Spectral functions in NRG Rok Žitko Institute Jožef Stefan Ljubljana, Slovenia.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Theory of the pairbreaking superconductor-metal transition in nanowires Talk online: sachdev.physics.harvard.edu Talk online: sachdev.physics.harvard.edu.
Advertisements

From weak to strong correlation: A new renormalization group approach to strongly correlated Fermi liquids Alex Hewson, Khan Edwards, Daniel Crow, Imperial.
Www-f1.ijs.si/~bonca SNS2007 SENDAI Spectral properties of the t-J- Holstein model in the low-doping limit Spectral properties of the t-J- Holstein model.
Quantum impurity problems (QIP) and numerical renormalization group (NRG): quick introduction Rok Žitko Institute Jožef Stefan Ljubljana, Slovenia June.
Point-wise Discretization Errors in Boundary Element Method for Elasticity Problem Bart F. Zalewski Case Western Reserve University Robert L. Mullen Case.
Aim – theory of superconductivity rooted in the normal state History – T-matrix approximation in various versions Problem – repeated collisions Solution.
- Mallorca - Spain Quantum Engineering of States and Devices: Theory and Experiments Obergurgl, Austria 2010 The two impurity.
Dynamical mean-field theory and the NRG as the impurity solver Rok Žitko Institute Jožef Stefan Ljubljana, Slovenia.
D-wave superconductivity induced by short-range antiferromagnetic correlations in the Kondo lattice systems Guang-Ming Zhang Dept. of Physics, Tsinghua.
2D and time dependent DMRG
Physics “Advanced Electronic Structure” Lecture 3. Improvements of DFT Contents: 1. LDA+U. 2. LDA+DMFT. 3. Supplements: Self-interaction corrections,
Non-equilibrium physics Non-equilibrium physics in one dimension Igor Gornyi Москва Сентябрь 2012 Karlsruhe Institute of Technology.
Improved Description of Electron-Plasmon coupling in Green’s function calculations Jianqiang (Sky) ZHOU, Lucia REINING 1ETSF YRM 2014 Rome.
Green’s function of a dressed particle (today: Holstein polaron) Mona Berciu, UBC Collaborators: Glen Goodvin, George Sawaztky, Alexandru Macridin More.
Chaos and interactions in nano-size metallic grains: the competition between superconductivity and ferromagnetism Yoram Alhassid (Yale) Introduction Universal.
Diagrammatic auxiliary particle impurity solvers - SUNCA Diagrammatic auxiliary particle impurity solvers - SUNCA Auxiliary particle method How to set.
Spintronics = Spin + Electronics
The noise spectra of mesoscopic structures Eitan Rothstein With Amnon Aharony and Ora Entin Condensed matter seminar, BGU.
Calculation of dynamical properties using DMRG Karen A. Hallberg Centro Atómico Bariloche and Instituto Balseiro, Bariloche, Argentina Leiden, August 2004.
Quasiparticle anomalies near ferromagnetic instability A. A. Katanin A. P. Kampf V. Yu. Irkhin Stuttgart-Augsburg-Ekaterinburg 2004.
Renormalised Perturbation Theory ● Motivation ● Illustration with the Anderson impurity model ● Ways of calculating the renormalised parameters ● Range.
Theory of the Quantum Mirage*
Field theoretical methods in transport theory  F. Flores  A. Levy Yeyati  J.C. Cuevas.
Avraham Schiller / Seattle 09 equilibrium: Real-time dynamics Avraham Schiller Quantum impurity systems out of Racah Institute of Physics, The Hebrew University.
Quantum Monte Carlo for Electronic Structure Paul Kent Group Meeting - Friday 6th June 2003.
Many-body Green’s Functions
Correlations in quantum dots: How far can analytics go?
Superglasses and the nature of disorder-induced SI transition
F.F. Assaad. MPI-Stuttgart. Universität-Stuttgart Numerical approaches to the correlated electron problem: Quantum Monte Carlo.  The Monte.
Ultracold Atoms Meet Quantum Gravity Boris V. Svistunov, University of Massachusetts Amherst, PHY Little is known precisely about overdamped dynamics.
Transport properties: conductance and thermopower
Tutorial 4: Kondo peak splitting in magnetic field, transport integrals, conductance and thermopower Rok Žitko Institute Jožef Stefan Ljubljana, Slovenia.
Theory of Intersubband Antipolaritons Mauro F
Order(N) methods in QMC Dario Alfè 2007 Summer School on Computational Materials Science Quantum Monte Carlo: From Minerals and Materials.
