2004 Portfolio Review 2005 Project Implementation Workshop, Bamako 2004 Portfolio Review: Main Findings.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

ROM reviews Saskia Van Crugten

Advertisements

Setting the scene: Improving project implementation in a changing environment 2005 Project Implementation Workshop, Bamako Improving project implementation.

UNOPS-DAKAR Regional Office for West and Central Africa EXECUTION OF IFAD PROJECTS: Constraints and proposed solutions.

IFAD’s regional communication strategy for Western and Central Africa.

Regional project implementation workshop in Western and Central Africa THE DOUALA ACTION PLAN DOUALA ACTION PLAN WORKING GROUP – NIGERIA, GHANA, SIERRA.

Corporate-Level Evaluation on IFAD’s Engagement in Fragile and Conflict Affected States and Situations: Draft Final Report 4 February 2014.

Interagency Contingency Planning and Emergency Preparedness: Challenges and Lessons Learnt V. Harutyunyan M.D. Head of Health / Merlin Global Nutrition.

The Bamako Action Plan - Achievements, Lessons, Way Ahead Regional project implementation workshop in Western and Central Africa Douala, Cameroon

Vietnam Country Programme Evaluation Presentation to the Evaluation Committee during their country visit to Viet Nam, 22 May 2013.

IFAD Reform towards a better development effectiveness How can we all do better? Mohamed Béavogui Director, West and Central Africa January 2009.

M&E Issues: RAFIP and REP Kaushik Barua Accra, 12 Dec

MONITORING AND EVALUATION – A PERSISTENT CHALLENGE 78 th Session of the Evaluation Committee Rome, 5 September 2013.

Independent Office of Evaluation 1 IFAD Policy for Grant Financing Corporate-level Evaluation IFAD Learning Event 10 December 2014.

Western and Central Africa Portfolio Performance Review Regional Project Implementation Workshop Accra, Ghana 1-4 December 2009.

Sub-Regional Workshop for GEF Focal Points in Asia Bangkok, Thailand 7-8 April 2009 Tracking national portfolios and assessing results.

United Nations Statistics Division

SPA-CABRI Project on “Putting Aid on Budget” Presentation to DAC Joint Venture on Public Finance Management Paris, July 2007 Peter Dearden, Strategic Partnership.

Technical Support Facilities (TSFs) Support for GF proposals and grant implementation Improving access to timely, quality assured Technical Assistance.

0 Kestutis Rekerta Strategic Planning Division, Government Office of Lithuania World Bank Workshop, Bratislava, September 6, 2006 STRATEGIC PLANNING IN.

Regional project implementation workshop in Western and Central Africa Douala, Cameroon January 2009.

Independent Office of Evaluation Evaluation synthesis IFAD’s engagement with indigenous peoples Emerging findings and key issues for reflection Emerging.

Title Consultation on the 7 th replenishment of IFAD’s resources IFAD’s operating model : overall structure and components Consultation on the 7th replenishment.

Western and Central Africa Portfolio Performance Review July 2009 – June 2010 Dakar, 09 November 2010.

GBA IT Project Management Final Project - Establishment of a Project Management Management Office 10 July, 2003.

© OECD A joint initiative of the OECD and the European Union, principally financed by the EU. Quality Assurance José Viegas Ribeiro IGF, Portugal SIGMA.

Joint Programme Enhancing judicial reform in the Eastern Partnership countries Judicial component.

Joanna Fiedler Enlargement and Neighbouring Countries Unit DG Environment European Commission REReP → RENA Vision of the European Commission PEIP Regional.

Sub-Regional Workshop for GEF Focal Points in West and Central Africa Accra, Ghana, 9-11 July 2009 Tracking National Portfolios and Assessing Results.

Tracking national portfolios and assessing results Sub-regional Workshop for GEF Focal Points Western and Central Africa Dakar, May 2007.

Commission on Teacher Credentialing Ensuring Educator Excellence 1 Biennial Report October 2008.

Workshop II Monitoring and Evaluation INTERACT ENPI Annual Conference December 2009 | Rome.

