NFL CONCUSSION LAWSUIT SETTLEMENT SUMMARY. “A class action settlement that offers prompt relief is superior to the likely alternative—years of expensive,

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
The Cost of Brain Injury – Legal Perspective BIRT Seminar “ Counting the costs of brain injury rehabilitation – the benefits of neurobehavioural rehabilitation”
Advertisements

Overview of Education Litigation FEA Delegate Assembly October, 2012.
Retirement Planning Fresno County Employees’ Retirement Association Location: 1111 H Street Fresno, CA Phone: (559) Stop Mail #: 40 Web Address:
What are my child’s rights under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act? Randy Chapman The Legal Center for People with Disabilities and Older.
WHAT DO YOU DO WHEN???. Reasonable Accommodation Gina Portillo, Reasonable Accommodation Coordinator (510)
Risks of Opting Out. Preemption “Many, if not all, of Plaintiffs’ claims could have been dismissed at this early stage of the litigation if the NFL Parties.
Social Security Administration Disability Programs Disability Programs.
© 2007 Prentice Hall, Business Law, sixth edition, Henry R. Cheeseman Chapter 3 Litigation and Alternative Dispute Resolution Chapter 3 Litigation and.
1 Judicial Review Under NEPA Bob Malmsheimer April 1, 2006.
Litigation and Alternatives for Settling Civil Disputes CHAPTER FIVE.
Deepwater Horizon Financial Claims Settlement Resource Guide NAACP Gulf Coast Financial Capacity Building Initiative.
IPERS Overview & Benefit Options
Social Security Administration Disability Programs Disability Programs.
Supplement to Accompany Workers’ Compensation Neal Bevans ISBN:
Operational and Actuarial Aspects of Takaful Claims Management.
© 2005 Dechert LLP CLASS ACTIONS IN THE UNITED STATES: OVERVIEW AND RECENT DEVELOPMENTS For Presentation at the British Institute of Comparative Law June.
What employers should know about the system in California CALIFORNIA WORKERS’ COMPENSATION.
Terms Service-connected Disability Eligible from 1st day of employment Must be permanently disabled Must have a direct causational link to the workplace.
Qualified Medical Evaluations and Spinal Surgery Second Opinion Presented by Janet Coulter, WCALJ James Fisher, Industrial Relations Council III Suzanne.
Workers Compensation Commission Sian Leathem Registrar 29 September 2008.
CHAPTER © 2012 The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved. 13 Workers’ Compensation and Disability.
Copyright © 2008 Delmar Learning. All rights reserved. Chapter 17 Workers’ Compensation.
Diane M Barnes, CDMS,CCM,CMC Barnes Consulting, LLC What Your Third Party Administrator Should Be Doing For You.
Continuity Clinic Liability Insurance 101 Modified from information on
1 Federal Employees’ Compensation Act (FECA) AFGE Firefighter Council Seminar.
Social Security Administration Yolanda York
© 2005 National Mental Health Association The Medicare Drug Benefit: What Is It and What Does it Mean for Mental Health?
Social Security Retirement John S. Whitelaw Community Legal Services 1410 West Erie Avenue Philadelphia, PA July 2014 This presentation was sponsored.
When Health Coverage Ends PASBO 48 th Annual Conference March 20, 2003 NCAS Pennsylvania P.O. Box Harrisburg, PA (717)
Clinical Trials. What is a clinical trial? Clinical trials are research studies involving people Used to find better ways to prevent, detect, and treat.
© 2007 McGraw-Hill Higher Education. All rights reserved. Lesson 2: Legal Liability.
