Highlights in the management of breast cancer How to improve the outcome of Triple-Negative Breast Cancer Claudia Bighin IRCSS – AOU S. Martino – IST Genova
«From benchside to bedside»
Bed-side
Dissecting the Heterogeneity of TNBC Metzger-Filho et al, JCO 2012 CK5/6, CK17
Lips et al, BJC % of the TNBC had a BRCA1-like aCGH profile
Good news from earlier stages?
Cheang et al, ASCO 2009
A-based vs CMF according to molecular subgroup (meta-analysis of 4 phase III trials) * 0.67 *Triple negative disease A-based vs CMF HR: % CI P value = 0.13 CMF A-based Di Leo et al, Lancet Oncol 2011
TNBC/Basal-likeHER2 + Luminal BLuminal A Hugh J et al. JCO 2009
Future perspective Joensuu et al, Ann Oncol 2012
SABCS 2012
pCR predicts favourable outcome in TNBC Liedtke C, et al. J Clin Oncol 2008 pCR rates RegimensTNBCNon- TNBC FAC/FEC/AC20%5% TFAC/TFEC28%17% Single agent Taxane 12%2% The Paradox of higher sensitivity to neoadjuvant chemotherapy in poor prognosis subtype (TNBC) is explained by the high relapse among pts with residual disease
TNBC and pCR von Minckwitz et al, JCO 2012
Ongoing neoadjuvant trial von Minckwitz et al, Ann Oncol 2012
Bevacizumab
von Minckwitz et al, NEJM 2012
Bear et al, NEJM 2012
Phase II study: FEC wPaclitaxel + Bevacizumab Clavarezza et al, The Breast 2013 (in press)
ASCO 2013 Breast Cancer Oral Session Abstract #1003 – PrECOG 0105: Final efficacy results from a phase II study of gemcitabine (G) and carboplatin (C) plus iniparib (BSI-201) as neoadjuvant therapy for triple- negative (TN) and BRCA1/2 mutation-associated breast cancer. (Melinda L. Telli) Abstract #1004 – A randomized phase II trial investigating the addition of carboplatin to neoadjuvant therapy for triple- negative and HER2-positive early breast cancer (GeparSixto). (Gunter Von Minckwitz)
Median survival with distant metastases Luminal A: 2.2 yrs Luminal B: 1.6 yrs Luminal/HER2: 1.3 yrs HER2 enriched:0.7 yrs Basal-like:0.5 yrs 3,732 EBC diagnosed between Basal-like treated with adj CT: 48%
TNBC: Annual Hazard Rate of Distant Recurrence Dent R, et al. Clin Cancer Res 2007 Peak of recurrence TN: 1 to 3 years Non-TN: steady risk over time
Foulkes et al, NEJM 2010
Re-biospy?
Cardoso et al, The Breast 2012
TNBC: “…Cytotoxic chemotherapy remains the mainstay of treatment in this group…» Cardoso et al, Ann Oncol 2012
Newly approved drugs in TNBC AgentPhase trialTNBC ptsSettingResults Ixabepilone 1 III433+ CapeSuperior ORR and PFS ORR: 31% vs 15% PFS: 4,2 mo vs 1,7 mo Bevacizumab 2 III (ECOG2100, AVADO, RIBBON) 621+ CTSuperior ORR and PFS ORR: 42% vs 23% PFS: 8,1 mo vs 5,4 mo OS: 18,9 mo vs 17,5 mo Eribulin 3 III144Mono vs TPC Superior OS HR=0,71 1 Rugo, SABCS O'Shaughnessy, ASCO Twelves, ESMO 2010
Targeted therapies
BALI-1 Trial Baselga, SABCS 2010
The difference between the arms was not significant (p=0.11) and the ORR in the cetuximab plus cisplatin arm did not exceed 20% (p=0.50; one-sided Z-test with a significance level of alpha/2=0.05), therefore the simultaneous null hypothesis could not be rejected. Baselga, SABCS 2010
Carey et al, JCO 2012 ORR < 20%
Targeted therapies
Tutt et al, Lancet 2010
O'Shaughnessy et al, NEJM 2011
[TITLE] ORR 30 vs 34% O'Shaughnessy et al, ASCO 2011
[TITLE] O'Shaughnessy et al, ASCO 2011
Chuang et al, BCRT 2012 Olaparib Iniparib
Can we find the Achille heel of TNBC?
Can we sub-classify TNBC? Pietenpol, SABCS 2012
Subtypes Characteristics SubtypeGene OntologyIHC analysis Hysto typePossible sensitivity Basal-like 1Cell cycle and cell division DNA damage response High Ki67--Cisplatin PARP-Inhibitors Basal-like 2Growth gactor signaling (EGFR, MET) --MedullaryAnti-EGFR Immuno- modulatory Immune cell processes-- Mesenchymal- like Cell motility and cell differentation (TGF-β, Src); GF patways -- Metaplastic PI3K-mTOR Inh (BEZ235) Src-Inhibitors (Dasatinib) Mesenchymal Stem-like Angiogenesis Low levels prolif genes Claudin-low --Anti-angio Luminal ARHormonally regulated pathways AR +Molecular Apocrine AR antagonist Lehmann et al, J Clin Inv 2011
TNBC subtypes differ in RFS RFS decreased in LAR subtype compared with BL-1, IM and MSL (p<0,005) Better RFS in BL-1 Lehmann et al, J Clin Inv 2011
Pietenpol, SABCS 2012
Shah et al, Nature 2012
Pietenpol, SABCS 2012
AR positive AR negative
West et al, BMJ 2013
ASCO 2013 Poster Discussion Session Abstract #1010 – Next-generation sequencing to find predictors for chemotherapy response in triple-negative breast cancer (TNBC). (Esther H. Lips) Abstract #1011 – Molecular identification of basal-like breast cancer through genomic analyses across five cancer types. (Aleix Prat) Abstract #1012 – NFKBIA deletion in triple-negative breast cancer. (Markus Bredel)
Aparicio, SABCS 2012
How to improve the outcome of TNBC?...at bedside Adjuvant setting – Anthra plus Taxanes Neoadjuvant setting – Anthra plus Taxanes Metastatic setting – Re-biospy – Bevacizumab – Platinum salts – Eribulin CLINICAL TRIALS!!!