The Wrong Kind of Railroad Whistle Blowing PA Rail Freight Seminar 2012 Jeff Jackson 1.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
OCCUPATIONAL SAFETY AND HEALTH ADMINISTRATION
Advertisements

Gerri Spinella Ed.D. Elizabeth McDonald Ed.D.
Confidentiality and HIPAA
THE CONSUMER PRODUCT SAFETY IMPROVEMENT ACT: WHISTLEBLOWERS KURT STITCHER LEVENFELD PEARLSTEIN, LLC DRI PRODUCT LIABILITY CONFERENCE APRIL 16, 2009.
NONSUBSCRIPTION UNDER THE TEXAS WORKERS’ COMPENSATION ACT James McCoy The McCoy Law Firm Coit Rd., Ste. 560 Dallas, Texas (214)
HR and the Law: Fairness and Safety I. Employment fairness II. Occupational Safety.
Suing the Federal Government. 2 History Traditional Sovereign Immunity US Constitution "No Money shall be drawn from the Treasury, but in Consequence.
OSH Act, OSHA Standards, Inspections, Citations and Penalties
Incentive Programs from OSHA’s Perspective Jim Shelton, CAS, HNAO.
Employment Law Chapter 18. Employment At Will Common law doctrine under which either party may terminate employment relationship at any time for any reason.
OUT IN FRONT OSHA Update: A Discussion About Two New Game-Changing Rule Changes Effective January 1, 2015 And a “Stealth Rule” expected to be effective.
Prentice Hall © PowerPoint Slides to accompany THE LEGAL ENVIRONMENT OF BUSINESS AND ONLINE COMMERCE 5E, by Henry R. Cheeseman Chapter 20 Employment.
New HR Challenges in the Dynamic Environment of Legal Compliance By Teri J. Elkins.
HUMAN RESOURCES ISSUES American University March 9-14, 2003.
Discipline and Discharge Just Cause – Synonyms “Cause” “Proper Cause” “Good Cause” Implied unless evidence indicates parties did not want it in the agreement.
LAUSD INJURY AND ILLNESS PREVENTION PROGRAM FOR SUPERVISORS AND EMPLOYEES As required by California Code of Regulations, Title 8, Section 3203.
OSHA Long Term Care Worker Protection Train the Trainer Program Part 1: Introduction.
 Most states have whistleblower protection laws, although some apply only to public- sector employees.  Some whistleblowers are protected under laws.
WHAT SHOULD MANAGERS KNOW ABOUT RETALIATION PROTECTIONS? Robin Soderblom BA 638 Bellevue University September 13, 2013.
Discrimination and Harassment in Employment Law: Overview and Helpful Hints Kenneth Tanji WorldEsquire Law Firm LLP 80 S. Lake Avenue, #708, Pasadena,
“To assure safe and healthful working conditions for working men and women; by authorizing enforcement of the standards developed under the Act; by assisting.
CHAPTER 22 Employment Law
Incident Reporting Procedure
/0203 Copyright ©2002 Business and Legal Reports, Inc. BLR’s Safety Training Presentations Safety and Health Program.
Claims Management Presented by: Patty Davidson – Qual-Lynx 2013 ACM JIF Retreat.
Providing Equal Employment Opportunity and a Safe Workplace
Employment-Related Injuries Chapter 24. OSHA Occupational Safety and Health Administration Primary representative of protective agencies Primary representative.
Office of Human Resources Presents….. Worker’s Compensation Information.
CHAPTER THREE Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964.
1. Objectives  Describe the responsibilities and procedures for reporting and investigating ◦ incidents / near-miss incidents ◦ spills, releases, ◦ injuries,
Sexual Harassment Increasing Awareness. Section I Introduction 2.
Employment Discrimination.  Fifth Amendment – Prohibits the federal government from: ◦ Depriving individuals of “life, liberty, or property” without.