Part I Sources of Corrections Law. Chapter 4 - Going to Court Introduction – Chapter provides information on appearing in court, either as a witness or.
Administrative Law Judge Oklahoma Workers’ Compensation Commission
Randy Costales Executive Director, The Arc of New Mexico 1.
1 An Act To Improve The Workers’ Compensation System HB 194/SB 200.
1 National Asbestos Workers Pension Fund Introduction Participation Participation Benefit Accrual Benefit Accrual Retirement Retirement  Types.
What is a lockout? A lockout is the exclusion of employees (players) by their employers (owners) from their place of work until certain terms (Collective.
Social Security & SSI Benefits for Children. The Social Security Administration manages two distinctly different programs that provide benefits based.
Special Education Process: Role of the School Nurse Marge Resan, Education Consultant Special Education Team Wisconsin Department of Public Instruction.
NFL Retirement Plans NFL Retirement Plans “What’s all the fuss about?” Charles Clark and Regine Rucker Thursday, November 29, 2007 Finance Employee.
Chapter Outline 16.1Overview Of Workers’ Compensation Laws 16.2.Workers’ Compensation Benefits Medical Benefits Disability Benefits Total Disability Benefits.
October 2009 Oregon Department of Education 1 Diploma Options 2009.
Chapter 16 Disability Income Insurance and Disability Benefit Programs Elsevier items and derived items © 2010, 2008 by Saunders, an imprint of Elsevier.
Chapter 16.1 Civil Cases. Types of Civil Lawsuits In civil cases the plaintiff – the party bringing the lawsuit – claims to have suffered a loss and usually.
Sports and Concussion.
1 SOCIAL SECURITY BENEFITS FOR PERSONS WITH DISABILITIES Amy C. O’Hara, Esq. Littman Krooks LLP
Covered Employer Training Program Leaving Covered Employment FY 2016.
© 2007 Sidley Austin LLP, Los Angeles, CA All rights reserved. What is a Civil Case?
United States Department of Transportation Notification And Federal Employee Anti- Discrimination And Retaliation Act of 2002.
Providing guidance and assistance to the American public in making decisions on their Social Security eligibility and continuing Social Security issues.
Your Rights! An overview of Special Education Laws Presented by: The Individual Needs Department.
2013. Over 56 Million People Who Receives Benefits from Social Security? 36.4 million Retired Workers 2.9 million Dependents 8.4 million Disabled Workers,
The Hearing Process 1. 2 Notice of Claim Status Issued by Carrier Legally Binding Triggers Protest Period (usually 90 days)
A Basic Guide to Social Security Disability Benefits Presented by Matthew Lane and Nancy Goodwin of Ziegler & Lane, LLC.
Social Security  1935 – Retirement Insurance  1939 – Survivors Insurance  1956 – Disability Insurance History of Social Security.
Legal Considerations and Administration
Workers Compensation Basics Prepared for Fresno County Self Insurance Group-FCSIG.
(202) King Street, Suite 650 Alexandria, VA WASHINGTON, DC DISABILITY QUALIFICATIONS.
SOCIAL SECURITY BENEFITS FOR PERSONS WITH DISABILITIES
Judicial Review Under NEPA
CLASS ACTIONS IN THE UNITED STATES: OVERVIEW AND RECENT DEVELOPMENTS
Schools for the deaf- class action
An overview of Georgia Workers‘ Compensation
Social Security Disability Benefits By Sara G. Khaki, Esq
CONTRACTS PRIVILEGED COMMUNICATION PRIVACY ACT
IEP Basics for Parents and Families
The SMI Evaluation and Determination Process
CONTRACTS PRIVILEGED COMMUNICATION PRIVACY ACT
Chapter 16.1 Civil Cases.
Paid Family and Medical Leave
Presentation transcript:

NFL CONCUSSION LAWSUIT SETTLEMENT SUMMARY

“A class action settlement that offers prompt relief is superior to the likely alternative—years of expensive, difficult, and uncertain litigation, with no assurance of recovery, while retired players’ physical and mental conditions continue to deteriorate.” – Judge Anita B. Brody U.S. District Court, Eastern District of Pennsylvania “In particular, it is my considered judgment that Plaintiffs would be unlikely to have obtained more money and benefits without going through years of discovery and trial, where they would face substantial risks of loss due to their inability to prove negligence or fraud on the part of the NFL Parties or judgments below what they will receive in this proposed settlement.” – Judge Layn Phillips, Former federal judge and Court-appointed mediator An Historic Agreement

Money now, not after years of litigating Uncapped fund guaranteed to last 65 years State-of-the-art medical testing, will contribute to research that makes football safer for future generations (in accordance with appropriate HIPAA protections) Medical benefits if you are impaired, compensation if you are diagnosed with a qualifying condition, protection over the long-run if currently asymptomatic Both the Baseline Assessment Program (BAP) and the Monetary Award Fund will be overseen by independent administrators These administrators will be approved by the Court The NFL will not determine who is eligible for benefits Benefits Now and for the Future

Background July 2011: First lawsuits filed against NFL January 2012: Lawsuits coordinated in Eastern District of Pa. June 7, 2012: Master complaint filed April 9, 2013: Oral arguments held on NFL’s motion to dismiss on preemption grounds July 8, 2013: Court orders parties into mediation, sets deadline of 9/3/13 August 29, 2013: Parties announce $760 million settlement January 7, 2014: Motion for Preliminary Approval of settlement is filed January 14, 2014: Court denies Motion for Preliminary Approval without prejudice, instructs parties to provide more information June 25, 2014: Plaintiffs re-file Motion for Preliminary Approval of new settlement, compensation now guaranteed over 65-year life of fund July 7, 2014: Court grants motion for preliminary approval of settlement

Background Baseline Assessment Program: $75 million Monetary Award Fund: All awards guaranteed over 65-year life of fund Education programs: $10 million

Who Is Eligible? The settlement includes all retired players, as of July 7, 2014, of the NFL, the American Football League (“AFL”) that merged with the NFL, the World League of American Football, NFL Europe League, and NFL Europa League, as well as authorized representatives of deceased, legally incapacitated or incompetent retired players and family members of retired players who meet certain criteria.

Determining Eligible Seasons The Settlement uses the term "Eligible Season" to count the seasons in which a retired player played or practiced in the NFL or AFL. A retired player earns an Eligible Season for: Each season where he was on an NFL or AFL Member Club's "Active List" for either three or more regular season or postseason games, or Where he was on an Active List for one or more regular or postseason games and then spent two regular or postseason games on an injured reserve list or inactive list due to a concussion or head injury A retired player also earns one-half of an Eligible Season for each season where he was on an NFL or AFL Member Club's practice, developmental, or taxi squad for at least eight games, but did not otherwise earn an Eligible Season

Settlement Benefits

Baseline Assessment Program All living retired players who have earned at least one-half of an eligible season may participate in the BAP. The BAP is a nationwide network of qualified and independent providers (not NFL-appointed doctors) BAP exams will include both a neuropsychological and neurological examination Timing (age as of Effective Date of settlement) 43 and older: two years to get a baseline assessment Under 43: Within 10 years of commencement of the BAP, or until you turn 45, whichever is earlier Players will receive information about the BAP after they register for the settlement

Baseline Assessment Program The baseline assessment examination will include a full battery of neuropsychological and neurological tests. They will examine retired players’ functioning in a variety of categories, including: Complex Attention / Processing Speed Executive Functioning Learning and Memory Language Spatial-Perceptual Mental Health

Baseline Assessment Program If diagnosed with Level 1 Neurocognitive Impairment (i.e., moderate cognitive impairment), a retired player will be eligible for medical benefits including: Medical treatment Pharmaceuticals Counseling If diagnosed with a Level 1.5 (i.e., early Dementia) or Level 2 (i.e., moderate Dementia) Neurocognitive Impairment: Can apply to the Monetary Award Fund to receive compensation NFL will not choose the doctors who participate in the BAP program NFL will not decide who is eligible for benefits or compensation

Baseline Assessment Program Early diagnosis and treatment means better medical outcomes Provides a baseline for future evaluations Contributes to research and medical science (in accordance with appropriate HIPAA protections) No Causation: retired players do not have to prove their neurocognitive condition was caused by NFL football to receive supplemental benefits

Monetary Awards Retired Players diagnosed with the following conditions may be eligible to receive monetary compensation: Amyotrophic Lateral Sclerosis (ALS) Death with CTE (between January 1, 2006 and July 7, 2014) Parkinson’s Disease Alzheimer’s Disease Level 2 Neurocognitive Impairment (i.e., moderate Dementia) Level 1.5 Neurocognitive Impairment (i.e., early Dementia)

Monetary Awards The uncapped fund guarantees that all qualifying retired players will receive monetary awards No Causation: retired players do not have to prove their neurocognitive condition was caused by NFL football to receive a monetary award All qualifying diagnoses will be made by a list of qualified and independent medical providers approved by the Claims Administrator Those who have received diagnosis from physician prior to Effective Date of settlement can submit claim to Appeals Advisory Panel NFL will not choose the doctors who participate in the MAF program Exact amount of a retired player’s award will depend on several factors, such as age of diagnosis, number of eligible seasons played, a prior stroke or traumatic brain injury unrelated to NFL football, and participation in the BAP NFL will not decide who is eligible for compensation If, during the term of the Fund, a retired player who has already received a Monetary Award from a qualifying diagnosis should subsequently be diagnosed with a different qualifying diagnosis, the retired player may be entitled to a Supplemental Monetary Award

