Private Sector Participation Lessons in Water Supply and Sanitation Tokyo June 28, 2007 Mohammed Benouahi, World Bank.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Water Services for the Poor – the Manila experience Global Forum on Sustainable Development Paris, France December 18, 2003.
Advertisements

Combines best global evidence into one definitive resource Targets the decision-makers: developers, investors and owners, and major tenants Looks specifically.
Public Private Partnership Investment and Construction Armando R. Araujo Cairo 2003.
OECD Water Programme Sustainable Financing to Ensure Affordable Access to Water and Sanitation EUWI Finance Working Group World Water Week Stockholm, Aug.20.
CONTRACT DESIGN FOR REGULATION A. Estache World Bank Institute.
An Overview of the Financial System chapter 2. Function of Financial Markets Lenders-Savers (+) Households Firms Government Foreigners Financial Markets.
May 2005 The French Water Services: Main present challenges.
PPP’s IN NIGERIA: Prospects in the Water Sector
Novel Procurement Options ARBE121 – PFI  Variants, additions to or environments for routes  Private Finance Initiative (PFI) A funding & operational.
Private and Public Roles in Water: Partners or Competitors? Declan Duff Director, International Finance Corporation Water: Dispute Prevention and Development.
An Overview of Financial Markets and Institutions
Department of Economics and BusinessBIS Phuket
Jeff Delmon FEU Financial Solutions World Bank. Why PPP? Procurement efficiency Lifecycle management Design/construction/operation management Monetizing.
Cross-Border Infrastructure: A Toolkit Universal Service Session on Regulation & Accountability Max Bradford Castalia The views expressed here are those.
Ch 9: General Principles of Bank Management
Chapter Twenty Financial Management in the International Business.
Financing Urban Public Infrastructure
Instruments of Financial Markets at Studienzentrum Genrzensee Switzerland. August 30-September 17, 2004 Course attended by: Muhammad Arif Senior Joint.
Saving, Investment, & Financial System
BUILDING SUSTAINABILITY: PARTNERSHIPS AND FINANCE by S. Adrian Ross Senior Programme Officer PEMSEA.
Review of the previous lecture Shortcomings of GDP Factor prices are determined by supply and demand in factor markets. As a factor input is increased,
A Microfinance Solution for Water, Sanitation, and Health in Peri-Urban and Rural Areas Presented at the Fifth World Water ForumDr. Richard E. Thorsten.
IGCSE®/O Level Economics
Copyright 2010, The World Bank Group. All Rights Reserved. 1 GOVERNMENT FINANCE STATISTICS COVERAGE OF THE GFS SYSTEM Part 1 This lecture defines the concept.
PRIVATE SECTOR PARTICIPATION IN SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT
1 Blue Revolution Initiative: Improving Water Management for Health, Prosperity and Security in the Middle East and Asia JOHN WILSON Deputy Director Office.
PPP’s: Theory & Practice SANPSHOTS: Manila Water Company, Inc. (MWC) MainstreamingPublic-PrivatePartnerships Anouj Mehta, Senior Infrastructure Finance.
PPP International Best Practice and Regional Application Overview of Public Private Partnerships (PPPs) April, 2008 Tegucigalpa, Honduras Filip Drapak.
Innovative funding for infrastructure services: the use of Output Based Aid in the Honduras water sector Cledan Mandri-Perrott Infrastructure, Economics.
Ukraine – Attracting Investments in the Municipal and Environmental Infrastructure.
1 Cost Recovery in Jordan March 2009 Eng. Kamal Zoubi Former CEO / Jordan Water Company.
Saving, Investment, and the Financial System
Doing Business With OPIC. OPIC’s Mission Statement “To mobilize and facilitate the participation of the United States capital and skills in the economic.
Utility reform in Romania example in Cluj Presentation of The Regional Environmental Center for Central and Eastern Europe Christelle Kapoen May 2008.
The Senegalese pro-poor approach to tackle the urban water sector affordability/viability issue 5th World Water Forum World Water – Istanbul – Thursday,
Inter-American Development Bank Private Sector Financing and the IDB Presentation by the IDB Private Sector Department February 2004.
1 Impact from Management and Lease/Affermage Contracts in Water Supply 1818 Society Water Chapter September 8, 2006 Klas Ringskog, World Bank consultant.
WSSB Capacity Enhancement Workshop1.  Definition: Public-Private Partnerships (PPPs) are a form of legally enforceable contracts between the public and.
WATER SUPPLY IN THAILAND - ENCOURAGE PRIVATE SECTOR INVOLVEMENT - IMPROVE ENVIRONMENTAL STANDARDS - PROVIDE BASIC NEED IN POVERTY AREAS - UTILIZE LOW-COST.
Financial Markets & Institutions
Market Structure & Policy Environment SMEs for Decentralized Energy Service Provision Loyda Alonso, General Manager Soluz Honduras, S.A.
1 Private Sector Roles in Delivering Public Services: Policy Options for Developing Cities Penelope Brook The World Bank.
An Overview of the Financial System chapter 2 1. Function of Financial Markets Lenders-Savers (+) Households Firms Government Foreigners Financial Markets.
Financing Alternatives in WSPs Patrick Nduati Mwangi, WASPA Conference, September 2011 Water and Sanitation Program.
LOGO SOCIÉTÉ Access to Water and Sanitation Services for All Responsibility & Organization of a (Private) Operator Alain Mathys.
“Chilean water utility model: A case of social and financial sustainability” Guillermo Pickering de la Fuente Executive President, Andess Istanbul, March.
Lecture 28. Lecture Review Financial Management in the International Business 1. investment decisions – decisions about what to finance 2. financing decisions.
Sources of Finance.
Lecture 27. Lecture Review Financial Management in the International Business 1. investment decisions – decisions about what to finance 2. financing decisions.
McGraw-Hill/Irwin Chapter 15: Fiscal Policy, Deficits, and Debt Copyright © 2010 by The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved.
Topic 3: Finance and Accounts
Stock Terminology (continued) Investors make money in stocks in two ways: –Dividends Companies may make payment to shareholders as part of the profits.
Chapter 7 Obtaining the Right Financing for Your Business University of Bahrain College of Business Administration MGT 239: Small Business MGT239 1.
Ratio Analysis…. Types of ratios…  Performance Ratios: Return on capital employed. (Income Statement and Balance Sheet) Gross profit margin (Income Statement)
1 European Investment Bank EIB's support for Energy Efficiency & Renewable Energy Investment in cities and regions - European Local Energy Assistance (ELENA)
Risk Management Lecture1 Introduction: Financial System, Institutions & Instruments Nadir Khan.
Role of Financial Markets and Institutions
PERU: STATE OF THE HOUSING INDUSTRY
Decision-making on the reform of urban water services in Ukraine
Sewerage and Sanitation Policies in Indonesia
Water Supply and Sanitation Projects in Indonesia An Overview of Their Performance International Seminar on Water Supply and Sanitation Sector Reform in.
Michael Jacobsen, Project Director - Water 18 MaY 2017
Bangladesh access to sanitation
«Water Sector Reform in Kenya »
The SWA Collaborative Behaviors
progress of the water reform in bulgaria
Water Utility Performance
Developing the power sector in Federal Nepal Main lessons from international experience Kathmandu, November 06, 2018.
BASICS OF PUBLIC PRIVATE PARTNERSHIPS
Presentation transcript:

