Chemical evolution modeling: the role of star formation histories and gas flows Monica Tosi INAF – Osservatorio Astronomico di Bologna Castiglione della.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
arvard.edu/phot o/2007/m51/. Confronting Stellar Feedback Simulations with Observations of Hot Gas in Elliptical Galaxies Q. Daniel Wang,
Advertisements

T.P. Idiart  and J.A. de Freitas Pacheco   Universidade de São Paulo (Brasil)  Observatoire de la Côte d’Azur (France) Introduction Elliptical galaxies.
CHEMICAL EVOLUTION MODELS CHEMICAL EVOLUTION MODELS Monica Tosi INAF – Osservatorio Astronomico di Bologna STScI, March INFALL and OUTFLOWS from.
Recent Star Formation Histories of Dwarf Galaxies Evan Skillman – U. Minnesota Gas Accretion and Star Formation in Galaxies - Munich – 
STAR-FORMING DWARF GALAXIES: Evolutionary self-consistent models Mariluz Martín-Manjón Mercedes Mollá Ángeles Díaz Roberto Terlevich VII Workshop Estallidos,
The Universe of Galaxies. A Brief History Galileo.
An introduction to Galaxies. The World of Galaxies Spirals barred unbarred Ellipticals Irregulars.
Formation of Globular Clusters in  CDM Cosmology Oleg Gnedin (University of Michigan)
Deep HST Imaging of M33: the Star Formation History
Nearby Star-Forming Dwarf Galaxies through HST Eyes Alessandra Aloisi (STScI) Talk 25 August 2010.
The Milky Way Galaxy part 2
Astro-2: History of the Universe Lecture 4; April
Early evolution of tidal dwarf galaxies Simone Recchi INAF – Trieste Observatory V Estallidos Workshop “Star Formation and Metallicity” Albayzin – Granada.
Galactic and Extragalactic star formation M.Walmsley (Arcetri Observatory)
The Milky Way PHYS390 Astrophysics Professor Lee Carkner Lecture 19.
© 2010 Pearson Education, Inc. Chapter 21 Galaxy Evolution.
The Milky Way Galaxy 19 April 2005 AST 2010: Chapter 24.
The gaseous halos of spiral galaxies
Three-dimensional hydrodynamical simulations of ISM pollution by type Ia and II supernovae in forming dwarf spheroidal galaxies Andrea Marcolini (Bologna.
The Complex Star Formation History of NGC 1569 L. Angeretti 1, M. Tosi 2, L. Greggio 3, E. Sabbi 1, A. Aloisi 4, C. Leitherer 4 The object The observations.
Dark Matter and Galaxy Formation (Section 3: Galaxy Data vs. Simulations) Joel R. Primack 2009, eprint arXiv: Presented by: Michael Solway.
Galaxies and the Foundation of Modern Cosmology II.
15.3 Galaxy Evolution Our Goals for Learning How do we observe the life histories of galaxies? How did galaxies form? Why do galaxies differ?
Stellar orbits change through interactions with inhomogeneities of gravitational potential (molecular clouds, spiral arms, bar) Resonant interactions.
Galaxies Chapter 16. Galaxies Star systems like our Milky Way Contain a few thousand to tens of billions of stars. Large variety of shapes and sizes.
Galaxies Chapter 13:. Galaxies Contain a few thousand to tens of billions of stars, Large variety of shapes and sizes Star systems like our Milky Way.
1 Galactic Science and MOS on the WHT Amina Helmi.
Resolved Stellar Populations outside the Local Group Alessandra Aloisi (STScI/ESA) Science with the New HST after SM4 Bologna – 30 January 2008.
Galaxies Read Your Textbook: Foundations of Astronomy
8th Sino-German Workshop Kunming, Feb 23-28, 2009 Milky Way vs. M31: a Tale of Two Disks Jinliang HOU In collaboration with : Ruixiang CHANG, Shiyin SHEN,
Observational Properties of Extragalactic Globular Cluster Systems
Galaxy Collisions Top left is an image of the Cartwheel galaxy. The ring of young stars was likely created as a smaller galaxy passed through the disk.
The Nature of Galaxies Chapter 17. Other Galaxies External to Milky Way –established by Edwin Hubble –used Cepheid variables to measure distance M31 (Andromeda.
© 2010 Pearson Education, Inc. Chapter 21 Galaxy Evolution.
After decoupling, overdense regions collapse IF Collapse timefor all sizes. More small ripples than large waves. --> Universe dominated by globular clusters.
