Erica Breslau, PhD, MPH Allen Dietrich, MD Russell Glasgow, PhD Kurt Stange, MD, PhD State of the Art and Future Directions in Multilevel Interventions.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Integrating the NASP Practice Model Into Presentations: Resource Slides Referencing the NASP Practice Model in professional development presentations helps.
Advertisements

World Health Organization
Introduction to the unit and mixed methods approaches to research Kerry Hood.
Multilevel Interventions: Study Design and Analysis Issues Paul D. Cleary, Ph.D. Yale School of Public Health Cary Gross, M.D. Yale School of Medicine.
Engaging Patients and Other Stakeholders in Clinical Research
1 CPCRN Mission To accelerate the adoption of evidence- based cancer prevention and control in communities.
Part A/Module A1/Session 4 Part A: Module A1 Session 4 Comprehensive Care for People Living with HIV/AIDS (PLHA)
A national perspective on information and technology in adult social care Charlotte Buckley DH.
Integrating Chronic Care & Business Strategies in the Safety-Net AHRQ Annual Meeting September 9, 2008.
Neighbor to Neighbor Lessons learned from a community- based HIV testing partnership: The HIV Minority Community Health Partnership Presented at American.
National Human Resources for Health Observatory HRH Research Forum Dr. Ayat Abuagla.
Current and Future Challenges in Designing Behavioral Interventions: From Randomized Trials to Community Implementation Current and Future Challenges in.
Planning an improved prevention response up to early childhood Ms. Giovanna Campello UNODC Prevention, Treatment and Rehabilitation Section.
Introduction to Strengthening Families: An Effective Approach to Supporting Families Massachusetts Home Visiting Initiative A Department of Public Health.
© Family Nurse Partnership FNP: Integration of a licensed programme Improving Integrated Assessment, Interventions and Developing Integrated Pathways.
SOCIAL MEDIA FOR CONSUMER INSIGHT Chapter Chapter Objectives  Describe the types of data used in social media research  Explain the different.
Overview of Nursing Informatics
Spreading and Scaling Prevention and Treatment Approaches: Centers of Excellence Model Janet E. Farmer, PhD School of Health Professions University of.
Evaluating Discipline-based Goals and Educational Outcomes in Developmental Psychology Anne L. Law Department of Psychology Rider University.
Objectives Students will be able to:
Child Welfare Workforce Changing Context & Implications Resulting from Privatization & Performance-Based Contracting Karl Ensign, Director Evaluation for.
Community Based Approaches: A review of intervention models and evidence of their effectiveness for preventing maternal-to-child transmission of HIV Joanna.
Community Level Models; Participatory Research and Challenges
Evaluation and Policy in Transforming Nursing
Analytic Frameworks Prepared for: Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (AHRQ) Training Modules for Systematic Reviews Methods Guide
EVOLVING PUBLIC HEALTH AND HEALTH CARE LANDSCAPE AND OPPORTUNITIES FOR CANCER COMMUNICATION NCI Health Communication and Informatics Research Branch CPCRN.
Integrated Framework for Reducing Racial and Ethnic Disparities in the Quality of Health Care Marshall H. Chin, MD, MPH, and Don Goldmann, MD University.
Building Capacity for Better Care Behavioural Support Systems Across Canada Dr. J Kenneth LeClair Sarah Clark.
Striving for Quality Using continuous improvement strategies to increase program quality, implementation fidelity and durability Steve Goodman Director.
Discussion of Section I Papers Maria E. Fernandez, PhD Associate Professor of Health Promotion and Behavioral Sciences University of Texas, School of Public.
National Center for Chronic Disease Prevention and Health Promotion (NCCDPHP)  Vision: a nation in which all people live healthy lives free from the devastation.
The Value of Being Healthy John Fitzgerald Victorian Health Promotion Foundation (VicHealth)
Evaluating Dissemination of AHRQ CER Products Darren Mays, PhD, MPH Department of Oncology Georgetown University Medical Center Lombardi Comprehensive.
