Tropical Cyclone-frontal interactions Lee and Eloise Richard H. Grumm National Weather Service State College PA 16803.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Anticipating Heavy Rainfall: Forecast Aspects By Richard H. Grumm* National Weather Service State College PA and Robert Hart The Pennsylvania State.
Advertisements

Briefing to Premier & Cabinet 18 October Very Wet during 2010.
Michael L. Jurewicz, Sr. WFO Binghamton, NY Northeast Regional Operational Workshop November 5, 2009.
Upcoming Changes in Winter Weather Operations at the Weather Prediction Center (WPC) Great Lakes Operational Meteorological Workshop Dan Petersen, Wallace.
Life on the edge Patterns and Probabilities of heavy rainfall Richard H. Grumm National Weather Service Office State College PA
“A Study of Causes Behind the Heavy Rainfall Amounts From Tropical Storm Allison” Paul Lewis National Weather Service WFO Houston/Galveston Contact information:
Using Standardized Anomalies to Identify Significant Heavy Rain Events Jason Krekeler And Richard H. Grumm National Weather Service State College, PA.
A Compare and Contrast Study of Two Banded Snow Storms Part I – January 6 th, 2002.
Using ensemble data assimilation to investigate the initial condition sensitivity of Western Pacific extratropical transitions Ryan D. Torn University.
Forecast Challenges Associated with the Valentine’s Day, St. Patrick’s Day and Tax Day Nor’easters of 2007 Neil A. Stuart NWS Albany, NY NROW 9.
Chapter 11: Winter Weather Heavy snowfall in St. Louis is typically associated with a developing low pressure system To examine snowfall within a developing.
Frantic About Frances Richard H. Grumm and John LaCorte National Weather Service State College, PA
The Use of Ensemble and Anomaly Data during the May 2006 New England Record Rain Event Neil A. Stuart Richard Grumm Walter Drag NOAA/NWS Albany,
Anomalies and Ensembles as tools to anticipate ice storms Richard Grumm NOAA/NWS State College, PA.
An Examination of the Tropical System – Induced Flooding in Central New York and Northeast Pennsylvania in 2004.
1 Utilizing Standardized Anomalies to Assess Synoptic Scale Weather Events in the Central United States Barbara E. Mayes and Joshua M. Boustead – NWS WFO.
The Blizzard Discussion 1.Summary Discussion a. Medium Range Issues (Days 4-7) b. Short-Range Issues c. Ensemble trends d. Upstream differences.
The March 01/02 Non-Winter Weather Event: Part 1 Michael W. Cammarata Anthony W. Petrolito.
Is the weather in the UK becoming more extreme? Learning Objective: 1)To know the evidence that suggest the UK weather is becoming more extreme 2)To understand.
National Weather Service Hydrometeorological Prediction Center Post-Tropical Cyclone Sandy Rain, Snow, and Inland Wind Impacts David Novak Jim Hoke, Wallace.
Medium Range Forecast - Global System Out To 14 Days Yuejian Zhu Ensemble Team Leader EMC/NCEP/NWS/NOAA Presents for NWP Forecast Training Class March.
Patterns of Historic River Flood Events in the Mid-Atlantic Region Richard H. Grumm NOAA/NWS Weather Forecast Office, State College, Pennsylvania and Charles.
Climatology and Predictability of Cool-Season High Wind Events in the New York City Metropolitan and Surrounding Area Michael Layer School of Marine and.
North Carolina Coastal Lows Rick Neuherz Service Hydrologist NWS Wilmington NC.
Weather Discussion August 30 th through September 1, 2011.
Verification of the Cooperative Institute for Precipitation Systems‘ Analog Guidance Probabilistic Products Chad M. Gravelle and Dr. Charles E. Graves.
David R. Vallee Hydrologist-in-Charge NOAA/NWS/Northeast River Forecast Center Eastern Region Flash Flood Conference.
1 The Historic Ice Storm of January 26-28, OUTLINE Brief review of the stormBrief review of the storm Review of the environment and forcing (Why.
The African Monsoon Recent Evolution and Current Status Include Week-1 and Week-2 Outlooks Update prepared by Climate Prediction Center / NCEP 10 January.
By Christopher Gitro NWS Binghamton, NY.  Flash flooding remains the number 1 weather killer across the US  29 flash flood related fatalities in BGM’s.
Ensemble Forecasting and You The very basics Richard H. Grumm National Weather Service State College PA
Seasonal Atlantic Hurricane Outlooks Dr. Gerald Bell Lead Seasonal Hurricane Forecaster Climate Prediction Center 27 May 2008 Archive of past outlooks.
