Health Sciences and Practice Subject Centre Ethics Special Interest Group 24 th April 2009 Helen Allan, Pam Smith.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Practical Learning: Achieving Excellence in the Human Services International Conference January 2008 Edinburgh International Conference Centre.
Advertisements

1 CPD, Workforce Development and GEES: How do we respond? Sharon Gedye GEES Subject Centre.
Dr Linda Allin Division of Sport Sciences The value of real life evaluation research for student learning and employability in Sports Development.
Ofsted ITE Inspection Briefing PCET trainees, ex-MMU PCET trainees, Course Team Leaders, Mentors and Quality Managers.
Dr Linda Allin Division of Sport Sciences Developing Staff and Student Engagement with up to date Evaluation Research in Sports Development.
School nursing – a fresh look Learning more about this unique career may surprise you. School nursing has changed a lot - and it’s still changing. June.
Objectives: To describe and explain examples of positive working practice with respect to individuals with additional needs To state how working practices.
Building Rapport Interpersonal skills of care workers were as important as practical skills and knowing how to do the job. Having a positive attitude could.
The Shirlie Project A clear view of Supported Employment in the Highlands Autism Network Scotland June 2013 June 2013.
Forms of racism and discrimination in career progression in the NHS: Evidence from Ghanaian nurses and midwives Leroi Henry Department of Economics The.
Monitoring and evaluation of carers’ services and projects Dr Andrea Wigfield - Associate Professor of Social Policy Centre for International Research.
‘Here for You’ Improving the Patient Experience Presented by Sally Quinn Deputy Director of HR & OD 03/05/2015.
Effective Questioning & Challenge – developing the right skills to get your views across.
Maggie Roberts on behalf of the Nottingham Team (Carol Hall, Mary Brown and Aaron Fecowycz) The University of Nottingham, UK. Wo r k I n g Across Borders.
International Staff in UK Business Schools: Difficulties and Student Perception Magda Abou-Seada & Michael Sherer BMAF Teaching Research and Development.
Only the best will do: How Nottinghamshire Healthcare involves service users and carers in recruiting staff.
Skills for Life Improvement Programme Professional Development Planning for literacy, language and numeracy The Skills for Life Improvement.
Ever thought about volunteering? A short introduction to the benefits of volunteering and how to start.
“The Lewisham Edge Project: An apprenticeship model for in-service vocational teacher training” Lewisham College Edge Foundation London South Bank University.
The Impact on Practice (ImP) Project: A framework to maximise the impact of continuing professional education on practice Liz Clark, Jan Draper and Shelagh.
Equality and Diversity: Resource for Level 4 students
Supervising Students in Social Work Placements in Wales and the U.K. Paula McCreary. Tutor and Placement Coordinator, Dept. of Applied Social Science,
Acknowledgements Skills for Care, Skills for Health and Health Education England would like to express their appreciation and thanks for everyone who contributed.
The LCVP is funded by the Department of Education and Science under the National Development Plan Preparing students for Work Experience.
The Dance Leadership Continuum for Young People Level One Key Stage 4 Level Two Key Stage 5 Level Three Key Stage 5 KS5 + Award in Dance Leadership Foundation.
Using a Board game to enhance mentor engagement within nurse education in practice settings Jo Hirdle and Belinda Humphries University Practice Learning.
Into Teaching Promoting access for disabled people Tony Stevens How do you make change happen? LINK Conference, Antwerp July 2011.
Dementia does not discriminate: the experiences of black, Asian and minority ethnic communities Alli Anthony, Alzheimer’s Society ________________________________________________________________________________________.
Prepared by London Pharmacy Education & Training 2011 based on previous work by North Thames and South Thames Pharmacy Education & Training March 2000.
Steve Flinders, York Associates and Ian McMaster, Business Spotlight ETAS 28 th Convention Yverdon-les-Bains Sunday, 29 January 2012 Communicating Internationally.
Teachership Lifelong Learning (TeLL) Making Mentoring a Resource in the Teacher’s Work TeLL Conference Jyväskylä Mentoring in Supporting Newly.