Introduction to the Performance Based Allocation System Smallholder Agriculture as a Business: Legal Dimensions of Building Inclusive Value Chains April.

Gulana Hajiyeva Environmental Specialist World Bank Moscow Safeguards Training, May 30 – June 1, 2012.

Managing for Results Regional Project Implementation Workshop Accra, Ghana 1-4 December 2009.

Results achieved under IFAD VII and directions for results measurement under IFAD VIII Edward Heinemann Programme Manager, Action Plan Secretariat, Office.

The Douala Action Plan – A preliminary assessment Regional project implementation workshop in Western and Central Africa Accra, Ghana December 1-4, 2009.

National Roundtable Workshop Nairobi 8 June 2011 Republic of Kenya Country Programme Evaluation Independent Office of Evaluation.

Workshop on the Execution of IFAD Projects and Programmes General Recommendations regarding the Action Plan Bamako, 11 March 2005.

Working Group on Public Debt Progress Report 7th Meeting of the Steering Committee of the INTOSAI Committee on the Knowledge Sharing and Knowledge Services.

Farmers’ organizations, policies and markets Implications of the Performance Base Allocation System for Countries and Projects.

MONITORING SYSTEM OF EU STRUCTURAL FUNDS: PHYSICAL INDICATORS International Conference for New Member States February 1-2, 2012, Vilnius (Lithuania) European.

Maximising the Use of Evaluation Reports 1 Thomas Alveteg HIV Joint Evaluation Workshop, Limbé, March 15 –

China Country Programme Evaluation Main Findings and Recommendations National Roundtable Workshop Beijing, 17 July 2014 Presentation by the Independent.

African Centre for Statistics United Nations Economic Commission for Africa Proposed Framework for Monitoring, Evaluation and Reporting Negussie Gorfe.

Tracking national portfolios and assessing results Sub-regional Workshop for GEF Focal Points in West and Central Africa June 2008, Douala, Cameroon.

Slide no. 1 © South African Tourism 2011 Click to edit Master subtitle style SA Tourism Presentation of the SA Tourism to Portfolio Meeting Tuesday 6 September.

IFAD Reform towards a better development effectiveness How can we all do better? Mohamed Tounessi Bamba Zoumana Virginia Cameroon Retreat 4-5 November.

Corporate-level Evaluation on IFAD’s Private Sector Development and Partnership Strategy 6 th Special Session of the IFAD Evaluation Committee 9 May 2011.

Independent Office of Evaluation The Gambia Country Programme Evaluation 2015: Main Findings and Recommendations National Roundtable Workshop Banjul, 3.

2009 An Overview of programmes. Overview Current country programmes – Ghana, Rwanda Transitioned country programmes – Namibia Potential new country programmes.

Monitoring Afghanistan, 2015 Food Security and Agriculture Working Group – 9 December 2015.

INFRASTRUCTURE AND HUMAN SETTLEMENTS Presentation by Delegation of the European Union Consultative Group Meeting Technical Session La Palm, Accra, 23/09/2010.

THE INDEPENDENT OFFICE OF EVALUATION’S WORK PROGRAMME FOR September 2013.

September 2005 DEA: First National Workshop 1 Development and Energy in Africa First National Workshop: Tanzania 12 September 2005 Introduction Gordon.

African Centre for Statistics United Nations Economic Commission for Africa Proposed Regional Medium-term Civil Registration and Vital Statistics Plan.

Croatia: Result orientation within the process of preparation of programming documents V4+ Croatia and Slovenia Expert Level Conference Budapest,

Danida support to the microfinance industry. Overall objectives of Denmark’s development cooperation Overall objective To combat poverty and promote human.

The Global Partnership Monitoring Framework Indicator on Use of Results Framework Seoul GP Annual Workshop Indicator Clinic 6 November 2014effectivecooperation.org.

Reporting, Monitoring and Evaluation Giovanni Rum, Chao Xing GEO Secretariat GEO Work Programme Symposium Geneva, 2-4 May 2016.

AFRICAN RENAISSANCE AND INTERNATIONAL CO-OPERATION FUND ANNUAL REPORT 2015/16 Presentation to Portfolio Committee on International Relations and Cooperation.

