Formation of Planets around M & L dwarfs D.N.C. Lin University of California with AAS Washington Jan 11th, 2006 S. Ida, H. Li, S.L.Li, E. Thommes, I. Dobbs-Dixon,

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Origin & Evolution of Habitable Planets: Astronomical Prospective D.N.C. Lin University of California, Santa Cruz, KIAA, Peking University, with Pathways.
Advertisements

Probing the Conditions for Planet Formation in Inner Protoplanetary Disks James Muzerolle.
Proto-Planetary Disk and Planetary Formation
Origins of Regular and Irregular Satellites ASTR5830 March 19, :30-1:45 pm.
Planet Formation Topic: Formation of gas giant planets Lecture by: C.P. Dullemond.
Star & Planet Formation Minicourse, U of T Astronomy Dept. Lecture 5 - Ed Thommes Accretion of Planets Bill Hartmann.
The Grand Tack Scenario: Reconstructing The Migration History Of Jupiter And Saturn In The Disk Of Gas Alessandro Morbidelli (OCA, Nice) Kevin Walsh (SWRI,
From Dust to Planetesimals D.N.C. Lin Pascale Garaud, Taku Takeuchi, Cathie Clarke, Hubert Klahr, Laure Barrier-Fouchet Ringberg Castle April 14 th, 2004.
Things that matter during the first stages of formation of giant planets Andrea Fortier Physikalisches Institut – UniBe 02/03/2011.
The formation of stars and planets Day 5, Topic 3: Migration of planets and Outlook... Lecture by: C.P. Dullemond.
STScI May Symposium 2005 Migration Phil Armitage (University of Colorado) Ken Rice (UC Riverside) Dimitri Veras (Colorado)  Migration regimes  Time scale.
D.N.C. Lin KIAA, Peking University,
Secular, Kozai, mean-motion resonances D.N.C. Lin Department of Astronomy & Astrophysics University of California, Santa Cruz Lecture 4, AY 222 Apr 11th,
Investigating the structure of transiting planets, from hot Jupiters to Kepler super Earths Jonathan Fortney University of California, Santa Cruz Thanks.
Planet Formation with Different Gas Depletion Timescales: Comparing with Observations Huigen Liu, Ji-lin Zhou, Su Wang Dept. of Astronomy.
Extrasolar Planets More that 500 extrasolar planets have been discovered In 46 planetary systems through radial velocity surveys, transit observations,
1 Why exoplanets have so high eccentricities - By Line Drube - November 2004.
Detection and Characterization of Jovian Planets D.N.C. Lin University of California, Santa Cruz with Exo Planet Task Force National Science Foundation.
History of the Earth Chapter 1: Formation of the Earth From the Big Bang to Early Planets.
10Nov2006 Ge/Ay133 More on Jupiter, Neptune, the Kuiper belt, and the early solar system.
Ge/Ay133 What have radial velocity surveys told us about (exo)-planetary science?
Ge/Ay133 What have radial velocity surveys told us about (exo)-planetary science?
Copyright © 2012 Pearson Education, Inc. The Formation of the Solar System.
Habitable Planets Astronomy 315 Professor Lee Carkner Special Topic.
Ge/Ay133 What effects do 1-10 M Earth cores & Jovian planets have on the surrounding disk? Or, … Migration & Gaps.
Ge/Ay133 What have radial velocity surveys told us about (exo)-planetary science?
Eccentric Extrasolar Planets: The Jumping Jupiter Model HD217107b as imagined by Lynette Cook Stacy Teng TERPS Conference Dec. 9, 2004.
Terrestrial Planet Formation and the Delivery of Water: Theory and Simulations Dara Zeehandelaar TERPS Conference, ASTR688 December 9, 2004 Dara Zeehandelaar.
The basics of terrestrial planet formation The origin of water 1798 engraving, Pass Lecture 3 Formation of the Terrestrial Planets and Origin of Earth’s.
Bit of Administration …. ReadingReading –BSNV Chaps. 9 and 15 No Mathieu office hours today (Monday)!No Mathieu office hours today (Monday)! Additional.
Open problems in terrestrial planet formation
The formation of stars and planets Day 5, Topic 2: The formation of planets Lecture by: C.P. Dullemond.