Health Sciences and Practice Subject Centre Mental Health Special Interest Group 22 nd April 2009 Tracy Lindsay & Jenny Oates.
Teaching for Diversity Dr Gill Cooke 15 February 2013 HEA STEM Workshop for Postgraduates who Teach.
The Important Role of Ward Sisters / Charge Nurses in HSC Trusts Alan Corry Finn Executive Director of Nursing / Director of Primary Care & Older People’s.
Educational Solutions for Workforce Development Unit 8 – How to Evaluate Aim To provide an overview of how to effectively evaluate learning programmes.
PRIMARY SCIENCE Education Consultancy Primary Science Quality Mark Funded by the Wellcome Trust.
Jill Rutland My Background Public Health Library Service to Public Health Professionals Need to reach out to ‘frontline’ staff Interested to know.
Professional perspectives on palliative care services for people with dementia in England Nathan Davies Laura Maio Dr Krish Vedavanam Professor Jill Manthorpe.
Providing mentor support for practice educators in training Exploring and evaluating approaches used by Bournemouth University 2010.
1 Intercultural Teaching and Learning in a PBL Environment Lars Peter Jensen, Xiangyun Du.
Helen Donnellan, RE:Search South-West, University of Plymouth.
Kerry Cleary An evaluation of the impact of Values Based Interviewing at the OUH Values Based Conversations and wider engagement strategies.
Extending the librarian role A Conversation Briefing with Linda Ward, Library Services Manager, University Hospitals of Leicester NHS Trust.
Amanda Garrow & Samantha Shann PPDF Working group.
Diversity and Equality Interview and Questionnaire Results.
CENTRE FOR EXCELLENCE IN TEACHING & LEARNING ASSESSMENT FOR LEARNING CETL Associates Project Angelina Wilson and Nicola Reimann CENTRE FOR EXCELLENCE IN.
Resident Impact Pam Lupo, CO Director of Orthotics and Post Breast Surgery Care.
Appraisal Skills with Charan Sarai Practice Manager Adviser.
Partnership Working – Mentorship and Supporting Students in Practice A Regulator’s Perspective.
Says Janet Cooper Faith Cross Stoke Speaks Out. Stoke Speaks Out history.. Stoke Speaks Out is a multi-agency City wide programme aimed at tackling the.
Preventing avoidable inpatient admissions: a qualitative study of mental health liaison nurse practice using the Think Aloud technique. Iain Hepworth Linda.
Graduate School of Medicine University of Wollongong Educators learning together and modeling interprofessional collaboration Sue Vella, Sal Sanzone, Helen.
DISCUSSION FOR DIVERSITY AND TALENT MANAGEMENT AT THE WORKPLACE.
Becoming the professional: The experiences of final year physiotherapy students on practice placement in the acute setting NAEP Conference 2016 Charlotte.
Race for Equality – A report on the experiences of Black students in further and higher education
Kerry Pace ~ Diverse Learners Michelle Sisson ~ Diverse Learners Michelle Cowen ~ University of Southampton Dyslexia tutors: “We don’t do the essays for.
Annual Conference 31 st May 2012 ‘Raising the Bar’ Mario Kreft, MBE Director, Pendine Park Care Organisation Chair, Care Forum Wales.
Maximising the Nursing Team
Race Matters: A report on the experiences of Black staff in the student movement NUS Regional Meetings – January 2015.
Consultation: Your Say ….
Experiences of Clinical Assessment and the Competency Assessment Process in Midwifery Midwifery Lecturer and Doctoral Student Carmel Bradshaw Supervisors.
Starting out on a clinical academic pathway: the experience of a newly- qualified nurse Sarah Lea Faculty of Health and Social Care, London South Bank.
Early Clinical Career Fellowships ECCF 2011 Introduction
BSHS 345 TUTOR Education Your Life-- bshs345tutor.com.
Sector Engagement Advisor, North of England
‘See Me’: Exploring unmet need among young adults in Bristol
Dr Lisa Collins Dr Rebecca Farrington Manchester medical school
Sector Engagement Advisor, Midlands
The Huddle: training opportunities
Presentation transcript:

Health Sciences and Practice Subject Centre Ethics Special Interest Group 24 th April 2009 Helen Allan, Pam Smith

Mentoring overseas nurses: a cautionary tale of managing diversity Helen Allan, Pam Smith http//:portal.surrey.ac.uk/reoh Allan, Henry, Larsen, Mackintosh & Smith

What do we teach in ethics and why? Unconnected episodes during data collection in two projects suggest that nurses find managing diversity in clinical practice difficult and that they don’t know where to ‘talk’ about it.