1 / 17 The Elemental Abundance Distributions of Milky Way Satellite Galaxies Evan Kirby (HF09) Caltech Small Magellanic Cloud, HST/ACS credit: NASA, ESA,
The chemical evolution of the peculiar “Globular Cluster” Omega Centauri Andrea Marcolini (Uclan, Central Lancashire) Antonio Sollima (Bologna University)
The coordinated growth of stars, haloes and large-scale structure since z=1 Michael Balogh Department of Physics and Astronomy University of Waterloo.
AIMS OF G ALACTIC C HEMICAL E VOLUTION STUDIES To check / constrain our understanding of stellar nucleosynthesis (i.e. stellar yields), either statistically.
High mass X-ray binaries and recent star formation in the host galaxy P.Shtykovskiy, M.Gilfanov IKI, Moscow; MPA, Garching.
Modeling the dependence of galaxy clustering on stellar mass and SEDs Lan Wang Collaborators: Guinevere Kauffmann (MPA) Cheng Li (MPA/SHAO, USTC) Gabriella.
PI Total time #CoIs, team Fernando Comerón 2n (ELT 42m) Not many people Low-mass brown dwarf formation in the Magellanic Clouds: A population long gone.
Modelling the Stellar Populations of The Milky Way and Andromeda Collaborators: Theory:Observations: Kathryn Johnston (Columbia) Annette Ferguson (Edinburgh)
Astronomy 404/CSI 769 Extragalactic Astronomy
Basic Concepts on Chemical Evolution Cesare Chiosi Department of Astronomy University of Padova, Italy.
Galactic structure and star counts Du cuihua BATC meeting, NAOC.
Feedback Observations and Simulations of Elliptical Galaxies –Daniel Wang, Shikui Tang, Yu Lu, Houjun Mo (UMASS) –Mordecai Mac-Low (AMNH) –Ryan Joung (Princeton)
Dust Properties in Metal-Poor Environments Observed by AKARI Hiroyuki Hirashita Hiroyuki Hirashita (ASIAA, Taiwan) H. Kaneda (ISAS), T. Onaka (Univ. Tokyo),
Milky Way thin disk. Q: in order to study the spatial distribution of the thin disk (which dominates the Milky Way luminosity) surface photometry in the.
June 5, 2006 AAS/Calgary Stellar Populations: Old Stars in the Nearest E Galaxy From Field Stars to Globular Clusters.
Galactic Archaeology wishy-washy Nobuo Arimoto NAOJ.
Hi. My name is Alexia Lewis
Rotation Among High Mass Stars: A Link to the Star Formation Process? S. Wolff and S. Strom National Optical Astronomy Observatory.
Star Formation Histories of Nearby Galaxies from Resolved Stellar Populations: What have we learned? Collaborators: J. Dalcanton, D. Weisz, B. Williams,
Model Chemical Evolution: Starburst Environment. Once upon a time… Somewhat big bang started it all. Radiation domination Matter domination Matter gets.
Chemical Evolution Models forDwarf Spheroidal Galaxies Gustavo A. Lanfranchi Núcleo de Astrofísica Teórica - Universidade Cruzeiro do Sul Chemical evolution.
Nearby Galaxies: What Next? D. Calzetti (Univ. of Massachusetts) and the LEGUS Team HUBBLE2020: Hubble’s 25 th Anniversary Symposium.
SPH Simulations of the Galaxy Evolution NAKASATO, Naohito University of Tokyo.
The High Redshift Universe Next Door
Chapter 21 Galaxy Evolution Looking Back Through Time Our goals for learning How do we observe the life histories of galaxies? How did galaxies.
KASI Galaxy Evolution Journal Club A Massive Protocluster of Galaxies at a Redshift of z ~ P. L. Capak et al. 2011, Nature, in press (arXive: )
Galaxy formation and evolution with a GSMT: The z=0 fossil record 17 March, 2003.
CIfAR Stanford 2008 SN Ia Rates: Theory, Progenitors, and Implications.
Gaia ITNG2013 School, Tenerife Ken Freeman, Lecture 4: the stellar halo September 2013.
The LCID Project (Local Cosmology from Isolated Dwarfs) A Brief Overview by Evan Skillman Prepared for the Michigan Workshop: “Extreme Star Formation in.
Galaxies Star systems like our Milky Way
The roles of Type Ia SN rates in galactic chemical evolution
Lecture 11: Age and Metalicity from Observations
Local Late Galactic Evolution (LOLA-GE)
Modeling Star Formation and Chemical Evolution in the Local Group dwarfs Oleg Gnedin University of Michigan.
Presentation transcript:

Chemical evolution modeling: the role of star formation histories and gas flows Monica Tosi INAF – Osservatorio Astronomico di Bologna Castiglione della Pescaia September 16 th 2013

Chemical evolution modelling: the role of star formation histories and gas flows or: Francesca and I over the years Castiglione della Pescaia September 16 th 2013

Once upon the time... In pre-history, Francesca and I lived in the same city (Rome), were students at the same University (La Sapienza), graduated roughly at the same time (1976 and 78), but didn’t know each other and didn’t work on chemical evolution models We first met in 1978

Then, roughly at the same time, we moved, … and found our way to astrophysics She got a fellowship to go to Padova and work with Cesare Chiosi on Galactic chemical evolution models, I got a fellowship to go to Yale and work with Beatrice Tinsley on Galactic chemical evolution models

SF and gas flows (in and out), and their rates ratio are the key ingredients in chemical evolution models One of the first basic lessons we learnt is that They govern element production and dilution, hence: Time scales of galaxy active life metallicity, and abundance gradients age-metallicity relations Etc…

Infall history: MW models (the 80s) Tinsley (1980 and references therein): continuous metal poor infall needed to solve G-dwarf problem and explain radial metallicity gradients Chiosi (1980): continuous slow infall [   nf ≈ (2-3)  10 9 yr] after first rapid collapse to account for G-dwarfs and radial distribution of gas and SFR in the disk Twarog (1980): infall rate ≈ 1/2 SFR (with / SFR now ≈ 2.5) needed to explain AMR => long lasting infall Tosi (1982 and 1988): almost constant infall of extragalactic metal poor gas (Z inf  0.2 Z  ) after disk formation to account for AMR and radial distribution of element abundances and abundance ratios, gas, SFR, etc. Current total rate 1-2 M  yr -1. Lacey & Fall (1985): radial gas flows make the observed gradients, but infall of metal-free gas is still needed to reproduce solar neighbourhood properties, with current total rate M  yr -1. Matteucci & Francois (1989): infall of extragalactic metal poor gas, with e- folding time proportional to galactocentric distance (i.e. the more distant, the longer) to account for abundance gradient of several elements.

infall to reproduce properties of stellar populations abundance gradients (HII regions) models with no infall models with metal free infall Z infall/ Z sun = dots: F stars local G-dwarfs data Shaver et al 83, models Tosi 88

Infall history: MW models (2) Then, people started arguing that HVCs were not sufficient evidence of significant persisting infall and, for more than a decade, only very few of us kept insisting on its need. Until … Chiappini, Matteucci & Gratton (1997): proposed the two-infall model, with a rapid halo collapse, followed by a slow gas accretion from outside the Galaxy to explain both disk and halo observed properties. Inside-out disk formation.

two-infall model: infall rate in  neighbourhood Halo and thick disk formation thin disk formation Chiappini, Matteucci & Gratton (1997)

Infall history: MW models (2) Then, people started arguing that HVCs were not sufficient evidence of significant persisting infall and, for more than a decade, only very few of us kept insisting on its need. Until … Chiappini, Matteucci & Gratton (1997): proposed the two-infall model, with a rapid halo collapse, followed by a slow gas accretion from outside the Galaxy to explain both disk and halo observed properties. Inside-out disk formation. Boissier & Prantzos (1999): inside-out disk formation; infall time-scale radially varying [t inf,  ≈ 7  10 9 yr]

Infall summary from chemical evolution models, infall of metal poor gas appears to be necessary in most spirals, even when radial flows exist (and help with the gradients …) infall is observed in HI in many spirals ( see Sancisi et al 2008 for a review ). In MW evidence is from HVCs ( e.g. Mirabel 1981, DeBoer & Savage , Songaila et al 1988 ); derived metallicity ~0.2 Z sun, rate ~0.4 M o yr -1 (Wakker et al 2008). Is 1 M o yr -1 available ? gas infall is predicted as residual of proto-galaxy collapse, accretion from surrounding halo, merging of gas rich satellites, intergalactic gas trapped during galaxy motion ( e.g. Songaila et al 1998, Blitz et al 1999 ). In MW Magellanic Stream will eventually fall in too ( e.g. Sofue 1994, Fox et al 2010 ).

