The State of Webber Pond Understanding the Factors Affecting Water Quality in the Webber Pond Watershed Colby Environmental Assessment Team Colby College.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Management of Drainage Water in Illinois
Advertisements

A section has been added regarding Stream Restoration Design Criteria: A. Designs for stream restoration try to mimic natural conditions present in stable.
Phosphorus As A Stressor Alexandra Arntsen, Alison Foster, Scott Ritter April 2011.
Phosphorus Index for Oregon and Washington Steve Campbell USDA - Natural Resources Conservation Service Portland, Oregon Dan Sullivan Oregon State University.
Togus Pond Development Surveys Lauren Wolpin. Development Overview Shoreland Zoning Regulations Wastewater Disposal Development Survey Buffer Strip Survey.
Cascade Charter Township
Truesdale Lake Lake Management Plan Truesdale Lake Association South Salem, NY.
Wes Marshall, P.E. University of Connecticut March 2007 CE 276 Site Design Chapter 10 – Soil Erosion & Sediment Control.
WATER CONSERVATION PRINCIPLES AND PRACTICES. Water conservation “ The conservation treatment meant to reduce or prevent sheet erosion while achieving.
The Benefits of Investing In Conservation… …and the Costs of Not Investing Developed by Daniel Mountjoy USDA - Natural Resources Conservation Service Laura.
Water Pollution. Watershed A watershed is an area of land from which all the water drains to the same location, such as a stream, pond, lake, river, wetland.
Ch  Know what design frequency means  Know how to delineate a drainage area on a topographic map 2.
An Investigation on the Effects of Climate Change On Algal Blooms in Lake Champlain Patricia Brousseau, Lauren Chicote, John Keyes, Jenna Mandelbaum, Christopher.
A Watershed Analysis of Threemile Pond: Implications for water quality and land use management Colby College Environmental Assessment Team Colby College.
The State of Webber Pond Understanding the Factors Affecting Water Quality in the Webber Pond Watershed Colby Environmental Assessment Team Colby College.
Geographic Information Systems and Modeling Andrew Mckenna- Foster.
Fundamentals of River Restoration and Salmonid Fisheries OWEB, 1999, Fundamentals of River Restoration and Salmonid Fisheries OWEB, 1999, Fundamentals.
Freshwater Fishery Management Objective- Discuss the lake habitat to include basic fishery management techniques.
Ohau Channel Diversion Wall  Lake Rotorua experiences anoxic bottom waters and cyanobacterial blooms (Fig. 1A). Water from Lake Rotorua flows through.
Overview of Watershed Systems
Water Quality.
Soil Science Faculty of Agricultural and Applied Biological Sciences Ghent University.
Successful Watershed Planning Forrest Bell, FB Environmental Associates.
What is a Watershed? (or Drainage Basin)
ABIOTIC. The pH of a stream or lake depends on the kinds of rocks and soil that water contacts. Proper pH is an important life requirement for all aquatic.
Land Uses & Water Pollution Sources Christopher Gale Bill Taft.
Forestry BMPs OUR GOAL: To Protect Our Waters and Site Productivity Through the Proper Use and Application of Best Management Practices. (BMPs)
Introduction to Modeling Unit V, Module 21A. Developed by: Hagley Updated: May 30, 2004 U5-m21a-s2 Module 21 Introduction to Modeling  This module has.
Forestry-related Ordinances in Florida What are the potential influences of county and municipal ordinances on forest land retention and sustainability?
Sanitary Engineering Lecture 11. Storm Water Runoff Storm water runoff is the precipitation which seeps into the ground if precipitation occurs faster.
Definition: Soil and water conservation engineering is the application of engineering principles to the solution of soil and water management problems.
Predicting Sediment and Phosphorus Delivery with a Geographic Information System and a Computer Model M.S. Richardson and A. Roa-Espinosa; Dane County.
Comprehensive Planning for Lake and Stream Protection Brie Begiebing Water Resources Specialist Portland Water District.