Data – clinical learning study funded by GNC Trust and REOH study Nurse Director reflected on her lack of understanding of ethnic monitoring (REOH); Lack of awareness or at the very least accommodation of cultural difference in clinical learning (REOH); Clinical nurse leads, practice educators, ward managers reflected on how difficult being honest about different learning styles was (GNC study)

Three: “ … people just don’t seem to do as much in handover, or [ask] why we are doing that. It’s not just because of people’s hesitation to that but I think it’s the also the response they get for doing that. I’ve got a couple of Sisters who work very much in that way and that’s the way I used to work. I don’t know rightly or wrongly. I guess you are putting people on the spot but as long you don’t humiliate them in that circumstance. But some of the staff have not reacted very well and as a pack have really affected the way the system now works. I think that’s got a lot to do with the challenging as well. R: And why is that? Three: I guess because they feel slightly threatened. R: But they presumably have been educated within the same system. All: No.

Three: A lot of our workforce haven’t been educated in the same system and that is something that culturally there are differences and training wise, it’s not a question of knowledge base or anything like that, but it is a system that is different and I think for a lot of the staff they haven’t experienced that so therefore if somebody… in the workforce that feel very hierarchical, if the Matron knows something and [it’s] not for you to be part of a team. … And breaking down those barriers and preconceived ideas has actually been quite difficult, to get a team that’s gelled and feel that yes, you can challenge, you can approach, you can do all of those things, and that’s never really been an issue for me. You go up to the Ward Sister, you talk to her, believe you me in our day when we trained some of them were pretty scary people, but you would go up and you would approach and you’d be part of a team; and that’s been quite difficult for some of our staff and I know that’s been a difficulty.

Four: I think there’s a huge under-estimation of differences in communication terms, everything. I think there are huge differences and it makes a hell of a difference to the care we’re delivering, and I don’t think people take that on board”.

Background 1 Evidence –Overseas nurses face discrimination & barriers to employment (Allan & Larsen 2003; Back 2003) We lack respect! –Fail to access learning opportunities & CPD (Allan & Larsen 2003)

Background 2 Induction courses fail to meet ONs’ training or/and educational needs –“culture shock” Lack of preparatory materials about British life Language and communication courses fail to meet ONs’ needs –Tests make this organisationally more difficult now Expectation on ONS to adapt not UK workforce

Researching Equal Opportunities for Overseas Nurses Project European Social Fund –January 2004 – June 2006 Structured qualitative interviews –3 case study regions N, Wales & SE 72 ONs; 38 British mentors & managers –Ghanaian case SE 25 ONs

Main finding Learning in the workforce –Lack of organisational thinking around how cultural differences affect mentoring and learning for both overseas nurses and their mentors I just wondered, you mentioned cultural awareness, I just wondered if you’d thought about mentor preparation. Mentor preparation, well mentorship is already within the organisation because we have pre registration students, so as a part of fitness for practice, which is the programme all pre reg students are following currently, they have mentorship preparation. At the end of the day, we cannot wrap them up in cotton wool, they are qualified nurses in their own right, from their own Country, but we need to assess and they will be provided with effective support.

Barriers to lifelong learning Mentoring Cultural differences Racism The British way Skills Standards of British nursing Induction

What do we teach and why? Another question might be where? Linking theory and practice for students at pre- reg and post reg levels Re-contexualising professional knowledge across education and workplace

Contact Us Health Sciences and Practice Subject Centre Higher Education Academy