F.F. Assaad. MPI-Stuttgart. Universität-Stuttgart Numerical approaches to the correlated electron problem: Quantum Monte Carlo.  The Monte.
1 P. Huai, Feb. 18, 2005 Electron PhononPhoton Light-Electron Interaction Semiclassical: Dipole Interaction + Maxwell Equation Quantum: Electron-Photon.
Coupled quantum dots: a laboratory for studying quantum impurity physics Rok Žitko SISSA, Trieste, Jožef Stefan Institute, Ljubljana, Slovenia.
Exploring Real-time Functions on the Lattice with Inverse Propagator and Self-Energy Masakiyo Kitazawa (Osaka U.) 22/Sep./2011 Lunch BNL.
Introduction 2. 2.Limitations involved in West and Yennie approach 3. 3.West and Yennie approach and experimental data 4. 4.Approaches based on.
Chung-Hou Chung Collaborators:
Application of the Cluster Embedding Method to Transport Through Anderson Impurities George Martins Carlos Busser Physics Department Oakland University.
1 Complex Images k’k’ k”k” k0k0 -k0-k0 branch cut   k 0 pole C1C1 C0C0 from the Sommerfeld identity, the complex exponentials must be a function.
Exact bosonization for interacting fermions in arbitrary dimensions. (New route to numerical and analytical calculations) K.B. Efetov, C. Pepin, H. Meier.
Generalized Dynamical Mean - Field Theory for Strongly Correlated Systems E.Z.Kuchinskii 1, I.A. Nekrasov 1, M.V.Sadovskii 1,2 1 Institute for Electrophysics.
Tutorial 3: spectral functions for SIAM, arbitrary DOS, finite-tempratures, T-matrix for Kondo model Rok Žitko Institute Jožef Stefan Ljubljana, Slovenia.
F.F. Assaad. MPI-Stuttgart. Universität-Stuttgart Numerical approaches to the correlated electron problem: Quantum Monte Carlo.  The Monte.
Theoretical study of the phase evolution in a quantum dot in the presence of Kondo correlations Mireille LAVAGNA Work done in collaboration with A. JEREZ.
Www-f1.ijs.si/~bonca/work.html Cambridge, 2006 J. Bonča Physics Department, FMF, University of Ljubljana, J. Stefan Institute, Ljubljana, SLOVENIA Conductance.
Higgs boson in a 2D superfluid To be, or not to be in d=2 What’s the drama? N. Prokof’ev ICTP, Trieste, July 18, 2012.
Discretization, z-averaging, thermodynamics, flow diagrams Rok Žitko Institute Jožef Stefan Ljubljana, Slovenia.
June 13, Hard Probes 2006 Masayuki ASAKAWA Department of Physics, Osaka University Quarkonium States at Finite Temperature An Introduction to Maximum.
Www-f1.ijs.si/~bonca/work.html New 3 SC-6, Sydney, 2007 J. Bonča Physics Department, FMF, University of Ljubljana, J. Stefan Institute, Ljubljana, SLOVENIA.
Numerical Aspects of Many-Body Theory Choice of basis for crystalline solids Local orbital versus Plane wave Plane waves e i(q+G).r Complete (in practice.
Slava Kashcheyevs Avraham Schiller Amnon Aharony Ora Entin-Wohlman Interference and correlations in two-level dots Phys. Rev. B 75, (2007) Also:
CHAPTER 2.3 PROBABILITY DISTRIBUTIONS. 2.3 GAUSSIAN OR NORMAL ERROR DISTRIBUTION  The Gaussian distribution is an approximation to the binomial distribution.
Kondo effect in a quantum dot without spin Hyun-Woo Lee (Postech) & Sejoong Kim (Postech  MIT) References: H.-W. Lee & S. Kim, cond-mat/ P. Silvestrov.
Complex magnetism of small clusters on surfaces An approach from first principles Phivos Mavropoulos IFF, Forschungszentrum Jülich Collaboration: S. Lounis,
Computational Physics (Lecture 11) PHY4061. Variation quantum Monte Carlo the approximate solution of the Hamiltonian Time Independent many-body Schrodinger’s.
NTNU, April 2013 with collaborators: Salman A. Silotri (NCTU), Chung-Hou Chung (NCTU, NCTS) Sung Po Chao Helical edge states transport through a quantum.
Hanyang University Antennas & RF Devices Lab. ANTENNA THEORY ANALYSIS AND DESIGN Prof. Jaehoon Choi Dept. of Electronics and Computer Engineering
Kondo Effect Ljubljana, Author: Lara Ulčakar
Quantum entanglement, Kondo effect, and electronic transport in
Adiabatic Green’s function technique and
Bumsoo Kyung, Vasyl Hankevych, and André-Marie Tremblay
Conductance through coupled quantum dots
Quantum Ising Model: finite T correlators
with Masaki Oshikawa (UBC-Tokyo Institute of Technology)
Conductance through coupled quantum dots
Dynamical mean field theory: In practice
Tunneling through a Luttinger dot
Presentation transcript:

Spectral functions in NRG Rok Žitko Institute Jožef Stefan Ljubljana, Slovenia

Green's functions - review Following T. Pruschke: Vielteilchentheorie des Festkorpers + if A and B are fermionic operators - if A and B are bosonic operators NOTE: ħ=1 Also known as the retarded Green's function.

Laplace transformation: Impurity Green's function (for SIAM): Inverse Laplace transformation:

Equation of motion Example 1:

Example 2:

Example 3: resonant-level model Here we have set  =0. Actually, this convention is followed in the NRG, too.

Hybridization function: fully describes the effect of the conduction band on the impurity

Spectral decomposition  =+1 if A and B are fermionic, otherwise  =-1.  spectral representation spectral function

Lehmann representation

Fluctuation-dissipation theorem Useful for testing the results of spectral-function calculations! Caveat: G"(  ) may have a delta peak at  =0, which NRG will not capture.

Dynamic quantities: Spectral density Spectral density/function: Describes single-particle excitations: at which energies it is possible to add an electron (ω>0) or a hole (ω<0).

Traditional way: at NRG step N we take excitation energies in the interval [a  N : a  1/2  N ] or [a  N : a   N ], where a is a number of order 1. This defines the value of the spectral function in this same interval.

Patching

p p  1/2 pp p: patching parameter (in units of energy scale at N+1-th iteration)

Broadening: traditional log-Gaussian smooth=old

Broadening: modified log-Gaussian smooth=wvd for x<  0, 1 otherwise.

Broadening: modified log-Gaussian smooth=new Produces smoother spectral functions at finite temperatures (less artifacts at  =T).

Other kernels smooth=newsc smooth=lorentz For problems with a superconducting gap (below  ). If a kernel with constant width is required (rarely!).

Log-Gaussian broadening 1) Features at  =02) Features at  ≠0

Equations of motion for SIAM:

Self-energy trick

Non-orthodox approach: analytic continuation usng Padé approximants We want to reconstruct G(z) on the real axis. We do that by fitting a rational function to G(z) on the imaginary axis (the Matsubara points). This works better than expected. (This is an ill-posed numerical problem. Arbitrary-precision numerics is required.) Ž. Osolin, R. Žitko, arXiv: arXiv:

Kramers-Kronig transformation

Inverse-square-root asymptotic behavior

Doniach, Šunjić 1970 J. Phys. C: Solid State Phys Inverse square root behavior also found using the quantum Monte Carlo (QMC) approach: Silver, Gubernatis, Sivia, Jarrell, Phys. Rev. Lett (1990) Anderson orthogonality catastrophe physics

Arguments: Kondo model features characteristic logarithmic behavior, i.e., as a function of T, all quantities are of the form [ln(T/T K )] -n. Better fit to the NRG data than the Doniach-Šunjić form. (No constant term has to be added, either.)

Osolin, Žitko, 2013

Comparison with experiment?

Experiment, Ti (S=1/2) on CuN/Cu(100) surface A. F. Otte et al., Nature Physics 4, 847 (2008) NRG calculation Excellent agreement (apart from asymmetry, presumably due to some background processes)

1/  tail Kondo resonance is not a simple Lorentzian, it has inverse-square-root tails!

Fano-like interference process between resonant and background scattering:

RŽ, Phys. Rev. B 84, (2011)

Density-matrix NRG Problem: Higher-energy parts of the spectra calculated without knowing the true ground state of the system Solution: 1) Compute the density matrix at the temperature of interest. It contains full information about the ground state. 2) Evaluate the spectral function in an additional NRG run using the reduced density matrix instead of the simple Boltzmann weights.

W. Hofstetter, PRL 2000

DMNRG for non-Abelian symmetries: Zitko, Bonca, PRB 2006

Spectral function computed as: W. Hofstetter, PRL 2000

Construction of the complete basis set

Completeness relation: Complete-Fock-space NRG: Anders, Schiller, PRL 2005, PRB 2006

Peters, Pruschke, Anders, PRB 2006

Full-density-matrix NRG: Weichselbam, von Dellt, PRL 2007 Costi, Zlatić, PRB 2010

CFS vs. FDM vs. DMNRG CFS and FDM equivalent at T=0 FDM recommended at T>0 CFS and FDM are slower than DMNRG (all states need to be determined, more complex expressions for spectral functions) No patching, thus no arbitrary parameter as in DMNRG

Rok Žitko, PRB 84, (2011) Error bars in NRG?

Average + confidence region!

Effect of the magnetic field: resonance splitting A. F. Otte et al., Nature Physics 4, 847 (2008) Ti atom S=1/2

Numerical renormalization group (NRG) calculation

Bethe Ansatz calculation using spinon density of states

Exact result for B→0: Δ=(2/3)g  B B Suggestion that for large B, Δ is larger than g  B B.

gives 2/3 for R=2, in agreement with Logan et al. (Factor 2 due to different convention.) Also find that Δ > 1g  B B, but they note that this might be non-universal behavior due to charge fluctuations in the Anderson model (as opposed to the Kondo model).

Interrelated problems: systematic discretization errors and spectral broadening  determines how  peaks are smoothed out!

Pessimistic error bars Rok Žitko, PRB 84, (2011)

Optimistic error bars The correct result is obtained in the  →0 limit!

NRG Agreement within error bars!

Experimental results for Ti adatoms: F. Otte et al., Nature Physics 4, 847 (2008) NRG calculation R. Ž., submitted B=7 T

Kondo model