Private Sector Participation Lessons in Water Supply and Sanitation Tokyo June 28, 2007 Mohammed Benouahi, World Bank

Overview of Presentation Sector objectives and strategies Options of private sector participation Experience from different PSP options Best practice lessons

Sector Objectives and Strategies Sector objectives should be to: Provide universal coverage of water and sanitation services (because of water’s positive external environmental and health benefits) Provide efficient service (service at least cost) Achieve sustainable service (operating revenue plus public subsidies sufficient to pay for operations, maintenance and investments)

Sector Objectives and Strategies Universal coverage is measured by: Share of population connected to piped water Share of population connected to sewerage Share of population with 24-hour service Share of water samples bacteriologically safe

Sector Objectives and Strategies Universal coverage best practice is: 100 % of urban and agglomerated rural population connected to water and sewerage in Chile 100% of urban population population with 24-hour service in Chile 100% of water samples bacteriologically safe in Chile Both public and private service providers can achieve best practice

Sector Objectives and Strategies Efficient service is measured by: Percentage of non-revenue water (NRW), i.e. share of water produced that does not produce financial revenue Staff productivity as measured by number of employees per thousand water accounts (connections)

Sector Objectives and Strategies Efficient service best practice is: NRW=4% in the case of the Singapore public water supply department and Japan water bureaus Staff productivity below 2.0 employees per thousand water connections for Santiago de Chile and Lima, Perú Both public and private service providers have achieved best practice

Sector Objectives and Strategies Sustainable service is measured by: Financial working ratio (cash operating costs/cash operating revenue) Share of collected wastewater treated and disposed of in an environmentally satisfactory fashion

Sector Objectives and Strategies Sustainable service best practice is: Financial working ratio 30% (Antalya lease operator) and below 50% (Santiago de Chile private concessionaire) Share of collected wastewaters treated 73% for Chile urban sector Both public and private service providers must have appropriate financial incentives to respond to environmental directives

Options of PSP OptionOwnershipFinancingOperations Service ContractPublic Public and some Private Management Contract Public Private Lease ContractPublic Private Concession Public Private Operate-Transfer Build-Own- Private then Public Private Reverse BOOT Public then Private PublicPrivate Joint Ownership Private and Public Private and Public Private and Public Divestiture Private Period, Yrs Indefinite

Options of Private Sector Presentation Based on the risk analysis the following PSP options are the riskiest for private operators: Concessions because of demand, tariff, political, financing and construction risks Lease contracts because of demand, tariff, and political risks

