The Physician Asthma Care Education (PACE) Study Michael D. Cabana, MD, MPH Implementation Research: Epi 245 October 9, 2008 Department of Pediatrics,

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Team/Organization Name Background and structure Location Brief system information (type, size) Pilot population.
Advertisements

Chronic disease self management – a systematic review of proactive telephone applications Carly Muller Dean Schillinger Division of General Internal Medicine.
WHO Antenatal Course Preparing the new WHO eProfessors.
The Chronic Care Model.
1 Healthier Generation Benefit: Supporting the Assessment, Prevention, and Treatment of Childhood Obesity Liz Martin, MS, CHES Director of Population Health.
Disease State Management The Pharmacist’s Role
Self-Regulation in Chronic Disease Noreen M. Clark, Ph.D. March 23, 2002.
Deductible-based Health Insurance Plans: Are Complex Deductible Exemptions Confusing Patients? Mary Reed, DrPH Center for Health Policy Studies, Kaiser.
Maria A. Wamsley, MD Professor of Clinical Medicine UCSF School of Medicine.
Improving Online Weight Loss and Dissemination Potential RC1 HL
Effect of Physician Asthma Education on Health Care Utilization of Children at Different Income Levels Randall Brown, Noreen Clark, Niko Kaciroti, Molly.
Journal Club Alcohol and Health: Current Evidence May–June 2005.
Physician Asthma Care Education. Background Excellence in medical treatment is worthless if the patient doesn’t take the medicine Compliance is closely.
USE OF PEAK FLOW METER AS AN OBSERVATION AND TEACHING TOOL IN AN EDUCATIONAL PROGRAM IN WOMEN WITH ASTHMA Noreen M. Clark, Molly Z. Gong, Martha B. DeRoeck,
Component 4: Education for a Partnership in Asthma Care The goal of all patient education is to help patients take the actions needed to control their.
Asthma: Shared Medical Appointments
Improving Outcomes by Helping People Take Control
Barriers and Facilitators of Implementation New York Academy of Medicine Peter Dayan, MD, MSc December, 2012.
Presented by Vicki M. Young, PhD October 19,
IMPACT OF A PARENT DIRECTED TEACHING PROGRAM IN FAMILY CENTERED CHRONIC CARE Teri L Turner, MD, MPH, MEd 1, Elaine Hime 2, Mark A Ward, MD 1 1 Department.
Chronic Disease Management: Driving Quality Improvement in Primary Care August 1, 2008 Jan Norman, RD, CDE Washington State Department of Health.
Transitioning from Children’s to Adult Hospital Inpatient Settings Sarah Ahrens, MD Ryan Coller, MD, MPH Jody Belling, RN, MS.
The potential impact of adherence to a guideline on the utilization of head CT scans in traumatic head injury patients. Frederick K. Korley M.D.
Basma Y. Kentab MSc.. 1. Define ambulatory care 2. Describe the value of ambulatory care practices 3. Explore pharmacy services in some ambulatory care.
Food Safety Professional Development for Early Childhood Educators Evaluation Plan.
Fundamentals of Evaluation for Public Health Programs ROBERT FOLEY, M.ED. NIHB TRIBAL PUBLIC HEALTH SUMMIT MARCH 31,
1 Jan Eldred Karen W. Linkins Lisa Mangiante December 10, 2008.
Effects of Pediatric Asthma Education on Hospitalizations and Emergency Department Visits: A Meta-Analysis June 3, 2007 Janet M. Coffman, PhD, Michael.
Patient-centered HIT: a pediatric case study Stephen C. Porter MD, MPH, MS Assistant Professor, Harvard Medical School Affiliate Faculty, Harvard-MIT Division.
Impact of the “Asthma Toolbox” for Improving Documentation of Pediatric Asthma Management in an Urban Community Health Center Presenter: Delaney Gracy,
The Role of Study Circles in Promoting Health Literacy A Presentation to NIFL Health Literacy Summit Regional Resource Center I Indianapolis, Indiana March.
Chapter Quality Network (CQN) Asthma Pilot Project Our Now and Our Future James C. Wiley, MD, FAAP CQN Chapter Physician Leader Alabama Chapter-AAP President.
Designing a mobile health intervention for diabetes management in India Fiona Y. Akhtar MBA, MS | Mobile Health Design | June 10, 2013
Health Disparities: Residents and Schools Partnering to Optimize Asthma Care Pediatric Academic Societies April 29 th, 2006.
“The Effect of Patient Complexity on Treatment Outcomes for Patients Enrolled in an Integrated Depression Treatment Program- a Pilot Study” Ryan Miller,
Asthma in Kentucky Kids Tricia McLendon, MPH Asthma Program Manager Kentucky Department for Public Health October 17, 2003.
Community and Clinician Partnership for Prevention (C2P2) Alex R. Kemper, MD, MPH, MS Philip Sloane, MD, MPH Rowena Dolor, MD, MHS Tricia L. Trinite’,