Teachers and the Law, 8 th Edition © 2011 Pearson Education, Inc. All rights reserved. Teachers and the Law, 8e by David Schimmel, Leslie R. Stellman,
Working Together The Key to Safety
OSHA WHISTLEBLOWER ACT. WHISTLEBLOWER PROTECTION What is a whistleblower?
The OSH Act, Standards, & Liabilities
Module 1.  Objectives - Provide information about worker rights under OSHA law - Learn how to file a complaint, and rights against discrimination and.
1 Landscaping and Horticulture Safety Introduction to OSHA This material was produced under grant number SH F-54 from the Occupational Safety.
OSH Act Workers’ & Employer Rights & Responsibilities
CASE STUDY WHISTLEBLOWER Federal jury renders landmark verdict in favor of railroad workers’ safety MARC WIETZKE - FLYNN & WIETZKE. P.C. - A Publication.
Safety and Health: Legal Framework Statutory – Occupational Safety and Health Act (OSH Act) of 1970 Sets uniform standards – All business affecting commerce.
Essentials Of Business Law Chapter 28 Employment Law McGraw-Hill/Irwin Copyright © 2007 The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved.
DEALING WITH THE PROBLEM EMPLOYEE John Ashby
Changing Currents in Employment: Recent Developments in Whistleblower Law Jason M. Zuckerman The Employment Law Group ® Law Firm Tel: Fax:
MIRMA SPRING TRAINING 2014 PRESENTED BY JANE DRUMMOND WHISTLEBLOWER PROTECTIONS EMPLOYMENT PRACTICS UPDATE.
UMBC POLICY ON ESH MANAGEMENT & ENFORCEMENT UMBC Policy #VI
Division of Risk Management State of Florida Loss Prevention Program.
Chapter 40 Labor and Employment Law. 2  What is the employment at will doctrine? When and why are exceptions made?  What federal statutes govern working.
©2001 West Legal Studies in Business. All Rights Reserved. 1 Chapter 21: Employment Relationships.
1 SAFETY SAFETY Introduction & Overview INSY 3020 SPRING 2005.
Why do I Have Miners’ Rights? 4 The Act gives miners and their representatives many rights because Congress wanted to encourage them to take an active,
The Army Reserve MR. TIMOTHY D. JOHNSON Chief, Labor and Employment Law U.S. Army Reserve Command Labor Law Update.
 Established to provide the exclusive remedy for industrially injured employees, irrespective of fault.  Established to provide industrially injured.
Introduction to OSHA (Part 1)
POST-ACCIDENT DRUG TESTING
Standards for Technical Educators Occupational Safety & Health.
Osha Workplace Safety MEGAN GOHEEN. Introduction  Prevents workers from being killed or harmed at work  Provides their employees with conditions that.
Safety and Health Program Don Ebert- Risk Manager (509)
Part 29 CFR 1960 is not Optional Madison, Wisconsin June 9, 2010.
D. Scott Landry Chaffe McCall, L.L.P United Plaza Blvd., Suite 103 Baton Rouge, LA Sexual Harassment Prevention Training Association of Levee.
Miners’ Rights The Miners’ rights and responsibilities under the Federal mine safety and health act of 1977 Larry R Harshbarger Heritage Group Safety.
OSHA Injury/Illness Electronic Filing Brian A. Zachetti, CSP
Introduction to OSHA (Part 1)
Missouri Association of Rural Education
OSHA Update:  Insight on New Rules and Rule Changes And a “Stealth Rule” expected to be effective in August, 2015 Adams and Reese LLP.
Chapter 17: Employment Relationships
Connections Abuse Prevention Plan 2018.
Occupational safety and health (OSH)
Presentation transcript:

The Wrong Kind of Railroad Whistle Blowing PA Rail Freight Seminar 2012 Jeff Jackson 1

2

Trends Frequency and severity of personal injuries has dropped dramatically Significant reduction of FELA claims over the past decade –Acute injuries –Occupational injuries/illnesses However, the number of Whistleblower cases has gone up dramatically in the past several years 3

Trends OSHA has beefed up their Whistleblower Office under the current administration Jurisdiction transferred from RLA (Adjustment Board) to OSHA Expansion of scope of statute Greater public awareness of Whistleblower protections 4

Remedies Reinstatement with same seniority and benefits Back pay with interest Special damages –Mental distress and suffering –Any economic losses stemming from railroad’s actions Attorney’s fees Litigation costs –Expert witness fees Punitive damages (capped at $250,000) 5

Other Factors OSHA investigation Two bites of the apple Jury trial 6

FRSA Jury Award: Barati v. Metro-North First FRSA jury award Plaintiff alleged he was terminated for reporting an injury on the job Railroad subsequently reduced the discharge to a suspension $50,000 in compensatory damages $1, in punitive damages 7

Elements of a FRSA Claim 1.Employee engaged in protected activity; 2.Railroad knew or suspected the employee was involved in protected activity; 3.Railroad subjected employee to an adverse employment action; 4.Employee’s protected activity was a “contributing factor” to the adverse action. 8

“Protected Activity” under FRSA 1.Report a hazardous safety condition 2.Notify Railroad of a work-related injury or occupational illness (yourself or co-worker) 3.Furnish information to any regulatory/law enforcement agency relating to railroad incident resulting in injury, death, or property damage. 4.Refuse to violate and federal law/rule/regulation relating to railroad safety or security 5.Refuse to work under hazardous safety/security conditions 9

“Protected Activity” under FRSA 6.Refuse to authorize use of unsafe railroad equipment, track or structures 7.Accurately report hours on duty pursuant to Hours of Service Act 8.Follow rules or treatment plan of their treating physician 9.File a FRSA complaint with OSHA’s Whistleblower Office 10.Testify regarding a FRSA complaint 10

Medical Attention Amendment 20109©(1) “…carrier…may not deny, delay, or interfere with medical or first aid treatment of an employee who is injured during the course of employment. If transportation to a hospital is requested…the railroad shall promptly arrange to have the injured employee transported to the nearest hospital where the employee can receive safe and appropriate medical care.” 11

Medical Attention Amendment 20109(c)(2) “…carrier…may not discipline, or threaten discipline to, an employee for requesting medical or first aid treatment, or for following orders or a treatment plan of a treating physician…” Exceptions –RTW situations when done pursuant to FRA FFD standards (or a carrier’s own FFD standards) 12

“Adverse Employment Action” Discharge Demote Suspend Threaten Harass Discriminate Reduce pay Reduce hours Fail to rehire 13

“Contributing Factor” Similar to “in whole or in part” More likely than not Burden then shifts to Railroad to establish protected activity was not a factor by “clear and convincing evidence”. 14

Possible Whistleblower Scenarios Railroad delays treatment/hospital trip to question employee about incident leading to injury Railroad disciplines employee for late reporting of an injury Railroad disciplines employee for violation of a safety rule 15

Walter Peck: OSHA Administrator 16

OSHA Memorandum March 12, 2012 Focused on Injury Reporting Disciplinary action premised upon the mere reporting of an injury, regardless of circumstances, is prohibited Discipline after reporting injury based upon violation of rule deserve “careful scrutiny” –Must be reasonable –May not unduly burden employee’s right and ability to report 17

OSHA Memorandum March 12, 2012 Discipline based upon safety rule violation –OSHA concerned with use as a pretext for discrimination Factors OSHA considers –Rule compliance monitoring in absence of injury –Consistency in application in absence of injury –Nature of rule General rules (“maintain situational awareness”) will be strictly scrutinized 18

OSHA Memorandum March 12, 2012 Employee Safety Incentives –Team rewards (bonuses, parties) –“Well intentioned” but may discourage employees from injury reporting –Disqualification of group from incentive based upon injury report may constitute adverse employment action –OSHA will look to nature of incentive (magnitude) 19

Guidance from Recent Decisions Length of delay in reporting Consistency in rule enforcement History of employee’s discipline Extent of violation versus extent of response (proportionality) 20

Guidance from Recent Decisions Railroad response to whistleblower complaint Railroad response to OSHA investigation 21

What Not to Do 22

Some General Guidance DoDon’t Educate Managers about FRSADiscipline Employees for Mere Injury Report Consistently Enforce RulesDeviate from Medical Treatment Protocols Follow Medical Treatment ProtocolsInvoke the “nuclear option” Encourage Employee Injury ReportingMislead OSHA Investigators Develop Good Recordkeeping Cooperate with OSHA investigators 23