Injury Patterns in Elite Canadian Divers Kate Milhausen, MD Dept of Orthopedic Surgery University of British Columbia Vancouver, BC, Canada Kristin Wingfield, MD,CCFP Center for Sports Medicine San Francisco, CA, USA
Canadian springboard and platform divers rank top in the world despite always being Injured Incidence of injuries in competitive diving % No studies to link factors like training practices, MD visits, treatment methods to injury patterns Introduction
Objectives 1) To determine: Injury patterns Mechanisms, diagnosis and treatment methods characteristics and training patterns of athletes with the most injuries factors associated with unresolved or chronic injuries 2) To recommend injury prevention and treatment strategies
Design Retrospective survey, convenience sample Participants: divers qualified for Senior National Summer Championships, Victoria, BC 2002 Self-reported injury details and outcomes Training, competition profiles of athletes
Main Outcome Measures Injury defined: training missed > 1week Injury types, body parts, mechanisms, duration, resolution and #/diver Training practices & techniques, training & competitions missed due to injuries MD visits, imaging, treatment modalities used All results reported here have significant p values <0.05
Demographics 64% response rate (44/69) Mean age: /- 3.8 yrs Average # hours training/week: 36 (min 13, max 66) Average # years at Senior Nationals: 3.7 (min 1, max 12) Med Hx: 5/42 asthma, 1 below elbow amputation 14/44 athletes participated in other sports, eg ballet, skiing
Results 44 divers, mean age 17.8 yrs, reported 93 injuries Sprains, strains, fractures, tendonitis, tympanic membrane perforations most common Lumbar spine, shoulder, wrist, hand, head Divers with 3 or more injuries each: 34% (male, older, higher DD) Chronic injuries > 6months duration: 39% Unresolved injuries: 47% Male-female differences Identified
Injury Diagnoses
Mechanisms of Injury
Overuse injuries: Caused 24% of injuries Shoulder, lumbar spine tendinopathies, mechanical back pain, strains 64% reported by females Platform entry: Caused 38% of injuries sprains, strains, fractures, subluxations, tympanic membrane perforations Wrist, lumbar spine, hand, shoulder, head 72% of injuries resolved in LESS than 6 months, p=0.017
Males vs. Females MALES: (41%) divers 52% of the 93 injuries 10/18 (56%) injured males had 3+ injuries each Platform entry injuries: 69% are in males FEMALES: (59%) divers 48% of the 93 injuries 21/29 (72%) injured females had 2 or fewer injuries each Overuse injuries: 64% in females, p=0.014
Injury Duration Chronic injuries (6 months or longer): 39%, 36/93 Unresolved injuries: 47%, 44/93 19 provincial, 18 national, 12 international competitions affected by injuries (49/93 injuries)
Chronic Injuries 39% of all injuries reported 44% from overuse, 28% from platform entry, p=0.017 Tendonitis, sprains, fractures, strains, mechanical back pain, dislocations, spondy’s Treatments: PT 75%, massage 53%, chiropractor 39%, acupuncture 33%, NSAIDs used in 87% (n=30)
Unresolved Injuries 47% of injuries unresolved Wrist, lumbar spine, shoulder Strains, tendinopathies, mech back, dislocations, spondy’s, disc injuries, stress fractures, patello- femoral pain NSAIDs used in 94% of unresolved injuries treated with medication, p=0.015
Injury Duration vs. Number of Injuries Resolved
Injury Interventions
CONCLUSIONS 1. Unresolved Injuries Almost ½ of all injuries reported by Canadian elite divers unresolved
2. Chronic Injuries 40% of Canadian athletes’ injuries Occur more commonly in FEMALES, due to OVERUSE Treatments (physio, NSAIDs, massage) largely unsuccessful
3. Divers with multiple injuries: Males Older Performing difficult dive lists Platform divers
RECOMMENDATIONS Male platform divers must be monitored closely & their injuries treated early & followed aggressively Female athletes may benefit from specific kinetic chain, core and eccentric strengthening to treat and prevent chronic, overuse injuries Divers need to be educated on the proper use of NSAID’s
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS Dr. C.W. Reilly, Dept of Orthopedic Surgery, UBC; Dr. C. Loock Dept of Pediatrics, UBC, Vancouver, Canada - coauthors Jonathan Berkowitz - statistical analysis Dr. Benjamin Rubin (USA diving) - questionnaire format CADA – support, coaches & administrators at 2002 Senior Nationals in Victoria, BC