Vermont Yankee Nuclear Power Corp. v. NRDC, 435 U.S. 519 (1978) Strategic Delay in Derailing Public Policy.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Overview of Education Litigation FEA Delegate Assembly October, 2012.
Advertisements

Judicial Review Getting Into Court Standards of Review Remedies.
1 Judicial Review Under NEPA Bob Malmsheimer April 1, 2006.
Vermont Yankee Nuclear Power Corp. v. NRDC, 435 U.S. 519 (1978) Strategic Delay in Making Public Policy.
Copyright © 2004 by Prentice-Hall. All rights reserved. PowerPoint Slides to Accompany BUSINESS LAW E-Commerce and Digital Law International Law and Ethics.
Introduction: The Role of Agencies
Introduction to Administrative Law and Process The Administrative Procedure Act Getting Into Court Standards of Judicial Review.
© 2004 West Legal Studies in Business A Division of Thomson Learning 1 Chapter 43 Administrative Law Chapter 43 Administrative Law.
Powers and Functions of Administrative Agencies
Deciding How To Apply NEPA Environmental Assessments Findings of No Significant Impact Environmental Impact Statements.
Federal Energy and Environmental Regulation Agencies and Laws
History of Administrative Law. The Administration of Government Moving beyond feudalism, all governments are divided into functional units that behave.
Rulemaking Part III. 2 Procedural Rules Procedural rules are exempt from notice and comment The form of an application for benefits is procedural The.
American Government and Organization PS1301 Wednesday, 21 April.
Copyright © 2005 Pearson Education Canada Inc. Business Law in Canada, 7/e, Chapter 3 Business Law in Canada, 7/e Chapter 3 Government Regulation and the.
Taking Action Before or After a Rulemaking or Bill is Proposed Warren Hoemann Senior Vice President – Industry Affairs American Trucking Associations.
 Administrative law is created by administrative agencies which regulate many areas of our government, community, and businesses.  A significant cost.
© 2013 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved. May not be copied, scanned, or duplicated, in whole or in part, except for use as permitted in a license.
Introduction to Administrative Law Spring What does Administrative Law Deal With? The formation, staffing, and funding of agencies. Rulemaking (legislation)
Introduction to Adjudications Every new tribunal, erected for the decision of facts, without the intervention of jury,... is a step towards establishing...
Quiz 3 DO ONE OF THE FOLLOWING ITEMS, BUT NOT BOTH : 1. Under ordinary circumstances administrative agency personnel are required to obtain a search warrant.
Vermont Yankee Nuclear Power Corp. v. NRDC, 435 U.S. 519 (1978) Strategic Delay in Derailing Public Policy.
Overview of Administrative Law. History of Administrative Law.
School Law and the Public Schools: A Practical Guide for Educational Leaders, 5e © 2012 Pearson Education, Inc. All rights reserved. Chapter 1 Legal Framework.
Rulemaking Introduction to The Regulators. 2 Jargon Alert Rule, legislative rule, or regulation They all mean the same thing Has the same effect as a.
Reading the Tea Leaves: The Future of Administrative Law in U.S. Supreme Court Jurisprudence Lecture by Dr. John M. Aughenbaugh Berglund Seminar Series.
Vermont Yankee Nuclear Power Corp. v. NRDC, 435 U.S. 519 (1978) Strategic Delay in Derailing Public Policy.
© 2010 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved. May not be scanned, copied or duplicated, or posted to a publicly accessible website, in whole or in part.
Chapter 3 Introduction to Adjudications Every new tribunal, erected for the decision of facts, without the intervention of jury,... is a step towards establishing...
Judicial Review "The rules governing judicial review have no more substance at the core than a seedless grape."
Rulemaking Introduction to The Regulators. 2 Jargon Alert Rule, legislative rule, or regulation They all mean the same thing Has the same effect as a.
© 2010 Pearson Education, Inc., publishing as Prentice-Hall 1 ADMINISTRATIVE LAW AND REGULATORY AGENCIES © 2010 Pearson Education, Inc., publishing as.
Chapter 3 Part I. Informal Adjudications We have been talking about informal adjudications Most adjudications are informal Goldberg hearings are the most.
Vermont Yankee Nuclear Power Corp. v. NRDC, 435 U.S. 519 (1978) Strategic Delay in Derailing Public Policy.
Licensing of a Potential Geologic Repository at Yucca Mountain Lawrence Kokajko, Director Division of High-Level Waste Repository Safety U.S. Nuclear Regulatory.
Rulemaking Jump Start Quick Introduction to Notice and Comment Rulemaking.
Rulemaking Introduction to The Regulators. 2 Jargon Alert Rule, legislative rule, or regulation They all mean the same thing Has the same effect as a.
Types of Law OBE-118, Section 10 Fall 2004 John McKinsey We are looking at the types of law from the perspective of how they are created, where they come.
Vermont Yankee Nuclear Power Corp. v. NRDC, 435 U.S. 519 (1978) Strategic Delay in Derailing Public Policy.
Chapter One State and Federal Administrative Law, 2nd ed
Fixing American’s Surface Transportation (FAST) Act and NEPA Section 1309 – Program for Eliminating Duplication of Environmental Reviews 23 USC 330 – CEQA/NEPA.
Rulemaking. Ex Parte Communications in Litigation What is an ex parte communication in litigation? Why do we ban them in litigation? If a party in a lawsuit.
©2001 West Legal Studies in Business. All Rights Reserved. 1 Chapter 6: Administrative Law.
Vermont Yankee Nuclear Power Corp. v. NRDC, 435 U.S. 519 (1978) Strategic Delay in Derailing Public Policy.
Overview of Administrative Law. History of Administrative Law.
Federal Energy Regulatory Commission 1 Overview of the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) Roland W. Wentworth Office of Markets, Tariffs and Rates.
The Emperor Has No Clothes: Confronting the D.C. Circuit’s Usurpation of SEC Rulemaking Authority By James D. Cox & Benjamin J.C. Baucom Washington, D.C.
Vermont Yankee Nuclear Power Corp. v. NRDC, 435 U.S. 519 (1978) Strategic Delay in Derailing Public Policy.
Vermont Yankee Nuclear Power Corp. v. NRDC, 435 U.S. 519 (1978) Strategic Delay in Derailing Public Policy.
Last Topic - Factor responsible for development of Administrative Law
Granting Certiorari.
Federal Energy and Environmental Regulation Agencies and Laws
Environmental and Regulatory Update: Opportunities and Challenges for the Renewable Industry in the Midwest Kevin D. Johnson
Judicial Review Under NEPA
The Changing Discourse on Water Policy
Administrative law Ch1 scope and Nature of Administrative Law.
Chapter 6 Administrative Law
NRC’s Decision Process: Judging The Safety Of A Proposed Repository
REGULATORY VIEW OF FUTURE NUCLEAR WASTE MANAGEMENT
The Rulemaking Process
Chapter 3 Introduction to Adjudications
Vermont Yankee Nuclear Power Corp. v. NRDC, 435 U.S. 519 (1978)
Adding Nuclear Power to the Grid
Unit 6 NEPA.
National Environmental Policy Act of 1969 (NEPA)
Essentials of the legal environment today, 5e
Introduction to The Regulators
Part I – Introduction to Non-Legislative Rules
Overview of Administrative Law
Chapter 23 Government Regulation and Administrative Law
Presentation transcript:

Vermont Yankee Nuclear Power Corp. v. NRDC, 435 U.S. 519 (1978) Strategic Delay in Derailing Public Policy

Modern Administrative Law The story of Adlaw post-1970 is the limitation of individual liberties in favor of efficient government. The DC Circuit was still in the Warren Court era when this case was decided. Why was the lower court suspicious of agency rulemaking in this case? What did it want to require to provide greater public protections? 2

3 Nuclear Power Plant Regulation Originally regulated by the Atomic Energy Commission Regulated and promoted nuclear power Regulation was split off to the Nuclear Regulatory Commission because of conflicts of interest Environmental impact analysis was added through NEPA after the initial permitting of this plant. Greatly complicates permitting.

4 The Permit History for Vermont Yankee Permitting is an adjudication Specific party, specific facts The agency makes a decision as to whether it will grant the permit. In 1967 Vermont Yankee is granted a construction permit. In 1971, post-NEPA, it applies for an operating permit. Why is it politically difficult to deny an operating permit?

The Permit Fight Who is the NRDC? Why does it oppose the operating permit? The EIS Because of NEPA, the NRC must prepare an environmental impact statement (EIS) The adjudication must deal with problems with the EIS, and the sufficiency of the EIS can be challenged in court. This the vehicle for a lot of environmental litigation. 5

Nuclear Waste and the EIS Why is nuclear waste disposal a big issue for NEPA? Does the NRC or the nuclear industry have a good solution in 1971? What would this mean about the completeness of the EIS? Why does the NRDC want the agency to explain in the EIS about the long term environmental impact of the reactor? 6

Avoiding the Issue What does the NRC do to avoid making this a subject of the hearing? Why does it not want this discussed in the public hearing? How will making a rule on waste disposal remove it from the hearing process? Classic narrowing of adjudication issues by rulemaking 7

The Rulemaking What additional process was provided beyond the usual APA notice and comment? Were there limits on the public participation? Which alternative did the NRC adopt after the public comment?..specified numerical values for the environmental impact of this part of the fuel cycle, which values would then be incorporated into a table, along with the other relevant factors, to determine the overall cost-benefit balance for each operating license. Why is the NRDC unhappy with this alternative? No requirement of a plan for disposing of fuel 8

9 DC Circuit What does the DC circuit want the NRC to do to improve the due process in their rulemaking? “it likewise clearly thought it entirely appropriate to "scrutinize the record as a whole to insure that genuine opportunities to participate in a meaningful way were provided” Did it specify exactly what procedures should have been used?

The Role of the APA Did the rulemaking comply with the APA? What is the lower court's theory about the APA requirements? Floor or ceiling? Who does the court think should decide on the appropriate procedures? Does this look like Goldberg or Matthews ? 10

11 The Substantive Issue What is the DC court's real problem with the rulemaking on waste management? What is the NRC’s plan? Did the technology exist at the time to dispose of the waste? Can an agency put off a problem by assuming that a solution will be found in the future? What about requiring a technology that does not exist? We are 35+ years latter - who was right about the technology?

Energy Conservation What is the energy conservation issue? Why is energy conservation a NEPA environmental impact issue? What event precipitated this concern? Is it fair to apply it to the operating permit for a reactor that has already been built? Did the lower court accept the agency’s finding on energy conservation? 12

13 The United States Supreme Court What does the United States Supreme Court think about the role of the APA in setting process? Who gets to make the call - agency or courts? In the court's view, what is the real issue? "The fundamental policy questions appropriately resolved in Congress and in the state legislatures are not subject to reexamination in the federal courts under the guise of judicial review of agency action. Time may prove wrong the decision to develop nuclear energy, but it is Congress or the States within their appropriate agencies which must eventually make that judgment. “ Why is this critical for the political control of agencies?