Madagascar The Toamasina Container Terminal. 2 Toamasina – Map and Location.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Ministry of Public Sector Development Public Sector Development Program Better Government Delivering Better Result.
Advertisements

Armand Racine Consultant Chemicals Branch
______________________
Vietnam Business Forum Pham Lien Anh VBF Secretariat PPD International Workshop Vienna, April 28-30, 2009 Public-Private Dialogue.
How to commence the IT Modernization Process?
SPUTNIC – Strategies for Public Transport in Cities Strategies for Public Transport in Cities Funded by the EU PT Market.
Appendix F: Common risk categories for the public sector Insert client-specific photo here.
Towards the Romania of PRINCIPLES OF PROGRAMMING The social and macroeconomic policy of Europe is the policy of Romania EU projects represent a.
INTERNATIONAL UNION FOR CONSERVATION OF NATURE. 2 Implemented in 12 countries of Africa, Asia, Latin America and the Middle East, through IUCN regional.
Taxes for Growth & Development RWANDA REVENUE AUTHORITY INTRODUCTION Rwanda Revenue Authority in its modernization program embarked on.
Regulatory Frameworks in OECD countries and their Relevance for India Nick Malyshev Senior Counsellor Public Governance and Territorial Development OECD.
Public Private Partnerships MUNICIPAL PPP CONFERENCE Date: 18 February 2010.
Challenges, Opportunities and Recommendations for private sector participation in REDD+ Erastus W. Wahome, Ministry of Finance – Kenya, 2 nd April 2012.
Brief Overview of the Passenger Transport Sector in the Philippines Gilberto M. Llanto C.P. ROMULO HALL, NEDA SA MAKATI BUILDING May 7, 2013.
Scoping study for Improving Transparency through Citizen Charters in Serbia Transparency Serbia Presentation September 27 th 2010.
DECENTRALIZATION AND RURAL SERVICES : MESSAGES FROM RECENT RESEARCH AND PRACTICE Graham B. Kerr Community Based Rural Development Advisor The World Bank.
PPA 502 – Program Evaluation Lecture 10 – Maximizing the Use of Evaluation Results.
Framework for Port Reform
Robert Watt Secretary General Department of Public Expenditure and Reform Public Service Reform in Ireland Jordanian Government Leaders’ Forum 1 November.
Student Assessment Inventory for School Districts Inventory Planning Training.
Session 3 - Plenary on implementing Principle 1 on an Explicit Policy on Regulatory Quality, Principle 3 on Regulatory Oversight, and Principle 6 on Reviewing.
ZHRC/HTI Financial Management Training
BENIN PORT – Private Concession of a Container Terminal CAIRO, April 13, 2010 PORTS Public Private Partnership Seminar.
Module 4 Legal Tools for Port Reform.
«Проект по экономической реабилитации и построению мер доверия» Integrating interests and institutions in water resource management 25 th June, 2013 Eng.
Information Seminar on the Framework for Public Private Partnerships in Ireland Alexander Hotel, Dublin 3 rd June 2003.
IFC Advisory Services Provide for fee advisory services to governments for PSP and PPP transactionsProvide for fee advisory services to governments for.
An Introduction to Public Private Partnerships: Why Government needs to work with the private sector Vilnius 22 nd November 2006 Stephen Harris - Head,
World Experience in Railway Restructuring Clell Harral, John Winner, Richard Sharp, Jonathan Klein HWTSK, Inc 15 December 2009.
Institutional Development for Improved Water Quality | November 2010 Operation and Maintenance for Safe Drinking Water – Institutional development to achieve.
Highlights from Sessions Key Messages and Actions from the Round Tables.
Contact Monitoring Regional Network (CMKN). Why procurement It is estimated that an effective public procurement system could save as much as 25% of government.
Assessments. Assessment in the Project Cycle DESIGN IMPLEMENTATION MONITORING EVALUATION ASSESSMENT.
