Alternative dispute resolution of financial complaints in the UK Walter Merricks chief ombudsman David Thomas corporate director and principal ombudsman.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
1 independent external review by Lord Hunt of Wirral UK Financial Ombudsman Service David Thomas corporate director and principal ombudsman.
Advertisements

Profitable Partnership Opportunities
EU nationals and benefits Update on 2014 changes
© May not be reproduced without permission of Financial Ombudsman Service Ltd 1 The Financial Ombudsman Service …..its role in complaint resolution Ian.
Standing for trust and integrity OROC Congress Ethics and Accountability Lisbon, 22 October 2010 Hilde Blomme FEE Director of Practice Regulation.
The European Union (EU)
Quaker Council for European Affairs – A Quaker Voice in Europe The European Union Budget Overview and Income.
East Anglia Branch Annual Seminar Downing College, Cambridge 14 June 2013 The Man* in the Middle *The masculine gender shall include the feminine.
Consumer ADR in the UK Gregory Hunt, Head of Business Relationships The Chartered Institute of Arbitrators.
André Piérard, ERGEG Project Leader on Complaints Citizens’ Energy Forum, London, September 2009 Draft advice on Customer Complaint Handling, Reporting.
SEPA The Single Euro Payments Area January SEPA Single Euro Payments Area or Single European Payments Area *) A single market for payment transactions.
Personal Finance for Accountants (U13763) Lecture 2 The Economic and Regulatory Environment.
EP/Council Division of Power Commission proposes law, EP response based on one of three models: Co-decision (most issues, currently) – policy goes to EP,
Study Visits IV KAM Prague, 3 rd to 7 th September 2014.
Knowledge Management LXV International Council Meeting Qawra, Malta 16 th - 23 rd of March 2014.
THE EUROPEAN UNION Lesson 5
THE EUROPEAN UNION Lesson 5
OSH professionals in European countries: an overview Andrew Hale Chairman Certification Committee ENSHPO Emeritus professor TU Delft, Netherlands Chairman:
Enforcement in the field of data protection
Alternative Dispute Resolution. Introduction Alternative dispute resolution is often referred to as ADR. It describes the ways that parties can settle.
Financial Services Ombudsman Credit Unions Complaint Experience William Prasifka Financial Services Ombudsman 3 November 2012 National Supervisor Forum.
© OECD A joint initiative of the OECD and the European Union, principally financed by the EU Public Procurement Review and Remedies in the Member States.
1 FP6 into perspective. 2 Understanding the context and exploiting the opportunities FP6 into Perspective The European Union.
Institutional Visits III KAM, Bratislava 4th to 8th September 2013.
Introduction to Europe & European Law
Study Visits LXV International Council Meeting Qawra, Malta 16 th - 23 rd of March 2014.
© May not be reproduced without permission of Financial Ombudsman Service Ltd 1 Financial Ombudsman Service Alison Hoyland Policy Unit Manager, Corporate.
© May not be reproduced without permission of Financial Ombudsman Service Ltd 1 Cross-border disputes Adrian Dally Head of Policy.
Insurance regulation, dispute- resolution and compensation in the United Kingdom David Thomas corporate director and principal ombudsman Financial Ombudsman.
1 by Michael CHAMIER Director of Finance European Parliament Maastricht, May 11, 2001 PRESENTATION.
1SEEurope network meeting April 2005 National transposition of SE legislation: an overview A preliminary report Lionel Fulton Labour Research Department.
Copyright© Underwriters Laboratories Inc. All rights reserved. No portion of this material may be reprinted in any form without the express written.
Equality Bodies By Berit Vegheim, the Civil Rights Foundation Stop Discrimination, Norway.
Certificate for Introduction to Securities & Investment (Cert.ISI) Unit 1 Lesson 59:  Breaches, complaints and compensation  The difference between a.
THE EUROPEAN UNION. HISTORY 28 European states after the second world war in 1951 head office: Brussels 24 different languages Austria joined 1995.
THE EUROPEAN UNION. EU  1993 European Union  Main Aims  All states in the EU = a single market  One currency throughout the EU = the Euro  To have.
Study Visits ICM Cluj Napoca, 19 th to 26 th April 2015 Patrick Zischeck, Assistant for IV and SV.
Strength in Numbers Mar The Delian League  Countries do not want to be dominated by other countries.  But there are many advantages to be gained.
Tomasz Obal Basel, May 2007 Deposit Insurance Cross-Border Issues Burden-sharing.
Role-play on EU decision-making. The European Union: 500 million people – 28 countries Member states of the European Union Candidate and potential candidate.
Tomasz Obal Basel, May 2007 Deposit Insurance Cross-Border Issues Burden-sharing.
© Enterprise Europe Network South West 2009 The Eurostars Programme Kenny Legg R&D Funding for the Environmental Sector – 29 June 2010 European Commission.
I will: Know how and why the EU was created. Understand the benefits of being part of the EU.
European Union. Refresher  Market: the interaction of buyers and sellers exchanging goods and services  Trade: the process of buying, selling, or exchanging.
EU Council. HOW MANY MEMBERS ARE IN EU COUNCIL? 28 members are elected from each member states GermanySpainGreeceHungaryDenmarkCroatiaEstonia FrancePolandBelgiumSwedenSlovakiaLithuaniaCyprus.
THE EUROPEAN UNION.
Three key players The European Parliament - voice of the people Jerzy Buzek, President of of the European Parliament The council of Ministers - voice of.
The European Union. Important Events in EU History May 9, 1950 – French Leader Robert Schuman proposes the idea of working together in coal and steel.
The European Law Students’ Association Albania ˙ Austria ˙ Azerbaijan ˙ Belgium ˙ Bosnia and Herzegovina ˙ Bulgaria ˙ Croatia ˙ Cyprus ˙ Czech Republic.
Your first EURES job Making it easier to move and work to recruit young people in Europe.
THE EUROPEAN UNION Background 11 June Image by Rock Cohen. Used with permission europa.eu – official website of the EU.
Complaint Handling What is a complaint ‘ Any expression of dissatisfaction, whether oral or written, and whether justified or not, from or on behalf.
Maps of Topic 2B Multilingualism in Europe Europe A Story of Empire (a united Europe) & Language.
Table 1. Number and rate of Legionnaires’ disease cases per population by country and year, EU/EEA, 2010–2014 ASR: age-standardised rate, C: case-based.
CONFIDENTIAL 1 EPC, European Union and unitary patent/UPC EPC: yes EEA: no EU: no (*) (*) Also means no unitary patent Albania, Macedonia, Monaco, San.
INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS Unit 2 Business Development GCSE Business Studies.
“Turning poachers into gamekeepers”
THE EUROPEAN UNION How does the structure of government within the EU compare with the structure of government in the United States?
A New Climate - Financial Services Ombudsman, Ireland
CISI – Financial Products, Markets & Services
BAR Independent Alternative Dispute Resolution
GCSE Business Studies Unit 1 Starting a Business
European Union Duy Trinh.
About the Financial Ombudsman Service Australia
The European Parliament – voice of the people
The European Parliament – voice of the people
The European Union United in Diversity.
EU: First- & Second-Generation Immigrants
European Union Membership
Role-play on EU decision-making
Presentation transcript:

