Meeting Purpose Otter Tail Power Company Profile Attachment O Calculation Capital Projects Question/Answer 2.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
CLECO TRANSMISSION RATE CASE. AGENDA Welcome and Introduction Purpose of Meeting Transmission System Update Formula Rate Overview Formula Rate Protocols.
Advertisements

October 30, 2014 Terry Wolf, Manager of Transmission Services.
1 TRANSMISSION FORMULA RATE ANNUAL TRUE-UP CUSTOMER MEETING June 24, 2014.
Transmission Formula Rate Annual True-Up Customer Meeting
1 Northern States Power Companies (NSP-MN & NSP-WI) Transmission Customer Meeting June 30, 2015 Rate Discussion: Attachment O Actual Costs 2014.
1 Northern States Power Companies (NSP-MN & NSP-WI) Transmission Customer Meeting October 14, 2014 Rate Discussion: Attachment O, GG & MM.
Great River Energy 2015 Attachment O Annual Projected Rate Meeting October 31, 2014.
Great River Energy 2013 Annual True-Up Meeting August 7, 2014.
Great River Energy 2014 Annual True-Up Meeting Todd Butkowski.
2014 Attachment O True-Up Customer Meeting August 25, 2015.
August 28, ATTACHMENT O TRUE-UP CUSTOMER MEETING.
VisTaTech Center Schoolcraft College September 14, 2006 Partners in Business Meeting 2007 Attachment O.
August 21, 2015 Terry Wolf, Manager of Transmission Services.
1 Westar Energy’s 2013 Annual Transmission Revenue Requirement Meeting October 30, 2012.
2011 Transmission Customer Meeting October 12, 2011.
October 23, 2015 Rochester Public Utilities Presentation on Formula Development of Transmission Revenue Requirements for 2016.
2016 ATTACHMENT O CUSTOMER MEETING OCTOBER 30, 2015.
1 Northern States Power Companies (NSP-MN & NSP-WI) Transmission Customer Meeting October 27, 2015 Rate Discussion: Attachment O, GG & MM.
1 Westar Energy’s 2013 Annual Transmission Revenue Requirement True-Up Meeting Westar Energy’s 2013 Annual Transmission Revenue Requirement True-Up Meeting.
August 22, 2014 Terry Wolf, Manager of Transmission Services.
1 Westar Energy’s 2016 Annual Transmission Revenue Requirement Customer Meeting October 27, 2015 Westar Energy’s Professional Development Center Topeka,
1 Westar Energy’s 2012 Annual Transmission Revenue Requirement Meeting October 25, 2011.
Willmar Municipal Utilities Annual Rate Update Meeting Wesley Hompe P.E. General Manager Friday, August 15,
November 16, 2012 Terry Wolf, Manager of Transmission Services.
2013 Annual True-Up Meeting
Rochester Public Utilities Presentation on Formula Development of Transmission Revenue Requirements for 2016 October 23, 2015.
Transmission Formula Rate Annual True-Up Customer Meeting
2016 Annual Attachment O Stakeholder Meeting Ameren Missouri
2016 Projected Attachment O-PPI Open Stakeholder Meeting
Northern States Power Companies (NSP-MN & NSP-WI)
2015 Attachment O True-up Customer Meeting
Northern States Power Companies (NSP-MN & NSP-WI)
Missouri River Energy Services
Westar Energy’s 2012 Annual Transmission Revenue Requirement
Northern States Power Companies (NSP-MN & NSP-WI)
Northern States Power Companies (NSP-MN & NSP-WI)
Northern States Power Companies (NSP-MN & NSP-WI)
Northern States Power Companies (NSP-MN & NSP-WI)
Rochester Public Utilities Presentation on Formula Development of Transmission Revenue Requirements for 2016 October 23, 2015.
Rochester Public Utilities Presentation on Forward-Looking Transmission Revenue Requirements Update for Calendar 2017 October 28, 2016.
Missouri River Energy Services
Missouri River Energy Services
2017 Attachment O Projection Stakeholder Meeting
2015 Attachment O True-up Customer Meeting
2016 Attachment O True-Up Stakeholder Meeting
Northern States Power Companies (NSPM & NSPW)
Missouri River Energy Services
2018 Attachment O Projection Stakeholder Meeting
2018 Attachment O Projection Stakeholder Meeting
2014 Annual Attachment O Stakeholder Meeting Ameren Missouri
Northern States Power Companies (NSP-MN & NSP-WI)
Northern States Power Companies (NSP-MN & NSP-WI)
2019 Attachment O customer meeting
2017 Attachment O Customer Meeting
2018 Attachment O customer meeting
2017 Attachment O Projection Stakeholder Meeting
Rochester Public Utilities Presentation on Forward-Looking Transmission Revenue Requirements Update for Calendar 2018 October 20, 2017.
2016 Attachment O True-Up Stakeholder Meeting Ameren Illinois Company
2016 Attachment O True-up customer meeting
2017 Attachment O True-Up Stakeholder Meeting
Rochester Public Utilities Presentation on Forward-Looking Transmission Revenue Requirements Update for Calendar 2019 October 17, 2018.
Transmission Formula Rate Annual True-Up Customer Meeting
2017 Annual Attachment O Stakeholder Meeting Ameren Missouri
2019 Attachment O Projection Stakeholder Meeting
2017 Attachment O True-Up Stakeholder Meeting Ameren Illinois Company
Northern States Power Companies (NSP-MN & NSP-WI)
2019 Attachment O Projection Stakeholder Meeting
2017 Attachment O True-up customer meeting
2018 Annual Attachment O Stakeholder Meeting Ameren Missouri
Southwestern Public Service Company
Presentation transcript:

Meeting Purpose Otter Tail Power Company Profile Attachment O Calculation Capital Projects Question/Answer 2

To provide an informational forum regarding Otter Tail’s 2013 Attachment O for True-up. The 2013 Actual Year Attachment O is calculated using the FERC Form 1 Attachment O template under the MISO Tariff utilizing actual data as reported in the 2013 FERC Form 1 for Otter Tail Power. Any True-up for 2013 will be included in the 2015 FLTY Attachment O Calculation for rates effective January 1, 2015 for the joint pricing zone comprised of Otter Tail, Great River Energy, and Missouri River Energy Services. 3

4

Actual Year Rate Requirements Rate Base Operating Expenses Revenue Requirement and Rate Network Rate Summary 5

By June 1 of each year, Otter Tail will post on OASIS all information regarding any Attachment O True-up Adjustments for the prior year. By September 1, 2014, and September 1 all years thereafter, Otter Tail will hold a customer meeting to explain its Actual Year True-up Calculation. Ex., 2013 Forward Looking Attachment O will be trued-up by June 1, 2014 with a corresponding Customer Meeting being held by September 1, Beginning Sept. 1, 2010 and Sept. 1 all years thereafter, Otter Tail will post on OASIS its projected Net Revenue Requirement,including the True- Up Adjustment and load for the following year, and associated work papers. Beginning in 2010 and each year thereafter, Otter Tail will hold a customer meeting by October 31, to explain its formula rate input projections and cost detail. Beginning in 2014 and each year thereafter, the MISO Transmission Owners will hold a Regional Cost Sharing stakeholder meeting by November 1. 6

Note: The above numbers are Transmission only Rate Base Item 2013 Actual 2013 Projected $ Change % Change Explanation Gross Plant in Service $275,626,777$287,571,748$(11,944,971)(4.2%) The decrease in Plant in Service from Projected to Actual was due to a combination of the Bemidji CAPX project going into service at less than expected capitalized cost as well as the delayed in-service of various line segments on the Bookings and Fargo CAPX projects Accumulated Depreciation $102,362,268$102,744,252$(381,984)(0.4%) Net result of Annual Depreciation Expense combined with projected retirements. Net Plant in Service $173,264,509$184,827,496$(11,562,987)(6.3%) = Gross Plant - A/D Adjustments to Rate Base $(42,727,177)$(44,023,296)$1,296,119(2.9%) ADIT - Book vs Tax Depreciation Timing Differences originating due to accelerated tax depreciation methods such as Bonus depreciation and MACRS tables created when large Transmission (i.e., Fargo Phase II and Fargo Phase III) projects go into service. CWIP for CON Projects $47,702,021$53,482,317$(5,780,296)(10.8%) Reduced spend on Fargo CAPX project in late 2012 due to delays associated with material deliveries that carried forward through All is expected to be timing in nature. Land Held for Future Use $9,037$9,038$(1)0.0% Working Capital $5,359,241$5,830,055$(470,814)(8.1%) Decrease in CWC due to drop in Transmission- related O&M which is discussed on the next tab. Rate Base $183,607,631$200,125,610$(16,517,979)(8.3%) = Net Plant + Adj + CWIP + Land + Working Capital 7

8 Note: The above numbers are Transmission only Expense Item 2013 Actual 2013 Projected $ Change% ChangeExplanation O&M $12,766,870$15,223,429 $(2,456,559)(16.1%) Total Company 2013 Actual O&M for Transmission expense decreased by ~$540K or only about 3% compared to the reported amounts used in the Forward Looking Test Year (FLTY). However, the amounts related to MISO 26/26A and Schedule 10 charges actually went up ~$1.75M which increased the amount removed from O&M’s on Attachment O. Depreciation Expense $5,785,772$5,923,798$(138,026)(2.3%) Decrease in depreciation expense coincides with the reduction in expected Plant in Service reported on the previous slide. Taxes Other than Income $2,173,165$2,373,190$(200,025)(8.4%) Property Tax Assessments came in lower than expected and a lower GP allocator are driving the decrease in transmission-related property tax allocations calculated on Attachment O. Income Taxes $7,144,939$7,933,216$(788,277)(9.9%) Decrease in Rate Base = Decrease in Return = Decrease in Income Tax Expense; Also, 2013 had a lower ETR than at the time the FLTY calculation was completed as the ND State Tax rate has been lowered from 5.15% to 4.53%. Operating Expense $27,870,746$31,453,633$(3,582,887)(11.4%) = O&M + A&G + Depreciation + Taxes

