Tessa Charles Australian Synchrotron / Monash University 1 Bunch Compression Schemes for X-band FELs
2 AXXS (Australian X-band X-ray Source) Upgrade the storage ring with an MBA lattice with < 1 nm rad, in the existing tunnel with the same source points. Build a 3 GeV x-band linac to inject a low emittance beam into the storage ring. Use a second x-band linac to generate a 6 GeV beam for an XFEL. CLIC Workshop 2015 – Tessa Charles - 2
Comparison of bunch compression schemes – Magnetic Chicane (most FELs) – Double Achromat (e.g. MAX IV) – Harmonic Linearization – Optical Linearization Today’s talk Why these schemes Preliminary simulation results Bunch compressors we’re considering CLIC Workshop 2015 – Tessa Charles - 3
Magnetic Chicane R56 0 δE z Chirped, linearized beam Compressed beam CLIC Workshop 2015 – Tessa Charles - 4
AXXS (Australian X-band X-ray Source) - Two Designs 1.Base line design: S-band with X-band structure for linearizing before BC1 1.Alternative design being considered: X-band the whole way Gun Injector BC1 BC2 Dogleg Linac2 Undulator Linac1 Experimental Station S-band ~40 MV/m 6 x 4 m X-band ~65 MV/m 4 x 0.75 m X-band ~65 MV/m 90 x 0.75 m ~150 m Gun Injector BC2 Dogleg Linac2 Undulator Linac1 Experimental Station X-band ~65 MV/m 10 x 0.75 m X-band ~65 MV/m 4 x 0.75 m X-band ~65 MV/m 90 x 0.75 m ~110 m BC1 CLIC Workshop 2015 – Tessa Charles - 5
AXXS (Australian X-band X-ray Source) CLIC Workshop 2015 – Tessa Charles - 6
How to linearize the longitudinal phase space? Harmonic vs Optical linearization CLIC Workshop 2015 – Tessa Charles - 7
All X-band design One way to linearize the longitudinal phase - Optical linearization CLIC Workshop 2015 – Tessa Charles - 8
Optical Linearization - Theoretical description Optimal compression => When higher order terms are considered… Bunch length after compression (to 1 st order): Y. Sun et al. Phys. Rev. ST Accel. Beams 17, (2014) CLIC Workshop 2015 – Tessa Charles - 9
Optical Linearization - Choosing R56, T566 & U5666 CLIC Workshop 2015 – Tessa Charles - 10
Optical Linearization Linac1 end / BC1 entrance BC1 end Linac2 end / BC2 entrance BC2 end Y. Sun et al. Phys. Rev. ST Accel. Beams 17, (2014) CLIC Workshop 2015 – Tessa Charles - 11
Optical Linearization Y. Sun et al. Phys. Rev. ST Accel. Beams 17, (2014) T566 = 80 mm R56 = 17 mm CLIC Workshop 2015 – Tessa Charles - 12
Positive R56 & positive T566 Self Linearizing BC1: R 56 = 3.23 cm T 566 = 9.26 cm BC2: R 56 = 2.6 c m T 566 = cm MAX IV Detailed Design Report on the MAX IV Facility (2010) CLIC Workshop 2015 – Tessa Charles - 13
Preliminary Simulation Results Four simulations of linac compression schemes compared. A work in progress CLIC Workshop 2015 – Tessa Charles - 14
01 – BASE LINE DESIGN Inc. 12 GHz linearizer CLIC Workshop 2015 – Tessa Charles - 15
S band with X band structure for linearizing before BC1 Base line design (S-band w X-band linearizer) Gun Injector BC1 BC2 Dogleg Linac2 Undulator Linac1 Experimental Station S-band ~40 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m X-band 12 GHz Initial beam parameters: m e c (pCentral) = Q = 2.5x C Bunch length (rms) = 2.64 ps Simulations based of Andrea Latina’s elegant files. CLIC Workshop 2015 – Tessa Charles - 16
S band with X band structure for linearizing before BC1 Base line design (S-band w X-band linearizer) Gun Injector BC1 BC2 Dogleg Linac2 Undulator Linac1 Experimental Station S-band ~40 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m X-band 12 GHz CLIC Workshop 2015 – Tessa Charles – 17
S band with X band structure for linearizing before BC1 Base line design (S-band w X-band linearizer) Gun Injector BC1 BC2 Dogleg Linac2 Undulator Linac1 Experimental Station S-band ~40 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m X-band 12 GHz CLIC Workshop 2015 – Tessa Charles - 18