Alternative dispute resolution of financial complaints in the UK Walter Merricks chief ombudsman David Thomas corporate director and principal ombudsman Financial Ombudsman Service

UK = United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland England, Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland

60 million people 60 million people £1 = ¥200 £1 = ¥200 Firm = financial business Firm = financial business

Financial Services Authority (the regulator) Financial Ombudsman Service (adjudicates on unresolved disputes) Financial Services Compensation Scheme where we fit in …

Financial Services Authority (FSA) makes and polices the rules makes and polices the rules supervises financial firms supervises financial firms prudential regulation prudential regulation conduct-of-business conduct-of-business some self-regulation through codes some self-regulation through codes

Financial Ombudsman Service (FOS) resolves individual disputes resolves individual disputes an alternative to the civil courts an alternative to the civil courts informal / quicker / cheaper informal / quicker / cheaper not a regulator not a regulator some decisions can have big effect some decisions can have big effect

Financial Services Compensation Scheme (FSCS) safety net safety net claims against ‘dead’ firms claims against ‘dead’ firms contributions from ‘live’ firms contributions from ‘live’ firms

Ombudsmen …

Characteristics … citizen/consumer v state/institution citizen/consumer v state/institution deal with unresolved disputes deal with unresolved disputes free to citizen/consumer free to citizen/consumer flexible and informal processes flexible and informal processes investigative procedure investigative procedure

