DEPARTMENT OF ECONOMICS CONFERENCE ON THE ECONOMY (COTE)

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
DOES ECONOMIC GROWTH ALWAYS REDUCE POVERTY? MARC WUYTS INSTITUTE OF SOCIAL STUDIES ERASMUS UNIVERSITY OF ROTTERDAM.
Advertisements

WORK AND PENSIONS SELECT COMMITTEE: Labour market seminar: 26 TH February: ‘Trends in part-time working and short-term employment contracts and the impacts.
What has happened to inequality and poverty in post-apartheid South Africa Dr Max Price Vice-Chancellor University of Cape Town.
Conference on Irish Economic Policy Union membership and the union wage Premium in Ireland Frank Walsh School of Economics University College Dublin
Storybook 01: South Africa’s Economic Output STANLIB Economics.
Inflation Chapter 7 Copyright © 2010 by the McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved. McGraw-Hill/Irwin Principles of Economics: Macroeconomics.
Mr. Weiss Unit 5 Vocabulary Words 1. gross domestic product (GDP); 2. inflation; 3. real GDP; 4. consumer price index (CPI) _____total dollar value of.
The Effects of Rising Food and Fuel Costs on Poverty in Pakistan Azam Amjad Chaudhry and Theresa Thompson Chaudhry.
1 Poor or Poverty Generally, a person who is unable to satisfy his basic food and non- food(education,health,housing..etc.) requirements can be considered.
Chapter 19 Aggregate Demand and Aggregate Supply
Public policy and European society University of Castellanza Session 3(a) Inequality and poverty in Europe and the USA November
Reinert/Windows on the World Economy, 2005 Development Concepts CHAPTER 19.
Australian Governments Economic Goals Low Inflation Strong and sustainable economic growth Full employment Equity in the distribution of Income External.
MONITORING JOBS AND INFLATION
Chapter 10 Inflation and Unemployment
Palestinian Central Bureau of Statistics (PCBS) Palestine Poverty Maps 2009 March
© Institute for Fiscal Studies Child poverty, tax and benefit policy and the labour market since Robert Joyce.
POVERTY PRESENTATION AT UNDP OFFICE POVERTY STATUS AND TREND IN TANZANIA MAINLAND, /12 Presented by Sango A. H. Simba National Bureau of Statistics.
2000/2001 Household Budget Survey (HBS) Conducted by The National Bureau of Statistics.
dp Farm, Rural and Urban Families and the Incidence of Low Income in Canada Second Meeting of the Wye City Group on Statistics on Rural Development.
Constructing the Welfare Aggregate Part 2: Adjusting for Differences Across Individuals Bosnia and Herzegovina Poverty Analysis Workshop September 17-21,
Measuring poverty and inequality in the Republic of Belarus Inna Konoshonok Head of the Living Standards Statistics and Household Survey Department NATIONAL.
The new HBS Chisinau, 26 October Outline 1.How the HBS changed 2.Assessment of data quality 3.Data comparability 4.Conclusions.
Effects of Income Imputation on Traditional Poverty Estimates The views expressed here are the authors and do not represent the official positions.
Measuring population development from social cohesion perspective by women and men according to the Census data Urve Kask Statistics Estonia.
The distribution of the State budget Total budget: 298 billion NIS, 2005 chart 1.
Allocating Spending Afternoon Session Part I. Topics Allocating Spending to Children –Direct methods: Per Capita and USDA –Indirect methods: Engel and.
Incentives and the Welfare State James Mirrlees University of Melbourne and Chinese University of Hong Kong Trevor Swan Lecture ANU 13 March 2008.
Brief Review of Lecture 4 on the Japanese Economy --- The Japanese economy is growing faster now than in the past. Currently, the annualized QoQ growth.
Chapter 11 Measuring the Cost of Living
© 2011 Pearson Education The CPI and the Cost of Living 22 When you have completed your study of this chapter, you will be able to 1 Explain what the.
Poverty Ms. C. Rughoobur Africa Statistics Day 18 November 2013.
Employment, unemployment and economic activity Coventry working age population by disability status Source: Annual Population Survey, Office for National.
Social Costs of the Asian Economic Crisis Yinglan Tan — Department of Economics, Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania Faculty Advisor:
Integrating a Gender Perspective into Statistics Selected topic: Poverty Statistics S. Nunhuck Statistics Mauritius.
Relative poverty in Scotland decreased in 2013/14 Communities Analysis Division– September 2015 In Scotland, relative poverty, before housing costs, fell.
Passive Investors and Managed Money in Commodity Futures Part 2: Liquidity Prepared for: The CME Group Prepared by: October, 2008.
Chapter 8 Inflation McGraw-Hill/Irwin Copyright © 2012 by The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved.
Department of Social Work and Social Administration UNIVERSITY OF HONG KONG Poverty Reduction Strategy – Singapore M Ramesh.
Poverty: Defined and Explained. Measuring Poverty Government Definition –Recently revised by the Census Bureau to include many of the criticisms from.
Michael Rogan & John Reynolds. Content International context International Labour Organisation SA context Income, wages & earnings over post-apartheid.
Social Welfare Policy Contending with Poverty In America.
Household food insecurity among low-income Toronto families: Implications for social policy Sharon Kirkpatrick & Valerie Tarasuk Department of Nutritional.
5 CHAPTER Measuring GDP and Economic Growth.
Additional analysis of poverty in Scotland 2013/14 Communities Analytical Services July 2015.
Adjusting for Family Composition and Size Module 4: Poverty Measurement and Analysis February, 2008.
How do we measure the changing value of money? Transformers: Revenge of the Fallen earned $400 million at the box office. Gone with the Wind earned $200.
Interstate Statistical Committee of the Commonwealth of Independent States (CIS STAT) Methodological approaches to measuring core inflation in the CIS.
Gregory Mankiw. Three Macroeconomic Variables 1. Real GDP- A. It grows overtime. B. It is not steady 2. Inflation Rate- 3. Unemployment rate A. Varies.
Data and Construction of Economic Table Washington Child Support Group December 2007 Session I.
WYE City Group Meeting on Rural Development and Agricultural Household Income Rome, June 2009 Anna Szukielojc-Bienkunska, CSO Poland
Poverty in Scotland and the UK Communities Analysis Division– September 2015 While relative poverty in Scotland fell in 2013/14, it remained flat in the.
Poverty and Income Inequality in Edinburgh September 2015.
Constructing the Welfare Aggregate Part 2: Adjusting for Differences Across Individuals Salman Zaidi Washington DC, January 19th,
Brief Review of Lecture 4 on the Japanese Economy --- The Japanese economy is growing faster now than in the past. Currently, the annualized QoQ growth.
BDO Monthly Business Trends Indices November 2010 Page 1 Current Confidence Index BDO Output Index BDO Optimism Index Movement in Month BDO Inflation Index.
By R. Gambacorta and A. Neri Bank of Italy - Statistical Analysis Directorate Wealth and its returns: economic inequality in Italy, The Bank.
Introduction to the UK Economy. What are the key objectives of macroeconomic policy? Price Stability (CPI Inflation of 2%) Growth of Real GDP (National.
€£$¥ Understanding Economics, © Richard Delaney, 2008, Edco CPI and Inflation The Consumer Price Index and Measurement of Inflation.
Persons in Family or Household 48 Contiguous States and D.C. AlaskaHawaii 1$10,400$13,000$11, ,00017,50016, ,60022,00020, ,20026,50024,380.
The CPI and the Cost of Living CHAPTER 6 C H A P T E R C H E C K L I S T When you have completed your study of this chapter, you will be able to 1 Explain.
Global extreme poverty rates for children, adults and the elderly 2013 CSAE conference / March 19 / Oxford / Cockburn Yélé Batana, Maurizio Bussolo and.
How do we know when we are better off?.  Satisfy our wants and needs  We do this through purchasing goods and services  Goods and services gives us.
POVERTY IN KENYA, 1994 – 1997: A STOCHASTIC DOMINANCE APPROACH.
As in the past – 5 focus areas & 23 indicators
International Labour Office
GDP Gross Domestic Product
Statistics Time Series
Poverty and household spending in Britain
Poverty and Inequality Statistics: Development of Methodology in the Russian Federation Geneva, 5-6 May 2015.
Presentation transcript:

DEPARTMENT OF ECONOMICS CONFERENCE ON THE ECONOMY (COTE) October 8th – 9th 2008 INCOME POVERTY AND STATE SUPPORT IN TRINIDAD AND TOBAGO: THE CASE FOR ALIGNMENT Karl Theodore and Ewan Scott   Labour Market and Poverty Studies Unit Department of Economics UWI October 9, 2008

OBJECTIVE The primary objective is threefold. First we would like to determine whether the poverty situation in Trinidad and Tobago has trended upwards or downwards since it was last officially measured in 2005. Second we would like to determine the extent of the support given to low income households by the state. Finally, putting the two sets of results together, we will open the case for developing a new poverty measure for Trinidad and Tobago.

CONTEXT The buoyancy of the economy is without question: per capita real income doubling between 1998 and 2008 (99.6%) Continuation of an upward trend for past decade is prima facie evidence that generally living conditions in the country are improving. Evidence from other places shows that even when average incomes are increasing there might be no change whatsoever in the poverty rate Same for T&T?

Quotable quotes For the USA we read that ”the inflation-adjusted incomes of median households rose by 1.3% in 2007 from the previous year, from $49,568 in 2006 to $50,233 in 2007 (2007 dollars), while the overall poverty rate increased slightly, from 12.3% to 12.5%.” Jared Bernstein(2008) For New York City in particular, it was found that “median income rose slightly from 2005 to 2006, but the number of people living in poverty also increased. The poverty rate remained stubbornly resistant at about one person in five…” Sam Roberts, New York Times, August 28, 2007, 

Study Approach Poverty estimates for Trinidad and Tobago have traditionally come from the Household Budget Surveys (HBS) done by the CSO or, more recently, on Surveys of Living Conditions (SLC). Since up-to-date HBS data are not available and since the last SLC was done in 2005, the attempt to determine poverty trend since 2005 will be based on the CSSP data produced by the CSO. Thanks to CSO for providing us with the datasets which made the poverty estimation possible.

LIMITATIONS There are at least five sources of overestimation of poverty levels using the CSSP data:   To the extent that some households may have no members employed and hence no employment income, at the outset such households will be categorized as poor. Income is thought to have a larger transitory component than consumption making it a less reliable indicator of welfare potential; Income sources are usually more diverse than consumption, highlighting the need for a wider range of survey questions, and making income a more difficult variable to measure; It is a widely accepted claim that incomes tend to be under-reported by respondents in a survey. In addition, there may be instances of non-reporting of employment income by members in some households thereby lowering the total income for such households.

METHODOLOGY Using the CSSP data, the procedure for arriving at an estimate of the poverty level for 2008 is necessarily different from that used in respect of the SLC data.  Given the absence of consumption expenditure data in the CSSP, and thus inability to compute Engel coefficients, computation of the poverty line is an adaptation. The 2008 poverty line was arrived at by inflating the 2005 SLC poverty line by the year-on-year changes in the CPI. By this procedure, the 2008 poverty line was found to be TT$815 per adult per month.   As a basis for comparison, CSSP poverty estimates were computed by applying the SLC 2005 poverty line of $665 to the 2005 CSSP data. A household was deemed to be poor if its per capita employment income in adult equivalence fell below the poverty line.

