Public outrage grows, governance credibility falls

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
SEC Announces Fraud Charges Against Former Rite Aid Senior Management June 21, 2002.
Advertisements

Business Ethics & Corporate Governance
Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002 UAA – ACCT 316 – Fall 2003 Accounting Information Systems Dr. Fred Barbee.
1 4 th session: Corporate Governance – Sarbanes Oxley Performance Evaluation IMSc in Business Administration October-November 2009.
Corporate Governance Reform Professor Blanaid Clarke Trinity College Dublin Law Reform Commission Annual Conference 11th December 2012.
Enron Corporate Control Presented by: Cary Cheung, Christie Cheung, Rita Chung, Ryan Chan D1: What has the Enron case showed about the problems of corporate.
Corporate Crisis Update Carolyn Hotchkiss and Eli Bortman Babson College Updated September 2005.
1 PRACTISING CORPORATE GOVERNANCE IN HONG KONG Speech to American Chamber of Commerce in Hong Kong, 12 December 2003 By Paul M Y Chow, Chief Executive.
Sarbanes-Oxley Act. 2 What Is It? Act passed by Congress in response to the recent and continuing corporate scandals. Signed into law July 30, Established.
1 Introduction of Panel Members Sarbanes-Oxley Section 404 Overview Insert Worlds Image / Client Specific Image Here Scott Henderson
By Aleksandra Whistle, Rachel Davis and Jie li
Fraud and SOX Compliance McGraw-Hill/Irwin Copyright © 2012 by The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved.
Third ICAC Symposium The New York Stock Exchange – A Regulator and a Listed Company James F. Duffy Executive Vice President & General Counsel NYSE Regulation,
Sarbanes Oxley Act. WHY? Public Company Accounting Reform and Investor Protection Act of 2002 Response to a number of major corporate and accounting scandals.
Robert Libby Patricia A. Libby Daniel G. Short
The Enron Affair EMBA 21 Program, 2003 Prof. L.J. Brooks.
Adam Bearhalter Kristy Kelly Julie Bland Alex Tiset.
© 2004 Ceridian Corporation. All rights reserved. Corporate Integrity and The Sarbanes-Oxley Act Victoria Nemerson Vice President Compliance, Ceridian.
Accounting and Scandals Javier Velez, Eddie Ababio, Michael Burns.
1 Financial Accounting: Tools for Business Decision Making, 4th Ed. Kimmel, Weygandt, Kieso CHAPTER 1 Prepared by Dr. Joseph Otto CSLA.
Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002 Ernesto G. Rodriguez EC 521 Winter 2007.
Sarbanes Oxley Act. WHY? Public Company Accounting Reform and Investor Protection Act of 2002 Public Company Accounting Reform and Investor Protection.
Sarbanes-Oxley Act a.k.a. “SOX”
New York Stock Exchange Enron was a publicly traded company whose shares were listed on the New York Stock Exchange and were bought, held and sold by individuals.
Group 5 Andrew Beamon Brandon Hall Joseph Gasparini Matthew Pugh
The Age of Compliance How Sarbanes-Oxley affects IT management.
ENRON SCANDAL.
ACCOUNTABILITY UPDATE Healthcare Trustees of New York State Audioconference September 22, 2005 Mark Thomas Wilson, Elser, Moskowitz, Edelman & Dicker General.
Copyright © 2008 McGraw-Hill Ryerson Ltd.1 Chapter Twelve Corporate Governance Canadian Business and Society: Ethics & Responsibilities.
The Fall of… Enron and Arthur Andersen ws/specials/enron/
HROFFICE USER CONFERENCE 2005 Creating an Effective Ethics and Compliance Program Ascentis User Group September, 2005.
Financing, Investor Protection And Online Securities Offerings Chapter 21.
Copyright © 2008 by West Legal Studies in Business A Division of Thomson Learning Chapter 46 Securities Regulation Twomey Jennings Anderson’s Business.
2012 Governance & Leadership Institute January 29 – 30, 2012.
Summary of the Investor Protection, Auditor Reform, and Transparency Act of 2002 (Sarbanes-Oxley Act)
FUNDAMENTALS OF CORPORATE FINANCE MGF301 Fall 1998 Vigdis Boasson SUNY at Buffalo
Signed into law on July 30, 2002 Response to highly publicized corporate scandals Provisions affect corporate governance, accounting, and auditing Purpose.
Corporate Governance at CDS Ian A. Gilhooley President and CEO.
COPYRIGHT © 2010 South-Western/Cengage Learning..
1 Today’s Presentation Sarbanes Oxley and Financial Reporting An NSTAR Perspective.
By: 1. Kenneth A. Kim John R. Nofsinger And 2. A. C. Fernando.
Sarbanes Oxley Act. The Sarbanes Oxley Act consists of 11 Sections I – Public Company Accounting Oversight Board II – Auditor independence III – Corporate.
By: 1. Kenneth A. Kim John R. Nofsinger And 2. A. C. Fernando.
New York Stock Exchange Enron was a publicly traded company whose shares were listed on the New York Stock Exchange and were bought, held and sold by individuals.
Communicating and Interpreting Accounting Information Chapter 5 McGraw-Hill/Irwin © 2009 The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc.
1 Sarbanes-Oxley Overview. 2 Sarbanes-Oxley Act Summary The Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002 §201Prohibited Non-Audit Services §202Audit Committee Pre-Approval.
ENRON Enron … took great pains to project an image of being a stalwart and responsible corporate citizen…(it) appeared to have superior internal controls,
Case 2.4 Enron: Quality Assurance
By Abdur Rashid Mirza University of Lahore School of Accountancy and Finance.
ENRON Thomas Clarke. “The company that once held the admiration of the business world, promised the future and envisioned itself to be the world’s leading.
By Brian, Froilan, Lisa, Pedro and Raissa
+ Enron the Unsinkable Ship Nancy Vazquez. + Overview Describe the concept of ‘Creative Accounting’. How the unsinkable ship was sunk to the bottom of.
A brief introduction to ENRON SCANDAL Student name: Olga Balzhinimaeva Student ID: Ma3n0231.
The Fall of… Enron and Arthur Andersen ws/specials/enron/
Sarbanes-Oxley Act a.k.a. “SOX” Georgia CTAE Resource Network Curriculum Office, February 2009 To accompany curriculum for the Georgia Peach State Career.
Building on Our Core Values Building on Our Core Values © 2003 by the AICPA The Sarbanes-Oxley Act.
Enron: 21,000 Arthur Anderson: 29,000 Retirement: $1.2 Billion Pensions: $2 Billion
Sarbanes-Oxley: Its effect on the accounting profession Signed into law on July 30, 2002 Response to highly publicized corporate scandals Provisions affect.
Accounting Seminar 1 Professor: Bonita Daly, PhD Accountancy Office: Room 423 Office Hours: By appointment.
Insurance Summit 2016 REGULATORY UPDATE. Panel Participants Ray Farmer (Director, South Carolina Department of Insurance) Tim Morris (Hanover Stone Solutions)
Impact On Government Contractors
Summary of the Investor Protection, Auditor Reform, and Transparency Act of 2002 (Sarbanes-Oxley Act)
Public outrage grows, governance credibility falls
Value Creation and Successful Management
Public outrage grows, governance credibility falls
ENRON CORPORATION.
Enron Seminar, Spring 2002 Class 2 Enron Before the Fall
Corporate Governance for Mutuals
Chapter 46 SECURITIES REGULATION
Presentation transcript:

Public outrage grows, governance credibility falls FIGURE 2.1 GOVERNANCE REFORM TIMELINE Public outrage grows, governance credibility falls Enron Bankruptcy December 2, 2001 WorldCom Restatement June 25, 2002; Bankruptcy July 21, 2002 SEC Regulations Stock Exchange Guidance Arthur Andersen Court Case Winter/Spring 2002 Sarbanes-Oxley Act Signed July 30, 2002

Enron Corp. (last price N/A) FIGURE 2.2 ENRON STOCK CHART, WEEKLY PRICES, 1997–2002 Enron Corp. (last price N/A) $ 90.00 $ 80.00 $ 70.00 $ 60.00 $ 50.00 $ 40.00 $ 30.00 $ 20.00 $ 10.00 $ 0.00 US Dollars

FIGURE 2.3 ENRON JEDI BARCLAYS BANK CHEWCO PLC Sources CHEWCO FINANCING, IN MILLIONS ENRON KOPPER & DODSON’s Company DODSON Companies $0.125 $11.4 $11.4 Loan* JEDI $132 Revolving Credit BARCLAYS BANK PLC CHEWCO $240 Loan Sources Bank $251.4 Non-cash 132.0 Investors 0.1

TABLE 2.1 ENRON’S KEY SPECIAL PURPOSE ENTITIES (SPEs) SPE SCHEME IMPACT Chewco/JEDI Syndicated investment Off balance sheet liabilities hidden ($628 million) Revenues recognized early Profits on own shares LJM Provided market for assets Artificial profits Off balance sheet liabilities hidden Equity overstated ($1.2 billion) LJM1/Rhythms Investment “hedge” Unrecognized losses ($508 million) LJM2/Raptors Unrecognized losses ($544 million)