Public Private Partnerships (PPPs) and The World Bank
Inter-American Development Bank Private Sector Financing and the IDB Presentation by the IDB Private Sector Department February 2004.
© HPC Hamburg Port Consulting GmbH Ukrainian Port Reform - Changes faced by a Terminal Operator - Klaus Schmöcker, President HPC Ukraine Maritime Days.
Sample of Stocktaking Exercise Replies Changes in African Agriculture Resulting from Implementation of CAADP Approaches Josue Dione, AUC/DREA.
Presentation to the Portfolio Committee on Labour 10 th June 2009 S.S. MKHONTO Compensation Commissioner.
DEVELOPMENT COOPERATION FRAMEWORK Presentation by Ministry of Finance 10 December 2013.
Bulgaria’s Pension Reform Responding to the Needs of Workers for the 21 st Century.
Consultant Advance Research Team. Outline UNDERSTANDING M&E DATA NEEDS PEOPLE, PARTNERSHIP AND PLANNING 1.Organizational structures with HIV M&E functions.
PPP Legal & Regulatory Framework. PPP Policy In July 2008 GOK approved the PPP policy directive through which: PPPs are identified as a method for investing.
Investment Agreement Negotiation Columbia University New York June 2014.
ESTABLISHMENT OF THE CLEAN DEVELOPMENT MECHANISM (CDM) NATIONAL AUTHORITY, OPERATIONAL FRAMEWORK AND SUPPORT SYSTEMS FOR THE PHILIPPINES Establishment.
HEALTH FINANCING MOH - HPG JAHR UPDATE ON POLICIES Eleventh Party Congress -Increase state investment while simultaneously mobilizing social mobilization.
Province of the EASTERN CAPE DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC WORKS DOH REVITALISATION PROGRAM EASTERN CAPE PROVINCE PRESENTATION TO SELECT COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS.
Urban Group Presentation. Commitment and Leadership Legislate Policies Increase Allocation Sanitation Champions at different levels Sanitation as a separate.
1 Implementing a Private Sector Arrangement Penelope Brook The World Bank.
Independence and powers of regulators: legal and institutional requirements Heinz Hilbrecht, Director, European Commission World Forum on Energy Regulation.
Presentation to the Portfolio Committee Establishment of an Agency for Social Security 26 February 2003 Department of Social Development.
Seminar on Public Private Partnerships February PPP Experiences – Challenges and Way Forward Administrative Staff College of India.
Amman October 1-2, 2003 Presentation Evolution of Saudi Telecom During Sector Reform 3 rd Annual Private Sector Cooperation Meeting in the Arab Region.
M O N T E N E G R O Negotiating Team for the Accession of Montenegro to the European Union Working Group for Chapter 32 – Financial Control Bilateral screening:
© OECD A joint initiative of the OECD and the European Union, principally financed by the EU Ensuring Good Quality PPP Projects Martin Darcy Regional Workshop.
ETUI EDUCATION AND COHESION WITH NATIONAL TRAINING COURSES
Business Briefing Security Service Providers
Marek Stavinoha Legal officer DG MOVE A4 European Commission
4/29/2018 NDA STRATEGIC PLAN AND ANNUAL PERFORMANCE PLAN PRESENTATION TO THE PORTFOLIO COMMITTEE ON SOCIAL DEVELOPMENT 3 MAY 2017 MRS THAMO MZOBE CHIEF.
STRATEGIC COUNSEL FOR ORGANIZATIONAL DEVELOPMENT AND MANAGEMENT FOR RESULTS October 4, 2016.
Title Strengthening and Modernizing the Public Transport Sector to achieve Mitigation and Sustainable Development.
LABOUR INSPECTION IN LAW AND PRACTICE
INTERCONNECTION GUIDELINES
Module 8 : Implementing Port Reform
Descriptive Analysis of Performance-Based Financing Education Project in Burundi Victoria Ryan World Bank Group May 16, 2017.
ERERA AND ECOWAS ELECTRICITY MARKET DEVELOPMENT AND REGULATION
progress of the water reform in bulgaria
ESCL – ANNUAL CONFERENCE 25 OCTOBER 2018 EDWINA UDRESCU, FCIArb Lawyer
Seventh Regional Public Procurement Forum, May , 2011
The Role of Private Sector in Capital Budgeting
Transparency Serbia Presentation September 27th 2010
Presentation transcript:

Madagascar The Toamasina Container Terminal

2 Toamasina – Map and Location

Background Madagascar:  New market-oriented government Came to power in 2002 Fully backed by multi and bi-lateral institutions Country growth rate of 9.6% in 2003 Expected growth rates of 6 to 8% p.a. for next 5 years  Reforms to attract Foreign Direct Investment New privatization law and property rights for foreign investors (2004)  Implementing key reforms in transport sector  For greater transparency and efficiency

Background Port of Toamasina  The principal port of Madagascar  Accounts for about 80% of all maritime trade and 95% of container traffic  Poor tariff structures  Slow handling (5-6 TEU per hour) Containers  55-65% of total traffic  1992 to 2004: traffic increased from 26,500 TEU to 91,900 TEU  Low transit (20 days average sitting time)  Outdated equipment

Background  GOM mandated IFC as its Principal Advisor to design, structure and implement a PPP for the Container Terminal (CT) of the Port of Toamasina  GOM’s principal objectives for the transaction:  Improve efficiency and competitiveness of CT  Implement a PPP in a transparent and competitive manner  Modify and adapt institutional and regulatory framework for better transparency and efficiency

6 Key Elements of the Transaction Structure A Careful Balance of KPIs/Output and Investment/Input Obligations  Key Performance Indicators (Operational and management) Container Handling productivity (e.g. 34 mvmts/hour in 2007) Berth Occupancy Container Yard Delivery productivity Theft of Containers Damages Employees accidents Investment Obligations: Enclosure and access buildings Rehabilitation of quay Lighting, access roads and other networks Administrative Building Rail Interface  Important penalties in case of non respect and enforcement mechanisms backed-up by Performance Bond

7 Key Elements of the Transaction Structure (Cont’d) Reinforced by sustainable incentives for all parties:  20 years Concession (with “rendez-vous” every 5 years)  Upfront Tariff reduction: -20% handling and -10% for reception & delivery  Obligation to keep 350 employees for 5 years  Social Fund: Funded by 1% of EBITDA – to fund training and other programs for employees  Concession upfront fee includes development costs of the project and initial budget of the Port Authority Purchase of existing equipment  Yearly Fixed and Variable concession Fees Fixed Fee increases in time (from Euro 1 ml to 2,5 ml) Variable Fee reduced by 20% once 200,000 TEU/year

8 Market Response  16 Expressions of Interest (November 2004)  4 consortia pre-qualified (January 2005)  Commercial bid (May 2005)  Four consortia presented offers  ICTSI  Maersk A.P. Moeller  Hutchinson Whampoa Ltd  Malta Freeport Terminals Ltd  Concession Award (June 2005)  Winning bidder: ICTSI

9 Since Then… June 2005: ICTSI Wins Madagascar Port Bidding October 2005: Contract signing ceremony Upfront payment (including asset acquisition): €10 million US$36 million invested in container handling equipment since  Quay strenghthening works  Gottwald heavy duty mobile crane, model GHMK 6407  Bromma twin-lift spreader (able to lift two 20ft containers simultaneously with each of these weighing up to 25 tons)  4 rubber tyred gantries  New reach stackers  14 new Kalmar terminal tractors.  Major investments made in IT hardware and systems including the successful rollout of the Navis SPARCS system.

Key Institutional Reforms Sept 2003 – Sector legislation: - New Port Law and creation of Agence Portuaire Maritime et Fluviale (APMF) July 2004 – Port of Toamasina: - Decree for the creation of new landlord Port Authority (Société de Gestion du Port Autonome de Toamasina “SPAT”) - Decree classifying the Port as a Port of National Interest with autonomous management - Decree setting forth transition mechanism and separating regulation and operation activities APMF (National Regulator) SPAT (Toamasina Landlord ) New SEPT (state owned, non-container) Private Container Terminal Other private concessions

Transaction Calendar Mobilisation Strategic options Prequalification Investors due diligence and negotiation of contractual documents Launch of bid Closing Mobilitsation IFC team Due Diligence (legal, technical, social, financial,accounting) January 2004Fall 2004Spring 2005Summer 2005 Diagnostic phaseImplementation Phase Summer 2004Winter EoI communication

In Reforms… There are winners, losers and fence sitters; Sometimes winners don’t know they are winners; Some of those who consider themselves losers don’t know they are not losers; All winners & fence sitters need to be mobilized; Opponents need to be identified; An overall vision is needed - where to start, where to go and how.

