1.  1. Future interest held by someone other than grantor ▪ Warning: Not all future interests held by a non- grantor qualify as remainders; they could.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
RULE AGAINST PERPETUITIES
Advertisements

Chapter 10: Construction of Trusts: Future Interests.
Estates in Land and Future Interests
 Grant of land that is, in some manner, conditional  Grantee could lose the “bundle of sticks”  Conditions may be added to:  Fee Simple  Life Estate.
DEFEASIBLE FEES DEFEASIBLE FEES Restatement Terms FEE SIMPLE DETERMINABLE (to grantor; automatic) F.S. ON CONDITION SUBSEQUENT (to grantor; must act)
A(LIB) - LE A’s widow (not LIB) -LE A’s issue then living Good, even if widow not yet born, because will vest by end of A’s life in being No good; widow.
 1. As to person – total intestacy  2. As to property – partial intestacy.
 In favor of a transferee (not the grantor), and  Does not qualify as a remainder.
Chapter 2 Land Interests: Present and Future
(F) Reggie “to Veronica for life, then to Betty and her heirs if Betty attains the age of 21.” Veronica: Life Estate Betty: Contingent Remainder in Fee.
 1. Possessory rights  Current, and  Until death.
 An interest is not good* unless it must vest**, if at all, not later than 21 years after some life in being*** at the time of the creation of the interest,
©2011 Cengage Learning. California Real Estate Principles Chapter 2 Part II: Estates and Methods of Holding Title ©2011 Cengage Learning.
Rule Against Perpetuities. No interest is good unless it must vest or fail within some life in being at the creation of the interest plus 21 years.
{ Chapter 12 Property: Real Property, Leases & Mortgages.
Real Property  Land and anything that is permanently attached to land (e.g., buildings, bridge, trees, crops, etc.)  Includes:  buildings  Subsurface.
Copyright © 2004 by Prentice-Hall. All rights reserved. PowerPoint Slides to Accompany BUSINESS LAW E-Commerce and Digital Law International Law and Ethics.
 1. Duration  Forever  Life only  Fixed number of years  Only as long as a condition satisfied.
McGraw-Hill/Irwin ©2008 The McGraw-Hill Companies, All Rights Reserved CHAPTER1CHAPTER1 CHAPTER1CHAPTER1 Introduction to Real Estate Finance and Investments.
Property Law Estates and Future Interests Boston College Law School November 1, 2006.
Property Law Estates and Future Interests Boston College Law School October 29, 2004.
Property Law Rule Against Perpetuities Boston College Law School October 29, 2009.
 Grant of land that is, in some manner, conditional [not “absolute”]  Grantee could lose the “bundle of sticks”  Conditions may be added to:  Fee.
CHAPTER ONE AN INTRODUCTION TO REAL ESTATE INVESTMENTS: LEGAL CONCEPTS.
Texas Real Estate Contracts 4 th Edition © 2015 OnCourse Learning.
Essentials Of Business Law Chapter 21 Real And Personal Property McGraw-Hill/Irwin Copyright © 2007 The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved.
 1. Possessory rights  Current, and  Until death.
Ownership of Property Chapter 23 Tools & Techniques of Financial Planning Copyright 2009, The National Underwriter Company1 Ownership Of Property Outright.
Property I Professor Donald J. Kochan Class
Rule Against Perpetuities. Classic Statement of RAP An interest is not good unless it must vest, if at all, not later than 21 years after some life in.
Chapter 48 Real Property.  Property that is immovable or attached to immovable land or buildings  Types of real property:  Land and buildings  Subsurface.
The Shadow of the Past MUSIC: CHANT The Benedictine Monks of Santo Domingo de Silos CHAPTER 7: The Shadow of the Past MUSIC: CHANT The Benedictine Monks.