Monetary Awards Average awards within each age range (excluding other adjustments) *Death with CTE claims must fall between January 1, 2006 and July 7, 2014 (date of preliminary approval of settlement),UNLESS the Court determines that claim would be allowed under applicable state law. For deaths occurring after July 7, 2014, there is no claim for Death with CTE. Age at Diagnosis ALSDeath w/ CTE* Parkinson’sAlzheimer’sLevel 2Level 1.5 Under 45$5,000,000$4,000,000$3,500,000 $3,000,000$1,500, $4,500,000$3,200,000$2,470,000$2,300,000$1,900,000$950, $4,000,000$2,300,000$1,900,000$1,600,000$1,200,000$600, $3,500,000$1,400,000$1,300,000$1,150,000$950,000$475, $3,000,000$1,200,000$1,000,000$950,000$580,000$290, $2,500,000$980,000$760,000$620,000$380,000$190, $1,750,000$600,000$475,000$380,000$210,000$105, $1,000,000$160,000$145,000$130,000$80,000$40, $300,000$50,000 $25,000

Monetary Awards Offsets for eligible seasons Number of Eligible SeasonsPercentage of Reduction 4.510% 420% 3.530% 340% 2.550% 260% 1.570% 180%.590% 097.5%

Players Retain All Other Benefits This agreement leaves intact all current benefit programs offered by the NFL to retired players. These benefits include: 88 Plan (CBA Article 58) Bert Bell/Pete Rozelle NFL Player Retirement Plan NFL Player Supplemental Disability Plan, including the Neuro-Cognitive Disability Benefit (CBA Article 65) Gene Upshaw NFL Player Health Reimbursement Account Plan Former Player Life Improvement Plan NFL Player Insurance Plan Retired players can still pursue workers’ compensation claims against NFL teams AND receive benefits under the agreement

Risks of Opting Out

Preemption “Many, if not all, of Plaintiffs’ claims could have been dismissed at this early stage of the litigation if the NFL Parties prevailed on the preemption issue.” – Judge Anita B. Brody Causation In Court, it is not enough to show that you are injured Need to demonstrate that the NFL’s wrongful conduct caused your injuries Need to show that the injuries resulted from NFL football (not college, high school, Pop Warner, family history, etc.) Risks of Opting Out

Statute of Limitations Most states have two or three year Statute of Limitations (SOL) Not all states have “Discovery Rule” Proof of fraud or late “Discovery” of claim to overcome SOL is case- specific and challenging Risks of Opting Out

Exclusive Remedy (Worker’s Compensation) The NFL was prepared to argue that the League was a “co- employer” of the players, with claims belonging exclusively in the worker’s compensation system Not only does this settlement avoid the elimination of claims due to this defense, but players may still pursue worker’s compensation claims against the team(s) for which they played Risks of Opting Out

Other Defenses Assumption of risk Proving reliance on the fraud Time and Uncertainty Those who opt out may face a long and uncertain road ahead Many retired players and their families cannot afford to wait “The significant legal challenges facing Plaintiffs support preliminary approval of the proposed Settlement.” – Judge Anita B. Brody Risks of Opting Out

Those who opt out will be permanently ineligible for the settlement benefits If you opt out and develop a neurocognitive condition, you will be ineligible for this settlement’s benefits If you opt-out, and your legal case is dismissed, you will be ineligible for this settlement’s benefits The Risks of Opting Out

Next Steps

The Court has granted preliminary approval of the settlement Next steps include: Formal notice mailed to class members: July 24, 2014 (can also be found at Fairness Hearing: November 19, 2014 If final approval is granted by Court, claims process may open by Q (estimated) Objectors who appeal settlement approval will delay Effective Date of settlement

Next Steps Registering for the Settlement Registration begins after final approval Website and phone information will be provided The Settlement Administrator will contact retired players with more information after they have registered You can currently sign up for more information on how to register at To apply for compensation Must be registered for the settlement Must submit “claim package” within two years of diagnosis or two years after settlement’s effective date (whichever is later)

Additional Information For more information, please visit or call

NFL CONCUSSION LAWSUIT SETTLEMENT SUMMARY