1 Protective measures for pregnant workers ERA Conference ‘EC Law on Equal Treatment Between Women and Men in practice‘ Trier, November 10, 2009 Prof.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
INTERNATIONAL LABOUR ORGANIZATION Conditions of Work and Employment Programme (TRAVAIL) 2012 Module 2: Maternity Protection at work: For whom? Maternity.
Advertisements

INTERNATIONAL LABOUR ORGANIZATION Conditions of Work and Employment Programme (TRAVAIL) 2011 Maternity Protection Resource Package From Aspiration to Reality.
Employment law – rights and responsibilities Riverland Community Legal Service.
Pregnancy Discrimination in the UK and the European Union Dr Katarzyna Gromek-Broc York Law School.
Maternity and Pregnancy Case Law Review Risk Assessment O'Neill v Buckinghamshire County Council [2010] IRLR no general obligation to carry.
INTERNATIONAL LABOUR ORGANIZATION Conditions of Work and Employment Programme (TRAVAIL) 2012 Module 8: Health protection at the workplace Maternity Protection.
Pregnancy Rights Information
National Breastfeeding Consultative Meeting Legal framework for promoting and protecting breastfeeding in the workplace by: Ms Thulani Ntshani NDOH
Employment Laws. Introduction The federal government has enacted many laws to protect workers. The Department of Labor is responsible for enforcing labor.
Recent developments in employment law Andrew Hambler.
OS 352 1/24/08 I. Organizational Justice II. Laws affecting human resource management. III. Federal enforcement of employment laws. IV. Reminders: A. Read.
CHAPTER SEVEN Gender Discrimination McGraw-Hill/Irwin © 2004 The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc., All Rights Reserved. 7-3 Gender Myths 1.Women are better.
Ministry of Employment Sweden Parental leave in Sweden Hanna Björknäs Division of labour law and work environment Ministry of Employment.
CHAPTER 7 Parental rights. Pregnant women and those who have recently given birth have rights to time off in particular circumstances. Parents have rights.
The European Social Charter The European Social Charter sets out rights and freedoms and establishes a supervisory mechanism guaranteeing their respect.
The Directive on temporary agency work: main provisions and implementation in the Member States Zagreb, 1 July 2013 Bertrand MULLER-SCHLEIDEN European.
Equality act 2010 A quick guide in 20 slides
INTERNATIONAL LABOUR ORGANIZATION Conditions of Work and Employment Programme (TRAVAIL) 2012 Module 6: Maternity leave and related types of leave Maternity.
INTERNATIONAL LABOUR ORGANIZATION Conditions of Work and Employment Programme (TRAVAIL) 2012 Module 12: Assessing national legislation on Maternity Protection.
ECJ Rulings with Regard to Discrimination on the Grounds of Disability – Case C-13/05 Chacón Navas Prof. Lisa Waddington, European Disability Forum Chair.
Gender and the Labour Act 11 of 2007 © Based on a template produced by the Gender Research and Advocacy Project of the Legal Assistance Centre The Legal.
Protecting Labour Rights in the Epidemic Anna Torriente, ILOAIDS International Labour Organization Prevent HIV, Protect Human Rights at.
,EU and Gender Equality’ Seminar on Best Practice of European Support to Women Entrepreneurship Petra Schott European Commission, October 2009
Update EU legislative affairs Pearle conference Geneva – agenda point May 2009.
Public Hearing on Maternity Leave, Paternity Leave and Parental Leave 19th January 2009 Committee of Women’s Rights and Gender Equality European Parliament.
JáN KIMÁK LEGAL CONCEPT OF EQUALITY IN INTERNATIONAL & NATIONAL LAW
LABOR LAW OF THE Islamic Republic of Afghanistan 1.
1 Maternity Protection Convention 2000, No ILO Standards on Maternity Protection Maternity Protection Convention, 1919 (No. 3) Maternity Protection.
1 Equal treatment in access to goods and services Dr Eugenia Caracciolo di Torella University of Leicester.
International legal frameworks Combating discrimination Luk Zelderloo, EASPD Secretary General 19 th – 20 th March 2009.
1 Reconciliation Current legal framework and plans to amend leave arrangements in the Commission’s work programme DG ‘Employment, Social Affairs & Equal.
Equal Treatment Outside Employment: Access to Goods and Services Elisabeth Holzleithner ERA, Trier, 19 May 2009 Holzleithner Goods and Services 1.
1 Community Legislation on Equal Treatment DG ‘Employment, Social Affairs & Equal Opportunities’ Equality, Action against Discrimination: Legal Questions.
Strategies to tackle wealth inequalities Legislation.
Flexicurity in the context of social security Ministry of Welfare of the Republic of Latvia Riga,
Pearle Conference Frankfurt, November 2010 Agenda point 16 EU employment and social affairs policy.
Labor Policy Keiichiro HAMAGUCHI. Chapter 4 Gender Policy.
SUPPORT TO THE STRENGTHENING OF THE SERBIAN OMBUDSMAN Experiences of the Greek Ombudsman, challenges and successes Mrs. Matina Yannakourou Deputy Greek.
Pag. 1 prof. dr. M. De Vos Positive Action & EC Law prof. dr. Marc De Vos.
The European Union and gender identity Silvan Agius, Policy Director, ILGA-Europe 1 September 2010 What can the EU do for trans equality? Silvan Agius,
INTERNATIONAL LABOUR ORGANIZATION Conditions of Work and Employment Programme (TRAVAIL) 2012 Module 9: Employment protection and non-discrimination Maternity.
Equal Pay for Work of Equal Value: EC Legal Framework and ECJ Case Law Prof. Dr. Eva Kocher, University of Frankfurt (Oder) Trier, 18 May 2009 Prof. Dr.
European Commission Employment & Social Affairs European Union against Discrimination Article 13 European Legislation to Combat Discrimination ENAR Conference,
Working conditions of pregnant and nursing women in EU countries, Member States’ experience Genoveva Tisheva, Bulgarian Gender Research Foundation.
Hearing of the Committee on Women’s Rights and Gender Equality on Maternity, Paternity and Parental Leaves Heidi Lougheed BUSINESSEUROPE.
International Labour Organization Women, Work and Families – An ILO Perspective Verena Schmidt Senior Specialist on Conditions of Work/ Gender Equality.
FMLA 12 weeks of unpaid leave during a 12 month period At the end of the leave, employees are to be reinstated to the same or equivalent (not similar!)
Benedetta Magri Key Elements of Maternity Protection at Work.
Council Directive 2003/9/EC laying down standards for the reception of asylum seekers European Commission Directorate-General External Relations.
M O N T E N E G R O Negotiating Team for the Accession of Montenegro to the European Union Working Group for Chapter 19 – Social Policy and Employment.
Jean Monnet Chair of EU Labour Law Academic Year Silvia Borelli:
Gender discrimination from the legal perspective
Family Friendly Working
EU law against Disability Discrimination
Dimitris Dimitriou European Commission EMPL/C3
Maternity Protection in the Framework of Human Rights
2016 Conclusions of the European Committee of Social Rights: Employment, training and equal opportunities 28 March 2017 Strasbourg Lauri Leppik Former.
Level 2 Diploma in Customer Service
Employee statutory rights and responsibilities
Discrimination.
Protected Characteristics
The Equality Act; employer statutory rights and responsibilities
Maternity and Pregnancy Case Law Review 2010
Overview of existing EC legislation on equal treatment between men and women and the role of the European Commission Rashmin Sagoo DG Employment, Social.
Rights and entitlements of the sna
Free movement of persons
European Labour Law Jean Monnet Chair of EU Labour Law Academic Year Silvia Borelli:
European Labour Law Jean Monnet Chair of EU Labour Law Academic Year Silvia Borelli:
Freedom of movement of workers in the EU
I.P. Asscher-Vonk Equal Pay, June This Course is funded by the Erasmus + Jean Monnet program of the European Commission. Iren.
Presentation transcript:

1 Protective measures for pregnant workers ERA Conference ‘EC Law on Equal Treatment Between Women and Men in practice‘ Trier, November 10, 2009 Prof. dr. Petra Foubert Law School, Hasselt University, Belgium Curia law firm, Leuven, Belgium

2 different approaches  Issues of pregnancy/ childbirth/ breastfeeding in the workplace approached from 2 angles: Discrimination angle Health and safety angle  The relationship between these 2 angles is not always a ‘pure’ one

Relevant EC legislation  Equal treatment/ non-discrimination: Dir. 2006/54/EC (recast directive)  Health and safety: Dir. 92/85/EEC (pregnancy directive)

Equal treatment/ non-discrimination  No general prohibition of discrimination in founding treaties  Still 2 specific instances of discrimination prohibited: Discrimination on grounds of nationality (within limits of EC ’ s powers) – art. 12 EC Wage discrimination between men and women – art. 141 EC

Wage discrimination  Art. 141 EC: Economic purpose ECJ opted for a fundamental rights approach Bedrock article (not legal basis!) for all EC sex equality measures

Dir. 2006/54/EC  Directive ‘ on the implementation of the principle of equal opportunities and equal treatment of men and women in matters of employment and occupation (recast) ’  A number of provisions explicitly relate to pregnancy/ childbirth

Dir. 2006/54/EC  Art. 2: ‘2. For the purposes of this Directive, discrimination includes: (a) […]; (b) […]; (c) any less favourable treatment of a woman related to pregnancy or maternity leave within the meaning of Directive 92/85/EEC.’

