Is there evidence of planets in debris disks? Mark Wyatt Institute of Astronomy University of Cambridge La planètmania frappe les astronomes Kalas, P.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Debris disks with CCAT Jane Greaves: ~2012??
Advertisements

Spitzer IRS Spectroscopy of IRAS-Discovered Debris Disks Christine H. Chen (NOAO) IRS Disks Team astro-ph/
Proto-Planetary Disk and Planetary Formation
Resonant Structures due to Planets Mark Wyatt UK Astronomy Technology Centre Royal Observatory Edinburgh.
ExoZodical Emission and ExoPlanets: Ground-based Challenges C. Beichman (NASA Exoplanet Science Institute) With lots of help from A. Tanner (Georgia State),
Planetary Migration and Extrasolar Planets in the 2:1 Mean-Motion Resonance (short review) Renate Zechner im Rahmen des Astrodynamischen Seminars basierend.
Signatures of Planets in Debris Disks A. Moro-Martin 1,2,3, S. Wolf 2, R. Malhotra 4 & G. Rieke 1 1. Steward Observatory (University of Arizona); 2. MPIA.
Are Planets in Unresolved Candidates of Debris Disks Stars? R. de la Reza (1), C. Chavero (1), C.A.O. Torres (2) & E. Jilinski (1) ( 1) Observatorio Nacional.
Are Planets in Unresolved Candidates of Debris disks stars? R. de la Reza (1), C. Chavero (1), C.A.O. Torres (2) & E. Jilinski (1) (1) Observatorio Nacional.
1 Concluding Panel Al Glassgold Sienny Shang Jonathan Williams David Wilner.
Dust Dynamics in Debris Gaseous Disks Taku Takeuchi (Kobe Univ., Japan) 1.Dynamics of Dust - gas drag - radiation 2. Estimate of Gas Mass 3. Dust Disk.
Depletion and excitation of the asteroid belt by migrating planets Kevin J. Walsh, Alessandro Morbidelli (SwRI,OCA-Nice) Sean N. Raymond (Obs. Bordeaux),
High-resolution Imaging of Debris Disks Jane Greaves St Andrews University, Scotland.
Image: ISAS/JAXA Christopher Stark University of Maryland NASA Goddard Space Flight Center Collisional Grooming: Including Collisions in (Prohibitively.
Debris Disks, Small Bodies, and Planets Alexander V. Krivov Astrophysical Institute and University Observatory Friedrich Schiller University Jena 4th Planet.
1 Debris Disk Studies with CCAT D. Dowell, J. Carpenter, H. Yorke 2005 October 11.
Extrasolar Planets More that 500 extrasolar planets have been discovered In 46 planetary systems through radial velocity surveys, transit observations,
February 10-11, 2011ANR EXOZODI Kick-Off meeting Transient dynamical events. The FEB hypothesis  Pictoris and Vega Hervé Beust Institut de Planétologie.
1 Why exoplanets have so high eccentricities - By Line Drube - November 2004.
The `Nice’ Model Öpik approximation Planet migration in a planetesimal disk The Nice model Consequences of the Nice Model: Epoch of Late Heavy Bombardment,
10Nov2006 Ge/Ay133 More on Jupiter, Neptune, the Kuiper belt, and the early solar system.
Spitzer Space Telescope Observations of the Fomalhaut Debris Disk Michael Werner, Karl Stapelfeldt, Chas Beichman (JPL); Kate Su, George Rieke, John Stansberry,
Sculpting Circumstellar Disks Feb 2008 Alice Quillen University of Rochester.
Sculpting Circumstellar Disks Netherlands April 2007 Alice Quillen University of Rochester.
« Debris » discs A crash course in numerical methods Philippe Thébault Paris Observatory/Stockholm Observatory.
How did the Solar System form? Is our solar system unique? Are there other Earth-like planets, or are we a fluke? Under what conditions can Earth-like.
Zodiacal Cloud: The Local Circumstellar Disk Sumita Jayaraman.
Mass Distribution and Planet Formation in the Solar Nebula Steve Desch School of Earth and Space Exploration Arizona State University Lunar and Planetary.
Solar System Read Your Textbook: Introduction to Physical Science –Chapter 20 –Chapter Answer Questions –Chapter 20: Q4;P1,4,6,9 W3 –Chapter 21:
A new class of warm debris disks? Rachel Smith, Institute for Astronomy; Mark Wyatt, Abstract.
Decoding Dusty Debris Disks AAAS, Februrary 2014 David J Wilner Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics.
Doug Johnstone: Former Associate Director JCMT, NRC Herzberg, Univ. Victoria JCMT: Debris Discs and Miscellaneous Sciences.