… characteristics wider dialogue wider dialogue encouraging complaint resolution encouraging complaint resolution encouraging complaint prevention encouraging complaint prevention

Public sector ombudsmen 1967: Parliamentary ombudsman 1973: Health service ombudsman 1975: Local government ombudsman

1981: Insurance Ombudsman established by industry voluntarily established by industry voluntarily in partnership with consumer bodies in partnership with consumer bodies independent council independent council alternative to civil courts alternative to civil courts but redress beyond the law but redress beyond the law binding on firm, but not consumer binding on firm, but not consumer

Other financial ombudsmen Banking Ombudsman Banking Ombudsman Building Societies Ombudsman Building Societies Ombudsman Investment [Management] Ombudsman Investment [Management] Ombudsman Personal Investment Ombudsman Personal Investment Ombudsman

FOS established by law … ‘a scheme under which certain disputes may be resolved quickly and with minimum formality’

Disadvantages compared with courts centralised centralised cannot cover third parties cannot cover third parties

Advantages over courts free to customer free to customer draw line for firm draw line for firm specialist knowledge specialist knowledge informal informal we mediate we mediate we investigate we investigate fair in the circumstances fair in the circumstances

Who we cover …

26,000 financial firms … banks banks building societies (mortgage banks) building societies (mortgage banks) other mortgage lenders other mortgage lenders mortgage intermediaries mortgage intermediaries credit unions credit unions electronic money institutions electronic money institutions

… 26,000 financial firms … insurance companies insurance companies insurance intermediaries insurance intermediaries investment/pension companies investment/pension companies investment/pension advisers investment/pension advisers stockbrokers stockbrokers

… for these activities … taking deposits, lending money and providing credit/debit/cash cards taking deposits, lending money and providing credit/debit/cash cards providing, arranging or advising on mortgages providing, arranging or advising on mortgages providing, arranging or advising on investments/pensions providing, arranging or advising on investments/pensions providing, arranging or advising on insurance providing, arranging or advising on insurance

… if they are provided in the UK in the UK from the UK from the UK

We cover business done from all UK branches of: UK firms UK firms Foreign firms Foreign firms We do not cover business done from non-UK branches: even of UK firms even of UK firms

Complainants covered Customers, potential customers and some others individual individual business (< ¥200 million turnover) business (< ¥200 million turnover) charity (< ¥200 million income) charity (< ¥200 million income) trust (< ¥200 million assets) trust (< ¥200 million assets) from UK and world-wide from UK and world-wide

Complaint process …

Complainants heard about us from: the firm 29% the firm 29% the press 28% the press 28% our literature 13% our literature 13% friend/relative 10% friend/relative 10% advice centre 7% advice centre 7%

If complainant comes to FOS and has not complained to firm FOS refers complaint to firm refers complaint to firm issues complaint form issues complaint form awaits complainant contact awaits complainant contact

What requires firms to do about complaints 8 weeks written response – final ombudsman referral rights 4 weeks written response – final or holding 5 business days written acknowledge- ment and recorded as complaint complaint unless resolved by close of next business day

Time limits after final response letter or 8 weeks (if sooner) after final response letter or 8 weeks (if sooner) 6 months from final response letter 6 months from final response letter 6 years from event or 3 years from knowledge (if later) 6 years from event or 3 years from knowledge (if later) we can waive time limits in exceptional circumstances we can waive time limits in exceptional circumstances

sift and respond cases written enquiries to casework phone enquiries

final decision by ombudsman 8% termination/mediation by adjudicator 42% initial decision by adjudicator 50% case

Termination by adjudicator no reasonable prospect of success no reasonable prospect of success no loss/material inconvenience no loss/material inconvenience fair settlement on offer fair settlement on offer court has dealt with merits court has dealt with merits more suitable for court more suitable for court legitimate commercial judgment legitimate commercial judgment [can ask for review by ombudsman]

Mediation by adjudicator evaluative mediation evaluative mediation by agreement by agreement

Initial decision by adjudicator initial view initial view (paper) investigation (paper) investigation power to compel evidence power to compel evidence adjudication adjudication [can ask for review by ombudsman]

Review by ombudsman (‘appeal’) request by either side request by either side additional evidence/arguments additional evidence/arguments possible hearing (rare) possible hearing (rare) ombudsman’s final decision ombudsman’s final decision if customer accepts, both bound if customer accepts, both bound otherwise, neither is bound otherwise, neither is bound [possibility of judicial review] [possibility of judicial review]

