WHEN DID CONTINENTAL CRUST FORM AND WHEN WAS IT DESTROYED? THE BRAHMA/SHIVA RATIO AND THE GEOLOGIC RECORD Robert J. Stern* and David Scholl** *University.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Plate Tectonics Imagine the Earth as a hardboiled egg…………………….
Advertisements

Earth Science 10.1 Volcanoes and Plate Tectonics
9.1 Continental Drift An Idea Before Its Time
Metamorphism The transformation of rock by temperature and pressure Metamorphic rocks are produced by transformation of: Igneous, sedimentary and igneous.
Continental Drift.
Silicate Earth Primitive mantle Present-day mantle Crust Oceanic crust Continental crust Reservoir Volume Mass Mass % (10 27 cm 3 )(10 27 g) Earth
Earth’s Interior and Geophysical Properties Chapter 17.
Lecture 1-2 continued Material balance and properties Uplift and subsidence. Topography, crustal and lithospheric thicknesses, 1)LATERAL TRANSPORT OF MATERIAL.
The main physical features of the Earth. 1 Atlantic Ocean Indian Ocean Pacific Ocean Southern Ocean North America South America Africa Europe Asia Oceania.
Evolution of Continental Crust Chapter 10. Hypsographic Curve.
Plate Tectonics.
Plate Tectonics.
The Rock Cycle S E C T I O N
Lecture 1-2 continued Material balance and properties Uplift and subsidence. Topography, crustal and lithospheric thicknesses, 1)LATERAL TRANSPORT OF MATERIAL.
Integrated Science One
Metamorphic Rocks. Metamorphism Literally translates to “change of form” In geology it refers to solid-state changes in mineral assemblages of a rock,
Major tectonic systems operating during the past 200 My
CHAPTER 2 Internal Structure of Earth and Plate Tectonics
Robert W. Christopherson Tim Schultz Chapter 11 The Dynamic Planet.
Metamorphic Facies Best, Chapter 10.
 Dispersion of the Gondwana continents  Closing of Tethys Ocean  Pacific System: rimmed by subduction zones East Pacific Rise moving towards the Americas.
(Chapter 10 in D & R) Geometry and Kinematics: Plates.
The Tectonic Plates The Violent Earth. Types of Crust Continental Crust – 20 to 70 km (10 to 30 miles) thick. Oceanic Crust – 7 km (4 miles) thick.
Imagine the Earth as a hardboiled egg……………………. The thin brittle shell is the crust that humans live on. The thick jelly like white is the deep hot magma.
PLATE TECTONICS: PLATE BOUNDARIES. LAYERS OF THE EARTH 1.Crust (brown/tan) 2.Mantle (light & dark orange) 3.Core (yellow & white) 1.Crust (brown/tan)
Plate Tectonics.
mountains, mountain building, & growth of continents
Plate Tectonics. What is plate tectonics? Earth’s lithosphere is broken into plates that move on the asthenosphere. The movement of these plates is ‘Plate.
Lecture ONE Introduction. Introduction The composition of the Earth: -Lithosphere (5-70 km, solid and rocky, 5 km thick under the oceans and up to 70.
Plate Tectonics ….and Your Community
Metamorphism Changes in rocks due to increasing P-T conditions and/or interaction with fluids.
CLASSIFICATION OF ROCKS.  Rocks are defined as natural solid massive aggregates of minerals forming the crust of the earth.  Petrology is the branch.
Metamorphic Facies and Mineral Assemblages
Chapters 5, 6, 13, 14, 21, 22 Section 4 for Hominid evolution 1.
Earth’s Layered Structure (Ch. 8.4 in the Text)
Pacific Northwest Geology. Northwest Geology Starting points We’re interpreting events & conditions in the past using available evidence – the rock record.
Supercontinent cyclisity?
Plate Tectonics Test Review HW-Finish Castlelearning Extra Help Today After School.
Undergraduate opportunities (1) Web design: "Structural geology of southwest U.S. and northwest Mexico" preceptorship vs. paid? Contact: Stuart Glogoff.
Plate Tectonics. The Structure of the Earth A thin crust km thick A mantle – has the properties of a solid but it can also flow A core – made.
IV. Modern Plate Tectonic Theory
Pg. 47/48 Plate Tectonics. Pangaea Continental drift caused the supercontinent Pangaea to separate Pangaea -Greek word meaning ‘all the earth’; most recent.
Chronology of geomagnetic field reversals magnetic anomaly “number” Ocean floor age, millions of years (Ma), determined largely from deep sea drilling.
EARTH SCIENCE. An Idea Before Its Time Continental Drift  Wegener’s __________________ ________________________hypothesis stated that the continents.
Metamorphism of Basic Igneous Rocks In this Lecture Tectonic Environment and Geothermal Gradients Changes in Metamorphic Facies Mineralogical Characteristics.
Cracking Crustal Questions. Convergent Also called convergent boundary The motion of two plates toward one another Requires that the subducting plate.
The India - Eurasia collision, Himalaya and the Tibetan plateau.
TIMANIAN OROGENY AND LATE NEOPROTEROZOIC SUBDUCTION V. PEASE, STOCKHOLM UNIVERSITY.
Copyright © 2014 All rights reserved, Government of Newfoundland and Labrador Earth Systems 3209 Unit: 3 Earth’s Materials Reference: Chapters 2, 3, 6,
Geography of Canada Mr. J. Brazeau Plate Tectonics.
We live on the crust, which varies in thickness from about 11km under the ocean to about 33km under the continents. The earths crust is made up of a great.
Eric H. Christiansen Brigham Young University
PLATE TECTONICS: PLATE BOUNDARIES
The Structure of The Earth Convection currents Tectonic Plates Plate Movements.
Metamorphism and Metamorphic Rocks Physical Geology.
Modification of Rocks by Temperature and Pressure
A. The theory that pieces of the Earth’s lithosphere, called plates, move slowly on top of the asthenosphere B. Explains the formation and movement of.
What is the thermal structure of a subduction zone?
Composition of the Continental Crust, Omer M. Ahmed, University of Kerala, India
Metamorphic Rocks Chapter 6 Dynamic Earth.
Fundamental Concepts GLY 4310 Spring, 2013
PLATES AND TECTONIC MOVEMENT
PLATE TECTONICS: PLATE BOUNDARIES
Alteration of Rocks by Temperature and Pressure
Chapter 8 Earth Systems Friedland and Relyea Environmental Science for AP®, second edition ©2015 W.H. Freeman and Company/BFW AP® is a trademark registered.
11.3 –Mountain Formation.
On the significance of short-duration regional metamorphism
How Earth changed from being Pangea to separate continents
Observations Among the silicate planets, Plate Tectonics is only found on Earth, indicating that special circumstances are required. Plate Tectonics (kinematic.
Presentation transcript:

WHEN DID CONTINENTAL CRUST FORM AND WHEN WAS IT DESTROYED? THE BRAHMA/SHIVA RATIO AND THE GEOLOGIC RECORD Robert J. Stern* and David Scholl** *University of Texas at Dallas **USGS, U Alaska Fairbanks

The rate at which continental crust has grown through time is commonly discussed… …but this is a flawed controversy, because it ignores crustal destruction. Continental crust “Growth Curves”

We now understand that continental crust is destroyed as well as created Stern & Scholl 2010

Today, we estimate that about twice as much continental crust is destroyed as created.

The controversy about changing volume of continental crust through time, correctly framed. Stern & Scholl, 2010

Brahma/Shiva ratio Assign continental crust formation to Brahma, Hindu god of creation. Assign continental crust destruction to Shiva, Hindu god of destruction. We want to know how the proportion of volumes of continental crust formation to destruction has varied over time.

Brahma is the Hindu “Creator” god Shiva is the Hindu “Destroyer” god When Shiva loses his temper, his third eye opens which turns most things to ashes. Brahmā holds a string of prayer beads which he uses to keep track of the Universe's time.

Let Shiva represent continental crust destruction Let Brahma represent continental crust creation We want to know the ratio of Brahma’s activities to that of Shiva over time: the Brahma/Shiva ratio.

Modern B/S ~0.64 to What was it in the past?

We have a powerful indicator of Brahma’s activities: zircon! Zircon U/Pb ages provide a robust record of creation Zircon: 232,000 hits in Google Scholar Zircon: the nearly indestructible indicator of igneous processes and continental crust production. Lawley’s Zircon Gallery

Zircon Age Distribution of Continental Crust Condie & Aster, 2009

But what geologic record do we have of Shiva’s activity? No “Shiva indicators” compare with Brahma’s zircons. Best indicator of continental crust destruction is Ultra-High Pressure (UHP) metamorphic rocks

UHP assemblages are characterized diamond or coesite. These require pressures corresponding to depths > 90 km. UHP terranes are samples of continental crust that were subducted, then returned to the surface. Schertl and O’Brien 2013

Worldwide UHP terranes from Gilotti (2013). Solid symbols indicate confirmed coesite or diamond. Open symbols are where UHP metamorphism is inferred from pseudomorphs or calculated P–T conditions, or cases where index minerals have been published in abstract. UHP occurrences globally are <650 Ma

P–T for UHP metamorphism (from Liou et al. 2012). Eclogite facies is shown in light and dark green. Metamorphic facies are delineated by thick gray lines (GS = greenschist, BS = blueschist, A = amphibolite, GR = granulite facies). The thicknesses of Tibetan and average continental crust are indicated. UHP metamorphism is the deeper part of the eclogite facies and corresponds to the coesite stability field (dark green). The yellow, orange, and red lines correspond to generalized cold, tepid, and hot P–T paths for UHP rocks.

How to interpret the UHP record? Assume UHP’s are minor fragments of continental crust subducted to > 90km; much more did not return to the surface. Why no UHPs >650 Ma? Hacker et al. 2013

Another Shiva Indicator: Truncation of Paleozoic sedimentary facies and structures against the Pacific margin ~250 Ma Karlstrom 2009Dickinson 2006

Massive truncation of older structures also occurred on other side of Pacific

A couple of thoughts: 1. What are the Shiva indicators for the pre 650 Ma record? 2. ~2/3 of continental crust is lost by subduction today. A pre-Plate Tectonic Earth would only lose crust by delamination and so should have a higher B/S ratio.

Brahma/Shiva ratio through time Pre 650 Ma: B/S >1 Post 650 Ma: B/S <1

Thanks for listening!

Extra slides

Collision Campbell et al Do zircon age spikes signify supercontinent assembly? Not if Himalaya is a good modern analogue of supercontinent assembly..

Subduction collision of the 2500-km-wide India crust began ~50 Ma. The volume of India Crust that entered the subduction zone is ~300 x 10 6 km 3 (2500 km x 40 km x 3000 km)

Ultra High Pressure(UHP) Metamorphic rock localities Oldest examples are ~630 Ma (Late Neoproterozoic) Modified from Maruyama and Liou (1998)

Pehrsson et al Do zircon age peaks reflect times of supercontinent assembly?