TABLE 2.2 PAYMENTS TO FASTOW & HELPERS INVESTMENT RETURN, IN MILLIONS OTHER, IN MILLIONS A. Fastow $25,000 $ 4.5 in 2 mo. $30 + stock options M. Kopper 125,000 10.0 incl. Dodson $2 in fees B. Glisan 5,800 1.0 K. Mordaunt

TABLE 2.3 ENRON WHISTLE-BLOWERS BLEW TO ACTION SUBSEQUENTLY Cliff Baxter, Vice Chair Lay None Exercised $32 million in stock options, just agreed to testify to Congress, found shot dead in his car—an apparent suicide—on Jan. 25, 2002 McMahon, Treasurer Fastow Reassigned, later returned as CEO Kaminski, Risk Mgr. Continued Sherron Watkins Discussed with Skilling and asked Vinson & Elkins to review

TABLE 2.4 ENRON STOCK PROCEEDS, OCTOBER 1998 TO NOVEMBER 2001, OVER $30 MILLION Lou Pai Chairman, Enron Xcelerator $353.7 million Ken Lay Chairman 101.3 Rebecca Mark-Jusbasche Director 79.5 Ken Harrison Director, Portland General Electrics 75.2 Kenneth Rice Chairman, Enron Broadband 72.8 Jeffrey Skilling Director (former CEO) 66.9 Mark Frevert Vice Chairman 50.3 Stanley Horton Global Chairman 45.5 Joseph Sutton 40.1 J. Clifford Baxter 35.2 Joseph Hirco CEO, Enron Broadband Andrew Fastow Chief Financial Officer 30.5 SOURCE: © 2002 The Washington Post. Reprinted with permission.

FIGURE 2.4 ENRON’S GOVERNANCE AND CONTROL STRUCTURE WAS SHORT-CIRCUITED BOARD Outside Law Firm Ken Lay: Chair; Co-Chair ZZZ Committees: Audit and Compliance Compensation, Finance, Nominating Financial Reports SPEs Internal Audit … AA MANAGEMENT CEO: Lay, Skilling CFO: Fastow CAO: Causey CRO: Buy Others: Kopper, McMahon, Glisan Watkins, Kaminsky Whistle-blowers Company Policies Code of Conduct LEGEND Missing Guidance AUDITOR Arthur Andersen Missing Compliance Consultant: Arthur Andersen Suspended Guidance

TABLE 2.5 ENRON’S ACCOMPLICE BANKS’ LAWSUIT SETTLEMENTS $ COMMENT Merrill Lynch 80m March 2003 Fine imposed by the SEC. Four of the Bank’s executives were found guilty of fraud and conspiracy, facing sentences of up to fifteen years in prison (Daniel Bayly, Robert Furst, William Fuhs & James Brown). JPMorgan Chase 2.2bn 135m August 2005. First Enron-related US Bank settlement. The bank denied wrongdoing. August 2003. Fine imposed by the SEC. JPMorgan’s Q2/Q3 profits were $1.83bn. Citigroup 1.7bn 120m June 2005. Citigroup did not admit liability, and said money already set aside for legal costs would cover the payment. August 2003. Fine imposed by the SEC. Citigroup’s Q2/Q3 profits were $4.3bn. Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce 2.8bn June 2005. More than annual profit yr 2005. December 2003. Fine imposed by the SEC. Two CIBC executives also will pay fines totaling $600,000. Toronto Dominion Bank 130m August 2005 Royal Bank of Canada 25m Royal Bank of Scotland 42m Sources: SEC files, newspaper articles and Enron’s website at http://www.enron.com for press releases on Megaclaims settlements.

TABLE 2.6 ENRON KEY EXECUTIVE INDICTMENTS INDICTED BY FOR PLEA/ COOPERATE  RESULT Ken Lay, Chair, Chair and CEO Jul 2004, 2 trials: 1 jury, 1 judge Conspiracy, fraud & false statements Not guilty Guilty in both trials, but died before sentencing, so verdicts vacated Jeffrey Skilling, CEO Feb 2004 Conspiracy, fraud, false statements, insider trading 24 yr, 4 month sentence Restitution $45 million Andrew Fastow, CFO Jan 2004 Securities fraud Plea agreement (guilty)  10 yr sentence, later reduced to 6 yrs, forfeit $23.8 mil Lea Fastow, Assistant Treasurer May 2004 Tax fraud 1yr sentence Richard Causey, CAO Dec 2005 7yr sentence Forfeit $1.25 million Michael Kopper Aug 2002 Fraud and money laundering 37 month sentence Forfeit $12 million Mark Koenig Investor Relations Aug 2004 Plea agreement (guilty)  18 month sentence Forfeit $1.49 million Ben Glisan, Treasurer Dec 2002 Sep 2003 Fraud Fraud Denied wrongdoing, later  5yr sentence,  later brought favors, forfeit $625,000. Kenneth Rice, CEO Broadband Services Apr 2005 Plea agreement (guilty) 10yr sentence Forfeit $29.4 million Kevin Hannon Sep 2005 Guilty 5yr sentence Forfeit $250,000 Timothy Despain Assistant Treasurer Apr 2004 5yr sentence, released on $100,000 bail Enron Board of Directors (18 members) Jan 2005 Breach of Fiduciary Duty Settlement $168 million; $155 million covered by insurance Source: SEC Files, newspaper articles, see also http://www.chron.com/news/specials/enron/ = Cooperates with prosecutors