Numerical Weather Prediction and EPS Products: Severe Weather and Quantitative Precipitation Forecasts Hamza Kabelwa Contributions from Richard H. Grumm.
The African Monsoon Recent Evolution and Current Status Include Week-1 and Week-2 Outlooks Update prepared by Climate Prediction Center / NCEP 7 February.
The African Monsoon Recent Evolution and Current Status Update prepared by Climate Prediction Center / NCEP 20 April 2009 For more information, visit:
Using Ensemble Probability Forecasts And High Resolution Models To Identify Severe Weather Threats Josh Korotky NOAA/NWS, Pittsburgh, PA and Richard H.
Climate Monitoring Branch. Global (Jan-Oct) Land ranked 6 th warmest. Anom.: +0.75˚C (+1.35˚F) WYR: 2007 (+1.02˚C/+1.84˚F) Ocean ranked 10 th warmest.
NOAA, National Weather Service Middle Atlantic River Forecast Center Briefing Monday, June 30, 2014.
1 THE ATLANTIC HURRICANE SEASON SUMMARY – 2009 ANTIGUA AND BARBUDA, THE LEEWARD ISLANDS AND THE BRITISH VIRGIN ISLANDS.
Heavy snow impacted Italy and the Balkans with record snows on both sides of the Adriatic ” of snow fell in 18 hours. Pescocostanzo, Italy – 21 miles.
The African Monsoon Recent Evolution and Current Status Update prepared by Climate Prediction Center / NCEP 07 July 2008 For more information, visit:
Ensemble variability in rainfall forecasts of Hurricane Irene (2011) Molly Smith, Ryan Torn, Kristen Corbosiero, and Philip Pegion NWS Focal Points: Steve.
Northwest European High Summer Climate Variability, the West African Monsoon and the Summer North Atlantic Oscillation Jim Hurrell, NCAR, & Chris Folland,
Model Jumpiness and the Need for Ensembles Richard Grumm National Weather Service Office and Lance Bosart State Univesity of New York at Albany Richard.
The African Monsoon Recent Evolution and Current Status Update prepared by Climate Prediction Center / NCEP 13 April 2009 For more information, visit:
The Record South Carolina Rainfall Event of 3-5 October 2015: NCEP Forecast Suite Success story John LaCorte Richard H. Grumm and Charles Ross National.
NCEP Vision: First Choice – First Alert – Preferred Partner NOAA Hydrometeorological TestBed at the NCEP Hydrometeorological Prediction Center (HPC) Faye.
The African Monsoon Recent Evolution and Current Status Update prepared by Climate Prediction Center / NCEP 6 July 2010 For more information, visit:
North Carolina Climate
Doppler Lidar Winds & Tropical Cyclones Frank D. Marks AOML/Hurricane Research Division 7 February 2007.
Models: General Characteristics Much better in Short Term –Doubling of error about every 2.5 days.
Evolution in identifying High Impact Weather Events since February 1979 Richard H. Grumm National Weather Service State College, PA Contributions:
An Overview of HPC Winter Weather Guidance for Three Warning Criteria Snowfall Events That Occurred During the Winter Season. A Review of the.
NCEP CMC ECMWF MEAN ANA BRIAN A COLLE MINGHUA ZHENG │ EDMUND K. CHANG Applying Fuzzy Clustering Analysis to Assess Uncertainty and Ensemble System Performance.
NOAA, National Weather Service Middle Atlantic River Forecast Center Briefing 1:00PM February 13, 2016 Peter Ahnert
The African Monsoon Recent Evolution and Current Status Update prepared by Climate Prediction Center / NCEP 4 October 2010 For more information, visit:
1 The Asian-Australian Monsoon System: Recent Evolution, Current Status and Prediction Update prepared by Climate Prediction Center / NCEP December 19,
Figures from “The ECMWF Ensemble Prediction System”
The African Monsoon Recent Evolution and Current Status Update prepared by Climate Prediction Center / NCEP 09 November 2009 For more information, visit:
REGIONAL SCALE ENSEMBLE FORECAST OF THE LAKE EFFECT SNOW EVENT OF 7 FEBRUARY 2007 Justin Arnott and Michael Evans NOAA/NWS Binghamton, NY Richard Grumm.
Colorado Flood. Where it rained When it rained.
Heavy Rain Climatology of Upper Michigan Jonathan Banitt National Weather Service Marquette MI.
Crashing the Timeline A Journal of Weather Interpretations and
Stone storm: An adventure golf course is completely swamped by pebbles after a storm surge hit Westward Ho! in North Devon in January 2014.
Hurricane Matthew Anatomy of a Flood
Ensemble variability in rainfall forecasts of Hurricane Irene (2011)
West Virginia Floods June 2016 NROW 2016 Albany NY
Richard Grumm National Weather Service State College PA
28-29 July 2013 Philadelphia Heavy Rainfall Event
Frantic About Frances Richard H. Grumm and John LaCorte
Presentation transcript:

Tropical Cyclone-frontal interactions Lee and Eloise Richard H. Grumm National Weather Service State College PA 16803

Motivation Tropical cyclone Lee brought flooding to northeastern US – Rain fell on heels of previous event – Enduring event frontal to synoptic-like rainfall event – Pattern & rainfall pattern relatively well predicted – Thus rainfall pattern evolution was well predicted Pattern was similar to that associated with Eloise 1975 We can learn from patterns and probabilities

The power of antecedent conditions Irene rainfall August 2011 Then a frontal event ahead of Lee – Not a true PRE – Transitioned with remnants of Lee

Frontal rain to TC Lee Plume Produces T-bone rainfall pattern (A1)

24-hour Rainfall 12Z 4-8 Sept 2011

T-bone rainfall Eloise September 1975 Frontal rains followed by southerly flow with remnant system

The tale of two T-bones 2011 & 1975

Eloise vs Lee Large scale Pattern

Eloise and Lee Pattern and Evolution

Moisture Plume evolution

TC Lee vs Eloise Salient points Similar large scale patterns – Atlantic ridge southern US trough Similar general storm track – And resulting moisture surge – Similar transition frontal to more synoptic rain pattern T-bone rain pattern due to transition – Both were significant flood events

Lee Forecast Issues The pattern was “well predicted” – We will show one example – 12Z 6-8 September frontal  synoptic 6hrs from 0000 UTC 7 September The rainfall was relatively well predicted Or was it…. – The devil is always in the details…and that is a hell of a problem! – Controversial too

Pattern Large scale to Mid-Atlantic end with QPF

GEFS QPF and Prob 75 mm

GFS Total QPF Forecast and errors

Shorter range GFS QPF

NAM Total QPF and Errors

QPF Pattern Looked good details not so good The GFS: – Over predicted the extent of heavy rainfall – And had position errors too far west – Saw this in Irene and the August NJ floods NAM – Too much QPF and clear location errors GEFS – See above so we likely have to over warn to protect those who might actually be affected

Decision to forecasts issues to ponder Uncertainty is not a reason not to act QPFs are not so good when verified over a small region  details are wanting For High Impact Weather we may have to accept that there are fewer wolves then we see, or are forced to see.

Summary Tropical cyclone Lee brought flooding to NE US – The pattern was well predicted – The event spanned days and antecedent conditions likely played role in impacts/flooding – The QPFs looked good but verified not so good The Pattern – was similar to that associated with Eloise 1975 – Similar rainfall T-bone – Similarly both were high impact events We can learn from patterns and probabilities – But may have to accept we know a big event but – We may not know the exact areas to be affect (will we ever?)

High resolution satellite image historic snow and how it was predicted!

Historic October East Coast Winter Storm October record snows Snow from Appalachians into New England Well predicted and nearly ideal pattern – For January! – Though October has February sun angles

Great Pattern and Forecast Forecasting record events – That deviate from climate – Climate is our base state our reference anchor We regress toward the mean – How we decide? Rare events take confidence Pattern and Probabilities  ENSEMBLES – Allow us not to regress toward the mean – They provide the confidence we need.

High probability record event

Classic ECWS pattern and -3to -5C Confidence and probabilities  good decisions

Thinking Fast and Slow Kahneman, D.(2011) – Need good data and confidence to forecast rare events – Not easy to do intuition, experience and reliable data Rare event snow: – Good pattern with supporting anomalies – Ensembles for probabilities and confidence – Result in relatively well forecast historic event!