IREG-4 Conference, Astana 2009 1 PERSPEKTYWY RANKING 2009 Updated Methodological Approach Waldemar Siwiński, President, Perspektywy Education Foundation,

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
IT-university in Kista May 2004 Swedish Program for ICT in Developing Countries Gunnar Landgren Rector IT-university in Kista.
Advertisements

Prof. V.J. Papazoglou on behalf of the Hellenic Quality Assurance Agency for Higher Education (HQAA) ENQA Seminar on Current Trends in the European Quality.
Education and global cities, St. Petersburg, March 2014 Quality of rankings in the spotlight Education and global cities, St. Petersburg, March 2014 Waldemar.
A Brief National Report on Higher Education, Research and Technology In IR Iran Hassan Zohoor Fellow, The Academy of Sciences of IR Iran; Professor and.
National university rankings and the evolution of global rankings Kazimierz Bilanow Managing Director, Perspektywy Education Foundation, Poland How quality.
Activity of Croatian Rector’s Conference Aleksa Bjeliš University of Zagreb 14 January 2005.
Modernization of Educational Process as a Mean to Satisfy the Requirements of Labour-market in the Field of Culture Management.
An Overview of Quality Assurance in the EHEA by Prof. Andreas G. Orphanides President of EURASHE, Rector of European University Cyprus, and Ex-President.
CYPRUS UNIVERSITY OF TECHNOLOGY Internal Evaluation Procedures at CUT Quality Assurance Seminar Organised by the Ministry of Education and Culture and.
National rankings as an integral part of the global university landscape Waldemar Siwiński Vice-President, IREG Observatory President, Perspektywy Education.
The Priority of Research and Doctoral School Nino Zhvania Head of the Quality Assurance Office.
HRK HRK Hochschulrektorenkonferenz 1 Higher Education in Germany Current Status and Challenges German-South African Rectors’ Forum 15 April 2013, Leipzig.
1 GETTING STARTED WITH ASSESSMENT Barbara Pennipede Associate Director of Assessment Office of Planning, Assessment and Research Office of Planning, Assessment.
University of Vienna Rectorate – Office of the Rectorate May 30, 2008 Claudia Kögler University of Vienna, Office of the Rectorate.
CENTRE FOR ENTREPRENEURSHIP AND INNOVATION RESEARCH & APPLICATION (CEIRA) June 2011, Cankaya University CANKAYA UNIVERSITY.
Sharing Best Practice amongst European universities 1 THE ARISTOTLE UNIVERSITY OF THESSALONIKI ISO 9001:2000 and AUTH Research Committee Christina Besta,
College Strategic Plan by Strategic Planning and Quality Assurance Committee.
COLLEGES of ENGINEERING SCIENCES & APPLIED ENGINEERING PROGRAMS ASSESSMENT.
Ranking universities: The CHE Approach Gero Federkeil CHE – Centre for Higher Education Development International Colloquium “Ranking and Research Assessment.
Quality assurance in higher education in Croatia – standards, procedures, results Đurđica Dragojević & Emita Blagdan Agency for Science and Higher Education.
The role of European standards and guidelines for the development of the national system of independent assessment of the quality of higher education Seidakhmetova.
Polish strategy for science in Ukraine and European perspectives REPRESENTATIVE OFFICE OF POLISH ACADEMY OF SCIENCES IN KIEV GEORGES CHARPAK - 90TH ANNIVERSARY.
National Frameworks of Qualifications, and the UK Experience Dr Robin Humphrey Director of Research Postgraduate Training Faculty of Humanities and Social.
The CHE ranking The multi-dimensional way of Ranking Isabel Roessler CHE – Centre for Higher Education Development International Conference “Academic Cooperation.
Tver Branch of MESI The E-xcellence Project Разработчик 1 Irina Tretyakova, Director, Tver Branch of MESI
Ministry of Education and Religious Affairs General Secretariat for Research and Technology EEA Financial Mechanism Research within Priority.
The evaluation of research units at HCERES
Quality Assurance at the University St. Kliment Ohridski Elizabeta Bahtovska National Bologna promoter TEMPUS SCM C-032B06 West Balkan Bologna Promoters.
Sub-theme Three The Self-Assessment Process and Embedding QA into the Life of an Institution by Terry Miosi, Ph.D. UAE Qualification Framework Project.