TABLE 2.7 SELECTED ENRON FINANCIAL STATEMENT DETAILS 2000 1999 1998 Summary Income Statement (millions) Revenues $101,789 $40,112 $31,260 Operating income 1,953 802 1,378 IBIT 2,482 1,995 1,582 Net Income before Cumulative Accounting Changes 979 1,024 703 Net Income 893 EPS (in dollars) - basic 1.22 1.17 1.07 - diluted 1.12 1.10 1.01 Detail of IBIT (millions) Transport & distribution Trans. Services $391 $380 $351 Portland General 341 305 286 Wholesale Services 2,260 1,317 968 Retail Energy Services 165 (68) (119) Broadband Services (60) Exploration & prod. - 65 128 Corporate and other (615) (4) (32) Summary Balance Sheet (billions) Current assets $30.4 $7.3 Investments, other 23.4 15.4 Property, plant, equip, net 11.7 10.7 Total Assets 65.5 33.4 Current liabilities 28.4 6.8 Long-term Debt 8.6 7.2 Deferred credits and other 13.8 6.5 Shareholders’ Equity 11.5 9.6 Total Liabilities & Shareholders’ Equity

TABLE 2.8 KEY CHANGES IN GOVERNANCE GUIDELINES AND REGULATIONS ANNOUNCED SOURCE OF CHANGE 1994 The Dey Report, “Where were the Directors?,” Toronto Stock Exchange To review corporate governance and make recommendations for best practice. 1999 Five Years to the Dey Report on Corporate Governance, Toronto Stock Exchange and The Institute of Corporate Directors To survey and analyze governance procedures at TSE companies. May 2000 The Combined Code: Principles of Good Governance and Principles of Best Practice Based on the Hempel (1998), the Cadbury (1992) and Greenbury Reports (1995), used by companies listed on the London Stock Exchange. 2000 Guidance for Directors on the Combined Code, The Turnbull Report. See Combined Code purpose. Nov. 21, 2001 The Saucier Report, “Beyond Compliance: Building a Governance Culture,” Joint Committee on Corporate Governance, CICA/TSE To review the current state of corporate governance in Canada, compare Canadian and international best practices, and make recommendations for changes that will ensure Canadian corporate governance is among the best in the world. Apr. 26, 2002 Toronto Stock Exchange (TSX) Guidelines Amended Revisions effective Dec.31, 2002 to adopt some Saucier Report recommendations. Apr. 4, 2002 SEC Blue Ribbon Committee Discussions 2002 Various Business Roundtable—various statements June 6, 2002 NYSE Corporate Governance Listing Requirements, Effective Aug. 2002, after SEC approval A review at the request of Harvey Pitt, SEC Chairman, to enhance the accountability, integrity, and transparency of companies listed on the NYSE. June 28, 2002 SEC Order effective Aug, 14, 2002 CEO and CFO to certify 8-K, quarterly and annual financial reports. July 9, 2002 President George Bush’s Proposals Speech Visit the text’s website for links to the organizations’ websites

TABLE 2.9 ORGANIZATION OF THE SARBANES-OXLEY ACT of 2002 SECTIONS TITLE 1, 2, 3 Short Title, Definitions, Table of Contents 101–109 I Public Company Oversight Board 201–209 II Auditor Independence 301–308 301 III Corporate Responsibility Public Company Audit Committees (including whistle-blower encouragement) Corporate Responsibility for Financial Statements (including CEO and CFO certification) 401–409 404 406 IV Enhanced Financial Disclosures Management Assessment of Internal Controls Code of Ethics for Senior Financial Officers 501 V Analyst Conflicts of Interest 601–604 VI Commission Resources and Authority 701–705 VII Studies and Reports 801–807 VIII Corporate Criminal Fraud Accountability 901–906 IX White Collar Crime Penalty Enhancements 1001 X Corporate Tax Returns 1001–1007 XI Corporate Fraud and Accountability