Options of Private Sector Presentation The demand risk is particularly significant for concessions and lease contracts because: the concessionaire and lease contractor in essence buys the right to the revenue stream in return for paying for investments (concession) and guaranteeing the service quality (both) demand can easily decrease with better control of consumption and higher effective tariffs

Options of Private Sector Presentation Affermage and lease contracts differ because: the remuneration under an affermage is a fixed fee (that not depends directly on the revenue) the remuneration under a lease contract is the difference between the collected revenue and the agreed lease fee paid to the owner of the system in both cases the owner finances investments but the operator pays for operations and maintenance

Options of Private Sector Presentation Based on the analysis the following PSP options are the least risky for private operators: Management contracts because payment is not linked to performance Service contracts because of short duration of contracts of a technical nature and few sanctions for lagging performance

Experience from different PSP options Failed concessions and reasons for failure: Buenos Aires (Government devalued currency and did not compensate with tariff adjustment) La Paz (Political opposition following change to populist government) Jakarta (Political changes and opposition due to lagging service improvements) West Manila (Political opposition to tariff increases due to lagging service improvements)

Experience from different PSP options Successful concessions and reasons for success: Casablanca (Economies of scale and cross subsidies due to combined power & water concession and limited financing risk) East Manila (Local concessionaire was able to manage political risk and benefit from links between improved service and real estate values)

Experience from different PSP options Successful concessions and reasons for success: Many systems in France and in Spain such as Barcelona and in new EU members such as Bucharest, and Sofia However, the financing needs are less in such mature systems with high coverage as compared to developing countries’ financing needs

Experience from different PSP options Concessions: Generally not possible because of risk averse private operators who have lost money Private operators not willing to accept demand risk (as under Build-Own-Operate-Transfer contracts) Private operators not willing to accept financing risks (and therefore try to delay investments)

Experience from different PSP options Failed lease contracts and reasons for failure: Antalya (Private operator bid low and Government refused adjustment of contractually fixed tariff which caused operator liquidation) Conakry (Political opposition to contract renewal in spite of service improvements)

Experience from different PSP options Successful leases and reasons for success: Gdansk (Improved performance and service quality to European standards helped by initially high service coverage) Senegal (Rapid service improvements helped by generous financing from World Bank group)

Experience from different PSP options Failed management contracts and reasons for failure: Trinidad & Tobago (Political opposition following lack of service improvements) Zambia (Opposition to contract extension following government change, in spite of rapid improvements of service quality & performance )

Experience from different PSP options Partly successful management contracts: Amman (Service improvements but even so government elected to replace management contract by government owned corporation, mostly for political reasons) Armenia (Widening participation of private sector based on improved performance and service quality)

Experience from different PSP options Successful joint ownership contracts and reasons for success: Barranquilla (Rapid service improvements due to skilled operator and successful mitigation of political risks because of joint public/private ownership) Cartagena (Rapid improvements due to successful mitigation of political risk and decent national regulation of tariff and service quality)

Experience from different PSP options Evaluation of selected management and leases: Households with piped water (percent) ContractBeforeAfter Amman90%100% Antalya93% 95% Barranquilla60% 89% Cartagena74% 95% Gaza58% 56% Senegal59% 73% Zambia100%100%

Experience from different PSP options Evaluation of selected management and leases: Constancy of supply (hours of service) ContractBeforeAfter Amman49 Antalya1923 Barranquilla1923 Cartagena1724 GazaNA 8 Senegal1622 Zambia1318 Tlipoli, Lebanon324

Experience from different PSP options Successful divestiture or privatization of assets: Chile (Steady service improvements over ten years before government-owned shares were sold to private operators at a huge financial windfall). The reasons for success includes a law that obliges operators to recover full costs of service, and a law that subsidizes up to 85% of the consumption of certified poor consumers.

Experience from different PSP options Successful divestiture or privatization of assets: England and Wales (But the divestiture was not a net money-maker for the Government that had to write-off substantial loans to the public regional companies plus pay a “Green dowry” and agree to real tariff increases in return for selling the shares to private companies Regulation under OFWAT has proven to be best practice but not transferable everywhere

Best practice lessons Lesson One: Best practice requires sustained political will and progress over many years (for Chile about ten years): Highest level political support of policies Creation of the instrumentation to reach political targets (laws, regulation, institutions) Consistent implementation of long-term plans to reach targets (15-year plans in Chile)

Best practice lessons Lesson Two: Both public and private operators can achieve best practice if appropriate policies are applied consistently: Chile achieved best practice under government ownership with policies identical for public and private operators. Assets were privatized for fiscal reasons Singapore’s government ownership and management represents efficiency best practice

Best practice lessons Lesson Three: Best practice pricing is to: Recover explicitly the full costs of service through user charges because otherwise all may be subsidized Avoid cross-subsidies since they create financial disincentives against service to poor Subsidize on the basis of income to enable the poor to pay for the full costs of service

Best practice lessons Lesson Four: Successful private sector participation requires that: The Government employer is as knowledgeable as the private operator Successfully tested regulation reduces the political risks of inconsistent policies The private sector is perceived as a partner and not an adversary as in Colombia