‘Impacts of Country-of-Origin Labeling on North.
Unit 7a Economics.
13-1 Hedging Hedge: engage in a financial transaction that reduces or eliminates risk Basic hedging principle: Hedging risk involves engaging in a financial.
Agricultural Growth Program- Livestock Market Development Ethiopia’s Livestock Sector: Ethiopian Livestock Investment Forum Adama Sept 4, 2014.
Exchange Rates. An exchange rate is the price of one currency in terms of another. –It indicates how many units of one currency can be bought with a single.
 The Free Enterprise System.  Traits of Private Enterprise.
Econ 337, Spring 2013 ECON 337: Agricultural Marketing Chad Hart Associate Professor Lee Schulz Assistant Professor
Market Vertical Coordination  Communication and distribution  Historically relied upon price signals »Markets and spot negotiation  Moving toward non-market.
Section 5.1 Traits of Private Enterprise Chapter 5 the free enterprise system Section 5.2 Business Opportunities.
Chapter 13 Processor Procurement Systems. Processor as Coordinator  Goal: to keep organization running with flow-through that is profitable  Profitable.
Exchange Rates. An exchange rate is the price of one currency in terms of another. –It indicates how many units of one currency can be bought with a single.
Agriculture Today Unit 1: Agribusiness in Today’s Agriculture Industry Lesson: AT1.
Financial Statements for a Corporation Making Accounting Relevant Public corporations often offer Web sites where they provide financial data. Making Accounting.
Unit 1 Introduction to Business & Forms of Business Ownership.
Chapter 5 The Free Enterprise System. Traits of Private Enterprise Section 5.1.
Farm Management Chapter 3 Acquiring and Organizing Management Resources.
Topic 3: Finance and Accounts
Cooperatives in the Food Industry Chapter 13 “Either we stand together or we hang separately”
Chapter 17 (pgs.445FL1-471) The Economic System. Chapter 17 Section 1 (pgs ) The Economic System at Work ESSENTIAL QUESTION: WHAT ARE THE DIFFERENT.
Unit 7a Economics.
Honour Tradition - Embrace Change
Alberta Livestock and Meat Agency
Understanding Economics Advanced Marketing
consumers want branded beef."
Livestock and meat industry
Unit 1: Agribusiness in Today’s Agriculture Industry Lesson: AT1
Agricultural Marketing
Agricultural Marketing
Production and Marketing Contracts in Agriculture
Agricultural Marketing
Presentation transcript:

Current Western Canada Beef Value Chain Approach Rancher / Cow Calf Annual Slaughter requirements 3.8 million fats; 700,000 cows 5,000 greater than ,000 less than 100 $2000 to $3000 investment per head Backgrounder Feedlot 50 typically less than to 700 investment per head Finisher Feedlot 25 typically more than to 800 investment per head Western Canadian Processors Cargill, IBP, XL Annual Capacity: 2.7 million Investment $200 to $300 per head Canada Wholesale/Retail USA Wholesale/Retail Other Country USA Processors Characteristics Mass market commodity based Low cost focused. Retail / Processor Buying Power Co-mingled “country of origin risk” There are no premiums only discounts Live animal market dislocation risk is solely the producers; subject to” predatory pricing”. No practical / reliable tracing from consumers point of view. Ownership and Control and Value Added is held by Processor / Retailer Represents “Auction” Transaction less than 30 month cattle Represents “Auction” Transaction of over 30 month cattle 1 2 1a a 8b 1.30% of animals go through backgrounder feedlots ( 2. 90% plus go traditionally into Canadian Finisher Feedlots) 1a.60% go directly to finisher feedlots. 3.Typically 50 to 60% of fat animals (US transportation net back+ without USA choice premium) 4.Typically 30 to 40% of fat animals (US transportation net back “Canadian Discount” 5.Typically 40% of cuts with higher percentage of premium cuts. 6.Typically 50% of cuts with higher percentage of discount cuts. 7.Typically less than 10% 8aTypically less than 50% of supply 8bTypically more than 50% of supply