Elaine Snouwaert – WA Department of Ecology Walt Edelen – Spokane Conservation District Spokane River DO Advisory Group Meeting January 19, 2012.
Highlights A Study of Phosphorus Loading of Ballston Lake by Tributary Inflow Presentation to BLIA Annual Meeting June 16, 2014 Scott Miller, Bob Duncan,
Sediment & Nutrient Management in the L’Anguille River Watershed St. Francis County Cost Share Project Patricia Perry St. Francis County Conservation.
Created by The North Carolina School of Science and Math.The North Carolina School of Science and Math Copyright North Carolina Department of Public.
Soil Quality Measurement Unit: Soil Science Lesson 7.
Natural vs. Accelerated Soil Erosion Natural geologic erosion has occurred at a relatively slow rate since the earth was formed. Natural erosion produces.
1. Measuring Soil Quality Soil quality integrates the physical, chemical, and biological components of soil and their interactions. Therefore, to capture.
Soil conservation practices Contents Soil conservation practices Soil conservation practices Crop rotation Crop rotation Wind break Wind break Cover.
™ Nutrient Management Planning ¨ Will these be mandated in your state?  An emerging national issue is how to account for agricultural non-point source.
Watershed Plan for Heredia, Costa Rica Whitney Thomas, Matthew O’Malley, William Brown Biological Systems Engineering, Virginia Tech Rio Tibas Watershed.
Lake Independence Phosphorus TMDL Critique Stephanie Koerner & Zach Tauer BBE 4535 Fall 2011.
Lesson 1.5 Pg
Habitat Mapping of High Level Indicators at Multiple Scales for Fish and Wildlife.
Transpiration Similar to evaporation, this is the loss of water through plants. – Pores in leaves (stomata) are opened to release oxygen and water vapor.
Phosphorus Stressor in Lake Champlain Basin Alison Nord, Anna Speed, Ashley Murphy.
Land Uses & Water Pollution Sources By Joan Schumaker Chadde, Western U.P. Center for Science, Mathematics and Environmental Education. All photos by Chadde,
EROSION CONTROL BY LAND MANAGMENT WHAT IS EROSION The detachment and transportation of soil particles from one place to other by running water, wind.
Lesson Understanding Soil Drainage Systems. Interest Approach Ask students the question, “What determines how fast water will flow through a funnel?”
Watersheds and Wetlands CHAPTER 1. Lesson 1.5 Factors That Affect Wetlands and Watersheds Human Activities Watershed Quality Health of U.S. Watersheds.
Subsurface Drainage (Tile) Design Thomas F. Scherer NDSU Extension Agricultural Engineer (701)
SWPPP: Stormwater Pollution Prevention Plan Creating/Implementing a Plan for Compliance.
Culler Lake Bathymetry: Potential Changes Following Dredging Spring 2013 Sampling Methods Class: J. Bruland, M. Dybala, N. Gunther, A. Hoffman, J. Jones,
1. Wolfeboro’s Tool Kit Implemented tools for water quality protection Municipal Watershed District Ground Water Protection Overlay District Steep Slope.
Soil Erosion. Objective 1: Explain soil erosion.  What is soil erosion?  I. Soil erosion is the process by which soil is moved.  As soil is eroded,
Hydrosphere Notes Part 9-Land Use. What is land use? The way people use land.
Human Impacts Part 2- Watersheds. What’s a Watershed? An area of land that drains into a common body of water.
2010 Water Quality Monitoring Activities -Medicine Lake -Twin Lake Keith Pilgrim Barr Engineering March 17, 2011 brain huser is great.
GIS M ETHODOLOGY Swearing Creek Watershed Restoration Plan 8/26/2015 Piedmont Triad Regional Council.
Definition: Soil and water conservation engineering is the application of engineering principles to the solution of soil and water management problems.
What is a Watershed? (or Drainage Basin)
8.E.1 Understand the hydrosphere and the impact of humans on local systems and the effects of the hydrosphere on humans. 8.E.1.3 Predict the safety and.
Fundamentals of River Restoration and Salmonid Fisheries OWEB, 1999, Fundamentals of River Restoration and Salmonid Fisheries Dylan Castle.
Hydrosphere Notes Part 9-Land Use.
BEST MANAGEMENT PRACTICES (BMP’S)
Soil Conservation.
Land Uses & Water Pollution Sources
Land Uses & Water Pollution Sources
Presentation transcript:

The State of Webber Pond Understanding the Factors Affecting Water Quality in the Webber Pond Watershed Colby Environmental Assessment Team Colby College Biology Dept. December 5, 2002 Vassalboro Town Office PART 2

Presentation Overview Introduction Water Quality Analysis Land Use Analysis - Intermission - GIS Analysis and Models Future Predictions Remediation Measures Recommendations

Geographic Information Systems Maps and Models of the Webber Pond Watershed Lauren Bliss

GIS and Modeling Geographic Information System (GIS) - Combines geographic data with thematic attributes - Creates layers of maps with themes aligned in a common coordinate system (“georeferenced”) Modeling - Representation of reality that helps to predict how natural systems will work - Simplifies systems by assessing pertinent factors - Uses ModelBuilder extension

Bathymetry Map Important for identifying sub-basins and water sampling sites, computing lake volume, and predicting the occurrence of organisms in Webber Pond ModelBuilder Bathymetry MapPEARL Depth Map

Bathymetry Map Webber Pond is primarily shallow 61% less than 16 feet deep Basin in southern portion Deepest point is 41 feet

Soils Organized into phases and grouped into series Classification depends on a number of factors: Important to consider soil type when developing in watershed Nutrients bind to soil particles and enter lake via runoff Erosion factors important

Georeferencing Aligning Print Maps Soil Map: An Overview Digitizing the Print Map Soil Map

Soil Map Theme Table with Multiple Attribute Fields K value - Erosion factor (0.00 to 0.49 for Webber Pond watershed soils) - Based on a standard size plot tilled and plowed - Value based on amount of water and sediments in runoff

Soil Map 31 phases divided into 16 series Majority (82.3%) of watershed composed of five soil series Septic limitations severe for most Webber Pond watershed soils Majority of K values (erosion factor) range from 0.20 to 0.32

Slope Map Contour Map ModelBuilder Slope Map

Septic Suitability Model Open residential land increased from 0.7% of the watershed in 1956 to 7.1% in 1997 Inadequate septic systems (leach fields) associated with residential or commercial land can contribute to non-point source nutrient loading into Webber Pond Beneficial to understand where septic system installment is suitable in the Webber Pond watershed

+ Slope Map Soil MapSeptic Suitability Septic Suitability Model Factors that influence septic suitability: Weighted Overlay

Septic Suitability Model Unsuitable areas Steep grade High septic rank Indicated by light purple shading Highly suitable areas Gentle slope Low septic rank Indicated by pale yellow shading

Septic Suitability Model 99% of the watershed is highly unsuitable for septic system development (rank of 4 or above) without prior modifications Attributed to steep slopes and soil composition Area near Quaker Lane most suitable Recommend working with the Kennebec County Soil and Water Conservation Service

GIS, Phosphorus Model, and Future Predictions Bill McCloy

Erosion Potential Model Inputs 1.Soil Map 2.Land Use Map 3.Slope Map Weighted Overlay

Soil Map K values represent a soil’s erodibility K values were reclassified to range from 1 to 9 9 represents the most erodible soil types and 1 represents the least

Land Use Map Erosion Risk Values Mature Forest - 1 Wetlands - 1 Transitional Forest - 3 Reverting Land - 4 Pasture - 7 Golf Course - 7 Cleared Residential Land - 8 Cleared Land - 9 Crop Land - 9 Commercial / Municipal -9 Roads - 9

Slope Map ModelBuilder Contour Map Slope Map

Weighted Overlay Combines 1-9 erosion risk value for each input Factors in the percent importance of each input for the model Slope- 50% Land Use - 25% Soil Type- 25%

Erosion Model Inputs + + =

Final Erosion Potential Map 93.9% of Webber Pond watershed ranks 5 and below for erosion potential Only 6.1% of watershed ranks above 5 No part of watershed ranks very high

Water Budget Threemile Pond Mud Pond Threecornered Pond Webber Pond A water budget measures a ponds inputs and output of water The water budget helps determine the flushing rate for a pond or lake The flushing rate is a measure of how many times the pond’s water is replaced per year

