Dr. Padam Simkhada Dr Jane Knight

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
"How's our impact?: Developing a survey toolkit to assess how health library services impact on patient care" Alison Weightman July 2008.
Advertisements

I 3 conference, June 2013 A typology of e-book interactions and the e-book literacy and tools required for achieving students study goals Dr Laura.
What is a review? An article which looks at a question or subject and seeks to summarise and bring together evidence on a health topic.
Action Research Not traditional educational research often research tests theory not practical Teacher research in classrooms and/or schools/districts.
Development of a Community SPIRIT ‘The Journey so Far’ Alun E Morgan MPhil Student.
Knowledge transfer to policy makers (with apologies to John Lavis!)
Comprehensive Literature Review Rowena Stewart, Liaison Librarian Tel: Knowing what you want to read about Bibliographic.
Introducing... Reproduced and modified from a presentation produced by Zoë Debenham from the original presentation created by Kate Light, Cochrane Trainer.
What do I do with the literature when I’ve found it? Alison Brettle, Lecturer (Information Specialist) School of Nursing and Midwifery University of Salford.
Systematic Reviews Dr Sharon Mickan Centre for Evidence-based Medicine
What is Evidence? Presented at the Data Leading to Action-From Chaos to Clarity Symposium Winnipeg, January 19-20, 2009 Dexter Harvey.
How the University Library can help you with your term paper
Doug Altman Centre for Statistics in Medicine, Oxford, UK
Authors and affiliation Research, University of Sheffield, 3 East Midlands Ambulance Service Study flow Conclusion In addition to measures relating to.
Mapping Studies – Why and How Andy Burn. Resources The idea of employing evidence-based practices in software engineering was proposed in (Kitchenham.
Transformation and research trends: dictated by preference Prof Ina Fourie Department of Information Science, University of Pretoria.
Evidence for ‘excellence in care’
Research Methods for Business Students
1 Improving Access to Public Health Information: A Study of Information Needs in a State Health Department E. Hatheway Simpson, MPH Nancy R. La Pelle,
Introduction to evidence based medicine
Guidelines for the reporting of evidence identification in decision models: observations and suggested way forward Louise Longworth National Institute.
How the University Library can help you with your term paper Computer Science SC Hester Mountifield Science Library x 8050
Information Retrieval for High-Quality Systematic Reviews: The Basics 6.0.
Their contribution to knowledge Morag Heirs. Research Fellow Centre for Reviews and Dissemination University of York PhD student (NIHR funded) Health.
Reporting results of systematic reviews
How to Critically Review an Article
Professor Tahseen Jafry GCU Climate Justice Resource Hub.
Systematic Approaches to Literature Reviewing. The Literature Review ? “Literature reviews …… introduce a topic, summarise the main issues and provide.
Systematic Review of the Literature: A Novel Research Approach.
KT-EQUAL/ CARDI Workshop: ‘Lost in Translation’ 23 June 2011 Communicating research results to policy makers: A practitioner’s perspective.
How to Write a Critical Review of Research Articles
Systematic Reviews.
Analysis of information sources. Different sources “A critique on of the omnipotence of hegemonies” Dictionaries, encyclopaedias, newspapers and books.
Zoe G. Davies Centre for Evidence-Based Conservation University of Birmingham, UK Systematic Review Methodology: a brief summary.
Writing with evidence: Source, Search, Summarize, and Synthesize Bandit Thinkhamrop, PhD.(Statistics)
Evidence-Based Public Health Nancy Allee, MLS, MPH University of Michigan November 6, 2004.
Identifying the evidence Laura Macdonald Health Protection Scotland
Finding research Nilusha Kapugama 28 March 2015, Nargarkot, Nepal This work was carried out with the aid of a grant from the International Development.
Systematic reviews to support public policy: An overview Jeff Valentine University of Louisville AfrEA – NONIE – 3ie Cairo.
Results The final report was presented to NICE and published by NICE and WHO. See
UKPopNet Workshop 1 Undertaking a Systematic Review Andrew S. Pullin Centre for Evidence-Based Conservation University of Birmingham, UK.
Workshop on VHL and HEN, Sao Paulo, April 2006 Workshop on VHL and HEN Sao Paulo, April 2006 Anca Dumitrescu, M.D. WHO Regional Office for.
Business Project Nicos Rodosthenous PhD 14/10/ /10/20141Dr Nicos Rodosthenous.
Evidence-Based Forestry: Networks of Practice, Research and Information SLA-DERM Forestry Section, SLA Monday, June 13, 2011 Gillian Petrokofsky University.
Deciding how much confidence to place in a systematic review What do we mean by confidence in a systematic review and in an estimate of effect? How should.
ProQuest Jennifer Jackson, Regional Sales Manager, ProQuest.
Objectives  Identify the key elements of a good randomised controlled study  To clarify the process of meta analysis and developing a systematic review.
Systematic Review: Interpreting Results and Identifying Gaps October 17, 2012.
Doing a Systematic Review Jo Hunter Linda Atkinson Oxford University Health Care Libraries 1 March 2006 Workshops in Information Skills and Electronic.
Sifting through the evidence Sarah Fradsham. Types of Evidence Primary Literature Observational studies Case Report Case Series Case Control Study Cohort.
R. Heshmat MD; PhD candidate Systematic Review An Introduction.
An Introduction to NHS Evidence
How to Write Literature Review ww.ePowerPoint.com
Validity and utility of theoretical tools - does the systematic review process from clinical medicine have a use in conservation? Ioan Fazey & David Lindenmayer.
Evidence Based Practice (EBP) Riphah College of Rehabilitation Sciences(RCRS) Riphah International University Islamabad.
CHAPTER 2 LITERATION REVIEW 1-1. LEARNING OUTCOMES 1.The reasons for a literature review being an essential part of every project. 2.The purpose of a.
PHE Knowledge and Library Services – building an interactive evidence base Anne Brice Head of Knowledge & Library Services Public Health England.
Systematic Reviews of Evidence Introduction & Applications AEA 2014 Claire Morgan Senior Research Associate, WestEd.
Review of all hazard disaster databases sub-committee
Knowledge Transfer Partnership Project Nottingham Trent University and Nottinghamshire County Council Dr Adam Barnard Rachel Clark Catherine Goodall 19/4/16.
The DELTA2 Study: Summary of Methodology and Results
Effective evidence-based occupational therapy
Lifestyle factors in the development of diabetes among African immigrants in the UK: A systematic review Alloh T. Folashade Faculty of Health and Social.
Second Edition Chapter 3 Critically reviewing the literature
Style You need to demonstrate knowledge and understanding beyond undergraduate level and should also reach a level of scope and depth beyond that taught.
THE CURRENT LANDSCAPE OF RESEARCH ON WORLD HEALTH ASSEMBLY INDICATORS IN WEST AFRICA: A SYSTEMATIC MAP TO GUIDE DECISION-MAKING Leah Salm1 . Roos.
What are systematic reviews and why do we need them?
Dr. Charmayne Dubé Dr. Beverley Temple
Dr. Charmayne Dubé Dr. Beverley Temple
Presentation transcript:

Dr. Padam Simkhada Dr Jane Knight Chasing the Grey Evidence: A Standardised Systematic Literature Review Approach Dr. Padam Simkhada Dr Jane Knight

Partners for Research in Emergency Nutrition Acknowledgement Partners for Research in Emergency Nutrition PREN Garth Reid, Laura Wyness, Lakshmi Mandava

Overview Evidence based public health Grey literature Advantages and disadvantages of using grey literature Some challenges The way forwards Conclusions

What is Evidence Based Public Health Evidence based public health as a public health endeavour in which there is an informed, explicit, and judicious use of evidence that has been derived from any of a variety of science and social science research and evaluation methods. Sacket et al 1996 BMJ 312 71-72

Evidence Based Public Health The definitions highlights two aspects of evidence based public health The use of a multiple methodologies evidence to inform public health decision; publication bias An emphasis on clear reasoning in the process of appraising and interpreting evidence for policy and implementation

Getting the evidence from Systematic Literature Review Searching for and locating appropriate literature Critically examining the results and extracting relevant detail Synthesizing and writing the review and produce a evidence

Evidence beyond RCTs

Evidence beyond RCTs Evidence

Evidence to Policy Evidence Previous perceptions Social and political context Culture Geographical context Policy Action Practice or

Levels of evidence & volume of grey literature

Research Questions Management of childhood malnutrition in complex emergencies

What is a Systematic Literature Review Aim is to reduce uncertainty by a rigorous methodology that is: Comprehensive Transparent or explicit Leads to minimum bias Reproducible

Childhood Malnutrition in Complex emergencies Initially identified 4802 Title/abstract scanned Included 173 Full paper scanned Non grey 12

Definition of grey literature “Grey literature is defined as any literature that is not published in academic peer reviewed journals and available through indexed databases for review”

Search for grey literature Call for information Personal and institutional contact World-wide web search

Challenges for a representative search Problems with call for information personal interest/limitations Problems with personal and institutional contact Staffs changes on NGOs World-wide web large number and difficulties in filter

Challenges for a representative search Difficult to control bibliographically Grey database not widely available institutional subscribe eg SIGLE (System for information on Grey Literature in Europe)

Different type of grey literature Annual reports Theses/dissertations Conference abstracts/proceedings Working papers Evaluation reports Facts sheets and others

Searching for representative literature Which organisations? Which key opinions? Which databases? Which web sites?

Framework for a representative search Local Level International National Level International level National Local

Childhood Malnutrition in Complex emergencies Initially identified 4802 *** Title/abstract scanned Included 173 Full report 102 Full paper scanned 20 Non grey 12 Grey 8 

Advantages of including ‘grey’ in a literature review Access to wider variety of information Reduces publication bias Contain more local information- important for planning Contain process information- important for policy makers

Advantages of including ‘grey’ in a literature review Reports not published in peer reviewed journals (e.g. UN, WHO, HTA) Access to new research World Wide Web (4-6 Billion web pages) Contain valuable and unique information, which is not found elsewhere

Searching for representative literature 1. Systematic review of published literature (databases) 2.Basic review of grey literature (web) 3. Personal communication with organisations and experts identified.  4. Validation of representaiveness Value of literature identified Phase 1 2 3 4

Literature review framework

Conclusion The identification of relevant studies in the grey literature and their inclusion in systematic reviews can be particularly time-consuming and difficult. However, the inclusion of grey literature in systematic reviews will help to overcome some of the problems of publication bias and evidence for process and context PREN at Aberdeen University is taking forward the development the tools which can be used to review the grey literature

For further information Please contact to PREN group PREN@abdn.ac.uk Dr. Jane Knight j.knight@abdn.ac.uk Dr. Padam Simkhada p.p.simkhada@abdn.ac.uk

Questions and comments ?