We decide what is fair in the circumstances of that case taking into account law law regulations regulations regulator’s rules regulator’s rules relevant codes relevant codes good industry practice good industry practice

Outcome of cases In about 35% of cases on average we agree with the complainant In about 35% of cases on average we agree with the complainant But that reflects rates of 15% to 80% depending on firm and product But that reflects rates of 15% to 80% depending on firm and product In about half the cases where we agree with the firm, it had not explained properly to the complainant In about half the cases where we agree with the firm, it had not explained properly to the complainant

Redress …

Remedy Generally, our aim is to put the complainant in the position they would have been in if the firm had not done something wrong

We can make the firm pay compensation up to ¥20 million pay compensation up to ¥20 million pay interest pay interest pay costs (rare) pay costs (rare) We can recommend more than ¥20 million, but the excess is not binding

Additionally, or alternatively, we can make the firm take ‘appropriate’ action This might be to put something right, reconsider an application or simply to apologise

We cannot make the firm compensate other customers in similar circumstances compensate other customers in similar circumstances change its products, procedures or staff change its products, procedures or staff

Complying with awards a firm must comply promptly with any award made by the ombudsman a firm must comply promptly with any award made by the ombudsman a complainant may enforce a money award or direction in the law courts a complainant may enforce a money award or direction in the law courts

Workload …

total enquiries (615,000) Enquiries to cases (111, 000) written enquiries (285, 000) phone enquiries (330, 000) to casework year ended 31 March 2005 …

banking and mortgages general insurance other investments mortgage endowments pensions securities current inflow …

number of new cases

>50% of complaints are about the 11 largest groups >50% of complaints are about the 11 largest groups >15% of complaints are about the 20 next largest groups >15% of complaints are about the 20 next largest groups <35% of complaints are about the other 22,000 firms <35% of complaints are about the other 22,000 firms

Resources …

Staffing 1 chief ombudsman 1 chief ombudsman 2 principal ombudsmen 2 principal ombudsmen 27 ombudsmen 27 ombudsmen 1,000 other staff 1,000 other staff

¥ Cost per case

Cost free to consumer free to consumer average cost of case = < ¥100,000 average cost of case = < ¥100,000 firms pay yearly levy (25% of cost) firms pay yearly levy (25% of cost) firms pay case fee (75% of cost) firms pay case fee (75% of cost)

Yearly levy based on market share bank pays ¥1 for every 2 bank accounts bank pays ¥1 for every 2 bank accounts insurance company pays ¥1 for every ¥100 of premiums insurance company pays ¥1 for every ¥100 of premiums small intermediary pays ¥10,000 small intermediary pays ¥10,000

Case fee ¥72,000 fee per case but first two cases per year are free ¥72,000 fee per case but first two cases per year are free only 7% of 26,000 firms covered pay case fees only 7% of 26,000 firms covered pay case fees 11 largest groups pay >50% of case fees 11 largest groups pay >50% of case fees

Information … consumer enquiries technical advice publications public website

Europe …

EUROPEAN UNION (EU) Austria, Belgium, Cyprus, Czech Republic, Denmark, Estonia, Finland, France, Germany, Greece, Hungary, Ireland, Italy, Latvia, Lithuania, Luxembourg, Malta, Netherlands, Poland, Portugal, Slovakia, Slovenia, Spain, Sweden and United Kingdom

EUROPEAN UNION (EU) Austria, Belgium, Cyprus, Czech Republic, Denmark, Estonia, Finland, France, Germany, Greece, Hungary, Ireland, Italy, Latvia, Lithuania, Luxembourg, Malta, Netherlands, Poland, Portugal, Slovakia, Slovenia, Spain, Sweden, United Kingdom EUROPEAN ECONOMIC AREA (EEA) European Union plus Iceland, Liechtenstein and Norway

EEA ‘passport’ rights Financial firms authorised in one EEA member state can provide services in or into any other EEA member state For example – UK-based internet bank directed at Spain and working in Spanish

FIN-NET  financial redress body network  refer cross-border complaints  advise on local law  meet six-monthly retail/finnet/index_en.htm

1998 European recommendation on principles for redress bodies  transparency  due process  independence  legality  effectiveness

Alternative dispute resolution of financial complaints in the UK Walter Merricks chief ombudsman David Thomas corporate director and principal ombudsman Financial Ombudsman Service