Assessment of Higher Education Learning Outcomes (AHELO): Update Deborah Roseveare Head, Skills beyond School Division Directorate for Education OECD 31.
PILOT PROJECT: External audit of quality assurance system on HEIs Agency for Science and Higher Education Zagreb, October 2007.
Institutional Evaluation of medical faculties Prof. A. Сheminat Arkhangelsk 2012.
Project:“Support to the Internationalization of Kosova Higher Education System through establishment of the Kosova Students’ Union” Status Quo on Student.
Internet Based Distance Education at the HAS Bratislava, February, 7th-9th
University of Warsaw The Office for Quality of Education 11th of December th of December 2008.
1. 2 Warsaw, 23 September 2011 Plan of presentation 1.The first 10 years 2.Summary Trends 4.Conclusions Introduction Source of data: Perspektywy.
Akkreditierungsrat The German System of Accreditation Franz Börsch Accreditation Council Office SYSTEM OBJECTIVES STANDARDS PROCEDURE.
Gero Federkeil Expert Seminar „Quality Assurance and Accreditation in Lifelong Learning“, Berlin, February 2011 Rankings and Quality Assurance.
MANAGEMENT SYSTEM AND STRUCTURAL ORGANIZATION FOR THE QUALITY ASSURANCE OF SPs ■ Slovak University of Technology in Bratislava ■ Faculty of Civil Engineering.
Recognition: the national centre and the ENIC Network Seminar on the recognition of qualifications Baku, 22 April 2005 Gunnar Vaht Head of the Estonian.
Role of University Rankings in Kazakhstan Prof. Sholpan Kalanova BRATISLAVA 2011.
THE INSTITUTE OF LAW  Speciality “LAW” qualification “LAWYER”  specializations: state law civil law criminal law international law  line.
Access to electronic scientific information: policies, strategies and programmes The Brazilian experience Elenara Chaves Edler de Almeida Brazilian Federal.
AMU DoQuP FINAL REPORT MD, PhD, Associate Professor G.Ahmadov Azerbaijan Medical University Bishkek, April 22, 2015.
Nguyen Cao Dat, MA Cuu Long Univeristy Some practices in branding at Cuu Long University in the age of globalization.
Creating a S.I.M.P.L.E. & Comprehensive Assessment Plan for Residence Life and Housing Dr. Mike Fulford Emory University Student Affairs Assessment Conference.
QUALITY ASSURANCE IN BULGARIAN HIGHER EDUCATION Prof. Anastas Gerdjikov Sofia University March 30, 2012.
POLAND-KRAKOW-FOUNDATION YOUR DESTINATION SCOUT Project, 1 st Partnership Meeting, Konya, Nov 2013 BRAŃKA SEBASTIAN FOUNDATION OF UNIVERSITY OF ECONOMICS.
Columbia University School of Engineering and Applied Science Review and Planning Process Fall 1998.
1 FIRST STAGE OF THE HIGHER EDUCATION REFORM IN CROATIA – TASKS OF AUTHORISED BODIES.
Overview of the Self Study Presented to NAQAAE Review Team November 7 th, 2010 November 7 th, 2010.
HISTORY With the establishment of Karabük University at 2007, Graduate School of Natural and Applied Sciences has started its education life with 8 graduate.
Quality Assurance System in Higher Education Institutions(HEIs) Professor Dr Mesbahuddin Ahmed Head of Quality Assurance Unit UGC, Bangladesh.
University of Warsaw. The quality of education assurance and enhancement system at the University of Warsaw.
30/10/2006 University Leaders Meeting 1 Student Assessment: A Mandatory Requirement For Accreditation Dr. Salwa El-Magoli Chair-Person National Quality.
Jagiellonian University - Towards Internationalization , Nis Anna Stadnicka.
Internal Quality Assurance System in Armenian HEIs Tempus JEP “ARMQA” Dr. Prof. Alexander Markarov Deputy Vice Rector, YSU
Quality Assurance in Higher Education
RE:LOD ISRAEL National Union of Israeli Students
Department of Political Science & Sociology North South University
Rhetoric Programmes in Saudi Universities: Movements of change
Gunnar Vaht Head of the Estonian ENIC/NARI Baku, 2017
Senior project leader at CIEP Former President of ENQA
Introduction to the training
Human resource and Work flow of the Research Office, RUPP
Polish Higher Education
Istanbul University, Department of Economics BEYAZIT-FATIH ISTANBUL
Internal and External Quality Assurance Systems for Cycle 3 (Doctoral) programmes "PROMOTING INTERNATIONALIZATION OF RESEARCH THROUGH ESTABLISHMENT AND.
Indicators&Criteria in External Quality Assessment
Faculty performance for Institutional achievement
Presentation transcript:

IREG-4 Conference, Astana PERSPEKTYWY RANKING 2009 Updated Methodological Approach Waldemar Siwiński, President, Perspektywy Education Foundation, Poland Mapping of academic excellence

PERSPEKTYWY RANKING Mapping of academic excellence IREG-4 Conference, Astana PLAN of presentation  Perspektywy Education Foundation.  Perspektywy university Ranking – basic facts:  target group,  changes in Polish HE system,  criteria of Ranking  Methodology evolution  Ranking credibility:  consultation,  presentation.  Summary.

PERSPEKTYWY RANKING Mapping of academic excellence IREG-4 Conference, Astana  private, non-profit organization,  IREG Secretariat,  promotes Polish HE abroad program Study in Poland,  organizes conferences and seminars on education,  prepares and publishes rankings,  Member of Academic Cooperation Association  established to support HE in Poland. Perspektywy Education Foundation:

PERSPEKTYWY RANKING Mapping of academic excellence IREG-4 Conference, Astana The Foundation in cooperation with the Conference of Rectors of Academic Schools in Poland runs a multi- year program “Study in Poland” promoting Polish universities abroad. Perspektywy Education Foundation:

PERSPEKTYWY RANKING Mapping of academic excellence IREG-4 Conference, Astana  The beginnings of the Perspektywy rankings go back to Since then Perspektywy have published over 40 rankings:  at first these were rankings of secondary schools – because of baby-boom period,  then rankings of universities and MBA studies.  The university ranking in Poland prepared by the Perspektywy Foundation annually since  Published by the monthly magazine Perspektywy and the national daily newspaper Rzeczpospolita.  The only ranking in Poland published continuously every year. Perspektywy Ranking History

PERSPEKTYWY RANKING Mapping of academic excellence IREG-4 Conference, Astana Prospective students - target group Warsaw University Information Day

PERSPEKTYWY RANKING Mapping of academic excellence IREG-4 Conference, Astana Changes in Polish HE system  Number of HEIs increased by 175% in past decade.  Growth of private HEIs sector.  In 2009: 139 public and 322 private HEIs.

PERSPEKTYWY RANKING Mapping of academic excellence IREG-4 Conference, Astana Changes in Polish HE system Baby-boom students wave.

PERSPEKTYWY RANKING Mapping of academic excellence IREG-4 Conference, Astana What is ranking?  RANKING IS INFORMATION ARRANGED IN ORDER information about: universities, faculties and programs sorted and arranged to serve those who seek such information:  high school graduates (and their parents) looking for college or university,  academics who want to compare its own faculty with other in the field,  politicians searching for tools to best (let’s hope!) allocate financial recourses.

PERSPEKTYWY RANKING Mapping of academic excellence IREG-4 Conference, Astana Two subjective factors?  Depending on the purpose of a ranking there always are two subjective elements present: CRITERIA and their PERCENTAGE WEIGHT.  All other factors can be objective and standardized: methodology of measuring, data verification, mode of presentation, but the selection of criteria and their weight will always remain subjective.

PERSPEKTYWY RANKING Mapping of academic excellence IREG-4 Conference, Astana Kapitula – Supervisory Board  Chairman: Prof. Marek Safjan, f. President of the Constitutional Tribunal, appointed Member, European Court of Justice.  Members:  Prof. Marek Rocki, Senator, President of the State Accreditation Committee,  Prof. Tadeusz Tołłoczko, f. Rector of the Warsaw Medical University,  Waldemar Siwiński, President of the Perspektywy Education Foundation, f. President of the Polish Press Agency,  Włodzimierz Kiciński, President, Nordea Bank Polska S.A.,  Dr Grzegorz Wójtowicz, f. Persident of the National Bank of Poland,  Piotr Gabryel, Deputy Editor-in-Chief, “Rzeczpospolita”,  Dr Jan Sadlak, Director, UNESCO-CEPES,  Prof. Joanicjusz Nazarko, f. Rector, Bialystock Technical University,  Dr Jan Krzysztof Frąckowiak, Director, Polish Science Contact Agency “PolSCA” in Brussels,  Dr Jerzy Głuszczyński, Vice President, PENTOR Research International.

PERSPEKTYWY RANKING Mapping of academic excellence IREG-4 Conference, Astana PRESTIGE - 30%  Peer review (14%).  Employers’ reputation (14%).  Olympians’ preferences (2%). SCIENTIFIC STRENGHT - 40%  Scientific potential (8%).  Scientific titles awarded (8%).  Growth of HEI’s own faculty (8%).  Saturation with the staff with highest qualifications (4%).  Rights to award scientific degrees (4%).  Breadth of teaching offer (4%).  Publications (2%).  Citations (2%).  Doctoral programs (2%).  Accreditation (1%).  Research projects (1%).

PERSPEKTYWY RANKING Mapping of academic excellence IREG-4 Conference, Astana STUDYING ENVIRONMENT - 15%  Student / staff ratio (6%).  Printed Library stock (2%).  Electronic collection (2%).  Cultural opportunities (1%).  Sport achievements (1%).  Facilities for out of town students (1%).  Individual development opportunities (2%). INTERNATIONALIZATION - 15%  Students’ mobility in & outbound (5%).  Programs taught in a foreign language (4%).  Students studying in a foreign language (3%).  Multicultural composition of student body (1%).  Courses given in foreign languages (0,5%).  Foreign teaching staff (1%).  Summer schools (0,5%).