Dir. 2006/54/EC  Art. 15: ‘Return from maternity leave A woman on maternity leave shall be entitled, after the end of her period of maternity leave, to return to her job or to an equivalent post on terms and conditions which are no less favourable to her and to benefit from any improvement in working conditions to which she would have been entitled during her absence.’

Dir. 2006/54/EC  Art. 28: ‘Relationship to Community and national provisions 1. This Directive shall be without prejudice to provisions concerning the protection of women, particularly as regards pregnancy and maternity. 2. This Directive shall be without prejudice to the provisions of Directive 96/34/EC and Directive 92/85/EEC.’

Dir. 2006/54/EC  General provision: Art. 14: Prohibition of discrimination on grounds of sex in relation to: Conditions for access to employment Access to vocational guidance, training, … Employment and working conditions Membership of/ involvement in employers/ workers organisations

Dir. 2006/54/EC  Case C-294/04, Carmen Sarkatzis Herrero, judgement of 16 February 2006 Temporary servant on maternity leave who gains a permanent post after taking part in a competition Calculation of seniority only as of end of maternity leave ECJ: Dir. 76/207 precludes unfavourable treatment of pregnant worker on the basis of maternity leave or in relation with such leave

Health and safety  Many MS had protective legislation for women workers long before E(E)C came into existence  1987: European Commission examined this legislation for compatibility with predecessor of recast Directive (76/207)  Commission distinguished between ‘ anomalous provisions ’, ‘ humanitarian provisions ’ and ‘ health and safety provisions ’

Health and safety  Status of what Commission called ‘health and safety measures’ remained rather unclear  EC contributed to this situation by the adoption of Dir. 92/85/EEC ‘on the introduction of measures to encourage improvements in the safety and health at work of pregnant workers and workers who have recently given birth or are breastfeeding (tenth individual Directive within the meaning of Article 16 (1) of Directive 89/391/EEC)’

Dir. 92/85/EEC  Approach = health and safety  No link with equal treatment directives: i.e. problematic  Pregnancy/ delivery/ breastfeeding = relevant traits for categorisation, as opposed to a specific derogation from equal treatment directives  Risk of discrimination of women workers

Dir. 92/85/EEC  2 types of protective measures: Restrictive/ negative protective measures: pregnant workers are excluded from certain jobs/ working conditions/… Enhancing/ positive protective measures: require employers to give pregnant workers special treatment

Dir. 92/85/EEC  Restrictive/ negative protective measures: E.g.: pregnant/ breastfeeding workers should be protected against hazardous agents, processes or working conditions Make available alternative to night work if medical certificate is produced

Dir. 92/85/EEC  Enhancing/ positive protective measures: E.g.: Maternity leave  Continuous period of min. 14 weeks before and/or after childbirth (right)  Including 2 weeks of compulsory leave before and/ or after confinement  Payment/ adequate allowance, at least equivalent to allowance in case of illness

Dir. 92/85/EEC  Enhancing/ positive protective measures (continued): E.g.: Prohibition of dismissal:  From beginning of pregnancy to end of maternity leave: no dismissal for reasons connected with pregnancy  Citation of substantiated rights in writing

Dir. 92/85/EEC Prohibition of dismissal (continued):  Case C-460/06, Paquay: prohibition also concerns decision to dismiss/ preparations for dismissal  Case C-506/06, Mayr: no prohibition in case of ova fertilised in vitro, but not yet transferred to uterus

Dir. 92/85/EEC  2008: Commission proposal for directive amending dir. 92/85/EEC: Art. 141 EC added to legal base of proposal Prohibition of dismissal:  Beginning of pregnancy till 6 months after end maternity leave  Also prohibited: all preparations for a dismissal

Dir. 92/85/EEC  2008: Commission proposal for directive amending dir. 92/85/EEC: Maternity leave:  18 weeks  6 of which to be taken after childbirth (compulsory)  12 other weeks (non-compulsory): before or after childbirth  Childbirth after due date: no reduction in post- natal portion of leave

Dir. 92/85/EEC Maternity leave (continued):  Additional leave in case of premature childbirth, children hospitalised at birth, children with disabilities, multiple births  Illness connected with pregnancy occurring 4 weeks or + before confinement: no impact on duration of maternity leave  Adequate allowance: if it guarantees income equivalent to last monthly salary or an average monthly salary (ceiling possible; not lower than allowance in case of illness)

Dir. 92/85/EEC  Missing issues in Commission proposal: Breastfeeding (breaks …) Position of fathers (possibilities to bond …) Reproductive health/ reproductive hazards  May 6, 2009: E.P. sent report back to Committee on Women’s Rights and Gender Equality