1 September 2003 IEEE 802.17 Draft 2.5 OAM Comment Resolution Las Vegas, NV - September 2003 Section Editor: Glenn Parsons Technical Editors: Leon Bruckman,

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Session # Maintenance Task Group Closing Plenary Report IEEE Presentation Submission Template (Rev. 9) Document Number: IEEE maint-11/0031.
Advertisements

Bob SultanMay 9, 2002IEEE RPRWG IEEE Resilient Packet Ring Draft D0.2 Section 1 Comment Resolution May, 2002 Ottawa, Canada
IEEE MEDIA INDEPENDENT HANDOVER DCN: REVP m-session-64-closing-report Title: m Session #64 Closing Report Date Submitted:
Harry Peng 1May, 2003 P802.17D2.1 CRG PHY CRG Report May Montreal, Quebec Harry Peng: technical editor Rhett Brikovskis: section editor.
Yang Shi, Chris Elliott, Yong Zhang IETF 73 rd 18 Nov 2008, Minneapolis CAPWAP WG MIB Drafts Report.
Session # Maintenance Task Group Closing Plenary Report IEEE Presentation Submission Template (Rev. 9) Document Number: IEEE maint-11/0015r1.
Topology/Protection Comment Resolution Summary Jason Fan, Section Editor Jim Kao, Technical Editor
1 IEEE MEDIA INDEPENDENT HANDOVER DCN: Title: , Session #21, Big Island Closing Plenary Date Submitted: September, 2007.
Editor_Report IEEE MEDIA INDEPENDENT HANDOVER DCN: Editor_Report Title: Editor Report Date Submitted: March.
Session # Maintenance Task Group Closing Plenary Report IEEE Presentation Submission Template (Rev. 9) Document Number: IEEE maint-11/0019.
Submission doc.: IEEE /439r0July 2002 Mika Kasslin, NokiaSlide 1 IEEE Liaison Report Mika Kasslin liaison to
Doc.: IEEE /296r1 SubmissionMitch Buchman May 2001 Slide 1 TGi Draft 1Clause Comments IEEE P802.11E Security/D1.0 Letter Ballot# 25.
PHYDate may 2002 PHY Comment Resolution Summary Clause 7 –Technical binding 1 –Technical non-binding17 –Editorial10 –Total 28 Annex B –Technical.
Doc.: IEEE /0054r0 Submission March 2013 Mika Kasslin, NokiaSlide 1 TG1 Closing Report for March 2013 Notice: This document has been prepared.
7/27/2004IETF San-Diego Plenary meeting 8/2004 EPON MIBs Lior Khermosh – Passave Technologies
1 IEEE MEDIA INDEPENDENT HANDOVER DCN: Title: , Session #20, Montreal Closing Plenary Date Submitted: May, 2007 Presented.
July 2007 CAPWAP Protocol Specification Editors' Report July 2007
802.16m Closing Report September 16, 2010 St. Petersburg, Russia Session # IEEE m-10/0030r1.
Doc.: IEEE /xxxxr0 Submission July 2007 Terry Cole, AMDSlide Common Editorial Comment Resolution Process Date: Authors:
Session # Maintenance Task Group Opening Slides IEEE Presentation Submission Template (Rev. 9) Document Number: IEEE maint-11/0017r1.
Doc.: IEEE /0160r0 Submission March 2004 Dr. John R. Barr, MotorolaSlide 1 Project: IEEE Working Group for Wireless Personal Area Networks.
16 January ???1 Section 2 (MAC) CRG Summary John Lemon Steve Wood David James.
CDB Chris Bonatti (IECA, Inc.) Tel: (+1) Proposed PKI4IPSEC Certificate Management Requirements Document IETF #61 – PKI4IPSEC Working.
Doc.: IEEE /0034r0 Submission January 2004 Dr. John R. Barr, MotorolaSlide 1 Project: IEEE Working Group for Wireless Personal Area Networks.
Session # Maintenance Task Group Opening Report IEEE Presentation Submission Template (Rev. 9) Document Number: IEEE maint-11/0020.
IEEE MEDIA INDEPENDENT HANDOVER DCN:
nnnnn, iii_xxxxx_vv Section 2 Comment Resolution Summary Jim Mollenauer Steve Wood Dave Meyer Med Belhadj May 9, nnnnn, iii_xxxxx_vv.
TG 1 March Session Closing Report
Submission Title: [LB 28 Results] Date Submitted: [14 March 2005]
Project: IEEE P Working Group for Wireless Personal Area Networks (WPANs) Submission Title: Proposed resolution of ESOR comments from LB53 (the easy.
IEEE MEDIA INDEPENDENT HANDOVER
Atlanta Jan 2003 PHY Comment Resolution Harry Peng
Submission Title: Sydney e/ Liaison Report.
Jan 14, 2010 La Jolla, CA Session #65
TGd Agenda March 2000 Meeting Albuquerque, NM March 2000
P b Status Sponsor balloting completed:
Matthew B. Shoemake Task Group G Chairperson November 15, 2002
Layer Management and MIBs Sections Report
Motions Date: Authors: January 2006
Reconsidering RA-OLSR
IEEE MEDIA INDEPENDENT HANDOVER
July 2002 Project: IEEE P Working Group for Wireless Local Area Networks (WLANs) Submission Title: Liaison Report, July 2002 Date Submitted:
Submission Title: [Draft Standard Overview]
Summary of Unresolved General Comments for 2/14 TGs Telecon
TGi Final Report for the September 2002 Session
Executive Committee Meeting
November 2018 Project: IEEE P Working Group for Wireless Personal Area Networks (WPANs) Submission Title: [SG SECN Amendment text] Date Submitted:
November 2010 doc.: IEEE < > November 2010
Voice: [ ], FAX: [None], blindcreek.com]
IEEE MEDIA INDEPENDENT HANDOVER DCN:
<month year> doc.: IEEE < e> <May 2018>
Nov 19, 2009 Atlanta, GA Session #64
TGad July 2010 Editor Report
<month year> doc.: IEEE < e> <May 2018>
IEEE MEDIA INDEPENDENT HANDOVER
802.11F Meeting Report Jan 2003 Month 1998 doc.: IEEE /xxx
Session # Maintenance Task Group Closing July 18, 2007
Proposed Resolutions for PICS & other General Comments
Session # Maintenance Task Group Closing September 20, 2007
PLE Comment Resolution Update
September, 2001 Project: IEEE P Working Group for Wireless Personal Area Networks (WPANs) Submission Title: [Briefing on IEEE Standards Style Manual]
Comment Resolution Actions
TG 1 November Session Opening Report
Submission Title: [LB 28 Results] Date Submitted: [14 March 2005]
<month year> doc.: IEEE < e> <July 2019>
TGd Report March 2000 Meeting Albuquerque, NM March 2000
Update for “Multicast Considerations over IEEE 802 Wireless Media”
<month year> doc.: IEEE < e> <September 2019>
<month year> doc.: IEEE < e> <July 2019>
General discovery comment resolution overview
Presentation transcript:

1 September 2003 IEEE Draft 2.5 OAM Comment Resolution Las Vegas, NV - September 2003 Section Editor: Glenn Parsons Technical Editors: Leon Bruckman, Gal Mor

2 September 2003 RPR OAM Met in 1 session (3 long hours) for: 72 comments reviewed Did not deal with most Editorials –Will ask for editorial license for 41 remaining editorials Punted 2 comments to WG Punted 2 comments to clause 0 Highlight of CRG resolutions Response to IETF on MIB

3 September 2003 OAM Comments Summary Clause 11: OAM41 –Accepted17 –Rejected3 –Withdrawn1 –Remaining Editorial22 Annex L: Echo & Flush OAM5 –Accepted2 –Remaining Editorial3 Clause 12: Management18 –Accepted12 –Withdrawn1 –Remaining Editorial5 Annex D: MIB26 –Accepted17 –Withdrawn1 –Rejected1 –Remaining Editorial3 All Technical done

4 September 2003 Clause 11 & L Highlights Fix RPR alarms references Fix PICS Various binding editorials Various wording clarifications Fix state machine routines Align frame/payload format with new clause 0 resolution

5 September 2003 Clause 12 Highlights Complete parameters Clarify & add reference for HC Various clarifications

6 September 2003 Clause D Highlights Various binding editorials Clarify security section Delicate text on clearing intervals Table D.2 improvements Change running counters back to counter64

7 September 2003 Rejected Clause 11 –391 - Table 11.2 Delete This table is useful clarification of a complex figure. It should stay. Annex D –Editorial rejection

8 September 2003 Punt to WG EUI vs OUI –Topology & OAM Organization specific protocol identifiers –Was OUI, currently EUI, comment to make OUI –EUI rejected for similar use in 802.3ah –Propose liaison to IEEE RAC DELAY_TO_CHECK, DELAY_TO_RESTORE –Clause 6 uses as constant –MIB uses as read/write

9 September 2003 Ongoing review Issues OAM Editors need some extra time at the end of the draft writing to align the MIB cross-references IETF MIB experts will be informed of the disposition of their comments and continue to be offered to provide comments on future WG ballots