S band with X band structure for linearizing before BC1 Base line design (S-band w X-band linearizer) Gun Injector BC1 BC2 Dogleg Linac2 Undulator Linac1 Experimental Station S-band ~40 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m X-band 12 GHz CLIC Workshop 2015 – Tessa Charles - 19
S band with X band structure for linearizing before BC1 Base line design (S-band w X-band linearizer) Gun Injector BC1 BC2 Dogleg Linac2 Undulator Linac1 Experimental Station S-band ~40 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m X-band 12 GHz CLIC Workshop 2015 – Tessa Charles - 20
S band with X band structure for linearizing before BC1 Base line design (S-band w X-band linearizer) Gun Injector BC1 BC2 Dogleg Linac2 Undulator Linac1 Experimental Station S-band ~40 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m X-band 12 GHz CLIC Workshop 2015 – Tessa Charles - 21
S band with X band structure for linearizing before BC1 Base line design (S-band w X-band linearizer) Gun Injector BC1 BC2 Dogleg Linac2 Undulator Linac1 Experimental Station S-band ~40 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m X-band 12 GHz Compression Ratio after BC1: 8.34 CLIC Workshop 2015 – Tessa Charles - 22
S band with X band structure for linearizing before BC1 Base line design (S-band w X-band linearizer) Gun Injector BC1 BC2 Dogleg Linac2 Undulator Linac1 Experimental Station S-band ~40 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m X-band 12 GHz CLIC Workshop 2015 – Tessa Charles - 23
S band with X band structure for linearizing before BC1 Base line design (S-band w X-band linearizer) Gun Injector BC1 BC2 Dogleg Linac2 Undulator Linac1 Experimental Station S-band ~40 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m X-band 12 GHz CLIC Workshop 2015 – Tessa Charles - 24
Base line design (S-band w X-band linearizer) Gun Injector BC1 BC2 Dogleg Linac2 Undulator Linac1 Experimental Station S-band ~40 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m X-band 12 GHz CLIC Workshop 2015 – Tessa Charles - 25
Base line design (S-band w X-band linearizer) Gun Injector BC1 BC2 Dogleg Linac2 Undulator Linac1 Experimental Station S-band ~40 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m X-band 12 GHz CLIC Workshop 2015 – Tessa Charles - 26
Base line design (S-band w X-band linearizer) Gun Injector BC1 BC2 Dogleg Linac2 Undulator Linac1 Experimental Station S-band ~40 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m X-band 12 GHz CLIC Workshop 2015 – Tessa Charles - 27
S band with X band structure for linearizing before BC1 Base line design (S-band w X-band linearizer) Gun Injector BC1 BC2 Dogleg Linac2 Undulator Linac1 Experimental Station S-band ~40 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m X-band 12 GHz CLIC Workshop 2015 – Tessa Charles - 28
Base line design (S-band w X-band linearizer) Gun Injector BC1 BC2 Dogleg Linac2 Undulator Linac1 Experimental Station S-band ~40 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m X-band 12 GHz End of linac: Compression Ratio: CLIC Workshop 2015 – Tessa Charles - 29
Base line design (S-band w X-band linearizer) Gun Injector BC1 BC2 Dogleg Linac2 Undulator Linac1 Experimental Station S-band ~40 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m X-band 12 GHz CLIC Workshop 2015 – Tessa Charles - 30
Base line design (S-band w X-band linearizer) Gun Injector BC1 BC2 Dogleg Linac2 Undulator Linac1 Experimental Station S-band ~40 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m X-band 12 GHz CLIC Workshop 2015 – Tessa Charles - 31
02 – ALL X-BAND Without a harmonic linearizer CLIC Workshop 2015 – Tessa Charles - 32