Brazil Country Programme Evaluation

End of Year Performance Review Meetings and objective setting for 2018/19 This briefing pack is designed to be used by line managers to brief their teams.

Statistics Governance and Quality Assurance: the Experience of FAO

Evaluation in the GEF and Training Module on Terminal Evaluations

Statistics in the Enlargement context

Proposed Regional Medium-term Civil Registration and Vital Statistics Plan First Conference of African Ministers Responsible for Civil Registration August.

Pilot River Basin Water Framework Directive.

Roles and Responsibilities

Role of Evaluation coordination group and Capacity Building Projects in Lithuania Vilija Šemetienė Head of Economic Analysis and Evaluation Division.

Presentation transcript:

2004 Portfolio Review 2005 Project Implementation Workshop, Bamako 2004 Portfolio Review: Main Findings

2004 Portfolio Review 2004 Portfolio Review: Main Findings What is the portfolio review? Status of the regional portfolio Performance indicators and ratings Implementation performance Major problems Crucial challenges Proposed indicators to improve the regional portfolio 2004 Portfolio Review: Main Findings

2004 Portfolio Review What is the regional portfolio review? Tool to analyse and assess the structure and quality of the regional portfolio –identify management issues at IFAD level –provide appropriate responses –basis for corporate reporting to IFAD’s governing bodies –provide input for PBAS –aggregate and analyse RIMS indicators Process is staff-driven –Project and country levels: Review of data available –Preparation of project status reports and country programme issues sheets (based on supervision reports) –Country review meetings with all relevant IFAD staff –Revision, aggregation and analysis of inputs at a regional level –Draft version, comments –Finalisation Period covered: 1 July 2003 – 30 June 2004

2004 Portfolio Review Status of the regional portfolio Current portfolio: 18 active countries 55 loan projects, 39 ongoing, $ 660 million Geographic imbalance –35 ongoing projects in 11 West African countries –only 4 ongoing projects in 3 Central African Countries Reactivation of loan portfolio in 3 post-conflict countries (Congo, DR Congo and Sierra Leone) No loan projects in 6 countries, Cote d’Ivoire “frozen” In general, quality and impact of the regional project portfolio has improved

2004 Portfolio Review Performance Indicators and Ratings Classification of ratings 1Above or on target Good ratings 2Mostly on target 3Substantially below target Risk Flags for low ratings 4Little or no progress Rating system: Project-at-Risk Methodology Indicators influence performance ratings and country allocations

2004 Portfolio Review Implementation performance 20% of effective projects show a disbursement lag of ≥ 40% Project management performance remains a concern in many countries Performance of Cooperating Institutions –Only in 35% of projects, supervision is found to be problem-free –54% with moderate problems –10% projects with major problems

2004 Portfolio Review Portfolio Performance PAR Classification Number of Projects % % Project Not at Risk Potential Problem Project 0000 Actual Problem Project Not Rated0025 Total

2004 Portfolio Review Areas of Low Performance

2004 Portfolio Review Project management performance remains a concern Measures –Regional Management Capacity Strengthening Programme –Regional M&E Capacity Strengthening Programme –Follow-up of case-specific supervision and mid-term review recommendations –Redesigning problematic project components as appropriate

2004 Portfolio Review Crucial challenges Manage time to achieve results (planning/implementation) of project cycle –Average time laps from approval to loan signature 3.4 months –Average time laps from signature to start-up 1 year –Low disbursement performance during implementation Manage quality throughout the cycle based on responsibilities assigned to the partners –Government: Ownership and implementation –Cooperating Institution: Basic Supervision/Implementation Support –IFAD: Ensure good governance in resource use

2004 Portfolio Review Proposed indicators to improve the portfolio By 2006, resources used annually for implementation support increased by at least 30% depending on needs identified in cooperation with the PCU, CPM and CI. By 2006, there are no projects rated at risk in the region. By 2007, low ratings are below 10% for all implementation performance indicators in ongoing projects. By 2008, all ongoing and new projects have action plans to improve performance of their M&E systems.