Community Services: Mapping Your Resources Kelli Crane, Ph.D. Debra Martin Luecking, Ed.D. TransCen, Inc. NSTTAC Secondary Transition State Planning Institute: Building for the Future
Learning Objectives Define Community Resource Mapping Describe purposes for resource map Introduce the process for resource mapping Share examples of the process
Resource Mapping Defined A system building process that links community resources with an agreed upon vision, goals, and expected outcomes.
Resource Mapping Defined A system-building process that: Leads to change Identifies resources and barriers to building a system Strategizes optimal uses of resources Identifies limitations and gaps in resource coordination Explores new resources Coordinates resources for strategic planning
Purpose of Resource Mapping Comprehensive approach to: build capacity sustain practice inform strategic action planning make informed decisions collect and analyze data share information that benefits all stakeholders
Outcomes of Resource Mapping Improved post-school results for youth Competitively employed Enrolled in postsecondary school More collaborative partnerships More efficient and effective in delivery of services to youth and families “Map” of resource available for youth and families
how come it NEVER gets done? If everyone is doing it, how come it NEVER gets done? — Joe Marrone, UMass-Boston
Four Step Process Step 1: Pre-Mapping/Assessment Step 2: Mapping Step 3: Strategic Implementation Step 4: Maintaining Mapping Efforts
Step 1: Pre-Mapping / Assessment Establish a Coordinating Team Create a Vision/Goal reduce drop-out rates improve transition results (e.g., competitive employment & postsecondary education)
Establish a Coordinating Team New or existing team Consider self-interest What brings people to the table & keeps them there? Common goal Diverse representation Significant ties to community Include “rotating” members to address particular issues and resources Why to work What are your desired outcomes (six months, 1 year)? How often will you meet? What is the work plan ( responsibilities, timelines, communication, activities)?
Potential Partners Secondary education staff (i.e., transition, general, special) Adult education representative Advocacy organizations Business-education partnership representative Community action agency representative Correctional education staff Drop-out prevention representative Employers Extension service representative Transportation representative Higher education representative Community-based organizations
Create a Vision Break traditional thinking Provide continuity of purpose & direction Prioritize issues & concerns Promote interest & commitment to action Create ownership of success
Step 2: Mapping Know your organizing framework Develop tools to collect resource data Collect and map community resource data Identify existing limitations, gaps and overlaps in resources Determine implications of the findings
Create an Organizing Framework Universal Resources- Resources available to all youth -- aimed at enhancing success and reducing barriers to the transition process Selected Resources- Supplemental resources provided to small groups of youth- to reduce the potential for increased difficulty and risk for long term failure Targeted Resources- Individually designed, intensive resources / interventions needed by very few youth
Organizing Framework NASET Transition Domains: Secondary Education & Graduation Career Preparation & Employment Family Involvement Youth Development & Leadership Supportive and Adult Services
Organizing Framework Taxonomy for Transition Student-focused planning Student development Family involvement Program structure Interagency collaboration
Data Collection Determine what data to collect & evaluate - vision & goals will drive data collection decisions Use a variety of evaluation strategies (on-line surveys, interviews, observations, focus groups, public forums) Value the opinions/ideas of both stakeholder groups & end-users Limitations, gaps, overlaps Analyze data for trends or patterns. Identify limitations, gaps and overlaps (duplication) in existing resources. Identify activities / services in place at each level of support (universal, selected, and targeted). If needed, conduct a formal “needs assessment.” Determine implications for practice and policy.
Step 3: Implementing the Map “The power of resource mapping comes with what happens after the resources have been identified.” Develop a strategic action plan Facilitate access to resources Communicate & disseminate information
Strategic Action Planning Strategize how resources can be redirected Determine which needs exist after realignment Identify other community resources Plan to access additional funding or resources Build mutually beneficial partnerships; Anticipate challenges, and solutions.
Facilitate Access to Resources Consider a variety of possible formats for sharing and aligning resources Work to increase access and use of the resources
Step 4: Maintaining Mapping Efforts Examine process Measure progress Maintain momentum Regular communication Sustain efforts Use of intermediaries Refresh, recycle
Evaluate Process and Progress Survey stakeholders (especially end-users) to determine if resource mapping process has served purpose. Survey team members to determine if process was beneficial and meaningful. Analyze outcome data to measure effectiveness of realigning resources.
Improved outcomes are the ultimate indicator of effective resource mapping.
Maintain Efforts Build your “Case for Support” Maintain flexibility Continue to increase and diversify resources by engaging community Evaluate and monitor progress periodically- report out to stakeholders Communicate both successes and challenge Build your “Case for Support” Maintain flexibility(mid-course corrections) Engage in marketing and promotion Continue to increase and diversify resources by engaging community Evaluate and monitor progress periodically- report out to stakeholders Communicate both successes and challenges
The Value of Reflection “Here is Edward Bear, coming downstairs now, bump, bump, bump on the back of his head, behind Christopher Robin. It is, as far as he knows, the only way of coming downstairs, but sometimes he feels that there really is another way, if only he could stop bumping for a moment and think of it.” - A. A. Milne, Winnie-the-Pooh
Mapping Experience 4 Stages of Change Contentment Denial Chaos Creativity Grand idea—brainstorm how they can improve outcomes Denial—people who say we have already done it. What will we gain. It is another process Chaos—making sense of the data…catotic if they have not determined what they want to map. Group—wanted to sustain but not sure what to sustain. Wanted grant source to pay to continue. Took awhile a … evaluating what they wanted to sustain and …. Lesson in that what it is they want to map.. The more specific the less catoci. Creativity – using resources differently…
Example—Mapping for Sustainability 7 communities in California Goal to sustain program practice “continue benefits services in schools” Defined “benefits services” Collected and analyzed project data Looked for new ways to “blend” & “braid” funds Determined who benefits Found new partners and new ways to do business
Example-Mapping for Improved Results State of Florida—Interagency Services Committee Vision: To develop strategies to eliminate barriers which will ensure successful transition to employment and further educational opportunities for youth with disabilities. Goals: 1) increase number of youth transitioning to competitive employment 2) increase number accessing post-secondary education
Example -- continued Mapping to gain baseline data on the resources to support transition to employment and post-secondary education Results provide the BIG PICTURE & strategic direction Present the plan to the state legislature and get support in implementing the actions Individual—need dedicated resources Foundation is action planning what learned into a FATAL mistake—don’t do because the gold star kid on block. Need to know how to use.
Lessons Learned Purpose driven – clearly defined goal Action plan must follow the data collection (e.g., map) Engage a “champion” or “champions” Inform those contributing to the map of the results Build come language and purpose across all players Action research….need to be on the same page. A facilitated process and strategic thinking. Need a clearly defined goal
Resources Essential Tools: Improving Secondary Education and Transition for Youth with Disabilities-Community Resource Mapping. (2005). Crane, K., & Mooney, M. http://www.ncset.org/publications/essentialtools/mapping Early Ongoing Collaboration and Assistance- Resource Mapping: A Toolkit. (2006). Sanetti, L., Kratochwill, T., Volpiansky, P., & Ring, M. http://www.eocaschools.org
Kelli Crane, Ph.D. TransCen, Inc. kcrane@transcen.org 240.418.2684 Debra Martin Luecking, Ed.D TransCen, Inc. dluecking@transcen.org 301.424.2002 ext. 245