galactic winds from chemical evolution models of galaxies, winds appear to be necessary in low mass starburst dwarfs, not in spirals winds are observed in H  and X-rays in some Irrs and BCDs, like NGC1569, NGC1705 (e.g. Waller 1991, Meurer et al. 1992, Della Ceca et al. 1997), not in spirals Winds are predicted by hydrodynamics of SN ejecta in starburst dwarfs (e.g. DeYoung & Gallagher 1990, MacLow & Ferrara 1998, D’Ercole & Brighenti 1999, Recchi et al. 2002), with low mass and intense star formation. In massive galaxies, like spirals, SN ejecta fail to escape.

first wind models: Matteucci & Tosi 85, Pilyugin 93, Marconi et al 94 to reproduce observed abundances in starburst dwarfs differential galactic winds are necessary no winds non selective winds Marconi, Matteucci, Tosi 94 differential winds

gas flows comparison chemical evolution of spirals and dwarfs: spirals RESULTS: Long-term infall of metal poor gas needed to dilute metals and favor gradients. Fountains possible. Winds unlikely. dwarfs RESULTS: Winds very likely in lower mass active galaxies. Infall present. Fountains unlikely. QUESTIONS: Can the accretion rate resulting from sum of discrete events be treated as continuous ? What is the effect on chemical evolution of its discontinuity ? QUESTIONS: What is the wind efficiency of SNe Ia and II ? What is the final fate of the ejected gas ?

Star formation history

Trend of [  /Fe] vs [Fe/H] depends on relative timescales of Sne II and Ia, hence on SF history Matteucci (1992, 2003) Stars born before the onset of the bulk SNIa explosions have high [  /Fe]. When SNeIa start yielding their large Fe, stars form with lower and lower [  /Fe].  -elements produced by massive stars; Fe mostly by SNeIa

Star Formation Sandage 1986 Schmidt – Kennicutt law: SFR = a Σ gas ~1.4 (Kennicutt 2008) Valid as climate, but what about weather ?

SF in the Milky Way radial distribution from chromospheric age of dwarfs (Rocha-Pinto et al 2000) solar neighbourhood Inside-Out formation and radially varying SFR efficiency required to reproduce observed SFR, gas and colour profiles (Boissier and Prantzos 1999) from chemev models (Micali, Matteucci, Romano 13)

Thanks to HST stellar populations have been resolved in several galaxies, both of early and late type, both in the Local Group and beyond. From their CMDs, with synthetic CMD method, we infer SF history, IMF and distance. These are inputs for new generation of chemical evolution models of individual galaxies, where SFH is not a free parameter any more. We need robust SFHs

SFH9 SFH5 SFH8 SFH10 Model Cignoni et al (2013) 6 HST/ACS fields in SMC

Cignoni et al 2012, HST/ACS fields in SMC now

Effect of distance on star resolution on reachable lookback times / stellar ages

SFHs in dwarf galaxies BCD dIrr Irr Dolphin 03 Skillman et al 03 dIrr dSph now lookback time Leo A Cole et al 07 now Cignoni et al 08 dIrr NGC346 in SMC dIrr dTrans Notice the similarity between SFH in starburst dwarfs and in SMC region with young cluster (where involved area is much smaller, though)

SFHs in Spirals Cignoni et al 06 M31 Brown 03  neighb from Hypparcos now M33 now Barker et al 07 The later the type and the lower the luminosity class, the more similar to dwarfs’ SFHs SA b I-II SAB bc II SA cd II-III Leo A

comparison chemical evolution of spirals and dwarfs: spirals SF: Continuous but as average of many contiguous episodes. On average slowly decreasing with time (the later the type, the slower the decrease). Varying with galactocentric distance. flows: flows: infall of metal poor gas needed to dilute metals and favor gradient. Fountains possible. Winds unlikely. dwarfs Fairly continuous, but less than in spirals. Gasping more than bursting. Peaked at early or recent epochs depending on morphological type. No dwarf currently at first SF episode ever found yet. winds very likely in lower mass galaxies; infall present, fountains unlikely.

Francesca : since 1978, 35 years of great fun together. I’m looking forward to the next 35 … THANKS !

Models in cosmological context are the new frontier, but still far from satisfactory Courtesy D. Romano 2013

And, by the way, We met our future husbands in the same place (Erice): they are both astronomers and sleeping lions (i.e. born in August)

SFHs from CMDs of resolved stellar populations Local Group galaxies: Photometric resolution of individual stars is possible down to fainter/older objects in all galactic regions long lookback time (up to Hubble time) for SFH is reachable and space distribution of SF is derivable More distant galaxies: Distance makes crowding much more severe and even HST has not resolved yet stars as faint as the MS-TO lookback time ranges from a few tens of Myr to several Gyr (reached only in outer, less crowded regions) and space distribution is derivable only in a few cases