Association of U.S. tornado counts with the large-scale environment on monthly time-scales Michael K. Tippett 1, Adam H. Sobel 2,3 and Suzana J. Camargo.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Plant Sector Workshop March 21, MIT – Progress on the Science of Weather and Climate ExtremesMarch 29, 2012 Motivation –Billion-dollar Disasters.
Advertisements

Tropical Cyclone Intrinsic Variability & Predictability Gregory J. Hakim University of Washington 67th IHC/Tropical Cyclone Research Forum 6 March 2013.
Suzana J. Camargo Lamont-Doherty Earth Observatory Columbia University ANALYSIS OF 20 TH CENTURY ATLANTIC HURRICANE POTENTIAL INTENSITY AND TROPICAL CYCLONE.
EL NIÑO-SOUTHERN OSCILLATION’S EFFECT ON AMERICAN TORNADOS Jake Mittelman April
The Effects of El Niño-Southern Oscillation on Lightning Variability over the United States McArthur “Mack” Jones Jr. 1, Jeffrey M. Forbes 1, Ronald L.
Indian Monsoon, Indian Ocean dipoles and ENSO Pascal Terray LOCEAN/IPSL, France Fabrice Chauvin CNRM/Météo-France, France Sébastien Dominiak LOCEAN/IPSL,
Tropical Cyclone Forecasts Dr. Richard J. Murnane Risk Prediction Initiative Bermuda Biological Station for Research, Inc.
Chukchi/Beaufort Seas Surface Wind Climatology, Variability, and Extremes from Reanalysis Data: Xiangdong Zhang, Jeremy Krieger, Paula Moreira,
“what a climate model is, and what uncertainty means” Noah S. Diffenbaugh Department of Environmental Earth System Science and Woods Institute for the.
West African Monsoon and Tropical Cyclones 1.Atlantic tropical cyclone variability: A climate perspective 2.Do African easterly waves matter?: A weather.
Warm-Season Lake-/Sea-Breeze Severe Weather in the Northeast Patrick H. Wilson, Lance F. Bosart, and Daniel Keyser Department of Earth and Atmospheric.
WEST AFRICAN STORM TRACKS AND THEIR RELATIONSHIP WITH ATLANTIC TROPICAL CYCLONES Susanna Hopsch Department of Earth and Atmospheric Sciences University.
Section 6: Tropical Cyclones 6.4 Maximum Potential Intensity How intense can a tropical cyclone get? Resources: Emanuel 1991 “The theory of hurricanes”,
Protecting our Health from Climate Change: a Training Course for Public Health Professionals Chapter 2: Weather, Climate, Climate Variability, and Climate.
Genesis Potential Index and ENSO Suzana J. Camargo.
+ Effects of Climate Change on Ocean Storms Chloe Mawer.
Climate Forecasting Unit Prediction of climate extreme events at seasonal and decadal time scale Aida Pintó Biescas.
The speaker took this picture on 11 December, 2012 over the ocean near Japan. 2014/07/29 AOGS 11th Annual Meeting in Sapporo.
Verification of the Cooperative Institute for Precipitation Systems‘ Analog Guidance Probabilistic Products Chad M. Gravelle and Dr. Charles E. Graves.
Cluster Analysis of Tropical Cyclone Tracks and ENSO Suzana J. Camargo, Andrew W. Robertson, International Research Institute for Climate Prediction, Columbia.
United States Landfalling Hurricane Webpage Application Philip J. Klotzbach and William M. Gray Colorado State University, Fort Collins, Colorado Abstract.
By Anthony R. Lupo Department of Soil, Environmental, and Atmospheric Science 302 E ABNR Building University of Missouri Columbia, MO
1 CUTTING-EDGE CLIMATE SCIENCE AND SERVICES Geoff Love.
The MJO signal in tropical cyclone activity A study using a genesis potential index Suzana J. Camargo Lamont-Doherty Earth Observatory, Columbia University,
Climate Change in the Yaqui Valley David Battisti University of Washington 1.Climatological Annual Cycle –Winter vs. Summer 2.Variability(Winter) –ENSO.
June 16th, 2009 Christian Pagé, CERFACS Laurent Terray, CERFACS - URA 1875 Julien Boé, U California Christophe Cassou, CERFACS - URA 1875 Weather typing.
Tropical Domain Results Downscaling Ability of the NCEP Regional Spectral Model v.97: The Big Brother Experiment Conclusions: Motivation: The Big Brother.
Page 1© Crown copyright 2006 Matt Huddleston With thanks to: Frederic Vitart (ECMWF), Ruth McDonald & Met Office Seasonal forecasting team 14 th March.
The climate and climate variability of the wind power resource in the Great Lakes region of the United States Sharon Zhong 1 *, Xiuping Li 1, Xindi Bian.
The Atlantic Multidecadal Oscillation, Climate Change, and Atlantic Hurricanes Michael E. Mann Department of Meteorology/Earth and Environmental Systems.
CC-07: Atmospheric Carbon Dioxide Concentrations and Weather: Evidence from Hawaii Kevin F. Forbes The Catholic University of America Washington, DC .
Research Needs for Decadal to Centennial Climate Prediction: From observations to modelling Julia Slingo, Met Office, Exeter, UK & V. Ramaswamy. GFDL,