2013 Actual 2013 Projected $ Change% ChangeExplanation Long Term Debt 46.48%46.17% 0.31% Tracking close to forecast. Common Stock 53.52%53.83% (0.31%) Tracking close to forecast. Total % = Debt + Equity Weighted Cost of Debt 5.49%5.73% (0.24%) Refinanced slightly more outstanding debt at a lower rate than originally expected. Cost of Common Stock 12.38% 0.00% Unchanged Rate of Return 9.18%9.31% (0.13%) = (LTD*Cost)+(Preferred Stock*Cost)+(Common Stock*Cost) Rate Base $183,607,631$200,125,610$(16,517,979)(8.25%) From "Rate Base" Calculation Allowed Return $16, $18,629,007$(1,778,695)(9.55%) = Rate of Return * Rate Base Operating Expenses $27,870,746$31,453,633$(3,582,887)(11.39%) From "Operating Expense" Calculation Attachment GG Adjustments $10,937,462$13,142,264$(2,204,802)(16.78%) As with the discussion associated with the change in CWIP on Attachment O, GG projects have spent less to date than expected due to delays in material deliveries which also leads to less than expected revenue requirements. Attachment MM Adjustments $2,377,316$3,007,552$(630,236)(20.96%) As with the discussion associated with the change in CWIP on Attachment O, MM projects have spent less to date than expected which leads to lower than expected revenue requirements. Gross Revenue Requirement $31,406,280$33,932,824$(2,526,544)(7.45%) = Return + Expenses - Adjustments Revenue Credits $4,566,650$7,328,404$(2,771,754)-37.82% 2013 Actual Year Other MISO Schedule revenue as well as ITA contractual payments were less than projected True-up (Including Interest) $(4,159,423) -0.00% N/A Net Revenue Requirement $22,690,207$22,444,998$245, % = Gross Revenue Requirement - Revenue Credits + True-up 9

Attachment O True-up Calculation 2013 Actual 2013 Projected $ Change% ChangeExplanation ATRR True-up $245,210 From “Net Revenue Requirement” line on previous slide. Divisor $704,697$670,317$(34,380)(5.13%) From FERC Form 1 Projected Cost ($/kW/Yr) $ From 2013 FLTY Attachment O Template Divisor True-up $(1,151,185) = Divisor x Projected Cost ($/kW/Yr) Total Principal True-up $(905,975) = ATRR + Divisor True-up Amounts Interest on True-up $(59,508) = Avg Monthly FERC Interest Rate on Refunds x Principal True-up Total Principal and Interest True-up $(965,483) To be Applied to 2015 FLTY Attachment O Calculation 10

11 $0.11 or 3.9% Decrease

Total Rev. Req. = $36,004,985 Net Attch. O ATRR = $22,690,207 Attch. GG Rev. Req. = $10,937,462 Attch. MM Rev. Req. = $2,

13

14 Project Forecasted 2013 Capital Addition Actual 2013 Capital Addition $ Change % Variance Reason for Variance Circuit Breaker Replacements $300,000$342,593$42, % Project scope changed to include 5 breaker replacements rather than 4 Rejected Pole Replacements$400,000$415,960$15,9604.0% Tracking close to forecast Jamestown – Edgeley – Oakes Line Rebuild $500,000$202,273($297,727)(59.5%) Reliability concerns addressed by a lower cost plan Parshall Area 115 kV Source$600,000$5,348($594,652)(99.1%) Project delayed due to negotiations with third party Summit 115/41.6 kV Transformer Replacement $1,000,000$619,717($380,283)(37.8%) Material costs were lower than expected Transmission Line Capacity Upgrades $5,000,000$2,452,216($2,547,784)(51.0%) Engineering has delayed the initiation of expected construction activities Oakes Area Transmission Improvements $5,637,004$455,650($5,181,354)(91.9%) Project delayed due to budget constraints

15 Project Forecasted 2013 Capital Addition Actual 2013 Capital Addition $ Change % Variance Reason for Variance Attachment GG Buffalo – Casselton 115 kV Line $7,506,464$3,326,581($4,179,883)(55.7%) Underlying improvements delayed until 2014 and 2015 Fargo – St. Cloud 345 kV Line $20,683,120$27,077,796 $6,394, % Material deliveries accelerated during 2013 Attachment MM Brookings – Hampton Line$11,587,249$10,493,282($1,093,967)(9.4%) Weather impacted expected project schedule. Big Stone South – Brookings Line $1,562,040$581,900($980,140)(62.7%) Project development activities did not occur as quickly as forecasted Big Stone South – Ellendale Line $3,865,059$2,420,133($1,444,924)(37.4%) Project development activities did not occur as quickly as forecasted

16 If you have any additional questions after the meeting, please submit via to: Kyle Sem, CPA Manager – Business Planning All questions and answers will be distributed by to all attendees. Additionally, the questions and answers will be posted on Otter Tail’s OASIS website ( within two weeks from the date of inquiry.