Draft decision – initial views Rob McMillan December 2014.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
CPUC CSI Workshop CPUC CSI Stakeholder Workshop San Francisco, CA February 15, 2012.
Advertisements

Regulatory Proposal December We provide distribution services to 1.4 million residential and business customers We deliver electricity to.
Regulation of network services Recent experience in the Australian National Electricity Market FSR Executive Seminar - 11 June Florence David Swift Executive.
Better Regulation workshop on Rate of Return Guidelines
A 2030 framework for climate and energy policies Energy.
NARUC-FERC Demand Response Collaborative Meeting NARUC Fall Meeting Anaheim, CA T. Graham Edwards President & CEO November 11, 2007.
The Australian Energy Regulator Public Forum April 29 Expenditure incentive guidelines Presentation on key issues.
1 A Review of Potential Gains from Reforms ECRA Workshop 6 November 2006 Dr Brian Wharmby Independent Consultant, former Technical Director of Ofgem
Better Regulation Expenditure Forecast Assessment Guideline 12 February 2013.
Australian Energy Regulator AER Preliminary decisions for Energex and Ergon Energy 2015−20 Conference 12 May 2015.
UNCLASSIFIED Department of Economic Development, Jobs, Transport and Resources Victorian Energy Efficiency Target Forum 16 April 2015 Village Roadshow.
SLIDE 1 AEMO INDEPENDENT ASSESSMENT OF NSW & TAS NETWORKS July 2014 PRESENTED BY NATIONAL PLANNING.
David Halldearn, ERGEG Conference on Implementing the 3 rd Package 11 th December 2008 Implementating the 3rd Package: An ERGEG Consultation paper.
Financing Urban Public Infrastructure
The Australian Energy Regulator SA Electricity distribution determination 2015–2020 Consumer/stakeholder forum 3 September 2014.
The Australian Energy Regulator. Today’s agenda Presentations from : ◦AER — Chris Pattas, General Manager - Networks ◦Consumer Challenge Panel — Hugh.
Better Regulation Program Service Provider Consumer Engagement Guideline Consumer Forum March 2013.
An Overview of Our Regulatory Proposal
Regulatory Change Measurement (RCM) Calculating Delay Costs These slides available at:
The Global Cost and Availability of Capital
Steve Paulone Facilitator Financial Management Decisions The financial manager is concerned with three primary categories of financial decisions:  1.Capital.
Regulatory Transparency and Interaction with the Government Dr. Konstantin Petrov Head of Section, Policy and Regulation.
Presentation by AER’s Consumer Challenge Panel (CCP) sub-panel 7 David Prins and Robyn Robinson.
The Cost of Capital ID: ma3n0224 name: Suvdaa. Chapter 11- Concept Cost of Capital is an extremely important financial concept.  In this chapter we will.
Victorian advanced metering infrastructure roll-out AMI budgets and charges AER draft determination Public forum Melbourne 21 August 2009.
Equity income: a niche asset class Neil Margolis, Portfolio Manager May 2007.
VENCorp Revenue Proposal 1 July 2008 to 30 June 2014 Initial Public Forum Presentation.
Multinational business
Draft decisions Access Arrangements for APT Allgas and Envestra (Qld) Warwick Anderson General Manager, Network Regulation 1 March 2011 Public.
The Australian Energy Regulator QLD Electricity distribution determination 2015–2020 Meeting with FNQ consumers/stakeholders 15 January 2014.
Draft Review Proposal 175 Encouraging Participation in the elective DM Regime Phil Broom 25 October 2007.
California Energy Commission 2015 IEPR Self-Generation Forecast Sacramento, CA 7/07/2015 Asish Gautam Demand Analysis Office Energy Assessments Division.
Better Regulation: Expenditure assessment and incentives 29 April 2013.
Australian Energy Regulator AER Preliminary decision for SA Power Networks 2015−20 Conference 13 May 2015.
The Australian Energy Regulator. Today’s agenda Presentations from : ◦AER – Sebastian Roberts, General Manager Networks ◦Consumer challenge panel – Robyn.
UK Parliamentary Committee Report on PFI (PPP) August 2011 All PFI projects have to complete a Value for Money (VfM) assessment of the PFI option compared.
Australian Energy Regulator Predetermination conference: AER draft decisions on NSW electricity distribution regulatory proposals December 2014.