Data needed for calculation: 1.Evaporation Rates 2.Precipitation (10 year average) 3.Runoff 4.Watershed area 5.Pond area 6.Average pond depth Areas calculated using ArcView® GIS Calculation

Flushing Rate Calculation constants I net

Phosphorus Loading Model Predicts total phosphorus concentrations Predicts relative phosphorus loading from each input category Input categories: 1.Land use patterns 2.Atmosphere 3.Septic systems 4.Soil retention potential 5.Sediment release Used to predict impact of future development in watershed

Creating the Model Area of input categories Export coefficients Surface area of lake Annual total water inflow Number of capita years - Lower for seasonal residences - Higher for year-round residences

Examples Mature Forest 0.10 kg/ha/yr ha24.52 kg/yr Camp Roads 3.45 kg/ha/yr6.51 ha22.46 kg/yr Golf Course 1.60 kg/ha/yr52.40 ha83.84 kg/yr Sediment Release 0.7 kg/ha/yr550.0 ha kg/yr Coefficient Area Phosphorus Loading

Calculated Phosphorus Concentrations CEAT/MDEP Sampling:22.97 ppb a Phosphorus Loading Model:23.35 ppb b a Mean epicore concentration from Site 1 b Best estimate

Percent Contribution for Different External Loading Categories

Historical Population Trends and Future Population Predictions : 1.26% annual pop. growth : 10% growth in population Webber Pond watershed population growing at about same rate as Vassalboro population Projected growth: 0.7% annual increase for next 25 years Projected 2022 population: 4,698

Future Development Predictions for Webber Pond Watershed Increased Residential Development Scenario 1.Incorporates new shoreline and non-shoreline residential land 2. Incorporates estimated population in Decrease in agriculture in watershed No Increase in Residential Development Scenario 1.Incorporates natural forest succession 2. No increase in residential land 3. Decrease in agriculture in watershed

Predicted Land Use Changes with Increase in Residential Land in 2022 Mature Forest acre increase Shoreline Residential10.50 acre increase Non-Shoreline Residential acre increase Transitional Forest acre decrease Reverting Land52.19 acre decrease Agriculture acre decrease Cleared Land10.00 acre decrease

Phosphorus Loading Model Predictions Increased Residential Land 2002 phosphorus concentration: ppb 2022 phosphorus concentration estimate: ppb 0.17 ppb increase No Increase in Residential Land 2002 phosphorus concentration: ppb 2022 phosphorus concentration estimate: ppb 0.53 ppb decrease Very small changes due to high level of internal phosphorus release, and also phosphorus input from Threemile Pond

Remediation Techniques and Recommendations Melanie Newton

Remediation Problem- Reducing phosphorus loading Direct Control - Decreasing amount of phosphorus that enters the watershed Point source diversion Erosion control Nutrient Control - Reducing sediment release of phosphorus Water Drawdown Phosphorus inactivation Hypolimnetic withdrawal

Point Source Diversion Diverting tributaries or point sources high in nutrients Seaward Mills Brook Tributary from Threemile Pond

Nutrient Interception Erosion carries sediment, nutrients, pesticides, and pathogens into the watershed Methods to control erosion: Maintenance of roads Control of shoreline erosion Construction of vegetated buffers Agriculture BMPs

Ideal Road Constructed of proper materials Graded and Crowned Diversions, turnouts, buffers, and ditches

Road Surface Larger gravel for base, finer gravel on top A crown should be 1/4 inch high for each foot of road width Grading uses a steel blade to level the soil material on the road’s surface. Grading should be done often and crowning should be done annually

Ditches Flat bottom and surface Gradually graded sides Trapezoidal or parabolic in cross-section Stone-lined or vegetated Sufficiently wide and deep

Culverts Convey water under road surface Discharge water into ditch or vegetated buffer area Should be adequately sized and have a 2% slope At least a foot of soil covering

Vegetated Buffers Remove sediments, nutrients from runoff water Forests: - Uneven surfaces obstruct flow - Roots promote absorption Seeding and mulching is beneficial where forests have been removed

Shoreline Erosion 914 m (6%) are high risk shoreline Several residents have taken action by constructing Concrete walls Log crib Riprap