Introduction 1. Climate – Variations in temperature and precipitation are now predictable with a reasonable accuracy with lead times of up to a year (
USING THE ROSSBY RADIUS OF DEFORMATION AS A FORECASTING TOOL FOR TROPICAL CYCLOGENESIS USING THE ROSSBY RADIUS OF DEFORMATION AS A FORECASTING TOOL FOR.
13 March 20074th C20C Workshop1 Interannual Variability of Atmospheric Circulation in C20C models Simon Grainger 1, Carsten Frederiksen 1 and Xiagou Zheng.
The Ingredients Based Tornado Parameter Matt Onderlinde.
Relationship between interannual variations in the Length of Day (LOD) and ENSO C. Endler, P. Névir, G.C. Leckebusch, U. Ulbrich and E. Lehmann Contact:
Severe Weather: Tornadoes Harold E. Brooks NOAA/National Severe Storms Laboratory Norman, Oklahoma
Refinements to Atlantic Basin Seasonal Hurricane Prediction from 1 December Phil Klotzbach 33 rd Annual Climate Diagnostics and Prediction Workshop October.
1 Fourth IAP Meeting February ° Extreme Event: Winter US Tornado Outbreak --- Attribution challenge °2007 US Annual Precipitation Extremes ---
Global Climate Change: Past and Future Le Moyne College Syracuse, New York February 3, 2006 Department of Meteorology and Earth and Environmental Systems.
1 Opposite phases of the Antarctic Oscillation and Relationships with Intraseasonal to Interannual Activity in the Tropics during the Austral Summer (submitted.
Tropical Cyclone Rapid Intensity Change Forecasting Using Lightning Data during the 2010 GOES-R Proving Ground at the National Hurricane Center Mark DeMaria.
Evaluating the ability of climate models to simulate extremes Eric Robinson Natalie McLean Christine Radermacher Ross Towe Yushiang Tung Project 6.
Summer Tornadoes – NWA 2015 Statistical Severe Convective Risk Assessment Model (SSCRAM) (Hart & Cohen, 2015) SPC Mesoanalysis Data Every hour from
© 2006 Accurate Environmental Forecasting Climate Effects on Hurricane Frequency and Severity Dail Rowe, PhD Accurate Environmental Forecating.
GEOGRAPHY 120: EARTH SYSTEM II. Atmospheric Sciences at a Glance.
Alan F. Hamlet Andy Wood Dennis P. Lettenmaier JISAO Center for Science in the Earth System Climate Impacts Group and the Department.
Quantifying the Significance of the April 2011 Severe Weather Outbreak Matthew S. Stalley, Chad M. Gravelle, Charles E. Graves Saint Louis University.
Climate Change & Tropical Cyclones Current Weather Finish Extreme Weather Tropical Cyclone Review Broader Context of Tropical Cyclones Previous Debates.
Interannual to decadal variability of circulation in the northern Japan/East Sea, Dmitry Stepanov 1, Victoriia Stepanova 1 and Anatoly Gusev.
Winter Outlook for the Pacific Northwest: Winter 06/07 14 November 2006 Kirby Cook. NOAA/National Weather Service Acknowledgement: Climate Prediction Center.
What is the impact of ENSO Cycle? Suzanne Fortin Cold season severe weather climatology.
Hurricanes and Global Warming Kerry Emanuel Massachusetts Institute of Technology.
Analysis of Typhoon Tropical Cyclogenesis in an Atmospheric General Circulation Model Suzana J. Camargo and Adam H. Sobel.
Description of the IRI Experimental Seasonal Typhoon Activity Forecasts Suzana J. Camargo, Anthony G. Barnston and Stephen E.Zebiak.
Trends in hail and thunderstorm in China over the past 50 years under the changing monsoon climate Qinghong Zhang 1,2, Xiang Ni 1, Fuqing Zhang 2, Mingxin.
The 2004 Atlantic Hurricane Season and Beyond Chris Landsea NOAA/Hurricane Research Division Miami, Florida, USA January and February 2004 Southern Region.
Marcel Rodney McGill University Department of Oceanic and Atmospheric Sciences Supervisors: Dr. Hai Lin, Prof. Jacques Derome, Prof. Seok-Woo Son.
Climate Change & Tropical Cyclones Current Weather Finish Extreme Weather Tropical Cyclone Review Broader Context of Tropical Cyclones Previous Debates.
Development and applications of a new genesis potential index
Michael K. Tippett1,2, Adam H. Sobel3,4 and Suzana J. Camargo4
Development and applications of an index for tropical cyclone genesis
Can CMIP5 models replicate long-term variability of storm characteristics in the WNP? James Bramante.
Alfredo Ruiz-Barradas Sumant Nigam
Ingredients approach for severe weather
Forecasting Seasonal and
Predictability of Indian monsoon rainfall variability
Forecast parameters, Tornadogensis, maintenance and decay
Differences Between High Shear / Low CAPE Environments in the Northeast US Favoring Straight-Line Damaging Winds vs Tornadoes Michael E. Main, Ross A.
Presentation transcript:

Association of U.S. tornado counts with the large-scale environment on monthly time-scales Michael K. Tippett 1, Adam H. Sobel 2,3 and Suzana J. Camargo 3 1 International Research Institute for Climate and Society, Columbia University, Palisades, NY 2 Department of Applied Physics and Applied Mathematics and Department of Earth and Environmental Sciences, Columbia University, New York, NY 3 Lamont-Doherty Earth Observatory, Columbia University, Palisades, NY

Outline How does climate control tornado activity? – Why this is a hard question. Atmospheric environment and tornadoes – Short time-scales An index relating monthly tornado activity and environment – Derivation – Properties

Motivation: 2011 “Year of the Tornado” April 2011 most U.S. tornadoes any month (753). Previous record May 2003 (542). Previous busiest April 1974 (267). Three of the top five tornado outbreaks on record. Damage estimates = $25 billion, >2X previous record from WeatherUnderground

Climate/tornadoes connection? “Tornado Season Intensifies, Without Clear Scientific Consensus on Why” -- NY Times, April 25, “The co-variability of 20 severe spring (March-May) tornado outbreaks over the contiguous US and phases of the El Niño/Southern Oscillation (ENSO) during the past 100 years presents a complicated picture of the historical relationships.” -- NOAA/ERSL Climate Attribution Rapid Response Team outside the work of Brooks and collaborators…, “Not much research has been done on climate change effects on middle latitude severe weather.” -- Kerry Emanuel