Next Generation Western Canada Beef Value Chain Approach Rancher’s Owners Now more than 30 Ultimately the number that elect to own Over time, will reflect the number that combine to cover the vast majority of the capacity of the plant. Rancher’s Feedlot More than 1/2 of the plant capacity owned Rest of Feedlot capacity organized by contract Rancher’s Processing 250,000 capacity (easily doubled and can grow further with market) Flexible (cow / bull & fats) Investment 200 to 300 per head Rancher’s Brand White Label Characteristics Rancher’s supply and processing separate from co-mingled mass market Differenced / Niche market based Value add based. Fully tracked “vertical” quality control Minimizes buyer discounts Creates opportunity to obtain premiums. Producers have opportunity to eliminate live animal market dislocation risk; accept the wholesale meat market risk. Producers no longer subject to” predatory pricing by processors”. Ownership and Control and Value Added is held by Rancher’s / Retailer Represents “Market Value Net-back Pricing” 3 1.Rancher’s Brands; BSE free by full testing; Hormone free.. others; Marketed to Canada; USA; Europe; Asia 2.Rancher’s will custom develop and process for any other compatible brand. 3.Owners can elect a “quality adjusted market based price” or can elect to pay custom processing fee and arrange market for the meat. 4.Owners can elect to retain ownership of animals through feedlot and elect options under 3 or can sell to Rancher’s for “quality adjusted market based price” Owners are hedged from discount live animal markets either through profits of Rancher’s or Wholesale meat market less custom processing and custom feedlot cost approach. All interested parties (including governments) get market transparency. Rancher’s ownership units will be listed and trade. Creates Private Sector Capital markets as source for growth capital; Creates competitive tension with Legacy Processors.

Current Situation Western Canadian Beef Industry produces 30 % more live animals than can be processed in Canada. Investment in production of livestock is 20 to 30 times as much capital as is required in the processing industry. International borders are closed to live animal movement; cattle and sheep. Over 80% of the processing capacity in Canada is in two American processing Plants in Southern Alberta. The international borders are open to meat with particular specifications. No other country in the world has a animal production industry that depends on this amount of international trade in live animals. Regulators, Trade agencies, Health Agencies are becoming more active as science moves forward and new tests are developed. It is not just BSE.

Depending on International Trade of Live Animals Makes No Sense Health issues with live animals are infinitely more complex than with meat. Live animals have limited shelf life and have every day carrying cost. Live animals are a potential health risk to other live animals. The cost of processing is minor relative to the cost of producing the animal. The cost of transport of meat is much less than the cost of transport of live animals. Why export the employment opportunities associated with processing?

Why Did the Industry Evolve This Way? Western Canada is amongst the best locations to raise and fatten cattle. Environment is good, superior genetics, land that is less useful for other purposes, abundant cereal grains for feed. (The meat is superior meat). Processing was driven by economies of scale; low cost - not value add. Main economy of scale was derived from the value of the non-meat part of the carcass. Small processors could not make up on the revenue side for the loss on the non-meat side. Now the main processors have buying muscle as well. Even though producers have much more invested than processors, they are many individuals. The producing industry had enough efficiency advantages to thrive even though it had access to a much inferior processing marketplace from a competition point of view. The discipline was their ability to export live animals to USA based plants.

Characteristics of a Lasting Solution Increase Processing Capacity so Domestic Processing is Able to Handle Domestic Production. Create the “Next Generation” Value Add Value Chain. Create Canada Based competition in processing to create a viable marketplace. Create value added specialty brands directly targeting specific markets whether in USA, Asia or Europe. Get away from the lose-all risk of the “Canadian Brand”. Create an environment that gives producers the option of investing in value added and marketing as opposed to being forced to accept the outcome of a non-competitive cost based marketplace. If producers had the option to create viable alternatives to the status quo then a number would evolve and the Government would no longer be exposed to risk that the trade in live animals is disrupted by other governments. A portion of any government funding for BSE related hardship should be targeted at initiatives that Canadians control and solve the market problem.

Rancher’s Beef Ltd Who is involved? Sunterra Farms is the founder. Successful family-owned farming enterprise that has value added processing and specialty marketing in pork, veal and lamb. (Markets to Canada, Japan, USA, Mexico). More than 50 other producers have committed to purchase ownership. (Alberta, BC, Saskatchewan). Over $25 million of assets and over $15 million of cash committed. Ownership is open to anyone that wants to invest. (Subscribers continue to grow). What is Rancher’s Business Objective? State of the art processing, combined with feedlot operations with ownership linkage to cow / calf and backgrounder. Will develop and market specialty branded beef products by organizing the supply chain to deliver a differentiated superior value to its customers. Business is organized so that producers are in control and own the profit that is generated by the value chain to the branded meat market. Customer driven; profit based. It is the first real example of the “Next Generation Value Chain” organized for the future as opposed to the past.

What Does Government Need to Do? To date, the Government supported initiatives have been supporting the status quo. Unless the domestic supply / processing imbalance and the lack of competition and diversity in the processing sector is addressed, the benefactor of government support programs will be large existing processors. (As has happened to date). Governments need to financially support the transition to a new domestic market-place which gives producers the option of investing in value added and creates the appropriate domestic competitive tension with the large commodity based processors. Rancher’s is an example: Federal government should agree to match provincial government funding for such initiatives. In Rancher’s case, we are proposing that if the Private Sector raises $25 million of equity, that the Province of Alberta and the Government provide funding of $10 million. Governments can support a number of these type of initiatives. (Three Rancher’s sized initiatives would bring domestic processing in line with domestic production).