RESULTS Shown in the diagram are the two different sets of poverty estimates for Trinidad and Tobago over the period 1997 to 2008: CSSP in blue and SLC in red. The data are shown in the Table below.

Poverty estimates CSSP data (quarters, 2,3) CSSP Headcount Index % SLC Headcount Index 1997 29.25 24 2005 22.95 16.7 2008* 18.00 - For 2008 only first quarter data are available

COMMENT What we see in the diagram is that although the CSSP poverty estimate is consistently higher than the SLC estimate, as expected, the trend in both estimates is almost exactly the same between 1997 and 2005. In both cases poverty is shown to be falling at almost the same rate. We note that according to the CSSP, in the period 2005 to 2008 poverty fell at a faster rate than before. If the SLC estimate for 2008 follows the same pattern we will expect the 2008 SLC estimate, when it is produced, not only to be lower than its 2005 counterpart of 16.7% but also to show a speeding up in the decline of poverty.

STATE SUPPORT OF LOW INCOME HOUSEHOLDS In the Table below we present a summary of the monthly value of the support that is made available to the poorer households of the country. Since the data on some grants and subsidies were not available in a form to be readily converted into monthly values these grants and subsidies have been omitted. The figures presented are therefore underestimates of the true level of support. The information is presented on the basis of the composition of low-income households in the country. For present purposes we identify five household categories.  

Composition of Five 5-person Households (Selected from SLC Combinations) Household Type 1: 1 adult (unemployed) 4 children (2 primary; 2 secondary) Household Type 2: 1 adult (employed) 4 children (2 primary; 2 secondary, including 1 disabled) Household Type 3: 2 adults (employed) 3 children (2 primary; 1 secondary) Household Type 4: 3 adults (1 employed; 1 unemployed; 1 elderly) 2 children (1 primary; 1 secondary) Household Type 5: 4 adults (1 employed; 1 unemployed; 1 elderly; 1 disabled) 1 child (1 secondary)

MONEY VALUE OF BENEFITS (MONTHLY) FROM SELECTED SUPPORT INSTRUMENTS, BY SELECTED HOUSEHOLD COMBINATIONS (1) 2008 POVERTY LINE = $815 No. Support Instruments H/Hold 1 H/Hold 2 H/Hold 3 H/Hold 4 H/Hold 5 $0 0<$ 500 < $1,500 <$ 1,000 < $1,000 Selected Grants & Subsidies: 1. Education Grant 560 420 280 140 2. Textbook Rental/Loan 696 348 232 3. School Transportation 756 567 378 189 4. Schools Nutrition Prog. 1,304 652 326 5. CDAP 52.30 104.60 6. Food Debit Card 400 7. Old Age Pension / Senior Citizens’ Grant - 1,650

MONEY VALUE OF BENEFITS (MONTHLY) FROM SELECTED SUPPORT INSTRUMENTS, BY SELECTED HOUSEHOLD COMBINATIONS (2) 2008 POVERTY LINE = $815 Monthly Income ($TT) No. Support Instruments H/Hold 1 H/Hold 2 H/Hold 3 H/Hold 4 H/Hold 5 $0 $0< 500 <$ 1,500 < $1,000 Selected Grants & Subsidies: 8. Public Assistance Prog 650 - 9. Disability Assistance Pro 1,100 10. Fuel Subsidy 36 11. Type 1 benefit 800 Total monthly benefits ($TT) 5,254.3 6,354.3 3,623.3 5,298.6 5,575.3 ANNUAL TOTAL SUPPORT ($TT) 63,051.6 76,251.6 43,479.6 63,583.2 66,903.6

CONCLUDING COMMENT Three conclusions seem to be warranted: In spite of its upward bias the CSSP poverty estimate faithfully mirrors the downward trend in the SLC estimate The money value of available income support for low-income households vastly exceeds the poverty line Traditional poverty estimates which exclude the impact of the income support will tend to overstate the poverty levels in the country. The prima facie case for a new measure of poverty in T&T seems to be a strong one.