CLIC Workshop 2015 – Tessa Charles All X-band (w/o harmonic linearizer) Gun Injector BC1 BC2 Dogleg Linac2 Undulator Linac1 Experimental Station X-band ~65 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m
02 All X-band (w/o harmonic linearizer) Gun Injector BC1 BC2 Dogleg Linac2 Undulator Linac1 Experimental Station X-band ~65 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m CLIC Workshop 2015 – Tessa Charles - 34
02 All X-band (w/o harmonic linearizer) Gun Injector BC1 BC2 Dogleg Linac2 Undulator Linac1 Experimental Station X-band ~65 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m CLIC Workshop 2015 – Tessa Charles - 35
02 All X-band (w/o harmonic linearizer) Gun Injector BC1 BC2 Dogleg Linac2 Undulator Linac1 Experimental Station X-band ~65 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m CLIC Workshop 2015 – Tessa Charles - 36
02 All X-band (w/o harmonic linearizer) Gun Injector BC1 BC2 Dogleg Linac2 Undulator Linac1 Experimental Station X-band ~65 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m CLIC Workshop 2015 – Tessa Charles - 37
02 All X-band (w/o harmonic linearizer) Gun Injector BC1 BC2 Dogleg Linac2 Undulator Linac1 Experimental Station X-band ~65 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m CLIC Workshop 2015 – Tessa Charles - 38
Compression Ratio after BC1: All X-band (w/o harmonic linearizer) Gun Injector BC1 BC2 Dogleg Linac2 Undulator Linac1 Experimental Station X-band ~65 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m CLIC Workshop 2015 – Tessa Charles - 39
02 All X-band (w/o harmonic linearizer) Gun Injector BC1 BC2 Dogleg Linac2 Undulator Linac1 Experimental Station X-band ~65 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m CLIC Workshop 2015 – Tessa Charles - 40
02 All X-band (w/o harmonic linearizer) Gun Injector BC1 BC2 Dogleg Linac2 Undulator Linac1 Experimental Station X-band ~65 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m CLIC Workshop 2015 – Tessa Charles - 41
02 All X-band (w/o harmonic linearizer) Gun Injector BC1 BC2 Dogleg Linac2 Undulator Linac1 Experimental Station X-band ~65 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m CLIC Workshop 2015 – Tessa Charles - 42
02 All X-band (w/o harmonic linearizer) Gun Injector BC1 BC2 Dogleg Linac2 Undulator Linac1 Experimental Station X-band ~65 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m CLIC Workshop 2015 – Tessa Charles - 43
02 All X-band (w/o harmonic linearizer) Gun Injector BC1 BC2 Dogleg Linac2 Undulator Linac1 Experimental Station X-band ~65 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m CLIC Workshop 2015 – Tessa Charles - 44
02 All X-band (w/o harmonic linearizer) Gun Injector BC1 BC2 Dogleg Linac2 Undulator Linac1 Experimental Station X-band ~65 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m CLIC Workshop 2015 – Tessa Charles - 45
End of linac: Compression Ratio: All X-band (w/o harmonic linearizer) Gun Injector BC1 BC2 Dogleg Linac2 Undulator Linac1 Experimental Station X-band ~65 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m CLIC Workshop 2015 – Tessa Charles - 46
02 All X-band (w/o harmonic linearizer) Gun Injector BC1 BC2 Dogleg Linac2 Undulator Linac1 Experimental Station X-band ~65 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m CLIC Workshop 2015 – Tessa Charles - 47 Optics not yet optimized
Compression Ratio: All X-band (w/o harmonic linearizer) Gun Injector BC1 BC2 Dogleg Linac2 Undulator Linac1 Experimental Station X-band ~65 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m CLIC Workshop 2015 – Tessa Charles - 48
03 – ALL X-BAND Inc. 24 GHz linearizer CLIC Workshop 2015 – Tessa Charles - 49
03 All X-band (24GHz linearizer) Gun Injector BC1 BC2 Dogleg Linac2 Undulator Linac1 Experimental Station X-band 12 GHz X-band ~65 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m X-band 24 GHz CLIC Workshop 2015 – Tessa Charles - 50