PERSPEKTYWY RANKING Mapping of academic excellence IREG-4 Conference, Astana

PERSPEKTYWY RANKING Mapping of academic excellence IREG-4 Conference, Astana Foreign students in Poland

PERSPEKTYWY RANKING Mapping of academic excellence IREG-4 Conference, Astana Year 2000: 15 criteria in 3 groups. Year 2009: 29 criteria in 4 groups.

PERSPEKTYWY RANKING Mapping of academic excellence IREG-4 Conference, Astana  Supervisory Board receives proposals to introduced new criteria.  Stabilization of the main group of criteria.  Changes of the system reflects changes in the world.  Implementing sources not available few years ago (database). New Criteria (Planned)

PERSPEKTYWY RANKING Mapping of academic excellence IREG-4 Conference, Astana New Criteria (Planned)  Introduction of „Innovation”, as a new group, with new criteria:  technoparks,  sturtups,  patents...  Modified criteria within the existed group f.e.:  increased weight of „citations” in „Scientific strength”,  „research centers”.

PERSPEKTYWY RANKING Mapping of academic excellence IREG-4 Conference, Astana Technoparks in Poland Wrocław Technopark

PERSPEKTYWY RANKING Mapping of academic excellence IREG-4 Conference, Astana  We know how to make rankings; the key-question now is how to gain credibility and acceptance within the:  academic society,  policy makers.  Ranking can act as an important factor in improving quality of the higher education.  Ranking Credibility

PERSPEKTYWY RANKING Mapping of academic excellence IREG-4 Conference, Astana  Presentation of results is equally important as results themselves.  Interactive presentation of results on the Internet.   Front-pages of monthly magazine Perspektywy presenting rankings since

PERSPEKTYWY RANKING Mapping of academic excellence IREG-4 Conference, Astana Gaining Credibility Data collected primarily from sources independent from the ranked HEIs, include:  Quantitative and Qualitative Survey conducted by the Perspektywy,  Survey of employers conducted by PENTOR International SA,  SCOPUS abstract and citation base,  report on HEIs published by the Statistical Office,  data available at the Ministry of Science and Higher Education.

PERSPEKTYWY RANKING Mapping of academic excellence IREG-4 Conference, Astana Maintaining credibility Consultations with academic community:  independent Supervisory Board of Ranking Kapituła,  collaboration with Conference of Rectors,  ongoing contacts with universities,  seminars for HEIs,  being flexible but sticking to principles.

PERSPEKTYWY RANKING Mapping of academic excellence IREG-4 Conference, Astana  Multidimensional, detailed presentation of ranked universities in Perspektywy magazine. „Publications” and „citations”.

PERSPEKTYWY RANKING Mapping of academic excellence IREG-4 Conference, Astana  Multidimensional, detailed presentation of ranked universities in Perspektywy magazine. „Internationalization”.

PERSPEKTYWY RANKING Mapping of academic excellence IREG-4 Conference, Astana Award giving ceremony 2000.

PERSPEKTYWY RANKING Mapping of academic excellence IREG-4 Conference, Astana Broad presentation of results Winner of 2004 ranking, prof. Barbara Kudrycka, rector of the MBA college. Ceremony 2007: prof. Barbara Kurdrycka, the Minister of High Education awards best HEIs.

PERSPEKTYWY RANKING Mapping of academic excellence IREG-4 Conference, Astana  Rankings belong to the group of tools – not unlike accreditation and benchmarking, used to improve the quality of higher education. “The outcomes of the Perspektywy University Ranking fully correspond with the results of accreditation process carried by the State Accreditation Committee. In fact the ranking provides even a fuller picture of universities, since it takes into account more factors and indicators, and analyze them deeper. Rankings, updated annually, are also more actual.” Prof. Marek Rocki, the head of the State Accreditation Committee Ranking Credibility

PERSPEKTYWY RANKING Mapping of academic excellence IREG-4 Conference, Astana Conclusions  Today everything gets ranked.  Instead of applauding the only winner – let’s look for strong and weak sides of various universities.  Rankings offer an important tool for improving the quality of Higher Education.

PERSPEKTYWY RANKING Mapping of academic excellence IREG-4 Conference, Astana Conclusions  Today everything gets ranked.  Instead of applauding the only winner – let’s look for strong and weak sides of various universities.  Rankings offer an important tool for improving the quality of Higher Education.  It is critical how, and in what way, rankings are published and presented to the public.

PERSPEKTYWY RANKING Mapping of academic excellence IREG-4 Conference, Astana Thank you for attention Waldemar Siwiński