Is there evidence of planets in debris disks? Mark Wyatt Institute of Astronomy University of Cambridge La planètmania frappe les astronomes Kalas, P.
AST3020. Lecture 09 Theory of transitional and debris disks The roles of radiation pressure Beta Pictoris as a young solar system Some observed examples.
Planets in Debris Disks Renu Malhotra University of Arizona Planet-Debris co-evolution Where can debris exist? Cases: Solar system, upsilon Andromedae,
Infrared Signatures of Planetary Systems Amaya Moro-Martin Department of Astrophysical Sciences, Princeton University.
Modeling Planetary Systems Around Sun-like Stars Paper: Formation and Evolution of Planetary Systems: Cold Outer Disks Associated with Sun-like Stars,
October 20, 2005 Nearly Resolved Debris Disks STScI, Baltimore Hervé Beust Laboratoire d’Astrophysique de Grenoble, France FOST group The origin of the.
David Nesvorny (Southwest Research Institute) David Nesvorny (Southwest Research Institute) Capture of Irregular Satellites during Planetary Encounters.
Alice Quillen University of Rochester Department of Physics and Astronomy Oct, 2005 Submillimet er imaging by Greaves and collaborato rs.
The PSI Planet-building Code: Multi-zone, Multi-use S. J. Weidenschilling PSI Retreat August 20, 2007.
The ε Eridani debris disk Jane Greaves St Andrews, Scotland with Wayne Holland, Mark Wyatt & Bill Dent and cast of thousands...
Origin of Our Solar System
The AU Mic Debris Ring Density profiles & Dust Dynamics J.-C. Augereau & H. Beust Grenoble Observatory (LAOG)
Solar System Formation Solar System Comprised of a star and the planets that orbit the star Binary – Two stars at center of system –Eclipsing is when.
The Origin of the Solar System. I. The Great Chain of Origins A. Early Hypotheses B. A Review of the Origin of Matter C. The Solar Nebula Hypothesis D.
Astronomy 340 Fall December 2007 Class #29.
Are transition discs much commoner in M stars? Recent claim that 50% of discs around M stars are in transition (Sicilia-Aguilar et al 2008) CAREFUL! For.
Millimeter Observations of the  Pic and AU Mic Debris Disks David J. Wilner Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics NASA/JPL-Caltech/T. Pyle S.Andrews,
Ge/Ay133 Can we study extrasolar Kuiper Belts?  Pic, A5V star AU Mic, M1Ve star.
Pinpointing Planets in Circumstellar Disks Mar 2009 Alice Quillen University of Rochester.
Submillimeter Observations of Debris Disks Wayne Holland UK Astronomy Technology Centre, Royal Observatory Edinburgh With Jane Greaves, Mark Wyatt, Bill.
1 ALMA View of Dust Evolution: Making Planets and Decoding Debris David J. Wilner (CfA) Grain Growth  Protoplanets  Debris.
Collision Enhancement due to Planetesimal Binary Formation Planetesimal Binary Formation Junko Kominami Jun Makino (Earth-Life-Science Institute, Tokyo.
Theoretical difficulties with standard models Mark Wyatt Institute of Astronomy, University of Cambridge.
Kate Su, George Rieke, Karl Misselt, John Stansberry, Amaya Moro-Martin, David Trilling… etc. (U. of A) Karl Stapelfeldt, Michael Werner (NASA JPL) Mark.
The Birth of Stars and Planets. Plan for the next ~45 min How do we learn about star formation? What can you see with your very own eyes or through our.
Circumstellar Disks at 5-20 Myr: Observations of the Sco-Cen OB Association Marty Bitner.
Figure 4. Same as Fig. 3 but for x = 5.5.
Capture of Irregular Satellites during Planetary Encounters
A cloud of gas falling towards the central black hole in the Milky Way. Jordi Miralda Escudé ICREA, Institut de Ciències del Cosmos University of Barcelona.
Extended debris discs around nearby, Sun-like stars as a probe of disc-planet interactions Astronomical Society of Australia ASM 5th July 2016 Dr. Jonty.
Debris Disk Studies with CCAT
Young planetary systems
Gas! Very few debris disks have detected gas, and it is generally only found around the youngest systems. So why should we consider gas here?
Debris Discs in Binaries
Bell Ringer What is the order of the planets?
Dynamical trapping (pile-up) of grains near the sublimation radius
Ge/Ay133 Can we study extrasolar Kuiper Belts?
Resonance Capture generalization to non-adiabatic regime
Presentation transcript:

Is there evidence of planets in debris disks? Mark Wyatt Institute of Astronomy University of Cambridge La planètmania frappe les astronomes Kalas, P. 1998, La Recherche 314, 38

Is there evidence for planets in debris disks? Yes!  Eridani has both a dust disk (Greaves et al. 1998) and a planet detected by radial velocity surveys (Hatzes et al. 2000) But radial velocity planets and debris disks are at different locations and it is unclear to what extent the two phenomena are related (Greaves et al. 2004; Beichman et al. 2005)

Do debris disks contain evidence for planets? What signature would a planet impose on a debris disk? Have these signatures been observed? Is there any other possible cause of these signatures? Can we make further testable predictions?

Central cavities Central cavities were inferred from the lack of mid-IR emission in the SED: Telesco et al. (2000) Kalas et al. (2005) HR4796 Fomalhaut But it was imaging which proved the existence of the inner holes: Walker & Wolstencroft (1998) Wavelength,  m Log(F, Jy)

Central cavities: without planets P-R drag would fill in the hole? Without planets to scatter or trap dust in resonance, P-R drag would fill in the inner hole in t pr = 400r 2 /M star  years Roques et al. (1994) With and Without Planets Kuiper Belt dust distribution Liou & Zook (1999) Number density Distance, AU This was the model proposed to explain the hole in the  Pictoris disk (>5M earth planet at 20AU)

Central cavities: no, P-R drag is insignificant The balance of P-R drag and collisions results in a surface density that depends only on  o = 5000  (r o )[r o /M * ] 0.5 /  Wyatt (2005) Tenuous disks Dense disks Tenuous disks  0 < 1 flat density distribution P-R drag dominated Dense disks  0 > 1 dust confined to planetesimal belt collision dominated P-R drag is insignificant in all detectable debris disks  o is an observable parameter, which for the known debris disks is >10

Origin of the inner holes? Lack of mid-IR emission implies few colliding planetesimals in inner regions (Wyatt 2005) Few planetesimals expected in middle of planetary systems as planets clear gaps along their orbits (Wisdom 1980) Growth of planetesimals into planets is faster closer to the star resulting in the formation of inner holes (Kenyon & Bromley 2002) Could the early evolution of circumstellar disks also produce inner holes? Radial transport of dust (Takeuchi & Artymowicz 2001) Viscous draining of inner disk (Clarke et al. 2001) Inner holes are weak, though credible, evidence of planets

Secular perturbations: warps A planet aligns planetsimals to its orbital plane so that a disk is warped if one planet is misaligned with the disk (Augereau et al. 2001) two planets with different orbital planes Augereau et al. (2001) Secular perturbations are the long term effect of the planet’s gravity and act on all disk material over >0.1 Myr timescales A planet's gravity affects the orbits of planetesimals and dust in a debris disk. Perturbations from a planet can be secular or resonant (Murray & Dermott 1999).

Secular perturbations: spirals and offsets Planets on eccentric orbits impose eccentricities on nearby planetesimals causing: Wyatt et al. (1999) spiral structure offset centre of symmetry Wyatt (2005)

Resonant perturbations: clumpy rings Resonances cover small regions of parameter space, but can be filled: Inward migration of dust Dust spirals in due to P-R drag and resonances halt inward migration Outward migration of planet Planet migrates out sweeping planetesimals into its resonances Resonant filling causes a clumpy ring to form along the planet’s orbit Pl Resonance Star Pl Resonance Star Resonances affect material at locations where orbital periods are a ratio of two integers times that of planet: P res = P planet *(p+q)/p

Why resonances are clumpy

Dust migration into resonance Dust created in the asteroid belt spirals in toward the Sun over 50 Myr, but resonant forces halt the inward migration… Earth  Sun Ozernoy et al. (2000) Wilner et al. (2002) Quillen & Thorndike (2002) Dermott et al. (1994) …causing a ring to form along the Earth’s orbit Time Semimajor axis, AU Models of dust migration into planetary resonances have also been applied to debris disks

Summarising dust migration structures The type of structure expected when dust migrates into planetary resonances depends on the planet’s mass and eccentricity (Kuchner & Holman 2003) : I low mass, low eccentricity e.g., Dermott et al. (1994), Ozernoy et al. (2000)  Eri II high mass, low eccentricity e.g., Ozernoy et al. (2000) Vega III low mass, high eccentricity e.g., Quillen & Thorndike (2002) IV high mass, high eccentricity e.g., Wilner et al. (2002), Moran et al. (2004)

Resonant structures due to planet migration Wyatt (2003)

Resonant structures due to planet migration Wyatt (2003)

Have these signatures been observed? Warps Spirals Offsets Brightness asymmetries Clumpy rings Yes!!