Building Clinical Infrastructure and Expert Support Michael Steinberg, MD, FACR ULAAC Disparity Project Centinela/Freeman Health System.
Put Prevention Into Practice. Understand the PPIP Program What is Put Prevention Into Practice (PPIP)? What is Put Prevention Into Practice (PPIP)? Why.
Chapter Quality Network (CQN) Asthma Pilot Project Our Present and Our Future Sandra Miller, MD Oregon Chapter Physician Leader Judy Dolins, MPH Director,
Origin and Process of Utah Guidelines Anna Fondario, MPH Utah Department of Health Violence and Injury Prevention Program.
System Changes and Interventions: Registry as a Clinical Practice Tool Mike Hindmarsh Improving Chronic Illness Care, a national program of the Robert.
Community Planning Training 5- Community Planning Training 5-1.
Medication Therapy Management Programs in Community Pharmacy Community Pharmacy October 17, 2006 Kurt A. Proctor, Ph.D., RPh Chief Operating Officer Community.
Copyright restrictions may apply Randomized Trial of Teaching Brief Motivational Interviewing to Pediatric Trainees to Promote Healthy Behaviors in Families.
Maine Prenatal Collaborative Susan Swartz, M.D. Judy Soper, RT(R), RDMS, BS Tim Cowan, MSPH Principal Investigator Project Director Data Analyst December.
Predictors of Asthma in Young Children Does Reporting Source Affect Our Conclusions? Jane E. Miller Jane E. Miller, Ph.D. Institute for Health, Health.
Office Redesign to Increase Prevention Services? Give “PEAs” a Chance Cheryl B. Aspy, Ph.D. Professor, Family & Preventive Medicine OUHSC – College of.
TB physicians’ perspectives on barriers to deliver brief counseling interventions (BCI) within routine tuberculosis services: A qualitative study on a.
Strategies to Improve Clinical Practice Through Guidelines: Experience from Recent Studies Michael Cabana (UCSF) Rebecca Beyth (University of Florida)
Practice Key Driver Diagram. Chapter Quality Network ADHD Project Jeff Epstein PhD CQN ADHD National Expert/CQN Data Analyst The mehealth Portal and CQN.
Addressing Tobacco Control In Dental Networks Eric E. Stafne, D.D.S., M.S.D. Director Tobacco Cessation Program University of MN School of Dentistry Shelley.
Readmissions Driver Diagram OHA HEN 2.0. Readmissions AIMPrimary Drivers Secondary DriversChange Ideas Reduce Readmissions Identify patients at high-risk.
Children’s Policy Conference Austin, TX February 24, ECI as best practice model for children 0-3 years with developmental delays / chronic identified.
Carol A. Miller, MD Professor, Pediatrics UCSF Benioff Children’s Hospital And the Asthma Task Force Team.
“STAR (Safe Transitions Across CaRe): A resident and faculty initiative to improve patient care across the healthcare continuum Nancy M. Denizard-Thompson,
Teaching and Evaluating the Follow-up Visit: A 2-staged Patient Simulation Carol P. Motley MD Ehab Molokhia MD University of South Alabama College of Medicine.
Increased # of AI/AN receiving in- home environmental assessment and trigger reduction education and asthma self-management education Increased # of tribal.
Clare Meernik, MPH 1 ; Anna McCullough, MSW, MSPH, CTTS 1 ; Leah Ranney, PhD 1 ; Barbara Walsh 2 ; Adam O. Goldstein, MD, MPH 1 Predictors of Quit for.
The Impact of Asthma Education CHKV Medical Mission 2011 By Jo-Anne St. Vincent Jo-Anne St. Vincent.
APHA, November 7, 2007 Amy Friedman Milanovich, MPH Head of Training and Dissemination Center for Managing Chronic Disease University of Michigan Using.
Drug Utilization Review & Drug Utilization Evaluation: An Overview
Improvements in asthma knowledge and self-efficacy among daycare staff, parents and health professionals following an interactive workshop Jonathan Ross,
A Systems Change Collaborative to Improve Asthma Care Peter Harper, MD, MPH University of Minnesota Kristi Van Riper, MPH, CHES American Lung Association.
Research Questions Does integration of behavioral health and primary care services, compared to simple co-location, improve patient-centered outcomes in.
Psychoeducational group therapy within a pediatric residency clinic:
Medical College of Wisconsin
Medical care and self-management support for asthma in primary care: a comparison between France and the United Kingdom A.Dima, E. van Ganse, H. Le Cloarec,
USE OF PEAK FLOW METER AS AN OBSERVATION AND TEACHING TOOL IN AN EDUCATIONAL PROGRAM IN WOMEN WITH ASTHMA Noreen M. Clark, Molly Z. Gong, Martha B. DeRoeck,
ICARE Trial Survey Post-Analysis
Presentation transcript:

The Physician Asthma Care Education (PACE) Study Michael D. Cabana, MD, MPH Implementation Research: Epi 245 October 9, 2008 Department of Pediatrics, Epidemiology and Biostatistics and the Philip R. Lee Institute for Health Policy Studies, University of California, San Francisco (UCSF) Funded by the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation (Princeton, NJ)

Four Components of NHLBI Guidelines Measures of Assessment and Monitoring Control of Contributing Factors Pharmacologic Therapy Education for a Partnership in Asthma Care

Knowledge Attitudes Behavior Lack of Awareness Lack of Agreement External Barriers Lack of Self-Efficacy Lack of Outcome Expectancy Inertia BARRIER Lack of Familiarity

Barriers to Effective Communication Visit time is limited Providers have multiple tasks to accomplish in a single visit Patients may have different beliefs, concerns and goals about the treatment plan Communication skills were not previously emphasized in medical education

Overview Guideline recommendations for patient communication –Communication skills –Key messages Controlled trial results Next Steps

Specific communication techniques have been shown to enhance physician communication and outcomes for patients

Key Messages from the Guidelines Set #1 What happens during an asthma attack How to take medicines How to respond to changes in asthma severity Set #2 Safety of medicines Goals of therapy Criteria for successful treatment Set #3 Managing asthma at school Identifying and avoiding triggers Sources of additional asthma education

Key Educational Messages Group important concepts into groups of 3 to 4 key messages Spread out the delivery of these groups of key messages over several visits Reinforce key messages over time Use the patient medical record to keep track of which messages have been delivered

The PACE Program Pilot Target audience: Primary care pediatricians Purpose: To improve primary care counseling for patients with asthma Faculty: General pediatrician, asthma subspecialist, health educator and coding/billing expert Format: brief lectures, case studies, video modeling effective practices, and tools for self- evaluation and education Two 2.5 hour seminars one week apart

Pilot Intervention Design: Controlled trial Participants:83 pediatricians (Ann Arbor and New York) Evaluation:Asthma care of 637 patients (2 year follow-up)

Patient Outcomes Patients whose physicians provided education plus inhaled corticosteroids did better than those who received corticosteroids alone: –Reduced emergency room visits –Reduced hospitalizations –Reduced days with symptoms

Further Questions Can this program work in other communities in the United States? What additional modifications are needed to successfully disseminate this information to other communities?