Planet Formation O V E R V I E W Jack J. Lissauer - NASA Ames.
Saving Planetary Systems: the Role of Dead Zones Ralph Pudritz, Soko Matsumura (McMaster University), & Ed Thommes (CITA) AAS 208, Calgary.
 formation of non-resonant, multiple close-in super-Earths (which exist around 40-60% (?) of solar type stars)  N-body simulation (Ogihara & Ida 2009,
Exoplanets Astrobiology Workshop June 29, 2006 Astrobiology Workshop June 29, 2006.
Giant Planet Accretion and Migration : Surviving the Type I Regime Edward Thommes Norm Murray CITA, University of Toronto Edward Thommes Norm Murray CITA,
Ge/Ay133 What effects do 1-10 M Earth cores have on the surrounding disk? Today = Gaps Wednesday = Migration (included here)
The Diversity of Extrasolar Terrestrial Planets J. Bond, D. Lauretta & D. O’Brien IAU Symposium th August 2009.
Mass Distribution and Planet Formation in the Solar Nebula Steve Desch School of Earth and Space Exploration Arizona State University Lunar and Planetary.
Astronomy 340 Fall December 2007 Lecture #27.
Lecture 3 – Planetary Migration, the Moon, and the Late Heavy Bombardment Abiol 574.
Problems Facing Planet Formation around M Stars Fred C. Adams University of Michigan From work in collaboration with: P. Bodenheimer, M. Fatuzzo, D. Hollenbach,
The Chemistry of Extrasolar Planetary Systems J. Bond, D. O’Brien and D. Lauretta.
1 Ch. 23: “Touring Our Solar System” 23.1: “The Solar System”
How do “Habitable” Planets Form? Sean Raymond University of Washington Collaborators: Tom Quinn (Washington) Jonathan Lunine (Arizona)
Jean-Pierre needs to be brought up to date on what’s really going on in astronomy these days!
Investigating the structure of transiting planets, from hot Jupiters to Kepler super Earths Jonathan Fortney University of California, Santa Cruz Thanks.
Introductory Astronomy History – Solar Nebula 1. Dust to Planetesimals Grains of dust (solids) collide and adhere Larger grains grow to 10 9 planetesimals.
The Galactic Habitable Zone Guillermo Gonzalez Iowa State University Fermilab August 21, 2002 Acknowledgements: Don Brownlee Peter Ward.
Sean Raymond University of Washington
© 2010 Pearson Education, Inc. Formation of the Solar System.
in protoplanetary discs and OUTER SOLAR SYSTEM ARCHITECTURE
Astronomy 405 Solar System and ISM Lecture 17 Planetary System Formation and Evolution February 22, 2013.
The Diversity of Extrasolar Terrestrial Planets J. Carter-Bond, D. O’Brien & C. Tinney RSAA Colloquium 12 April 2012.
The PSI Planet-building Code: Multi-zone, Multi-use S. J. Weidenschilling PSI Retreat August 20, 2007.
Late Work Due 12/20/13 Remember ain’t no butts about it! Sticking your head in the sand won’t make the deadlines go away 11 Days Remain.
NEW CHAPTER Our Solar System CHAPTER the BIG idea Planets and other objects form a system around our Sun. Planets orbit the Sun at different distances.
From Planetesimals to Planets Pre-Galactic Black Holes and ALMA.
Astronomy 340 Fall December 2007 Class #29.
Universe Tenth Edition
Massive planets in FU Orionis objects Giuseppe Lodato Institute of Astronomy, Cambridge In collaboration with Cathie Clarke (IoA)
Collision Enhancement due to Planetesimal Binary Formation Planetesimal Binary Formation Junko Kominami Jun Makino (Earth-Life-Science Institute, Tokyo.
Planet Formation in a disk with a Dead Zone Soko Matsumura (Northwestern University) Ralph Pudritz (McMaster University) Edward Thommes (Northwestern University)
Delivery of Volatiles to the Terrestrial Planets Hans Rickman Uppsala Astronomical Observatory Hans Rickman Uppsala Astronomical Observatory.
Solar system Sergei popov.
Bell Ringer What is the order of the planets?
Protoplanetary Formation efficiency and time scale
Ge/Ay133 What have radial velocity surveys told
Astrobiology Workshop June 29, 2006
Presentation transcript:

Formation of Planets around M & L dwarfs D.N.C. Lin University of California with AAS Washington Jan 11th, 2006 S. Ida, H. Li, S.L.Li, E. Thommes, I. Dobbs-Dixon, S.T. Lee,P. Garaud, M. Nagasawa Doug Lin: 17 slides

Disk properties Hillenbrand Calvet 1 Disk life time is independent of M * :similar available time 2 Disk accretion rate varies as M * 2 : Less gas content 3 Disk heavy element mass varies as M * 1-2 ?Less metals

Preferred locations Meteorites: Dry, chondrules & CAI’s Icy moons Enhancement factor > 4

Stellar mass dependence T(snow line) ~160K, L ~ M 2 a(snow line) ~ (L) 1/2 /T 2 ~2.7(M * /M o ) AU V k (snow)~(M/a) 1/2 ~Const ; H/a ~Const Similar aspect ratio and Keplerian speed! But shorter time scales (a/V k ) for lower M * Water-rich planets form near low-mass stars

Feeding zones:  10 r Hill Isolation mass: M isolation ~   a 3 M * -1/2 From planetesimals to embryos Initial growth: (runaway) Shorter growth time scale at the snow line

M * dependence M isolation ~1.3  a/1AU) 3/4 (M * /M o ) 3/2 M earth less massive embryos  embryos ~0.033  a/1AU) 59/20 (M * /M o ) -16/15 Myr longer growth time Can form >3M earth embryos outside 5AU within 10Myr Scaling disk models with M * : a)Solar system: Minimum-mass nebula b)Other stars:  (a) =  SN (a) h d where h d = (M * /M sun ) 0,1,2 c)Embryos with M p >M earth are formed outside snow line Importance of snow line: Interior to it: growth limit due to isolation Exterior to it: long growth time scale Outside the snow line:

type-II migration planet’s perturbation viscous diffusion type-I migration disk torque imbalance Disk-planet tidal interactions viscous disk accretion Goldreich & Tremaine (1979), Ward (1986, 1997), Tanaka et al. (2002) Lin & Papaloizou (1985),....

Low-mass embryo (10 Mearth) Cooler and invisic disks

(Mass) growth vs (orbital) decay Loss due to Type I migration Embryos’ migration time scale Outer embryos are better preserved only after significant gas depletion Critical-mass core:M p =5M earth

Flow into the Roche potential Equation of motion: Bondi radius (R b =GM p /c s 2 ) Hill’s radius (R h =(M p /3M * ) 1/3 a) Disk thickness (H=c s a/V k ) R b / R h =3 1/3 (M p /M * ) 2/3 (a/H) 2 decreases with M * If R b > R h,, a large decline in  (+ve r gradient) would be needed to overcome the tidal barrier. A small  at the Hill’s radius would quench the accretion flow.

Reduction in the accretion rate Growth time scales: Embryos’ emergence time scale: ~  a/1AU) 59/20 (M * /M o ) -16/15 Myr KH cooling/contraction of the envelope: ~ (M p /M earth ) -(3-4) Myr Uninhibited Bondi accretion: ~(H/a) 4 (M * 2 /M p M d  k ~ yr(M J /M p ) Uninhibited accretion from the disk: ~M p /(dM/dt)~ yr(M p /M J ) Reduction due to Hill’s barrier: >  disk depletion Tidal barriers suppress the emergence of gas giants around low-mass stars

Gap formation & type II migration Viscous and thermal conditions Lower limiting mass for gas giants around low-mass stars Neptune-mass planets can open up gaps and migrate close to the stars

Hot Neptunes around low-M * stars Radial extent is determined by V k > V escape

Migration-free sweeping secular resonances Resonant secular perturbation M disk ~M p (Ward, Ida, Nagasawa) Ups And Transitional disks

Dynamical shake up (Nagasawa, Thommes) Bode’s law: dynamically porous terrestrial planets orbits with low eccentricities with wide separation

Formation of water worlds Jupiter-Saturn secular interaction & multiple extrasolar systems Sweeping secular resonance may be more intense in low-mass stars. But the absence of gas or ice giants would leave behind dynamically-hot earth-mass objects

Summary 1.Snow line is important for the retention of heavy. Around low-mass stars, planets with mass greater than that of the earth are formed outside the snow line. 2. Planet-disk interaction can lead to depletion of first generation planetesimals, especially around low-mass stars 3.Self regulation led to the stellar accretion of most heavy elements, the late emergence of planets, and perhaps the inner holes inferred from SED’s. 4. Around low-mass stars, gas accretion rate onto proto gas giants is also suppressed by a tidal barrier. 5. Neptune-mass embryos can open up gaps and migrate to the stellar proximity. 6.Residual planetesimals may have modest eccentricities. 7 There will be a desert of gas giants and an oasis of terrestrial planets, including short-period water worlds around dwarfs.