The Australian Energy Regulator SA electricity distribution determination 2015–2020 Framework and approach Presentation to the Energy Consumers’ Council.
CHAPTER 3 Structure of Interest Rates © 2003 South-Western/Thomson Learning.
The Australian Energy Regulator. Today’s agenda Presentations from : ◦ AER – Chris Pattas, General Manager – Networks ◦ Consumer challenge panel – Ruth.
NSW Public Forum Essential Energy’s Regulatory Proposal 10 July 2014 Gary Humphreys, Chief Operating Officer.
The Australian Energy Regulator Public Forum NSW electricity distribution & transmission revenue proposals July 2014.
AER Consumers Forum Brisbane 18 December 2014 Thoughts on DM in the QLD network businesses’ regulatory proposals.
Getting Ready! Potential issues for consumers Ergon Distribution Network Regulatory Proposal Bev Hughson, Consumer Challenge Panel (CCP) 2 September 2014.
Essentials of Managerial Finance by S. Besley & E. Brigham Slide 1 of 23 Chapter 1 An Overview of Managerial Finance.
EXAMINING NEW BUSINESS MODELS WITH LOCAL NETWORK CHARGES AND VIRTUAL NET METERING Ed Langham, Research Principal 15 th September 2015.
BUILDING A LEVEL PLAYING FIELD FOR DISTRIBUTED ENERGY WITH LOCAL NETWORK CREDITS AND VIRTUAL NET METERING Jay Rutovitz, Institute for Sustainale Futures.
Investment Agreement Negotiation Columbia University New York June 2014.
Chapter 9 The Cost of Capital. Copyright ©2014 Pearson Education, Inc. All rights reserved.9-1 Learning Objectives 1.Understand the concepts underlying.
Getting Ready! Potential issues for consumers Queensland Distribution Network Regulatory Proposals Bev Hughson, Consumer Challenge Panel (CCP) 8 August.
The Australian Energy Regulator QLD Electricity distribution determination 2015–2020 Consumer/stakeholder forum – No 4 8 August 2014.
Proposed Consolidation of Albury and Victorian Access Arrangements 10 November 2015.
Madrid Forum 6-7 November 2008 Implementating the 3rd Energy Package: An ERGEG Consultation paper Lord Mogg, ERGEG chairman.
Public Forum 10 December 2014 SAPN Regulatory Proposal Bev Hughson Consumer Challenge Panel Member.
Energy Market Issues for Biomethane Projects Workshop - 31 October 2011 RIIO-GD1 Environmental Incentives.
15 October 2013 Briefing on draft s 56G report on the effectiveness of information disclosure regulation at Christchurch Airport.
Briefing for financial market analysts 30 April 2013 Draft report on the effectiveness of information disclosure regulation at Auckland Airport.
The next part of the specification. The key factors of 1.5 There are basics that need to understood before we can start 1.5 – basic terminology.
Investment Decision-making Learning Outcomes To be able to perform investment appraisal calculations (E) To be able to analyse the investment appraisal.
June 17, 2015 (Regina) June 18, 2015 (Saskatoon) SaskEnergy 2015 Rate Application.
Default price-quality paths for gas pipeline services Briefing on the Commission’s final decision for financial market analysts 28 February 2013.
Transmission Pricing Webinar 12 October Agenda for Webinar Introductions Purpose Potential Areas of Change – Overview –Revenue Proposal –Business.
CIAL Pricing Reset 1 December  Why CIAL wishes to move to a medium term pricing methodology  The key properties of the pricing model: how it works.
 Ensure utilities plan for and provide services by which Missouri’s residents and businesses can achieve their goals with less energy over time, with.
The Australian Energy Regulator SA electricity distribution determination 2015–2020 Framework and approach 20 November 2013.
DNPC05 Consultation Paper Balance of Revenue Recovery between LDZ System Charges and Customer Charges Steve Armstrong 27 th July 2009.
1 Chapter 1 Money, Banking, and Financial Markets --An Overview © Thomson/South-Western 2006.
New Customer Contributions for the Water Sector: Workshop 4 August 2004.
Revised draft decision: Initial default price-quality paths for gas pipeline services Briefing for financial market analysts 24 October 2012.
Phase 3: Building community support: Communications strategies
Presentation transcript:

Draft decision – initial views Rob McMillan December 2014

2 Agenda In a nutshell… Many areas of agreement, some important areas we will question Presentation agenda NSW gas market – our perspectives Customer engagement – building on a positive start Draft decision – areas we agree Draft decision – areas we will question Your views – our contact details

3 Gas market changes

4 The gas market is changing

5 A potential future Actual and forecast gas demand in the JGN (PJ per year) JGN’s response Currently a typical residential gas bill is around $1000, but a typical gas bill could be $200 more expensive by 2019/20 (incl. inflation) due to higher wholesale gas prices Our concern: – Rising retail gas prices make people look for value for money options… – …and most customers have access to a range of options for powering their homes and businesses (e.g. grid-electricity, solar PV) – …putting downward pressure on gas demand. What is the potential impact on retail prices? Participating in government policy reform to seek regulatory barriers are lifted to bring new gas supply on line as soon as possible Continue to be proactive in attracting new customers Keep downward pressure on our costs and our network prices—especially for key markets Respond to changes in the way gas is used Provide a service that customers value.

6 Customer engagement

7 Our on-going engagement commitments Help our customers, stakeholders and the community understand how gas services and prices are determined Keep our customers, stakeholders and the community informed of emerging factors that are influencing the energy market (including JGN), and our customers and stakeholders Involve our customers, stakeholders and the community in our decision making, and provide opportunities for them to provide feedback on the range of issues that are important to them Acknowledge and respond to the feedback we receive, including how it has influenced our decision making Be transparent about what we can and cannot do to manage gas prices and services, and what customers can do Measure, report and improve the effectiveness of our engagement through time.

8 AER draft decision

9 We are efficient, but can continue to improve Customer engagement highly regarded Efficient and equitable pricing Areas where we agree Historical capital expenditure 98.8% of JGN’s forecast operating expenditure (exc. debt raising costs) 5 per cent opex productivity factor for the period. Tariff structures, including low fixed charges to support gas connections New tariffs for energy intermediaries We have taken genuine steps to engage with our customers Our proposal was strengthened by the overall quality of our engagement Our engagement met the requirements of the AER’s guidelines

10 Pick a winner or use a consensus Questions AER approach Areas we will question – cost of equity AER picked one model as its foundation—the Sharpe-Lintner CAPM—and used it to filter other relevant evidence An alternative is to use a consensus approach to estimating the cost of equity By filtering evidence, AER constrains its effect on the cost of equity AER also makes other evidence meaningless by either not using it or by suggesting it produces wide ranges that cannot force a rethink of its estimate How should various pieces of evidence be combined? Does the AER approach lead to more or less stable cost of equity estimates over time? Does the AER approach support efficient investment?

11 Value or redemption Questions AER approach Areas we will question – gamma AER estimates gamma by looking at how much imputation credits are used (or redeemed), or are assumed to be used An alternative is to look at how much they are valued by the market, much like stocks and bonds AER looks primarily at tax redemption and equity ownership statistics to estimate gamma AER places limited weight on studies of how much investors value imputation credits, which leads to a higher estimate of gamma (and lower allowed tax) Does it matter whether investors value imputation credits or not? If investors that can or do use credits are assumed to value them fully, then does this affect their incentives to invest efficiently if they do not? Should gamma be estimated consistently with how the cost of equity is?

12 Areas we will question – demand forecasts Demand forecasts – reality check

13 Areas we will question – capital expenditure JGN established new contracts for routine construction in October As it was a competitive tender price, we are satisfied that the unit rates drawn from these contracts which form the basis of estimates used in JGN's proposed capex are efficient. Versus We therefore calculated the connection unit rates using actual data between 2008 and Connections – concerning inconsistencies Major projects 20 page consultant report to challenge almost $100M worth of projects that deliver important customer outcomes Technical errors in engineering assessments Explanatory documentation ‘missed’, leading to rejection of costs

14 Your views

15 Preparing our revised proposal Have your say Review the AER’s draft decision Customer Council meeting on 8 Dec 14, and potentially another in late Jan/Feb 15 Engage with customers and stakeholders Jan/Feb 15 Prepare our revised proposal and lodge by 27 Feb 15 Our revised proposal