The Hawthorne Effect and Maternal Depression Care Research Advisors: Jim Coyne, PhD Ian Bennett, MD, PhD Steve Marcus, PhD John Paul Julien University.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

Other Mental Health Issues that Impact Learning

Advertisements

Impact of an antidepressant adherence program in a managed care organization Kara Zivin Bambauer, PhD Stephen Soumerai, ScD Alyce Adams, PhD Fang Zhang,

Multilevel Interventions: Study Design and Analysis Issues Paul D. Cleary, Ph.D. Yale School of Public Health Cary Gross, M.D. Yale School of Medicine.

Lessons from Neurobiology: Understanding the Overlap between Pain and Mood Disorders Rakesh Jain, MD, MPH R/D Clinical Research, Inc. Lake Jackson, Texas,

Best Practices in Mental Health Services in Nursing Homes Steve Bartels, MD, MS President, American Association for Geriatric Psychiatry.

APPLIED PSYCHOLOGY LABORATORY East Tennessee State University Johnson City, Tennessee INTRODUCTION CONTACT:

Behavioral Health Services for Injured or Ill workers – Collaborative Care Analysis and Recommendations January 22, 2015.

The Integrated Behavioral Health Service Tiffany Cummings, M.S., Natasha Mroczek, M.S., & Thom Harrell, Ph.D. School of Psychology Florida Institute of.

The Contribution of Health Economics to Health in the United States Mark McClellan, MD, PhD Brookings Institution.

Types of help and psychiatrists Clara Berlanga Period 2 Behavior health.

Background Information : Projected prevalence of arthritis is expected to increase from 2.9 million to 6.5 million Canadians, a rise of 124% (Badley.

Discussion Gitanjali Batmanabane MD PhD. Do you look like this?

APPLIED PSYCHOLOGY LABORATORY East Tennessee State University Johnson City, Tennessee INTRODUCTION CONTACT: Yasmin A. Stoss,

QCOM Library Resources Rick Wallace, Nakia Woodward, Katie Wolf.

Depression: An overview Most cases are managed in primary care Role of secondary care largely applies to severe and complex cases Secondary care would.

Electronic Health Records and Clinical Decision Support Systems Impact on National Ambulatory Care Quality Max J. Romano, BA; Randall S. Stafford, MD,

RESPONSE TO ANTIDEPRESSANT MEDICATION, COGNITIVE BEHAVIOR THERAPY AND PLACEBO IN CHRONIC TENSION-TYPE HEADACHE VARIES WITH PSYCHIATRIC COMORBIDITY & HEADACHE.

Effectiveness of Depression Care Management in a Multiple Disease Care Management Model Bruce Friedman, Ph.D. Departments of Community and Preventive Medicine,

Institutional Assessment Implementing Electronic Medical Records in a Suboxone Clinic Tonya Anderson NURS 7250.

Copyright © 2008 Delmar Learning. All rights reserved. Unit 8 Observation, Reporting, and Documentation.

APPLIED PSYCHOLOGY LABORATORY East Tennessee State University Johnson City, Tennessee INTRODUCTION CONTACT:

“The Effect of Patient Complexity on Treatment Outcomes for Patients Enrolled in an Integrated Depression Treatment Program- a Pilot Study” Ryan Miller,

Periodontal Health and Birth Outcomes Secretary’s Advisory Committee on Infant Mortality – SACIM November 30, 2006 M. Ann Drum, DDS, MPH, Director Department.

Insert Program or Hospital Logo Introduction BACKGROUND Breastfeeding is very beneficial to the health and development of infants and is therefore highly.

Barb Supanich, RSM, MD, FAAHPM Holy Cross IP Palliative Care Team November 11, 2010.

Study Objectives and Study Design Dr. Abdel Moniem Mukhtar, Dr.P.H., MPH, BDS, Research Methodology Module, AUW on Septmember 2012.

Systematic Review Module 3: Study Eligibility Criteria Melissa McPheeters, PhD, MPH Associate Director Vanderbilt University Evidence-based Practice Center.

APPLIED PSYCHOLOGY LABORATORY East Tennessee State University Johnson City, Tennessee INTRODUCTION CONTACT:

STAR*D Objectives Compare relative efficacy of different treatment options –Goal is REMISSION, not just “response” –Less than half of patients with depression.