Perioperative fasting guideline Getting it into practice Getting started.
Agenda Setting Input and Status Agenda Setting Input and Status.
Multilevel Interventions: Measurement and Measures Martin P. Charns Mary K. Foster Elaine C. Alligood Justin K. Benzer James F. Burgess Allison Burness.
Improving Implementation Research Methods for Behavioral and Social Science Working Meeting Measuring Enactment of Innovations and the Factors that Affect.
Implementing universal Lynch Syndrome screening in a large healthcare system.
Clinical Care Improvement System Mark Murray, MD, MPA Mark Murray & Associates.
Addressing methodological challenges: measuring resilience + international coherence Juliet Field Climate and Environment Dept.
Potential Roles for Health Technology Assessment Agencies: Opportunities and Challenges for an Effective Health Technology Assessment Practice at the Meso.
The Center for Health Systems Transformation
Program 1 Healthy Start, Healthy Life. ‘To enhance the effective implementation of evidence-based techniques, tools and resources that support the delivery.
Amy Fine Center for the Study of Social Policy
Counseling, Caregivers and Alternative Transportation Panel C 12/02/03.
PHSB 612: Interventions Diane M. Dowdy, Ph.D. Spring 2008.
Third Sector Evaluation: Challenges and Opportunities Presentation to the Public Legal Education in Canada National Conference on “Making an Impact” 26.
Why a CPCRN? CDC Expectations Katherine M. Wilson, PhD, MPH CPCRN Technical Monitor Division of Cancer Prevention and Control CDC.
Nursing Philosophies, Models and Theories
A Multimethod Tailored QII for Sustainable Practice Change Mary C. Ruhe, B.S., R.N. Kurt C. Stange, MD, PhD Research Association of Practices (RAP) & Case.
Multilevel Interventions in Health Care: Building the Foundation for Future Research March 4, 2011 Stephen Taplin, MD MPH | Steven Clauser PhD Rebecca.
GUIDE TO EVIDENCE-BASED INTERVENTIONS. ASDs now affect one in every 110 children Centers for Disease Control and Prevention Lifelong effect on functioning,
+ Evidence Based Practice University of Utah Evidence-Based Treatment and Practice: New Opportunities to Bridge Clinical Research and Practice, Enhance.
Social Ecological Models
1 Strategic Plan Review. 2 Process Planning and Evaluation Committee will be discussing 2 directions per meeting. October meeting- Finance and Governance.
PEER Module 4: Research & Evaluation Questions
Self-Management Support: Shared Decision-Making Stephen Taplin MD, MPH 3/21/07 Adapted from work by Michael G. Goldstein, MD Bayer Institute for Health.
Update from the Division of Epidemiology, Services and Prevention Research Wilson M. Compton, M.D., M.P.E. Director, Division of Epidemiology, Services.
A Multi-Level Framework to Understand Factors Influencing Program Implementation in Schools Celene E. Domitrovich, Ph.D. Penn State Prevention Research.
Key Characteristics of Participatory Learning 1. Well Defined Objectives: Participatory learning requires setting, clarifying objectives with the students,
Implementation Science: Finding Common Ground and Perspectives Laura Reichenbach, Evidence Project, Population Council International Conference on Family.
Copyright © 2014 Wolters Kluwer Health | Lippincott Williams & Wilkins Chapter 42 Emerging Theories Debra Tupe.
Evaluating the Impact of a System- Level Intervention Using a Developmental Evaluation Approach S. Elizabeth McGee, MA Evangeline Danseco, PhD Kyle Ferguson.
Bringing Diversity into Impact Evaluation: Towards a Broadened View of Design and Methods for Impact Evaluation Sanjeev Sridharan.
Provider Initiated HIV Counseling and Testing Unit 2: Introduction and Rational for PIHCT.
BEST ET AL., 2007 ISIS: Initiative on the Study and Implementation of Systems Systems Thinking in Tobacco Control.
Critical Program Movement: Integration of STD Prevention with Other Programs Kevin Fenton, MD, PhD, FFPH Director National Center for HIV/AIDS, Viral Hepatitis,
Joining the Research Team in Global Mental Health
The Arizona Chronic Disease Plan:
Raising the bar Meeting Europe’s future challenges
Presentation transcript:

Erica Breslau, PhD, MPH Allen Dietrich, MD Russell Glasgow, PhD Kurt Stange, MD, PhD State of the Art and Future Directions in Multilevel Interventions across the Cancer Control Continuum Mulitlevel Interventions in Health Care March 4-5, 2011, Las Vegas NV

Methods Multidisciplinary team Multiple iterations of literature searches Designed to include the breadth of the field Concentrated on cancer control continuum Included other fields (particular cardiovascular disease studies) Developed a matrix of article types Immersion at O’Hare Airport hotel Characterize how multilevel research currently is conceptualized and implemented Described illustrative examples Identified opportunities for MLI to advance cancer control 2

Threads of Shared Thinking & Research Contextualized single-level studies intervene at the person/patient or provider/practice, but consider other contextually-important levels Health care systems research includes individual, practice & system levels, and sometimes considers community or policy factors Community-wide studies public health perspective, often including nested health care system, practice, family, person levels Community heart studies Community cancer control studies 3

Observations from the Literature Multilevel interventions are context-dependent, but context is reported inadequately in most reports Typically, less than 3 levels are reported Theory, models and interventions are not well integrated in reports/studies Most focused on prevention and screening; seldom on diagnosis, treatment, survivorship Reporting of temporal issues is limited Many glimmers of potential of MLI Thought pieces Theory Empirical 4

Opportunities Design Analysis Dissemination 5

Design Greater attention to: Contextual factors across Levels Time Rapid learning designs that evolve over time Dynamic Adaptive Emergent Interfaces across and within levels Specifying levels affecting the phenomena under study (even if they are not the focus of the study) 6

Analysis Greater attention to: Evaluate both process and outcomes Capture, but move beyond measures of central tendency Use multi-method approaches that Integrate quantitative modeling across multiple levels where relevant quantitative data can be generated, and Qualitative methods to evaluate levels with small numbers, and to identify key inter-level processes Complex systems and dynamic simulation modeling may provide additional insights where data are sparse 7

Translation Greater attention to: Transparent reporting of contextual factors Moving beyond fidelity to Local adaptation / reinvention / evolution Participatory approaches How multiple levels interact in context, (vs. in isolation) Move beyond sustainable to evolvable interventions 8

An Example LevelWho/What Individual and Family Low income, pregnant mothers, and their children <2 PracticePrimary care and home visits Healthcare System Multilevel advisory committee included Medicaid representatives CommunityCommunity organization and town and state government Margolis PA, Stevens R, Bordley WC, et al. From concept to application: the impact of a community-wide intervention to improve the delivery of preventive services to children. Pediatrics. 2001;108(3):E42. Design: Observational / intervention Focus: Preventive services & health behavior 9

Challenges The future is multiple (conditions, behaviors, interactive modalities) The future is complex (and we ignore complexity at our peril) 1 “All models (and designs) are wrong” 2 – tolerance, respect, & creativity are needed We may need to UN-learn much of what we have been taught to answer the tough questions 1 Glasgow RE, Emmons KM. Annual Review of Public Health, StermanJD. Syst Dynam Rev 2002;18:

Discussion Questions How do we develop MLI that Create synergy across multiple levels? Continually pay attention to context? Adapt and learn over time? How do we develop designs and analytic techniques that reflect the complexity of the phenomena we are studying? How do we disseminate to foster Informed adaptation or re-invention? Continued evolution and learning? 11

Extra Slides Not for handout May be used for discussion

Critical Elements Program as Tested Evidence-Tested Program Health Care System Organization Program Delivery Staff Clinic(s) Delivery Site(s) Research Design Team And Adaptive Design Fit Design Appropriate for Question Partnership Broader Health Policy and Cultural Context Adapted from Estabrooks et. al. AJPM, 2005, 31: S45 Integrated Dynamic, Multilevel Research-Practice Partnerships Systems Approach Non-critical Packaging Program as Marketed 14

Cultural, Historical, Social-Environmental Factors (Fundamental “distal” Determinants) Social-Community Context Work, built environment, environmental exposures, family, friends Ubiquitous Media and Technology Work, built environment, environmental exposures, family, friends Individual Level Malleable Factors: Self-efficacy, activation, problem-solving, etc. “Trait” Factors: Preferences, illness Representations, emotions Health Care System Priorities, Resources, Guidelines, etc. Patient-Provider Encounters Shared Decision-making Sub-personal/Biological Genomics Breadth of Impact Malleability in Short Timeframe Community Building Infrastructure; Regulations, resources on food, tobacco, transportation Feedback, Monitoring Social Norms Transportation Programs Incentives, Coverage Public Reporting Personal Health Records (PHR) Interoperable EMRs and PHRs Monopolies vs. Open Access Tracking, Monitoring Progress Action Plans Genetic Counseling Community programs Personal Health Records (PHR); Social Media mHealth (mobile) devices Opportunities for Integrating Across Levels 15

“The significant problems we face cannot be solved by the same level of thinking that created them.” A. Einstein 16

17

Implementation and Dissemination Research Characteristics 18 Contextual Complex Multi-component programs and policies Non-linear Transdisciplinary Multi-level

19