03 All X-band (24GHz linearizer) Gun Injector BC1 BC2 Dogleg Linac2 Undulator Linac1 Experimental Station X-band 12 GHz X-band ~65 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m X-band 24 GHz CLIC Workshop 2015 – Tessa Charles - 51
03 All X-band (24GHz linearizer) Gun Injector BC1 BC2 Dogleg Linac2 Undulator Linac1 Experimental Station X-band 12 GHz X-band ~65 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m X-band 24 GHz CLIC Workshop 2015 – Tessa Charles - 52
03 All X-band (24GHz linearizer) Gun Injector BC1 BC2 Dogleg Linac2 Undulator Linac1 Experimental Station X-band 12 GHz X-band ~65 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m X-band 24 GHz CLIC Workshop 2015 – Tessa Charles - 53
03 All X-band (24GHz linearizer) Gun Injector BC1 BC2 Dogleg Linac2 Undulator Linac1 Experimental Station X-band 12 GHz X-band ~65 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m X-band 24 GHz CLIC Workshop 2015 – Tessa Charles - 54
CLIC Workshop 2015 – Tessa Charles - 55 Compression Ratio after BC1: Gun Injector BC1 BC2 Dogleg Linac2 Undulator Linac1 Experimental Station X-band 12 GHz X-band ~65 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m X-band 24 GHz 03 All X-band (24GHz linearizer)
Gun Injector BC1 BC2 Dogleg Linac2 Undulator Linac1 Experimental Station X-band 12 GHz X-band ~65 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m X-band 24 GHz CLIC Workshop 2015 – Tessa Charles - 56
03 All X-band (24GHz linearizer) Gun Injector BC1 BC2 Dogleg Linac2 Undulator Linac1 Experimental Station X-band 12 GHz X-band ~65 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m X-band 24 GHz CLIC Workshop 2015 – Tessa Charles - 57
03 All X-band (24GHz linearizer) Gun Injector BC1 BC2 Dogleg Linac2 Undulator Linac1 Experimental Station X-band 12 GHz X-band ~65 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m X-band 24 GHz CLIC Workshop 2015 – Tessa Charles - 58
03 All X-band (24GHz linearizer) Gun Injector BC1 BC2 Dogleg Linac2 Undulator Linac1 Experimental Station X-band 12 GHz X-band ~65 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m X-band 24 GHz CLIC Workshop 2015 – Tessa Charles - 59
03 All X-band (24GHz linearizer) Gun Injector BC1 BC2 Dogleg Linac2 Undulator Linac1 Experimental Station X-band 12 GHz X-band ~65 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m X-band 24 GHz CLIC Workshop 2015 – Tessa Charles - 60
03 All X-band (24GHz linearizer) Gun Injector BC1 BC2 Dogleg Linac2 Undulator Linac1 Experimental Station X-band 12 GHz X-band ~65 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m X-band 24 GHz CLIC Workshop 2015 – Tessa Charles - 61
03 All X-band (24GHz linearizer) Gun Injector BC1 BC2 Dogleg Linac2 Undulator Linac1 Experimental Station X-band 12 GHz X-band ~65 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m X-band 24 GHz End of linac: Compression Ratio: CLIC Workshop 2015 – Tessa Charles - 62
03 All X-band (24GHz linearizer) Gun Injector BC1 BC2 Dogleg Linac2 Undulator Linac1 Experimental Station X-band 12 GHz X-band ~65 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m X-band 24 GHz Along the length of the linac CLIC Workshop 2015 – Tessa Charles - 63
04 – ALL X-BAND Inc. 36 GHz linearizer CLIC Workshop 2015 – Tessa Charles - 64
04 All X-band (36 GHz linearizer) Gun Injector BC1 BC2 Dogleg Linac2 Undulator Linac1 Experimental Station X-band 12 GHz X-band ~65 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m X-band 36 GHz CLIC Workshop 2015 – Tessa Charles - 65
04 All X-band (36 GHz linearizer) Gun Injector BC1 BC2 Dogleg Linac2 Undulator Linac1 Experimental Station X-band 12 GHz X-band ~65 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m X-band 36 GHz CLIC Workshop 2015 – Tessa Charles - 66