Bakersfield, CA Corpus Christi, TX Jacksonville, FL New Castle County, DE Omaha, NE St. Paul, MN Nashville, TN Columbus, OH Indianapolis IN Kent County, MI Methods Design: Randomized Controlled Trial in 10 sites in the United States Randomization: 10 sites matched into 5 pairs Subjects: Over 100 physicians with follow-up of 870 of their patients with asthma Follow-up period: 1 year

Program Modifications Collaboration with opinion leaders –General pediatrics and asthma subspecialty care –“Train-the-trainer” session Endorsement of local medical organizations Additional segment on documentation, coding and billing for asthma education

Program Format Target audience: Primary care providers Faculty: General pediatrician, asthma subspecialist, health educator and coding/billing expert Format: brief lectures, case studies, video modeling effective practices, and tools for self-evaluation and education Two 2.5 hour seminars one week apart

Knowledge Attitudes Behavior Lack of Awareness Lack of Familiarity Lack of Agreement Lack of Self-efficacy Lack of Outcome Expectancy Inertia of Previous Practice External Barriers Knowledge Attitudes Behavior Copy of Guidelines Short lectures/discussion Review of Guidelines Handouts Opinion Leaders Local endorsement Teaching & Modeling specific skills Review of Data from previous studies One week test period Documentation, coding & reimbursement Checklists & reminders Placebos & Patient education materials

Provider Confidence Provider Confidence Provider Counseling Outcomes Patient Symptoms Asthma Healthcare Utilization Asthma Healthcare Utilization Self-administered physician questionnaires Telephone interviews with parents of asthma patients. Healthcare utilization validated by chart audit.

Analysis Plan ‘Intention to treat’ analysis Multivariate regression analyses –We controlled for baseline values, site, demographic characteristics, severity of illness and group assignment –Generalized estimating equation analysis for significant clustering –We included an interaction term for (group) x (baseline asthma utilization)

Results 101 primary care providers participated –48 control –53 intervention Patients randomly selected –870 of 1051 (83%) eligible parents interviewed –Median number of patients/provider = 7

Communication Technique OR95% CI Finding out the family’s biggest asthma concern , 2.40 Working with the family to develop a short- term asthma plan , 8.10 Working with the family to develop a long- term asthma plan , 11.7 Discussing specific criteria for managing asthma , 5.65 Impact on Provider Confidence Controlling for physician gender

Impact on Provider Communication Controlling for patient age, gender, severity of illness, tobacco exposure, insurance and baseline use of communication technique Communication Technique OR95% CI The doctor tried to find out my biggest asthma concern , 2.58 After talking to the doctor, we had a good idea of the short-term asthma plan , 1.82 After talking to the doctor, we knew about the long-term asthma plan , 2.59 The doctor discussed specific criteria about managing asthma , 2.24

Days Limited by Asthma Symptoms † ControlIntervention Mean Days/Year BaselineFollow-up Baseline Follow-up † p < 0.05; controlling for patient age, gender, severity of illness, tobacco exposure, insurance, baseline values and the interaction term for (group assignment) x (baseline value)

Emergency Department Utilization † ControlIntervention Mean ED visits per Year BaselineFollow-up Baseline Follow-up † p < 0.05; controlling for patient age, gender, severity of illness, tobacco exposure, insurance, baseline values and the interaction term for (group assignment) x (baseline value)

Inpatient Asthma Hospitalization ControlIntervention BaselineFollow-up Baseline Follow-up Mean Hospitalizations per Year

Physician Prescribing Patterns Improving Asthma Corticosteroid Therapy (IMPACT) Design: Randomized Controlled Trial Purpose: To evaluate the effectiveness of physician education for improving prescription of daily inhaled corticosteroids for asthma. Duration: 5 years Source: National Heart, Lung & Blood Institute (NHLBI)

Location of Physicians for Pilot Study D.A.L.I Distance Asthma Learning Initiative

Implementation Lessons Learned Standardization to make sure the message is consistent –Based on national asthma guidelines –Standard speaker’s guide, slides and video Tailoring the program to the community –Endorsement of professional organizations –Use of opinion leaders as faculty Consider multiple opinion leaders with different areas of expertise Appreciate and understand barriers –Perception that asthma counseling won’t be reimbursed –Perception that asthma counseling takes a lot of time

Lessons Learned Difficulty in reaching physicians in isolated communities Intervention may only attract “early adopters” Need to address perceived barriers (e.g., lack of outcome expectancy, reimbursement) Skills-based, interactive programs can be effective in improving physician practice and patient outcomes

Thank you