1 Chapter 1 An Introduction to Real Estate Investments: Legal Concepts.
Mahrenholz P583: [A] grantor should give a FSD if he intends to give property for so long as it is needed for the purposes for which it is given and no.
Weekend Schedule Class: Saturday 9:00 a.m.-10:20 a.m. Office Hours (Room 263) –Saturday 11-2 –Sunday 2-4:30 New on Course Page: Comments & Corrections.
An interest is not good unless it must vest, if at all, not later than 21 years after some life in being at the time of the creation of the interest,
Revised Schedule TUE 11/1 8:00-9:20 WED 11/2 8:00-10:00 THU 11/3 8:00-9:20 SAT 11/5 9:00-10:20 MON 11/7 8:00-10:00 (Review) TUE 11/8 8:00-9:10 (Exam)
Slide Set Fifteen: Real Property – Estates in Land
 “To A and the heirs of his (her) body.”  “To A and her (his) issue.”  Words of purchase ▪ “To A”  Words of limitation ▪ “and the heirs of his (her)
Executory Interests. Elements of Executory Interests In favor of a transferee (not the grantor) but, not a remainder.
Right to possess and use forever Right to transfer all present and future rights (inheritable/devisable) Right to liquidate assets Default estate today.
PROPERTY A SLIDES Tuesday March 17 Wynton Marsalis, Trumpet Classic Wynton (1998) Detailed Instructions on Course Page for Thursday: REDWOOD:
WHITE v. BROWN LIVE OAK Discussion Questions
PLEASE PUT ASSIGNMENT #4 FACE DOWN IN BASKET ON CHAIR  MUSIC: Bach, Concertos for Two Harpsichords ( ) THE ENGLISH CONCERT Trevor Pinnock, Conductor,
Real Estate Investment Chapter 4 Ownership of Real Property © 2011 Cengage Learning.
Remaining Schedule Office Hours: 6:30-9 p.m. Deans’ Suite – Qs sent before 9 p.m. To be Posted Today –Slides from Today (Probs RSTU) –Suggested Analysis.
ESTATES & FUTURE INTERESTS THE SHADOW OF THE PAST:
Future Interest Chart. Remainders Held by a third person (not the grantor) Created by the same instrument (deed or will) as the possessory interest Becomes.
Estates & Future Interests Problems. Problem 1 “To A.”
THE SHADOW OF THE PAST MUSIC: CHANT THE BENEDICTINE MONKS OF SANTO DOMINGO DE SILOS CHAPTER 6: THE SHADOW OF THE PAST MUSIC: CHANT THE BENEDICTINE MONKS.
Fee Simple Absolute. “To A and his heirs.” “To A” = Words of Purchase [who takes] “and his heirs” = Words of Limitation [what is taken]
PROPERTY E SLIDES YOSEMITE: Problem 4I HALF DOME.
Chapter 3 Ownership of Property. Definitions Real Property versus Personal Property Tangible Personal Property versus Intangible Personal Property Fee.
PROBLEMS A-D Featuring the Mangos: Hutzler;GottLiebowitz;JMason; Sarinsky.
Review pRoblem R Renee conveys “to Stacy for life, then to my heirs, but should Stacy marry before she turns 35, to Marni.” AMBIGUITIES/QUESTIONS?
 In favor of a transferee (not the grantor), and  Does not qualify as a remainder.
 What did you think of the Awards show? A. Did not watch and do not care. B. Great to see AC/DC perform Highway to Hell. C. Always fun to see Kim and.
PROPERTY D SLIDES Florida Primary Day National Everything-You-Think is Wrong Day.
Introduction to Real Estate Finance and Investments
Chapter 48 Real Property.
Chapter 48 Real Property.
Rule Against Perpetuities Boston College Law School October 27, 2010
Agenda for 13th Class Admin stuff Name plates Lunch sign-up Handouts
Property Law Estates and Future Interests Boston College Law School
Agenda for 14th Class Admin stuff Name plates Handouts Slides Leases I
Real Property: Estates in Land Interests in Land – Time and Possession
Real Property: Estates in Land Interests in Land – Future Interests
Intestate Succession.
TEXAS INTESTATE DISTRIBUTION OF REAL PROPERTY
Problem 5, p. 258 A(LIB) - LE A’s widow (not LIB) -LE
Presentation transcript:

1

 1. Future interest held by someone other than grantor ▪ Warning: Not all future interests held by a non- grantor qualify as remainders; they could be executory interests. 2

 2. Created by the same instrument (deed or will) as the possessory interest 3

 3. Becomes possessory immediately upon the expiration of the prior estate (no gaps).  “To A for life, then one year after A’s death, to B and his heirs” would NOT create a remainder. X 4

 4. Does not divest or shorten a prior estate; the prior estate must end naturally  “To A for life, but if X becomes U.S. President, then to B and her heirs” would NOT create a remainder. X 5

 Fee simple  Absolute (“and his/her heirs”)  Determinable (“so long as,” “until,” “while”)  Subject to condition subsequent or executory limitation (“but if..., then”)  Life estate  Estate for years 6

 1. Owner is born and ascertained  2. Interest is not subject to condition precedent  Nothing must happen for the owner to get “stick of possession” other than prior estate to end naturally. 7

 Owner of remainder will get possession  “To A for life, then to B and her heirs.” 8

 Remainder limited to a class of which there is at least one living member.  “To A for life, then to B’s children and their heirs” assuming: 1.B has at least one child at the time of the conveyance, and 2.B is still alive (so could have more children). 9

 Vested remainder (either of the other two types) which is subject to a condition subsequent (“but if..., then”).  “To A for life, then to B and her heirs, but if B predeceases A, then to C and his heirs.” 10

 Owner of remainder will get possession  “To A for life, then to B and her heirs.” 11

 Remainder limited to a class of which there is at least one living member.  “To A for life, then to B’s children and their heirs” assuming: 1.B has at least one child at the time of the conveyance, and 2.B is still alive (so could have more children). 12

 Vested remainder (either of the other two types) which is subject to a condition subsequent (“but if..., then”).  “To A for life, then to B and her heirs, but if B predeceases A, then to C and his heirs.” 13

 Will you attend the Review Session on Friday, February 20 from 11 a.m. to 1 p.m. and would enjoy having pizza for lunch? A. I will attend and will eat. B. I will attend but I will not eat. C. I will not attend. D. I will not attend but I might stop by to eat anyway. 14

15

 Characteristics Generally  Nothing must happen for the owner to get “stick of possession” other than prior estate to end naturally thus:  Owner is born and ascertained, and  Interest is not subject to condition precedent.  Types:  Indefeasible Vested Remainder  Owner of remainder will get possession.  Vested Subject to Partial Divestment  Owner of remainder will get possession but share may reduced if additional members join the class of grantees.  Vested Subject to Total Divestment  An event could occur to prevent grantee from getting possession, “but if” (condition subsequent) construction. 16

 Holder is unborn or unascertained. or  A condition precedent must occur before the holder of the interest actually has the possibility of obtaining possession. 17

 “To A for life, then to B’s children and their heirs” assuming: 1. B has no children, and 2. B is still alive.  Grantor retains a reversion because B could die without having a child. 18

 “To A for life, then to B’s heirs” assuming:  B is still alive ▪ Cannot have heirs while alive.  Grantor retains a reversion because B could die without heirs. 19

 “To A for life, then to B and her heirs if B marries before A’s death” assuming:  B is still unmarried.  Grantor retains a reversion because B might not marry before A’s death. 20

 Astoria Township -- NE 1/2 of Section 7, East 3/8 of S 1/2 of NW 1/2 of said Section 7, T3N R1E 21

 “To Ross * * * for his natural life only, at his death to his lawful children [one of whom is Oscar who went bankrupt] [and if a child predeceases, to that child’s descendants by representation].”  Issue = Is this a vested or contingent remainder? ▪ Important as under Illinois law at the time, contingent remainders were inalienable. 22

 What if the contingency could still happen after the prior estate ends?  “To A for life, remainder to B and her heirs if B marries X” ▪ A could die with both B and X surviving but not yet married.  To A for life, then to B and his heirs if B attains age 21” ▪ A could die with while B is still alive but under age

 What if the contingency could still happen after the prior estate ends?  Common law = contingent remainder destroyed, grantor’s reversion takes effect, and grantor has fee simple absolute.  Modern law = grantor has fee simple subject to executory limitation, grantee has executory interest. 24

25

A. Life Estate B. Reversion C. Indefeasibly Vested Remainder D. Vested Remainder Subject to Partial Divestment E. Vested Remainder Subject to Total Divestment F. Contingent Remainder G. Executory Interest H. Nothing 26

27

 Triggering facts:  Grantee has a freehold interest in real property, and  Heirs of same grantee have a remainder interest in same property. ▪ Remainder is contingent as grantee has no heirs until grantee dies. 28

 Result if Rule applies:  Grantee’s heirs lose their contingent remainder.  Grantee gains a remainder.  If no intervening interests or conditions, grantee now has fee simple absolute. ▪ The sticks merge into a “full bundle.” 29

 “To A for life, then to A’s heirs.”  Merger occurs (sticks come back into one bundle as in common ownership) thus giving A fee simple absolute. 30

 “To A for life and then to A’s heirs if A graduates from the Texas Tech University School of Law.” 31

 “To A for life and then to A’s children and their heirs.” 32

 Historical Background 33

 Texas  Sybert v. Sybert – p. 323  Abolished for conveyances on or after January 1,

 Problems – p

 Triggering facts:  Future interest transferred inter vivos to heirs of the grantor. 36

 Result:  Future interest in heirs of the grantor is void. ▪ Read the deed as if the words are not there.  Thus, grantor has a retained interest (reversion, possibility of reverter, etc.). 37

 From Grantor “to A for life and then to my [Grantor’s] heirs.” 38

 “To A and his heirs until A gets married, then to my heirs.” 39

 Texas  Abolished for conveyances on or after January 1,

 Problem – page