The Effect of Electronic Medical Record Alerts on Processes of Care Related to Preventing Falls in Community- Dwelling Elderly Patients David R. Goldmann.

Long-term Efficacy Data for Psychiatric Drugs Rationale for Long-Term Treatment Earl Giller, MD, PhD Pfizer Global Research & Development Long-Term Efficacy.

Evidence based interventions in dementia: the EVIDEM early diagnosis trial Steve Iliffe, Jane Wilcock, Mark Griffin, Priya Jane, Ingela Thuné- Boyle, Frances.

The Integrated Behavioral Health Service Tiffany Cummings, M.S., Natasha Mroczek, M.S., & Thom Harrell, Ph.D. School of Psychology Florida Institute of.

Rate of Visual Field Progression in Eyes With Optic Disc Hemorrhages in the Ocular Hypertension Treatment Study De Moraes CG, Demirel S, Gardiner SK, et.

PHQ-9 Severity and Screening Tests Predictive of Remission Outcomes at Six Months Kurt B. Angstman, MS MD Associate Professor John M. Wilkinson Assistant.

Lauren W. DePaola, MSW, LCSW Florida Children & Youth Cabinet May 4, 1016.

Do abnormally low concentrations of Vitamin D during pregnancy contribute to postpartum depression? Anita Cintron-Rivera, PA-S School of PA Studies | Pacific.

DEEPA A. VASUDEVAN, MD, MPH MICHELLE R. KLAWANS, MPH THOMAS F. NORTHRUP, PHD ANGELA L. STOTTS, PHD Tools for Implementing Resident and Medical Student.

Discussion Background Objectives Office Based Prevention of Child Abuse and Neglect: Lessons Learned from the Practicing Safety QuIIN Project Diane Abatemarco,

Biomedical Research Centre for Mental Health and Dementia Unit at South London and Maudsley NHS Foundation Trust the Institute of Psychiatry, King’s College.

ORAL ANTIHYPERTENSIVE THERAPY FOR SEVERE HYPERTENSION IN PREGNANCY AND POSTPARTUM: A SYSTEMATIC REVIEW Tabassum FirozLaura Magee Karen MacDonellBeth Payne.

©2016 MFMER | slide-1 Patient screening tools associated with prediction of depression remission at six months Kurt B. Angstman, MS MD Professor of Family.

Sarah Kunin, MD Princeton Baptist Medical Center Baptist Health Systems Alabama Multiple Myeloma: Treatment with Bisphosphonates.

Use of Mentored Residency Teams to Enhance Addiction Medicine Education Maureen Strohm, MD, Ken Saffier, MD, Julie Nyquist, PhD, Steve Eickelberg, MD MERF.

©2015 MFMER | slide-1 PTSD: Worsening outcomes for comorbid depression… even with collaborative care management. Kurt B. Angstman, MS, MD Professor of.

Parity and Post-traumatic Stress: A Preliminary Study Benjamin Reissman 1, Sharmilla Amirthalingam 1, Gabriella Deanne 1, Jackie Finik 1,2, Yoko Nomura,

Date: March 10, 2017 Nelly burdette, psyD IBH Practice facilitator

Abstract Results Background Discussion Methods

Concordance Of Clinical & Electronic Data In Assessment of Depression: Findings From The Smartphone And Online Usage Based Evaluation For Depression (SOLVD)

Patti Olusola, M.D. Kathryn Wortz, Ph.D. Robert B. Tompkins, M.D.

Tanner Nissly DO, Laura Miller MD, Emily Kidd MD PGY-3

Using Population-Based Data to Estimate Treatment Gaps in Depression and the Impact of Physician Incentives Joseph H Puyat, MA (Psychology), MSc, PhD.

A systematic review of the relationship between substance abuse and psychotropic medication adherence: opportunities to improve outcomes for patients with.

Texas Pediatric Society Electronic Poster Contest

Suzanne Allen, MD, MPH Jeralyn Jones, MD Catherine Serio, PhD

Major Depressive Disorder: Latest Clinical Update

Bruce Waslick, MD Medical Director UMass / Baystate MCPAP Team

Matthew H. Liang, MD Malcolm P. Rogers, MD Ira R. Katz, MD, PhD

Minimum prevalence of non-compliance recorded in an audit of antenatal care in a district general hospital joint obstetric epilepsy clinic Smyth C, Gornall.