Prevents erosion and allows nutrient-rich runoff to be absorbed by shoreline first. Grade of slope should be reduced 2:1 Base of bank should be stabilized with gravel blanket and rock riprap Slope covered by vegetation

Water Drawdowns Purpose: Remove water high in nutrients Kills some nuisance macrophytes Benefits: Low cost Facilitate other remediation techniques May increase spawning areas for bass Drawbacks: Could facilitate growth of some macrophytes Interferes with recreational activities Could kill planktivorous fish Removes only water from surface

DEP Drawdown Management Plan Presented in 1991 to Webber Pond Association Water Quality Manager, Dam Manager Water Level Coordinator Bi-weekly transparency readings Algal bloom before July, no drawdown Algal bloom late August, drawdown as soon as possible Drawdown 1.5 ft. below spillway by Labor Day Drawdown no later then September 3rd

Compromise Residents Recreational use of Webber Pond Swimming, Boating, Fishing, until Labor Day Natanis Golf Course Draws water from Webber Pond to maintain holes Best Biological Practice Drawdown occur as soon as possible after algal bloom, when nutrient levels are highest

Phosphorus Inactivation Process Al 2 (SO 4 ) 3 and sodium aluminate added to water, bind with phosphorus forming AlPO 4 Falls as floc onto sediment Aluminum best in anaerobic conditions pH must be between 6-8. pH below 6 forms toxic Al(III)

Phosphorus Inactivation as Remediation Purpose To reduce internal phosphorus Benefits Very effective long-term benefits Drawbacks Costly. Estimates for Webber Pond from $180,000-$890,000 Potentially toxic Increase in macrophyte growth

Hypolimnetic Withdrawal Purpose To remove nutrient-rich, deoxygenated water from hypolimnion Benefits Cheap Effective reduce from 200 mg/L to 91 mg/L Drawbacks Where will water go? Pipes for hypolimnetic withdrawal

Possible Collaboration with Natanis Golf Course Golf Course uses approximately 1 million gallons of water from Webber Pond each year If golf course could extend pipe deeper than 6 m into hypolimnion, it could drain nutrient-rich water Golf course could use this in irrigation and possible fertilization Remove nutrients from Webber Pond

Recommendations The primary problem at Webber Pond is cultural eutrophication Nutrient run-off from agriculture, roads, residential, and commercial land uses Historical cultural eutrophication created the problem in high internal phosphorus recycling levels Remediation must address both of these issues

Monitoring Suggestions Bi-weekly transparency readings from May through August Test surface and epicore samples for phosphorus yearly DEP Site (Site 1) Green Valley Campground (Site 6), Natanis Golf Course (Site 9), Dam (Site 10). Transparency and Dissolved Oxygen profile at Site 1 monthly May-September

Regulatory Measures Agriculture Increase use of BMPs in agriculture Better monitoring of these farms Forestry Restrict future timber harvesting If harvesting occurs follow a BMP Roads Conduct road surveys frequently to identify trouble spots Repair Trouble Spots

Residential Measures Encourage addition and enhancement of vegetated buffers and riprap Encourage road improvements and maintenance by residents Limit use of lawn fertilizers Reduce shoreline alteration

Nutrient Control Measures Continue the yearly drawdown, investigate the possibility of drawing water down from hypolimnion not just surface Investigate the possibility of using nutrient-rich hypolimnetic water in irrigating the Natanis golf course Investigate the possibility of phosphorus inactivation

Educational Measures Encourage the availability of this report to the general public Work closely with the China Region Lake Alliance Develop and distribute pamphlets to homeowners (road repair, riprap, vegetated buffers, detergents, and water level drawdown) Involve local schools in monitoring Webber Pond

Acknowledgements Peter AbelloKelly Karter Roy BouchardJim Lucas Bob & Julie BrownKevin Michaud Russell ColeJudy Moody Gene FieldPeter Mosier Dale FinesthRebecca Manthey David FirmageEdward Noel Betsy FitzgeraldFrank Richards Nate GrayBruce Rueger David HalliwellDan Tierney Vassalboro Town Office Staff Maine Department of Environmental Protection Staff Maine Department of Inland Fisheries and Wildlife Staff Maine Soil and Water Conservation Staff Green Valley Campground

Questions