Conditional probabilities P(tornadoes | ENSO)? P(tornadoes | Climate change)? Two approaches Statistical – E[tornadoes | something] = regression Dynamical – Tornadoes in physical model forced by something

The problem with statistical and dynamical approaches “Tornadoes, the deadliest weather disaster to hit the country this year, present a particularly thorny case.” “Tornadoes are small and hard to count, and scientists have little confidence in the accuracy of older data.” “The computer programs they use to analyze and forecast the climate do not do a good job of representing events as small as tornadoes.” Harsh Political Reality Slows Climate Studies Despite Extreme Year -- NY Times 12/25/2011 “Tornadoes are not in the least bit ‘thorny.’”-- Roger Pielke, Jr

Observations

Atmospheric environment and tornadoes: Short time-scales

Useful relation between large-scale environmental parameters and tornado activity on short time-scales April 26, :30Z

1.Can environmental parameters explain tornado activity? 2.What makes one month more active than another? Basic Questions Does the distribution of environmental parameters during a month determine tornado activity? Changes in mean? Changes in spread? ? Easier? Harder?

What are the key environmental parameters? Typical: Instability, updrafts, e.g. CAPE Shear, e.g., 0-6km shear, Storm Relative Helicity (SRH)

Probability of severe thunderstorm with F2 tornado, 5cm hail, or 120 km/h wind gusts Significant severe parameter (Craven and Brooks, 2004) CAPE x 0-6 km Shear > 10,000 m 3 s -3 Figure from Brooks and Dotzek (2008)

NCEP/NCAR 6-h reanalysis environmental parameters near severe thunderstorms (Brooks et al. 2003)

Classification of environments (Brooks et al 2003)

6-hourly reanalysis

(Brooks et al 2003)6-hourly reanalysis

Monthly time-scales Are monthly means of environmental parameters related to monthly tornado activity? Likely to see impact of large-scale climate phenomena in monthly means. Path to extended-range prediction, climate projection.

An index relating monthly tornado activity and environment

Large-scale climate phenomena potentially modulating monthly tornado activity Precipitation (Galway, 1979) Greenhouse gas forcing (Trapp et al., 2007, 2009) ENSO in winter. (Cook & Schaefer, 2008) Antecedent drought (Shepherd et al., 2009) IAS April-May (Muñoz et al., 2011)

Index methodology borrowed from tropical cyclone genesis TC genesis index (Gray 1979). Genesis index = function of the local environment – Monthly values of SST Shear Humidity Vorticity Climatological distributions, interannual variability, climate projections.

(Tippett et al., 2011) Tropical Cyclone Genesis Obs. & Index (annual values)

Apply index methodology to monthly tornado counts Index = exp(constants x environmental parameters) Poisson regression Parameters = CAPE, CIN, lifted index, lapse rate, mixing ratio, SRH, vertical shear, precipitation, convective precipitation and elevation Estimate constants from observed climatology – Same index at all (U.S.) locations, all months of year – NARR data 1x1 degree grid – SPC Tornado, Hail, and Wind Database – All tornadoes (>F0). [F1 and greater gives smaller number, similar sensitivities]

Picking predictors cPrcp cPrcp:SRH

2-parameter indices

Why not CAPE/SRH?

Why not CAPE:SRH?

How well does the index capture climatology?

Log(Expected number of tornadoes)

ObservationsIndex Obs. Index

Observations Index Month of Maximum Activity

Annual cycle

Pattern correlation

Each month fit separately

Does the index capture interannual variability?

US totals JanFebMarAprMayJunJulAugSepOctNovDec Index SRH only cPrcp only Correlation between index and observed number

Conclusions Some association between environmental parameters and tornado activity on monthly time-scales. – Climatological variability – Interannual variability Tornado “index” = potentially useful tool for: – Attributing observed variability – Extended-range prediction – Climate projections