Other causes of signatures? collisions Could this be the cause of the clumps? Yes for clumps seen in the mid-IR around young systems (e.g.,  Pictoris): smaller colliding objects, ~100km witnessed at special point in time No for clumps seen in the sub-mm (e.g., Fomalhaut): the collision would have to involve two >1400 km objects too few can coexist in the disk for this to be likely Wyatt & Dent (2002) Telesco et al. (2005)

Other causes of signatures? ISM sandblasting If ISM sandblasting of a debris disk is important, substantial asymmetries can arise… … however, the ISM contribution is only important >400 AU from the star Motion relative to the ISM Artymowicz & Clampin (1997)

Other causes of signatures? binary companions As well as truncating disks, binary companions can also impose spiral structure and asymmetries… Augereau & Papaloizou (2003) Quillen et al. (2005) Secular perturbations cause asymmetric extended structure Tidal perturbations cause open two armed structure … but the binary companions cannot explain all the spiral structure in the HD141569A disk (Wyatt 2005)

Other causes of signatures? stellar flybys Stellar flybys induce perturbations which excite eccentricities which cause spiral structure which collapses into nested eccentric rings Such an event may explain clumps seen in the NE of the  Pictoris disk Kalas et al. (2000) Larwood & Kalas (2001) However, flyby encounters of field stars at an appropriate distance to perturb the disk (<1000 AU) are extremely rare

Exoplanet statistics? Is it too early to consider the statistics of these putative planets in debris disks? Perhaps it is, but these planets occupy a region of parameter space unexplorable with other techniques Thus it is vital to confirm their existence

Debris disk planet predictions Detect planet itself directly or indirectly: hard Multi-epoch imaging: Resonant structures orbit with planet decade timescales 2  detection of rotation in  Eri (Greaves et al. 2005) Secular structures >0.1Myr timescales Multi-wavelength imaging: can be done now!

Summary of the Vega planet migration model Orbit Distribution Spatial Distribution Emission Distribution Vega’s two asymmetric clumps seen in the sub-mm can be explained by the migration of a 17M earth planet from 40-65AU in 56 Myr Most planetesimals end up in the planet’s 2:1(u) and 3:2 resonances Observed Model Wyatt (2003)

Dynamics of small bound grains Radiation pressure alters the orbital periods of small dust grains and so their relation to the resonance Libration widths increase for small grains until they fall out of resonance for  >0.002  0.5 or D<200  m (L star /M star )  -0.5 where  =M pl /M star in M earth /M sun Wyatt (submitted) 3:2 2:1

Dynamics of small unbound grains Radiation pressure puts small (  >0.5) grains on hyperbolic trajectories The collision rate of planetesimals in resonance is higher in the clump region Wyatt (submitted) 3:2 2:1

Particle populations in a resonant disk Population Spatial distribution I Same clumpy distribution as planetesimals II Axisymmetric distribution III   r -1 distribution IIIa Spiral structure emanating from resonant clumps IIIb Axisymmetric distribution Wyatt (submitted) 3:2 2:1

Application to Vega SED modelling used to convert Su et al. 3 component model into continuous size distribution to assess contribution of different grain sizes to observations in different wavebands Wyatt (submitted) Observations in different wavebands sample different grain sizes, thus multi-wavelength images should have different structures and can be used to test models For Vega: Sub-mm observations sample population I grains Mid- to far-IR observations sample population III grains

Application to Vega Size distribution used to derive collisional lifetimes of different grain sizes Wyatt (submitted) Conclusions: Population II reduced by collisions with blow-out grains (Krivov et al. 2000) Population III grains removed at 2M  /Myr Population II destroyed at 0.02M  /Myr Population III is type IIIa and mid- to far-IR images should exhibit spiral structure emanating from clumps Size distribution Collisional lifetime

Conclusions Planets would impose structures on debris disks ranging from clumps to warps, offsets, brightness asymmetries and spirals All of these structures have been observed in debris disks and (in most cases) there is no other explanation Planets also cause holes, but this is weak evidence of planets This is a credible and unique exoplanet detection technique We need to confirm planetary interpretation through multi-epoch imaging multi-wavelength imaging