A Correlation Between The Therapeutic Nursing Approach and Quality Patient Outcomes: An Integrative Literature Review Isabel Galang, MS, DePaul University.

Volume 4, Issue 2, Pages (February 2017)

Volume 3, Issue 2, Pages (February 2016)

The Challenges of Bipolar Disorders

Volume 3, Issue 7, Pages (July 2016)

Copyright Notice This presentation is copyrighted by the Psychopharmacology Institute. Subscribers can download it and use it for professional use. The.

The Effects of Mothers’ Postpartum Depression

July 30, 2018 Ian Stockwell, PhD Fei Han, PhD

Copyright Notice This presentation is copyrighted by the Psychopharmacology Institute. Subscribers can download it and use it for professional use. The.

Stakeholder engagement and research utilization: Insights from Namibia

The Preterm Birth Clinic Wellbeing Study

Presentation transcript:

The Hawthorne Effect and Maternal Depression Care Research Advisors: Jim Coyne, PhD Ian Bennett, MD, PhD Steve Marcus, PhD John Paul Julien University of Pennsylvania

Background A brief overview

Major Depressive Disorder 4 – 16 % of women experience depression during pregnancy Discontinued use of antidepressants when pregnant, increased rate of recurrence Difficult detection due to overlapping pregnancy symptoms

Hawthorne Effect Observational phenomenon Highly debated amongst scholars Shown to alter patient and physician behaviors

Pace (Pregnancy and Changing Emotions) Study 5R01MH grant (P.I. James Coyne) Identify influences on access and barriers to care of major depressive disorder (MDD) for pregnant and postpartum women Mixed methods observational study Assess how social and institutional factors affect detection and treatment of maternal MDD

Baseline maternal MDD rate Jan March 2009 Start of PACE Study July 2009 Comparison maternal MDD depression rate Jan 2010 – March 2010 End of PACE Study May 2013 Timeline of PACE Study

Project Goals

Goals Determine whether or not Hawthorne Effect alters the detection and treatment of MDD in POGA practice Quantify the Hawthorne Effect Create baseline rate of depression detection before the PACE study

Initial Work

Initial work Learn the methodology of health services research ◦ Literature search ◦ Article analysis ◦ Understand bigger picture Obtaining Data ◦ Delivery Log abstraction ◦ Construct chart abstraction form ◦ Electronic medical record training ◦ Depression detection rate spreadsheet Writing projects ◦ Introduction to Hawthorne paper ◦ Methods section of Hawthorne paper

Methods

Methods Abstract 3 month period of deliveries from POGA delivery logs Use EPIC EMR medical records to view patient files Document depression diagnoses with chart abstraction form Obtain rate of depression detection and treatment through spreadsheet

Work in Progress Completing documentation via EPIC medical records Quantifying rate of depression detection Determining whether or not there is a Hawthorne Effect

Reflections A look back

Special Thanks Jim Coyne, PhD Ian Bennett, MD, PhD Steve Marcus, PhD Jessica Rinaldi Laura Hanisch, PhD Steve Palmer, PhD

References Halbreich U. Prevalence of mood symptoms and depressions during pregnancy: implications for clinical practice and research. CNS Spectr. 2004;9(3): Kupfer DJ, Frank E, Perel JM, et al. Five-year outcome for maintenance therapies in recurrent depression. Arch Gen Psychiatry. 1992;49(10): Anita H. Clayton, MD. Considerations in Women’s Mental Health: Depression During Pregnancy. Primary Psychiatry. 2004;11(7):17-18 Amici et al, “Impact of the Hawthorne Effect in a Longitudinal Clinical Study: The Case of Anesthesia,” Controlled Clinical Trials 2000; 21: Rob McCarney, James Warner, Steve Iliffe, Robbert van Haselen, Mark Griffin Peter Fisher, “The Hawthorne Effect: a randomised, controlled trial,” BMC Medical Research Methodology 2007; 7: 30 PH Feil, JS Grauer, CC Gadbury-Amyot, K Kula, MD McCunniff, “Intentional use of the Hawthorne effect to improve oral hygiene compliance in orthodontic patients,” Journal of Dental Education 2002; 66: Rita Mangione-Smith, Marc N Elliott, Laurie McDonald, Elizabeth A McGlynn, “An Observational Study of Antibiotic Prescribing Behavior and the Hawthorne Effect,” Health Services Research 2002;37,6: 1603–1623.