Communication Issues Opposition within SEPT (executive officers) to the transfer of power to the new entity to be created by APMF (SPAT); Opposition at labor level to labor rationalization, fear of retrenchments; Union opposition to port “privatization”; A common mistrust of placing management (and perceived control) of the national port into the hands of private—in particular foreign—hands; Ideological holdover from the socialist past; It is difficult for the public to understand the potential financial benefits of an efficient functioning port; 5000 households depend on jobs provided by the port.

Labor Strategy SEPT  1716 permanent workers  1784 daily workers Container Terminal  314 Staff  80% >45 yrs old  14% retirement age given relatively low wages and old age of workers: IFC recommends a conservative approach to ensure social balance during transition

Triggers to Communication Intervention Local Consultant  Social Plan,  stakeholder analysis  communication action plan Inadequate communication approach Government  Lack of communication capacity  Lack of transparency on the reform process Media  Articles echoing unions’ opposition to “privatization” JDW’s visit to Madagascar  He strongly recommends an effective communication campaign before prequalification process

High Enlist Help, Support and Lead Involve as Needed Address Concerns and Engage Keep Informed D D C C B B A A E E H H G G F F I I K K J J Example Enlist help, support and lead Involve as needed Address concerns and engage Keep informed D B E H F G HighLow Potential Impact on Project Success Level of Support for Project Enlist Help, Support and Lead These individuals become the champions. They should be enlisted to be leaders in communicating key messages. Involve as Needed This group should be called upon as neededto rally support. Address Concerns and Engage Design ways to engage these individuals who don’t support the project. Help to build ownership, increase involvement, and suppress negative notions. Keep Informed These individuals need only to be kept abreast of program or respond to inquiries as appropriate. Enlist help, support and lead These individuals become the champions. They should be enlisted to be leaders in communicating key messages. Involve as needed This group should be called upon as needed to rally support. Address concerns and engage Keep Informed These individuals need only to be kept abreast of program or respond to inquiries as appropriate. Design ways to engage these individuals who don’t support the project. Help to build ownership, increase involvement, and suppress negative notions. A C SEPT Government Officials Public A– B– C– D – E– F– G– H–Vice Prime Minister General Public A–SEPT employees B – Labor Union C– Local Official D SEPT executives E– Line Ministers F– G– H– Stakeholders Prioritization Media Journalists Mayor Associations

Targeted communication strategy AudiencesObjectives SEPT Employees Reassure them that they will not lose their jobs and they are entitled to the collective bargaining benefits SEPT Executives Explain benefits of improved management by private operator and possible career developments Politicians Counter political opposition within Government by ensuring support of line Ministers and local authorities (Mayor) Journalists Ensure good understanding of PPP process and benefits of concession General Public Inform about benefits of reform

Key messages  Benefits of reform: improve performance and competitiveness, modernization et development of Container Terminal (CT)  Country pride: importance of CT attracting 16 investors  Golden Rule: “nobody will suffer because of the reform” (constantly repeated by VPM)  Reform milestones and next steps are clarified and reminded

Immediate Communication Actions  Establish an Info point in the Port premises where a spokesperson for the VPM respond to employees' inquiries  Report the type of inquiries and redesign/update the info material as needed  Disseminate brochures (Q&A format), and place posters in the port cafeteria, at the entry….  General meeting between SEPT staff and VPM and AD  Local radio interview with VPM and Manager of SPAT (AD)  Presentations to the Inter Ministerial Committee  Face to face meetings with local authorities  Press releases  2-3 weeks before prequalification and afterwards communicate all steps in the concession process

Toamasina lessons  Proactive approach  Government Communication “supported” by IFC project team  Clearly assigned communication responsibilities in the team (communication specialist)  Communication action plan integrated into project timeframe  Continuous monitoring of communication activities, feedback and adjustment  Positive outcome of stakeholders engagement:  Creation of a monthly stakeholders’ roundtable to discuss concerns relating to the port and its operations

THANK YOU MERCI