04 All X-band (36 GHz linearizer) Gun Injector BC1 BC2 Dogleg Linac2 Undulator Linac1 Experimental Station X-band 12 GHz X-band ~65 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m X-band 36 GHz CLIC Workshop 2015 – Tessa Charles - 67
04 All X-band (36 GHz linearizer) Gun Injector BC1 BC2 Dogleg Linac2 Undulator Linac1 Experimental Station X-band 12 GHz X-band ~65 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m X-band 36 GHz CLIC Workshop 2015 – Tessa Charles - 68
04 All X-band (36 GHz linearizer) Gun Injector BC1 BC2 Dogleg Linac2 Undulator Linac1 Experimental Station X-band 12 GHz X-band ~65 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m X-band 36 GHz CLIC Workshop 2015 – Tessa Charles - 69
04 All X-band (36 GHz linearizer) Gun Injector BC1 BC2 Dogleg Linac2 Undulator Linac1 Experimental Station X-band 12 GHz X-band ~65 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m X-band 36 GHz Compression Ratio after BC1: CLIC Workshop 2015 – Tessa Charles - 70
04 All X-band (36 GHz linearizer) Gun Injector BC1 BC2 Dogleg Linac2 Undulator Linac1 Experimental Station X-band 12 GHz X-band ~65 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m X-band 36 GHz CLIC Workshop 2015 – Tessa Charles - 71
04 All X-band (36 GHz linearizer) Gun Injector BC1 BC2 Dogleg Linac2 Undulator Linac1 Experimental Station X-band 12 GHz X-band ~65 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m X-band 36 GHz CLIC Workshop 2015 – Tessa Charles - 72
04 All X-band (36 GHz linearizer) Gun Injector BC1 BC2 Dogleg Linac2 Undulator Linac1 Experimental Station X-band 12 GHz X-band ~65 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m X-band 36 GHz CLIC Workshop 2015 – Tessa Charles - 73
04 All X-band (36 GHz linearizer) Gun Injector BC1 BC2 Dogleg Linac2 Undulator Linac1 Experimental Station X-band 12 GHz X-band ~65 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m X-band 36 GHz CLIC Workshop 2015 – Tessa Charles - 74
04 All X-band (36 GHz linearizer) Gun Injector BC1 BC2 Dogleg Linac2 Undulator Linac1 Experimental Station X-band 12 GHz X-band ~65 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m X-band 36 GHz CLIC Workshop 2015 – Tessa Charles - 75
04 All X-band (36 GHz linearizer) Gun Injector BC1 BC2 Dogleg Linac2 Undulator Linac1 Experimental Station X-band 12 GHz X-band ~65 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m X-band 36 GHz CLIC Workshop 2015 – Tessa Charles - 76
End of linac: Compression Ratio: Gun Injector BC1 BC2 Dogleg Linac2 Undulator Linac1 Experimental Station X-band 12 GHz X-band ~65 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m X-band 36 GHz 04 All X-band (36 GHz linearizer) CLIC Workshop 2015 – Tessa Charles - 77
Gun Injector BC1 BC2 Dogleg Linac2 Undulator Linac1 Experimental Station X-band 12 GHz X-band ~65 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m X-band 36 GHz Along the length of the linac: 04 All X-band (36 GHz linearizer) CLIC Workshop 2015 – Tessa Charles - 78
04 All X-band (36 GHz linearizer) Gun Injector BC1 BC2 Dogleg Linac2 Undulator Linac1 Experimental Station X-band 12 GHz X-band ~65 MV/m X-band ~65 MV/m X-band 36 GHz Along the length of the linac: CLIC Workshop 2015 – Tessa Charles - 79
Comparison of the 4 simulated scenarios End of linac comparison CLIC Workshop 2015 – Tessa Charles S-band w X-band linearizer (Base line)02 all X-band w/o linearizer 03 all X-band w 24 GHz linearizer04 all X-band w 36 GHz linearizer
Where to from here… Further optimization of chicane simulations and inclusions of additional effects (CSR) & optimize optics Look into beam parameters optimal for photon production Investigate optical linearization in chicanes Investigate optical linearization in double achromats CLIC Workshop 2015 – Tessa Charles - 81
Thank you